YSK how to decrease medical bills in the US significantly
[deleted] · 20434 points · Posted at 03:44:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
afcagroo · 1043 points · Posted at 04:02:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What is a "self pay bill"? (I'm guessing I know what it is from context, but I'd like to be sure.)
[deleted] · 954 points · Posted at 04:06:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Self pay usually means straight out of pocket with no insurance involved. We require soooo much less from that. It can also mean insurance paid some but not all. The provider will charge you the balance without applying a multiplier discount so ask for the self pay after the insurance payment. It will be much less.
afcagroo · 265 points · Posted at 04:22:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks!
So to make sure I understand this right: If you have insurance, they will bill you at an inflated rate. If the insurance won't pay all of that inflated rate, you can ask for the "self pay" rate and they'll just change the bill?
[deleted] · 322 points · Posted at 04:31:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They will bill you at the charged rate which the main insurance groups only pay at roughly 40%. Never ever pay the denied insurance rate. It’s inflated to ensure we receive the max amount possible depending on contracted rates.
Also worth mentioning, if you take the “Self Pay” route it will not go towards your deductible. This is a good alternative when you have a high deductible that you will most likely not reach.
That should be its own LPT. If you're getting a procedure late in the calendar year and can find out the hospital rates (which, if the courts allow it, will soon be published information), you would be able to make an educated decision as to whether out of pocket costs would be lower via self-pay or insurance due to the ever-increasing deductibles and co-pays (and coinsurance!). Don't do this for routine visits and preventative care, or normal Rx.
Here's the real life pro-tip for good healthcare: vote for Bernie Sanders in the primaries. He's the only candidate that I believe will get universal healthcare for all Americans. He has a track record of fighting for everyone and doing the right thing.
He has demonstrated that he will do the right thing and fight for people, whether it's easy or hard. From protesting segregation to fighting for LGBT rights, he was on the right side even when everyone warned him that it could end his political career. He has shown that he genuinely cares about people and he has shown that he will stand on his principles. There's no other candidate who has a record like him and there's no other candidate who deserves our trust as much as he does. Bernie has been fighting for us every day of his life since before most of us were born, and he has a long list of accomplishments.
The media won't give Bernie fair coverage, so we have to. Support Bernie in any way you can, and get the word out as much as possible. Let people know that the media is covering him up, and tell them who he really is. Get people registered to vote and remind them to vote in the primaries. If we all work together we can do this!
We don't like what we see and we can't do anything about it.
that's how it kinda feels in America sometimes
even when we do vote for Hope and Change (because we don't want Romney's plans) we ended up with....... Romneycare
not to mention continued Military Imperialism and refusals for anyone in that Administration to call for prosecution of Wall Street
guess that woulda made Obama's dinners with rich donors kinda awkward. the same ones where he takes a massive dump on the "far left" that helped him get elected in the first place
The left and right are all playing a game dude. We all forget that the people hold the power in the US. We have the amendments to protect us from them. The 2nd one allows us to remove corruption and restore our republic. I'm not some crazy far right dude. I'm a Democrat that's tired of my party and the other party and I know alot of you are as well. No matter who we vote for they all are in on it and are together making themselves more powerful. It doesnt matter anymore who we vote for that's the issue. We can fix it but they have us stuck thinking we have to vote red or blue to do so. It's not true, we can change and help America but only we can do it.
Goondor · 7 points · Posted at 09:52:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is Defeatism and it has no place in a thread with Bernie Sanders above it in the thread. He's been for the people from the start, look at his record and vote. And vote in your local elections, that's where this all starts.
skz129 · 1 points · Posted at 09:15:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I live here and I don't like what I see and also can't do anything about it. Most people in this country are playing team blue vs team red and are absolutely too stupid to see that we're all losing until the two party system is destroyed and our entire approach is significantly overhauled.
If the system weren't rigged, Sanders would have been our president for the last three years. We are trying. I'm sincerely hoping that the last election was enough of a wakeup call to the younger generation on how important voting actually is, so that Trump will lose (to whoever.. hopefully Bernie) by a wide enough margin that they can't jack it again. That is the only way any Republican has won for the past few decades.
[deleted] · -11 points · Posted at 08:13:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well, they certainly speak for me and my family, as well as a lot of people I know here.
[deleted] · 9 points · Posted at 08:42:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They share the same opinions as everyone I know in my corner of the world... of course they can't know if they speak for every single person, but they definitely speak for a lot of us.
Jushak · 5 points · Posted at 08:59:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 09:52:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
You don't even see bernie in the media but he has the largest donor base the people with money sure as hell don't want him to win as he will change things. He has shown that throughout his lifetime fighting for the middle class and unjust laws. They want someone like biden who I can't morally justify he reminds me of hillary nothing will change. The same status quo for the rich keep the poor poor. I wonder how many millions our for profit healthcare system has killed so far.. I liked that sleep now in the fire trump for president sign! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w211KOQ5BMI good video and song
What happened with the DNC makes me realize there's more corruption than I knew about. I'm really hoping for Bernie and no one else seems as genuine as him . I cannot wait for the chance to vote for him again
As a Trump supporter, Bernie Sanders is the only Democrat candidate I respect. I may not agree with his stances on a vast majority of subjects, but he's the only Democrat candidate I feel actually believes in what he's trying to get implemented and the only one I believe would do it the way his supporters want it done.
not against Yang or the Gang, but for us we are really trying to do the Mass Movement thing right now that Bernie is still capable of leading it and strike while the iron is hot and the Establishment is scared
although it is certainly refreshing to see someone not ordained by our Corporate Overlords getting lots of support
Almost makes the race feel like an actual democracy
I like Yang. I don't agree with him on everything, but I think he's running a genuine campaign for the right reasons. He's smart, he's passionate, and he has real grassroots support. I'd like to see him and Bernie work together, I feel like they could both learn a lot from each other. Quite frankly, I think Yang should endorse Bernie at the next debate. Yang has ran a great campaign but I don't think he will have enough of a surge to become a top tier candidate, especially because the media won't give him fair coverage. I think it would be better for everyone if he throws his lot in with Bernie. It would give Bernie's campaign a huge boost and I think it will work well for Yang too, I believe that Bernie would be very open to working together and potentially creating the Department Of Technology that Yang has talked about. And if Yang Gangers and Bernard Brethren joined forces, we would be combining the two strongest groups of the democratic election.
Bernie has a way longer track record and more political experience to accomplish his goals, but id be stoked for Yang if it comes to it. Hoping 0ne of the two gets the nomination for sure
Zuwxiv · 8 points · Posted at 08:26:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren, too. I know she's Diet Bernie but people get more caught up on arguing the (comparatively) small differences that they forget we're on the same side.
Warren changed her healthcare plan to a public option that she plans to enact 3 years into her term.
The presidents political party almost always loses seats in the election following their nomination. Warren is suggesting we wait to push m4a through a most likely Republican controlled Congress or senate.
In this particular situation, while talking about healthcare, I dont think she's entirely relevant. She backtracked on her healthcare stance pretty quick.
Wasn't she previously a republican also?
Stranex · 2 points · Posted at 11:56:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
less than a minute on google shows that she was registered as a republican almost 30 years ago. is this supposed to reflect negatively on her?
As someone who gets excellent health insurance from work tha would almost certainly be worse under Bernie, pays 40-50% taxes because I live in the Bay Area (which judging by the fact there’s a homeless guy in front of my apartment building who blasts music all day when all restaurants nearby have hiring signs, isn’t being spent wisely), and has high employment mobility, why should I vote for Bernie? Honest question. Because my understanding is my taxes would go up even more to 60%+, I would lose healthcare benefits, and the useless bum in front of my building would get free healthcare.
Visit BernieSanders.com to see what the payroll tax deduction would be. 3% for every dollar above $29,000 I believe. See any doctor or specialist. Any hospital. Includes dental, eyeglasses and hearing aids. Also mental health. Leave your job if you don’t like it. Your insurance does not depend on your employer. No premiums, deductibles or co-pays. Free at point of service. So what if your local bum has healthcare? Does he deserve to die because he is not as fortunate as you?
For starters, that "useless bum" (and the rest of "useless bums", uninsured, and underinsured people you and your family may come into contact with) won't be at risk of contracting and transmit infectious diseases.
On the other hand, even though your taxes would go up, since your company doesn't have to pay any healthcare insurance for you, that money should go directly to you, increasing your salary.
Sounds like corbyn over here not that I want to vote for him
pradgun · 1 points · Posted at 08:38:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What are the chances of a universal healthcare bill getting passed by both the house and the senate under Bernie ?
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:03:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Depends on how many seats get flipped and how scared of being primaried from the left the corporate democrats get. If Sanders becomes PotUS they damn better be scared if they go against overwhelmingly popular changes.
Free at the point of use. And people don't own our hospitals - that's kinda the point. They're publically owned and non profit making.
Saw a really interesting analysis recently comparing tax. You Americans actually pay more tax than the UK overall. So why don't you have free healthcare when you pay more? You also get less paid vacation, fewer workers rights, next to no maternity/paternity leave, no sick pay - what are all your taxes being used for?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 02:34:06 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
When I need a GPs appointment I am charged - nothing.
When my daughter was born I was charged - nothing.
When my wife needed an emergency C section for my son, and more medical staff than i've ever seen before swarmed the room, I was charged - nothing.
When my mum had breast cancer (fully recovered) and the best option drug was 20k a dose she was charged - nothing.
The government uses tax revenue to fund the NHS. Yes i know you're trying to claim that that makes it not free to make yourself feel better about your shitty overpriced health system, but like i said - Americans pay more tax and get less for it. Why is that?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:37:40 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Free at the point of use.
Free at the point of use.
Free at the point of use.
My taxes fund a whole range of things nationally. Some of my taxes may be spent on the NHS - but that is not my call, nor do I know where my taxes go. If i didn't pay any taxes it would still be free at the point of use. Not that any hospital or doctor i attended would have a way of charging - see that's another thing we don't have in our free at the point of use NHS - a billing department.
So why are Americans paying more tax, getting less for it, and having to pay exhorbitant medical costs too?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:23:15 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
It also changes the nature of what gets paid for and to whom.
Insurance/medicare pays for what you can afford - the more you pay for insurance the better the treatment you get. On the NHS you get the best option for what you need - cost is not a factor.
The US system is a business - it's not about care, it's about making money. The NHS is about patient care first.
As a yank you could take a visit to the UK, take a walk around a city centre and trip over a kerb and break your leg. Your ambulance and treatment, including recovery physiotherapy, would cost you nothing.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 10:46:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Nah he's got way too many wacko policies. His tax plans alone are fucking nuts
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 11:48:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Name one, any one.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 21:14:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
His medicare for all tax plan for one. Here are list of tax hikes that are spelled out in his policy to pay for medicare for all.
A 4% employee payroll tax
7% employer payroll tax
77 % death tax on inheritances
And then the obvious wealth and bank taxes. And the self employment taxes on top of it.
Like yes, there are nuances to this, like the death tax kicking in at 3.5 mil at 45% and all that shit, I get it.
But fuck's sake that's waaaay too many taxes for a single plan.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 00:50:53 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
" that's waaaay too many taxes for a single plan "... according to who Lol?
The way you generate revenue is by raising taxes. These aren't pie in the sky proposals, they require taxes be raised and the bulk of the taxes will be paid by those who can afford it the most, everyone receives the healthcare WE pay for. I don't mind helping out my fellow American, what's the problem?
While our taxes will be raised a little (our being people who make less than $300,000 a year), our overall savings will be much greater in comparison . Here's a simple breakdown of what the current brackets look like as of right now. https://i.imgur.com/tWH8hq4.png
Almost every legitimate study ever done on the savings provided by moving to a single payer system has us saving money not spending more for healthcare. Bernies plan would see us saving 2 trillion dollars over a 10 year period and that's from a conservative Koch funded study. People cry over Bernie proposing a bill that would cost 32 trillion over a 10 year period but don't bother asking what the current systems costs us, more than 34 trillion over the same period, some estimates have it much higher than that.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 01:10:24 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
According to me. You asked so I named one lol. You admit it
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:16:37 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Weak ass rebuttal. I was hoping you understood that your premise was a faulty one to begin with but I guess it's too much for you to admit you know nothing John Snow.
Don't worry though, when we finally get medicare for all and you see your fellow Americans lives improving before your eyes, you'll come around, I have hope for you yet.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 01:20:14 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
No wasn't looking to debate the merits of the crazy tax plan. Just simply state that it exists. You acknowledged that it does. To you its worth it. Cool.
Bernie isn't going to fix healthcare any more than President Obama did because a President cannot do it alone and the Democratic party is not only unlikely to have the necessary votes in Congress to do so, even when they've had them for short periods they cannot get a noncompromised bill through due to disagreements within their own party.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:29:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Look I'm a Bernie supported but stop plastering this shit everywhere. It's Reddit, we get it, stop posting his shit in every thread.
Don't get me wrong here because I am part of the buerocracy, but bernie can't get the "damn bill" passed now as a senater... he wont be able to do anything as president as long as Mitch controls the Senate... flip that shit or there is no chance.
Obama made a lot of if promises then ran weapons to Syria and Ukraine, funded mercenaries in Libya and forced everyone to buy into the broken healthcare system. Bernie also rolled over and endorsed Hillary after the DNC completely shafted him and I honestly don’t believe he has the balls do jack in Washington.
Obviously Bernie didn’t want Trump to be president.
No, he can’t take on the system alone but he has inspired hundreds of progressive candidates, who otherwise would not have run for office, to get involved. It’s a movement towards taking control back from corporations and the political elites they have purchased.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 00:55:09 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're a moron. Bernie stayed true to his word. He said if and when he lost during the debates, he would support whoever won the nomination. But you don't care about facts.
Honestly, I'm planning on voting Bernie solely because there's a sliver of a chance he'll forgive my student loan debt. I don't care if the chance is miniscule, or if I'm being naive believing that there's a chance at all. I owe over $450k, for that amount of money, I would be stupid not to vote for that.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 09:39:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Here's the real life pro-tip for good healthcare: vote for Bernie Sanders in the primaries.
Honestly just vote for anyone that isn't a Republican.
mrbungl · 0 points · Posted at 11:11:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any rational person realizes that there is no way to pay for all his "free" shit.
Have you ever looked into the how? It’s not free, he has been planning this stuff probably for decades.
“We can guarantee higher education as a right for all and cancel all student debt for an estimated $2.2 trillion. To pay for this, we will impose a tax of a fraction of a percent on Wall Street speculators who nearly destroyed the economy a decade ago. This Wall Street speculation tax will raise $2.4 trillion over the next ten years. It works by placing a 0.5 percent tax on stock trades – 50 cents on every $100 of stock – a 0.1 percent fee on bond trades, and a 0.005 percent fee on derivative trades.
If Wall Street can be bailed out for several trillion dollars, 45 million Americans can and will be bailed out of the $1.6 trillion burden of student loan debt and we can provide free college for all. Some 40 countries throughout the world have imposed a similar tax, including Britain, South Korea, Hong Kong, Brazil, Germany, France, Switzerland and China.”
eorabs · -11 points · Posted at 07:26:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"his message has been consistent for decades" and yet he hasn't gotten shit done. You should maybe downplay his long history of being an ineffective politician who only has pie-in-the-sky for sale to idiots. He is the left version of Trump. No plans, no compromises, no hope of healing a national divide. Just empty rhetoric. Bernie is not a savior, he's a rich fox in the poor henhouse.
You know why right? Because you propose a plan, congress MAYBE votes on it, then it gets shot down and never comes to fruition.
See; the current situation of the House proposing HUNDREDS of plans/bills and the Senate(Mitch McConnell) REFUSES to even have the bills be voted on.
Fuck off.
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 07:31:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
He has plenty of plans tho ya dingdong. It was pretty hard being a socialist for like, oh, 8 decades but its swinging around now and Bernie is building quite the movement.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:14:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:25:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He's worked his entire life, what else is he going to do with the money.
It's incredible the level of idiocy that still allows a human to function. I wonder if they can walk and talk at the same time?
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:01:10 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Except for the simple fact that Universal Healthcare wasn't even in the political conversation until Bernie ran on it in 2015. Now, almost every Democrat in one way or another supports a single payer system model, while many others running for President have backed Bernie's proposals before running themselves.
The fact that he has held firm on his positions after all these years despite his proposals not being popular at the time isn't a knock against him you dam fool. All that means is that he's ahead of the curve on every damn issue, everyone is playing catchup to Bernie. He's an OG.
eorabs · 0 points · Posted at 03:09:18 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow, the amount of ignorance and boot-licking in this comment would be hilarious if not for the fact that this is really what Bernie's supporters think. You genuinely think that he was the first to propose the idea of Universal Healthcare in this country? An OG, eh? Bernie is a do-nothing candidate who has all you fools thinking you're going to be walking around in free tuition and universal healthcare. You all apparently have no idea of the limited scope of executive power, and since Bernie is allergic to compromise you will never have these things. Words and ideas are nice, but they are promises for empty headed fools.
You can post all the links to how much you love the guy, but I mean.. come on the man is 78 years old! He’ll be 79 when it comes time to vote, I’m sorry but I just don’t think it’s sane to vote for someone that old. Sure he seems to be more sound of mind that Biden.. but it’s just insane to me the the top democratic candidates are older than Trump, when we all thought he was too old
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:06:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lifestyle means a shitton more than age. Sanders is visibly much more healthy than most people decades younger than him.
“Visibly much more healthy than most people decades younger than him” boy those rose colored glasses are incredible
Edit: Dude just had a fucking heart attack!
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 12:41:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He works harsher schedule both before and after said "heart attack" (which isn't exactly correct term for what happened, but I digress) than any other candidate and keeps on going.
Calling it "rose tinted glasses" does nothing to discredit objective reality.
We’re just not gonna have the same opinion of the man, what you see as hard work, I see as pulling the wool over peoples eyes, spouting an Agenda promising free everything around the country isnt very hard work imo. But like I said our opinions are like assholes, everyone has one and they usually stink
I know. These type of people watch fix news and eat up whatever their minds make up.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:04:10 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're a moron. Bernie stayed true to his word. He said if and when he lost during the debates, he would support whoever won the nomination. But you don't care about facts.
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 08:22:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Remember folks, the US has the greatest doctors in the world because of how expensive healthcare is here. Canada has universal healthcare and most end up coming down here for serious procedures due to either lower skill doctors or long wait times.
Not commenting on the state of our healthcare system as it pertains to every single citizen, but just be thankful you have so many great doctors to choose from.
My concern with Bernie is he will reduce incentives for US doctors, causing some to straight up deny insurance and raise their premiums so only the ultra rich can actually afford their services. He also strongly believes in heavy government spending which will be funded by the highest tax rates our country has ever seen, just something to keep in mind.
This is plain wrong. The Toronto general hospital is on the top 10 world wide list, while being the largest transplant centre in north America. 400 000 a year is a perfectly acceptable wage for a doctor. It is revolting to think financial incentive is the only thing that would drive people to work in American hospitals.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:49:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
not Canada, but an example where US “financial incentive” saved someones life in Germany.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:17:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I never said Canada doesn’t have good hospitals....Im sure Toronto General is a fantastic hospital. But financial incentive is what drives doctors to work in the US whether you agree with it or not. Financial incentive dictates almost every single decision made. Im sure when you search for doctors in the US, the cost of the procedure is going to play a factor in where you go (aka financial incentive to pay less)
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:01:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Such a load of bull on every regard in your post. Read up on some history on US taxation and educate yourself.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:14:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
please tell me whats bull, i’m very interested.
EDIT: If your going to throw figures from over 100 years ago then don’t even bother. 50% tax on $2m+ income is just insane. paying an extra $100k in taxes because you made $2m instead of $1.99m is not something most entrepreneurs are going to be happy about. Why give the government an interest free loan? The government is wildly notorious for being extremely inefficient. Ask literally anyone in a government office how long it takes for things to be done. Why would we want to bank the future of our healthcare on a government that spends $640 on plastic toilet seats?
ajdeemo · 2 points · Posted at 09:45:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
EDIT: If your going to throw figures from over 100 years ago then don’t even bother. 50% tax on $2m+ income is just insane. paying an extra $100k in taxes because you made $2m instead of $1.99m is not something most entrepreneurs are going to be happy about.
Who has argued for having an exact tax bracket jump like that? If anything it would work exactly like progressive tax brackets do now: you would only pay 50% tax for all income after 2m. I've never seen him advocate for the exact situation you describe.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:54:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
thank you for actually providing facts and links and not personal attacks. Im glad to hear this is a progressive tax. Thank you!
ajdeemo · 1 points · Posted at 10:05:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Glad I could help. There's a lot of misinformation out there around taxes, a lot of people purposely leave out the "progressive" part when talking about tax changes, either to trick people or because they assume everyone knows it's progressive. It's usually safe to assume that proposed changes are still progressive, because flat tax brackets are complete trash for the reasons you listed, and not just for corporations but people too. (I'd still recommend checking just in case)
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 09:43:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There is no reason why anyone should have that much money anyway. I couldn't give a fuck about whether rich people like it or not either. They can suck it up and pay back to the society that makes their riches possible in the first place.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:52:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
how did that taxation work out for the US?
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 10:50:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not sure what you are trying to insinuate with that question.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:08:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
literally asking if that tax was successful or not
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 13:18:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Considering it is sometimes called the golden age of US I would say it was pretty fucking successful.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:53:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
LOL
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:05:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who gives a damn if we have the greatest doctors when most people can't afford them without going bankrupt?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:07:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
because they are alive and not dead
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 16:16:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
... yet. Poverty kills too.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 22:48:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
seems we are at an impasse
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 23:04:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's ok, let's stop here. Not every difference has to be resolved. Situations can change, and Sanders may not even get the nomination. Everybody should just vote with their own conscience. Good day to you.
my prescription medications are always cheaper via self-pay than going through my insurance. and I never meet my yearly deductible so it would be out of my pocket either way.
Jushak · 2 points · Posted at 09:08:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Doesn't that defeat the point of insurance? Man the US system sucks.
Random, but I have a genetics test done on my unborn daughter and through insurance (0% paid) it's $650. Cash is $250. Our yearly deductible resets in mid June. The baby is due before that. I think we should do nearly all out of pocket payments as the delivery will 100% cost more than our out of pocket cost.
Somewhat confusing comment, but if the test is covered by insurance I would think you'd go through insurance and pay toward the deductible bec you know you're definitely going to eclipse it within the plan year, so it's money you'd pay anyway later. You'd pay 650 up front but recover it later and save 250 on the back end.
Unless your deductible is obscenely high. Maybe I'm missing something.
We haven't hit our deductible. It's ($3250) for family. We're maybe $500 into it, so no help from insurance. Our next daughter will 100% be born before our plan "renews". Our last kid was $9,000 after insurance, if which we only had to reach our out of pocket ($6500).
We'd save money now by just doing the self pay. Or am I missing something?
has there ever been a time someone called their doctor, or hospital before hand (when applicable) to find out the cost of their procedures and weren't given an estimate of the costs and their portion?
the provider does know what they charge, and patients can ask - and should!
my office policy is to notify patients as soon as possible (like a week or two) before their surgery of what their costs are - and to collect the patient share about 90% of the time (90% or more of the estimate we give over 90% or more of the patients who have share of costs).
We would rather you don't come, or find somewhere cheaper, than to come, be seen, then have to waste time trying to collect what a patient owes, when they don't want to pay. Not to mention, information provided timely and accurately is just good costumer service and patient care.
Also be aware that some offices may not give you the self pay option if they know you have insurance. And some offices may just refuse you an appointment.
foxbase · 16 points · Posted at 05:45:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Damn I could have really used this information a few months ago. My insurance denied my claim and I ended up having to pay almost triple what I was quoted with insurance. I always thought that billing departments weren’t allowed to bill self-pay rates if you had insurance.
The last few places that I worked would not bill as self-pay if a person has insurance.
foxbase · 2 points · Posted at 14:18:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s always the policy I’ve been told. I’ve been told they can’t bill self pay if the person has insurance for legal (?) reasons. I guess they’ll get in trouble if they do.
Probably only if it’s a state or federal insurance like medicaid! There’s no legal implication otherwise- if insurance doesn’t pay any on the claim at all, they should be able to give a self pay discount. If insurance has made any adjustment at all they really can’t because of a contractual agreement with that insurance company that a patient is responsible for the amount left after insurance adjustment.
foxbase · 1 points · Posted at 02:27:26 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Interesting, not sure where mine falls under, I have private health insurance through my work. That last part makes sense though, because my instance did adjust the end bill, it was just much higher than what I was quoted originally. I didn’t really understand that part though because they denied the claim, but adjusted the bill anyway, weird.
Don't know where you are, but Duke med let's you self pay even when they know you have insurance. I asked for both prices because I have noticed that sometimes even with insurance the out of pocket cost is higher than w/o it. The worst thing that happens if you ask is they say no... But I think if I recall they said they knock about 75% of costs if you go non insurance.
So the insurance costs as far as I can tell are inflated but sometimes do help for bigger procedures like MRI's and such if you've met the deductible. Idk, bit what I know for sure is that medical billing seems unnecessarily complicated!
foxbase · 1 points · Posted at 14:23:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah I’m not near Duke, I’ve never had a place tell me they allowed self pay if I was on insurance unfortunately. I think it has to do with the contracts hospitals have with insurance companies, so a lot of places err on the side of caution and don’t let you self pay in case they might be in violation of their contract. At least that’s what I’ve been told when I asked about this before.
self-pay should also apply for MRIs as well! It's usually a 3-4x markup especially in hospitals for MRI than if you were to go self-pay. The outpatient is the way to go there if you have that available in your area. Most of the large machine sit idle 50% of the time, so the outpatient places are willing to negotiate rates. Im working to make this process more transparent but only in NYC right now.
Why is it illegal? I'm surprised at how much the US hate its own citizens.
twir1s · 20 points · Posted at 06:37:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m confused by your statement. Balance billing is a way to price gouge the patient. Making it illegal protects u.s. citizens/patients. How does making balance billing illegal mean the US hates its own citizens? Making it illegal is a form of consumer protection.
They probably misunderstood the comment. I did too, until you clarified. I read that as balance billing is the same as self pay. For us novices, we have never heard these terms so it’s all new information.
Apologies for not completely explaining. "Balance billing" is the practice where the insurance denies the claim and then the provider (hospital/doctor) Bill's you for the total/gross/charge amount without an appropriate "self-pay discount" which could be well over 50% of charges.... it is confusing.
There are many contracts with insurance companies that will never pay more than 50% of the billed price. If your cost of doing the procedure is $800, and you bill $800, then you're going to get $400 and actually lose money on caring for that patient. So you have to bill $1600 so you can get $800.
Yeah, and it should be illegal for insurers to say "I have a load of patients with you, give me a 30% discount or I'll remove you from the list of places they can go for care". How do you think we got here in the first place? Insurers demanded a discount, hospitals and doctors and such need to pay bills, so they've been going back and forth for decades of complying with demands for steep discounts one year and raising prices next year to cover it. Somewhere early on they realized there were no organized or standardized pricing rules so they could gouge each orher back and forth and somewhere in the middle the system of medical coders, claims adjusters, control documentation providers, and negotiaters became a self sustaining nightmare.
Skilol · 1 points · Posted at 09:35:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Especially when they can leave the deductible so high that the inflated cost ends up as mostly not being covered anyway. Pay monthly insurance that's already higher than in 100% of the developed world, just to then pay more for actual medical services than without insurance. What the fuck, America?
This insurance system in the US is the most venal and corrupt institution short of the Oval Office. The sooner the insurance business is brought to heel, the better.
This sounds like you’re almost better off not having insurance. My husband pays like $550/mo for the both of us and we have a 3k deductible per year (aside from preventative visits). So that’s already $9,900 per year we pay before seeing much in benefits. Then the stuff that’s actually covered isn’t even covered 100%, usually 65-75%. So we pay out of pocket that 25-35%. Which you’re telling me now seems to be the cost of the self-pay rate, anyway?
Insurance Co. A will give you $2 for a certain procedure. Insurance Co. B will give you $5. How high will they go? If it’s your job to negotiate the highest payments, and there’s no downside, you can just set the rate at $1000 and see what you get.
This is why I don’t see any good in forcing hospitals to reveal their rates. They’re all just inflated nonsense numbers.
Wouldn't they be likely to jump them up even more before revealing them?
hmstd · 1 points · Posted at 08:48:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's because insurance companies want to haggle/bargain with doctors/hospitals and with each other. I just went through a small ordeal where my insurance wouldn't pay for a procedure until I provided them with a notice of if I had any other insurance plans.
They want to know if someone else will pay for anything before paying any themselves. I can't haggle or change my insurance premiums, I have to pay the same no matter what, why should they care or be able to change what they pay based on what else another insurance might pay.
It's a bunch of bullshit that's a result of trying to run healthcare like a business.
essentially insurance companies have bargained to pay certain rates due to their bringing in a certain amount of ”business”.
this is like you being the biggest seller and thus purchaser of tires in town and going to the suppliers or rather manufacturers and saying ”i sell all the f’ing tires in town okay and so im only going to pay 40 cents on the dollar compared to if those suckers actually just bought from you guys directly. you guys charge too much anyways.” now this sort of bargaining might work if there werent only a few insurance companies left in most areas. more and more people are on government insurance anyways which also pays a cut rate and from my understanding takes longer to pay. As a result it seems to me certain healthcare providers are ”medicare/medicaid” designed while others dont accept it and thus provide a higher level of service. So now what we essentially have is a two tiered system where poorer people have ”public healthcare” on the ”free market” but really dont access the same class of services so its like we have two healthcare systems.
From what I’ve seen health insurance is getting so expensive it is single handedly pushing many young individuals and familys to either choose between medicaid territory or trying to fight out of there with no health coverage. This is increasingly difficult if not merely because well if you have any issues like for instance mental health issues due to stress (surprise) you may become essentially debilitated and or practically and really suicidal (hence the drug overdose epidemic.) It’s really hard to exist in a hopeless bind. I think many people are choosing drug overdose even subconsciously. Affording, for instance, the leading drug for treating opiate addiction will put you into needing probably gold tier insurance in most states (~$500/month)
It is completely screwed and all of congress is to blame. they passed a healthcare bill with unrealistic optimism it would catch on but in reality the other side was so hell bent on destroying it (it was sort of forced down their throats, up for debate as to whether that was neccessary) its been so unsupported that its gotten so expensive and thus received such bad PR that its only a matter of time before healthcare gets so expensive we have a crisis and essentially chaos and possibly a healthcare inspired revolutionairy uprising. only so many people are going to tolerate having their kids die of overdoses because doctors choose to perscribe instead of treat since its more profitable and less legally risky. only so many people are going to tolerate that one medical issue they have in life-crushing their dreams of upward mobility completely.
insurance in general is a social (dare i say socialist) policy that is meant to spread risk among the population and give us all a way to depend on the community for support when we have bad luck. people have forgotten this and its become a place for profit, period.
thats my prediction and understanding at least.
over 30 of my friends from high school and young adulthood have died of overdoses and i dont come from a typically economically challenged area. many of them were well educated and come from good families.
When I went to my 20 week ultrasound appt my bill was $500 because my insurance wouldn't cover it until the deductible was met ($5,000). When I asked them if that was the only option, they told me about a self pay option which would cost $240 😑
[deleted] · 24 points · Posted at 07:12:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not pregnancy/birth related, but my father was diagnosed with bowel cancer after a routine FREE bowel cancer screening test, having recently moved to Australia from NZ within the previous 12 months.
The colonoscopy, pathology, surgery, chemotherapy have all been $0 out of pocket. He has a team of Dr’s he meets with fortnightly to discuss how things are going and has a nurse on call 24/7 for any emergencies/questions etc.
This was all put together within a week of the initial screening positive. I will take this “socialised medicine” any day of the week.
wcdma · 3 points · Posted at 09:18:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Kia ora bro, Glad to hear. You only get one whanau - Kia Kaha my bro
WKGokev · 5 points · Posted at 10:55:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yet, I will have to wait until April to see a dermatologist to have a melanoma looked at, but republicans swear that everyone else waits while we just roll in and get taken care of.
I’m no doctor but isn’t that the kind of thing that needs to be actioned as a priority? Is there not any provision for medical necessity to determine the wait list order?
WKGokev · 1 points · Posted at 20:05:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Nope, my sister in law had to wait 6 months for a colonoscopy, her mom died from colo-rectal cancer.
Jeez. I’m sorry to hear that. I’d like to think it’ll all change one day there. I just hope it’s still uncorruptible. There is far too much money and politics in that business
WKGokev · 1 points · Posted at 12:43:07 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah, I was talking to a guy said he knows a dermatologist who does some rare procedure, charges 15k, keeps 12k for himself. That's a 400% profit margin, which should be criminal and would have been in 1972.
Fuck, yes!! Please! So tired of this bullshit weighing whether to get care or wait til it might be an emergency that kills me. I've had chest pains and headaches for the longest time. I put off seeing anyone for so long (years) but I honestly thought I had some sort of tumor or maybe I was developing aneurysms that any day would take me out of this world. Headaches would last for days and sometimes months. I troopered along until I finally got a job that let me be able to pay for the huge deductible and out of pocket costs to find out. Turns out it's not cancer and not aneurysms. But what if it had been...?
And it's not like if you go they just can identify what's wrong immediately. No they have to run tests and each test costs. And most people just can't afford it even with insurance.
And I hear people from countries ask about why more people in the US don't get STD screenings? It costs like almost 400 if not through planned Parenthood. And then you get harassed by evangelicals at the door it's just not worth it to a lot of people.
And I can go on and on, so yes!! Please can we get some universal healthcare?? Ffs!
I'm in Canada and have to get multiple colonoscopies a year. Like one year I had to get one every other month. Reading Reddit has made me grateful for our healthcare here because I couldn't imagine having to worry about whether insurance would cover or deductibles or whatnot. I just go, check in, get my stuff done and leave, never thinking about the bill or the cost. In fact, I don't get anything from the hospital, ever.
Anecdotally.. when I had my first child in the US, the pregnancy, birth and aftercare were completely covered by Medicaid. He was born prematurely, was in the NICU for a long time, and it was expensive... I didn't ever get asked for a dime. And it was first-rate care.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 09:04:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, we pay a little more in taxes but the US government spends far more on healthcare per person than the Australian government. Your system is well and truly set up to benefit the rich.
24.6% in 2018, compared with the OECD average of 25.5% and the American average of 23.8%.
Median wage is $ $65kAUD (45k USD) vs 46k USD.
So the tax difference is about $3-400 per year.
Certainly less than what most Americans pay in Health Insurance.
Australians also get minimum 4 weeks annual leave each year, paid sick leave, paid parental leave (2 weeks for the father and up to 16 weeks for the mother).
Many business also have additional incentives, (especially around parental leave).
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:53:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When I told my American wife about Long Service Leave she thought I was joking.
Also worth noting our annual and sick leave rolls over into the next year. That’s not common in America
Water2B · 1 points · Posted at 12:20:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, I found that shopping around for image services is very helpful, I was charged $800 for a mammogram, that's via insurance before I met the deductible, when the doctor said everything looks good but i need another memo in a few weeks, just to make sure, i just didnt go to a doctor for a few years.. f*ck that, I have other bills to pay.. so eventually I needed to do another memo, I called a few places, good references, etc, 1 hour schlep, $120 mamo
Really?? $620 difference?
They bloody scare you senseless and rob you blind..
I used to work as an AR specialist in a medical billing department that handled billing for multiple provider groups. I was the one who sent the claims to the insurance company and contacted the patient for the remaining balance. This is somewhat accurate but I’m careful not to mention it as a blanket resolution because some providers don’t offer a self pay discount. You need to talk to the billing department to determine if the option is available, I sometimes had to refuse negotiations like this because it wasn’t in the contract we had with that specific care provider. I could only process the request about 60-70% of the time.
Also, keeping in contact with us didn’t help at all unless you were making payment that actually impacted your bill. I heard my coworkers scoff over the phone plenty of times at patients saying things like “if you continue to make payments in that amount, it’ll take you 20 years to pay off the bill,” which would then impact my coworkers stats, so they’d send them to collections. It was all about getting payments and clearing old accounts so that our overall numbers were optimal.
Anyway, it was a pretty toxic environment which is why I left but a lot of providers are no longer using in-house billing departments, which seriously impacts the quality of service.
Having seperate tariffs for insurance companies and private persons isn't even legal where I live. That said, most people here never see a medical bill in their life as those are send from the hospital to the health insurer directly.
Damn socialist country taking care of all people. /s
Seriously, people love complaining about "What is this Socialist Sweden" or "It will never work this is America!" but whatever the fuck happened to American exceptionalism, can do attitude and hatred of terrible rules? The healthcare system is just a thinly veiled free for all, hidden by bullshit that most folks can't see through. Get rid of all the fucking BS, and suddenly the system will work. Even if the new system somehow fucks up, we can't do worse than this.
I hope you guys really get your shit together. I don't know what the bookmakers do at the moment, but it seems a 50/50 bet if the US makes it back to democracy or slides further down the slope to totalitarian rule. Which would be exceptional for a developed country, but not in the good way.
I just looked it up. Bookmakers here in Australia are favouring Dems (1.72) over GOP (2).
As for individual candidates Trump is the favourite (2.25) over the nearest rival Biden (6.50)
Explanation for U.S gamblers:
Our odds work differently to yours. We use decimal odds rather than moneyline odds. If you bet $1 on Trump for example you give your $1 away and receive $2.25 if you win, a profit of $1.25
You can sometimes negotiate a prompt pay discount or something like that, but if the balance due is because of your deductible/copay/coinsurance, this is money that you agreed to pay when you signed up for your insurance plan. Either way, call the billing office and see if they can work with you.
You can also ask for financial aid. Works better in big nonprofit hospitals but I’ve gotten 70% off my bill and I make ok money. Best part is as far as the insurance company is concerned you paid 100% of what they charged you initially and it can max your deductible.
Self pay usually means straight out of pocket with no insurance involved. We require soooo much less from that. It can also mean insurance paid some but not all.
This seems like an egregious acknowledgement that this "insurance" service is just an exercise in bureaucracy.
Healthcare runs a Black Friday pricing model all year long. The insurance companies think they can use their size to pressure providers into accepting lower payment, so the providers jack up their billing amount, then "discount" it for the insurers. This, on top of the price bump to account for non-payers.
Universal coverage with a single payer, and we could discover how much health care actually costs, without the layers of bickering bureaucrats, fake discounts and exaggerated sticker prices.
I went to several dermatologists in a major US city, got different estimates on a routine, non-emergency outpatient procedure. I tried to get cost estimates, I got none.
When I picked the office I went with, I asked how much the procedure would be if I didn't have insurance. They panic-asked to make sure I did, but I wanted to get the worst of the damage. She said she couldn't give it to me, but guessed it would be ~$700. Ok, that's my ceiling I thought.
After the procedure, my portion (after insurance) was $1500. Why? Well given my insurance, they charged ~$3200, and my insurance covered ~$1700, leaving me with the balance.
I argued for months and months and eventually settled to pay some portion of the OoP bill, which was around $700. Had I known to ask for that, it would've saved me time and frustration.
This. I had a medical emergency that turned into a two week hospital stay (massive cluster of pulmonary emboli exacerbated by pneumonia - had to be resuscitated twice) and I had no insurance. Setting it up as self-pay saved me around $60,000, taking my total bill to around $20,000. This was ten years ago, mind you, but it took me from filing bankruptcy to something I was able to pay over time.
Oh I know. I said it half in jest, as tough it does sound like a low price it's still exorbitantly expensive. I feel like it would be double that now if not over 200,000.
Absolutely - I’d definitely be looking at bankruptcy over that now if I didn’t have insurance. I was surprised it was as cheap as it was then. Didn’t mind paying it a bit - those folks literally saved my life.
Don't forget that a lot of community clinics and FQHC will have a sliding fee scale and can work with you on a price point to be basically $0 if you are low income as they get paid per patient seen instead of percentages based on service rendered!
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 07:24:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is it possible to 'self pay' and then pass the bill/receipt onto your insurance company for a rebate?
sorry to rain on your parade but its breach of contract for providers to provide self pay after insurance adjustment.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:54:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you believe this system is one that works? Obviously your job is in this field but doesn't it seem completely unnecessary that we need an anonymous user to tell us how not to get scammed out of our money?
It’s a great information, but the system is flawed, shouldn’t be like this. This is a horrible system, can’t believe people has to try to find all kind of ways to lower their bills, it’s like a medieval market where people negotiates for things, crazy!
Anecdotally, the companies I've dealt with literally charge you less if they know you don't have insurance. Instead of ~600 bucks for my dental visit, I only paid about 120 because I asked the lady at the desk what they could do to reduce the bill so I didn't have insurance.
It's the real reason health care is broken in America. A lot of blame goes on the insurance companies, but the reality is that health care providers show us exactly what they could be charging and still stay in business. Health insurance is a bargain considering what they're charged for a claim.
[deleted] · 76 points · Posted at 04:55:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For real, fuck insurance. They have a “glitch” in their system every few months causing everything to drop to patient responsibility. There’s a reason why their stock prices continue to climb no matter the economic environment.
So much this... you want to know where the money is going? Commercial insurance companies, pharma companies and medical device companies.
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 07:03:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's also a well known fact that a huge percentage of all Healthcare spend is just administration. These intentionally complicated insurance policies require literal armies to work through claims.
That’s why single payer or Medicare for all is such a nightmare. How many tens of thousands stand to lose their jobs if it happens? These are difficult, intellectual and high skill jobs, but they were deliberately created by an intentionally confusing system. The system was created to foster an environment that allows a man in the middle (the insurance) to suck up money like there’s no tomorrow.
I’m not sure why you’re getting downvoted. 2.9 million people work in the insurance sector. There are 900 health insurance companies in the US. You can’t just make an intire industry disappear through legislation. The lobbying to keep it would be massive.
You could elect Bernie, but there is no way single payer is passing congress or the judicial system.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:37:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's going to be a painful transition, but the job shouldn't be necessary so in a sense they aren't economically productive. We'd have to give the insurance and medical administration professionals an increased and prolonged unemployment in the event that 80% of their jobs evaporate over a few months.
True though stock seems to always go down during summer but bounces back in autumn and winter to a net positive.
conscwp · 20 points · Posted at 05:43:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's more complicated than that. Insurance companies aren't actually paying those crazy high bills, either. A hospital will send a bill for, say, $10,000 to an insurance company because they know that the insurance company has an entire department of negotiators that will find a reason to knock the bill to only $5,000. When sending it to an individual without insurance, they know that the individual has less power to negotiate so they have to put less of a buffer on it.
health care providers show us exactly what they could be charging and still stay in business
The reason that providers are able to charge less to non-insured patients is because they are subsidized by the high payments from insured patients.
A hospital will send a bill for, say, $10,000 to an insurance company because they know that the insurance company has an entire department of negotiators that will find a reason to knock the bill to only $5,000. When sending it to an individual without insurance, they know that the individual has less power to negotiate so they have to put less of a buffer on it.
As someone not in the US, that still sounds insane to me. Healthcare should not be some yard sale where you're expected to haggle and it's entirely on you if you pay the asking price.
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 07:43:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yep. The US government is absolute fucking garbage. They let corporation and insurance companies fuck their citizens all over the place.
The weirdest part is how many Americans defend this trash system. I've literally had multiple people tell me they wouldn't want universal healthcare, even if it costs far less for the same or better care, just because some of their money would go to somebody else who they consider undeserving.
Sometimes I feel like they have the government they deserve. But then I remember that the vast majority of US citizens are kind decent people who do want a better system that helps everybody.
It's just that the republican party is either grossly incompetent or downright evil. And the democrats are definitely incompetent.
I've literally had multiple people tell me they wouldn't want universal healthcare, even if it costs far less for the same or better care, just because some of their money would go to somebody else who they consider undeserving.
That's what I don't get, either. Like, how do these people think their car insurance or homeowner insurance or whatever works? You put money in a pot and (ideally) it's there when you need it, even if what you need is more than you've put in.
Your car insurance doesn't pay for new tires, or oil changes, or new wiper blades. Your HO insurance pays for catastrophic damage from fires, thefts, etc, but NOT for the cleaning lady, the new carpet you want when the old stuff is worn out, or when a major appliance needs to be replaced. Americans expect healthcare insurance to pay for routine maintenance as well as for the big stuff, and face it, we don't take responsibility for BAD lifestyle health choices! Obesity, alcoholism, smoking, etc, take a toll on a body, and the expenses to care for the people who abuse their own health are passed to everyone in a single-payer system. I'm NOT talking about children who need life-saving operations, or victims of accidents or cancers that devastate lives and finances. But don't lump it all together, and it's NOT as simple as blaming "capitalism" for everything we don't like in our country.
I was trying to point out how insurance works in general, not what insurance covers. But I am actually very glad that my health insurance (in my capitalist home country, since we seem to be talking about that now) pays for my six-monthly or 12-monthly checkup at my dentist and ob/gyn - those have helped detect a few issues early on. Would I go if insurance didn't cover those checkups? Probably not. So why do they cover it if they could just save that money? I know it's not out of the goodness of their heart, duh. It's because they are clever enough to know that spending a little on "maintenance" goes a long way when you're trying to detect and avoid any issues that might become a very expensive problem later, and their calculations have confirmed that.
Now about those "bad lifestyle health choices" - I agree, it bugs me to know that I'm paying for the cancer treatment of people who smoke like chimneys and drink like fish. But most health choices are not black and white, there're almost always pros and cons. A tradesman who busts his back lifting has not made a better health choice than a desk worker who ruins his back sitting. Is it a bad choice not to be a vegetarian? Not to run 5k every day? To play football because that might cause a whole lot of injuries? No country is made up of health nuts and couch potatoes alone, it's mostly reasonably healthy people with maybe a few bad habits (or genetic predispositions that are not their fault).
What I'm trying to say is, it's not super-healthy people literally pulling the weight of super-unhealthy people, it's a few bad apples benefiting from a system that benefits many, many others. Why would I want to punish the majority to weed out a handful of assholes?
Hope I made my point clear. I'm not trying to insult your country, or you, or your opinion.
I don't think either party is incompetent. I think they're doing exactly what they're paid to do. Which is create a show, a distraction, so the populace doesn't realize that their pocket is being silently picked a nickel at a time.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:30:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That just depends on what you consider their job to be. If their job is to take care of their citizens and to pass legislation that has been proven to work in other countries, then they're some of the most incompetent pieces of garbage on this planet.
Based on that job description, you're 100% correct
TheNoxx · 2 points · Posted at 07:40:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Also, currently, hospitals have to eat the cost of people without health insurance. Any time a homeless person has a heart attack or cancer, or someone struggling to get by that can't afford any insurance has a life-threatening car crash or disease, the hospitals are required by law to save their lives.
This is another big reason why costs are inflated: they have to make up for everyone that comes in that can't pay their bill.
no its even more complicated than that. hospital charges $10,000 because they have to charge every insurance company the same price, per every contract including Medicare. And, Insurance company A might pay 8,000 and company B $5,000. But if you charge company A only $6,000, you are leaving money (2,000) on the table. Hospital might theoretically need only $5,000 to stay in the black and pay their doctors, so you might wonder, well fucking hospital don't be a dick and just charge $5,000. Well, thats more complicated too. If every bill was paid, then they would. But for every 10 visits they see, 2 might have come in with no insurance to the ER, and some states require (and many hospitals policy), is to treat first, and try to bill later. but for the poor, its virtually always a write off. So now the hospital is 10k in the hole. Another 2 get fully denied from insurance for some shaaaaadddy reason (or sometimes legit) , usually a retired doctor on payroll at the company that sends a letter saying "in my professional estimation, this was not medically necessary". Hospitals can then start the 3 month appeals process. any business types reading this already thought about the major cash flow problems this creates. so now hospital 20k in the hole. for good measure, not unlikely, a 5th gets partially denied, so now a 22k hole. For the remaining 5 patients, they need as much as they can get.
So, your big bill is partially subsidizing a strangers free care.
We can solve this mess, surprisingly, if the government outlawed claim denials and paid for poor care better, in exchange for insurance companies forcing providers to post price averages for diagnoses. the market would work then
THANK YOU. You’re the first person I’ve seen ITT accurately explaining why bills are so high. Providers are required to charge all parties the same amount for the same services BY LAW, regardless of what they actually EXPECT to be paid.
They might expect $100 from Medicaid for a service, but $1,000 from commercial insurance, but they can’t bill them different amounts, so they bill $1,000 (or more) for the so they don’t lose money.
It’s also important to remember that contracted and government payers process claims differently, so the provider has to account for that as well. It’s ridiculously complicated, but just understanding the basics would clear up a lot of misunderstandings I see constantly posted all over Reddit.
1982000 · 29 points · Posted at 05:43:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance companies are entirely unnecessary. If we had group non-profit insurance, our Bill's would be so much lower. Insurance companies not only have to pay all of their employees, but the CEO's make obscene amounts of money. Like $22,000 a day. Look it up. Then they have to pay their shareholders. It's a FOR PROFIT business. They're not interested in you. They exist to make money. Why do you think they shit their pants when Bernie wants to get rid of them and expand Medicare. I have a disabled brother, and getting treatment for him is like a 20 hour a job week for my mom, filling out paperwork and trying to justify why he needs a surgical procedure. Smh.
Don't compare insurance companies and unions. While you pay dues to be in a union, the increase in pay and benefits because of the union greatly outweigh the cost of union dues. Insurance and insurance companies don't benefit anyone but the insurance companies. If healthcare was nationalized the government and all but a tiny portion of Americans would save a ton of money
[deleted] · 44 points · Posted at 04:53:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yep. That is why for profit healthcare should not be legal.
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to
Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you
4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make
A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
I am going to look into this at work, but I have been told that self pay and its discount is for people who do not have insurance. I can't just remove a person's insurance from the hospital account and say they dont have insurance, just because their insurance company is not covering a visit or procedure. Its insurance fraud, or so I have been told. I can help get the bill covered by proving the visit or imaging was medically necessary by sending in office notes, a letter of medical necessity, etc.
As someone who used to work in healthcare on the financial side, I absolutely agree. Many times the wrong thing gets booked and no one catches it until way too late.
Yup this happened to me. Went to the ER for a migraine (had them since I was 3 years old) but because I was pregnant they coded it as pregnancy related and it wasn’t covered on the insurance and I noticed too late so nothing they can do. Meanwhile it’s fucking up my credit score, since I just left it go to collections. I’m just waiting for it to drop off my record in like 7/8 more years 😑😢
Insurance generally covers "shit happens" stuff. Pregnancy is viewed as a choice to medical insurance, so you have to make sure you have insurance that specifically covers it.
That's not 100% though is it? Even if it's 1 out of 10,000 people still getting pregnant. It's unfair on that 1 person who doesn't have the option of abortion.
Get this. My vasectomy was 100% covered. I never even saw a bill. About a year later, my wife had to have a uterine ablation, but we couldn’t find a doctor willing to do one unless she also had her tubes tied, removed, or some sort of permanent birth control. It increases the chances of ectopic pregnancy, and the doc’s logic (which I do understand) is that just because your husband had a vasectomy, you can still get knocked up. Vasectomies occasionally fail, people cheat, etc.
But, they deemed her salpingectomy was considered “elective,” and it wasn’t covered. Thanks, insurance!
Pregnancy is covered as an essential heath benefit, so that is not the case since the ACA was passed. Just guessing here, but they probably sought out insurance after getting pregnant, preACA. Unless large group and self insured plans are underwritten (extremely rare), this is something that hasn’t been a thing for years. All health insurance plans are required to be aca Compliant (cover pregnancy and natal care).
At the time I was still on my parents insurance as a dependent and they don’t cover pregnancy for dependents. Got married and switched to my husband’s insurance but couldn’t change anything for that ER bill
[deleted] · 43 points · Posted at 07:13:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 07:35:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
TIL conservatives have controlled the government for the last half century.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 09:19:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 10:15:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 11:30:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most voters have been brainwashed into thinking we woyld only get the worst parts of universal healthcare.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 16:47:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The hospital basically scammed the insurance by providing wrong code. In medicare-for-all insurance would just pay scammers with your taxes, basically saying them they can continue. How is this ok and when insurance doesn't pay scammers it is "fuck yeah murika"? I feel for the situation the lady ended up in, but it's a hospital scam, fraud, not different from any other.
I know it’s a separate point you’re making here but I’ll jump in on the Medicare-for-all part. Depending on how it is implemented, the system could sidestep this issue entirely. In a public hospital the patient doesn’t get a bill nor do they have an insurance company. The staff and doctors in the hospital are employed in that capacity by the government’s health department and provide whatever services are needed.
For foreigners who aren’t covered by Medicare, their bill is comprised of bill codes of a set and pre-determined value that are arrived at by a non-commercial non-political board of experts. Bill codes are all on the website. That’s how it works where I am
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 17:15:55 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)*
That would mean the government needs to directly own a lot of hospitals and directly employ all doctors, nurses, physicians in physician offices, their helpers, everyone basically who does medicine and accepts this government insurance, making all of them federal workers.
Sounds like an even worser scenario if you know what I mean.
And the question of private practitioners would be left wide open. What happens if I only have govt. insurance, but private doctor treated me? Will he bill government for this? If so what stops them from billing the wrong code? (back to square 1)
I can only really speak from the experience of what we have here in Australia but I’m sure you’d find other implementations and opinions from various countries.
We have a bit of a hybrid system of public and private here. The government (State, not Federal) owns the public hospitals and employs the staff. Many doctors will work partially in the public system and also do private work either in hospital or clinical practice. No one in medicine is forced to work for the government.
Public hospitals are generally bigger, have many departments, and have Emergency. Private is more for scheduled elective day-surgery.
The objection to government run healthcare is largely cultural from what I can tell. Americans tend not to like it (and I’ve been to a few USPS centres so I think I know why) but we don’t have an issue with these sorts of things in principal. It’s more common and normalised. It also means there’s better transparency, accountability, and a formalised complaint process.
You’re not going to run into the issue of being billed by a private practitioner in a public hospital because they don’t work there. Anything you had done there including anesthetists is not billed at all so there are no surprises. You will however get billed with those billing codes if you’re a foreigner and it’d be up to you to get reimbursed by your travel insurance.
Private surgeons can set their own prices but they must get Informed Financial Consent from their patients. You’ll get a quote in advance for surgery from the doctor and your private insurance will also tell you in advance how much they’ll pay. There’s often an out of pocket cost with private surgery but the advantage is you choose your doctor, have shorter wait times, and more luxurious facilities. If it’s not worth it to you then you can go have it done in a public hospital and not pay anything if you choose to.
The billing codes are used in outpatient clinical consultations which are largely private practices. They are mostly small businesses or individual doctors working for themselves. To your point, yes, it’d certainly be possible for an admin person to get it wrong and submit the wrong code but it’s less likely as the codes in outpatient work are very straightforward, they use the same ones all the time, and there aren’t nearly as many codes as there are in America. There might be one for “15 minute GP consultation” or “throat endoscopy” instead of the very granular ones you get in the American system. Again, you’ll get all this cost information in advance when you call to make an appointment. They’ll tell you exactly how much the doctor charges (if they do charge) for each item and also the Medicare rebate for each item (or ‘bill code’ if you want to call it that). You pay the doctor in full on the spot then Medicare sends you the money to your bank account of the value of that bill code. This is the same rate for everyone except those in poverty with serious medical issues get more reimbursement as does any household of any income who has exceeded ~$1200 USD per year in out of pocket costs. Many doctors don’t charge at all and are happy to simply accept the payment of that biller code amount from the government directly to them without the patient being involved. Specialists rarely do that but GPs (same thing as PCPs) often do. Some will do it as standard practice for all patients where as some may charge most patients but not charge some based on their personal circumstances. In those cases the doctor still gets paid by Medicare but they make less without the patient also paying a chunk.
I’ve always thought our implementation of Medicare would appeal a lot to Americans compared to other countries’ systems. Doctors can set their own prices if they don’t want to work in public health, patients have the choice of going public or private, and costs are agreed upon in advance and if you don’t like it you can take your business elsewhere. A lot of that gels well with American capitalism as far as I can tell.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 03:24:02 on December 7, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! This is exactly the system I imaged as the best case scenario for US, mixed with private option, and even including the Consent part! I had no idea that I basically imagined already working Australia's system! Thanks a lot for writing such a descriptive commentary!
You’re welcome! Yes it’s not a bad implementation. There are always improvements to be made but on the whole it works well. Hopefully America does something similar.
That’s such bullshit that it wouldn’t be covered. As a coder (in the UK) there are rules about how to code conditions during pregnancy and a lot of the time you have to use a code from the obstetrics chapter instead of the usual body system code. However I don’t think a migraine would fall into that category unless it was caused by or aggravated by the pregnancy or it was complicating the pregnancy in some way.
It's 7 years. If it's still on there by then, contact the credit bureau and they can manually remove it. I've had to do that for a loan that I paid off and still showed up afterwards.
I would especially do this if you have a high deductible just so you know what to expect to pay OOP. Ask the doctor for a list of all possible procedure and diagnosis codes and call your insurance company and ask about each one.
So if I have a huge bill, how would I even know if the codes are wrong? I gave birth recently and it was complicated and I asked for an itemized bill and it was miles long. I ask what certain charges are and they get annoyed. I can't do that for all 300 items on there, I literally do not have time. Also I was kind of out of it and don't remember exactly what happened a lot of the time.
Also, can I dispute charges after I've already paid? I honestly don't have time to dispute the bills now since the baby gives me almost no time to myself, so I just paid them rather than worry about them going to collections and hoped maybe I could look at them more thoroughly later.
When I had to have two major surgeries back to back I asked my doctor for what codes they usually billed that procedure under. They sent me a list. Not perfect but I caught a lot of mistakes.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 06:32:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
othsoul · 3 points · Posted at 07:13:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In my case, the hospital had multiple National Provider Numbers (NPI) but only one NPI was registered in my insurance. The claiming dept in the hospital were incompetent enough to not check which NPI is covered. As a foreigner, it took me way too long to figure this out myself and let the hospital know.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 11:15:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yup. I have ADHD and was on stimulant medication when I started considering trying to get pregnant. I made an appointment with an OB to talk about his thoughts on my medication while trying to conceive and while pregnant. I think it was coded as something fertility related, which insurance said “yeah fuck no”. Called billing and explained what the appointment was actually about and the gal said they would change it to something like “medication consultation” since fertility was never really part of the conversation. Viola, insurance now covered.
Also, a fun fact, you’d be surprised how specific medical billing codes get. My mom originally went to school for medical billing and they have codes for damn near everything you can think of, even “injury due to turkey attack” lol
BigDew · 2 points · Posted at 11:15:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Imagine if health insurance wasn’t a thing and you just got healthcare regardless of a clerk entering the wrong number
Yes! I was getting billed for a nurse's visit to get birth control injections. I called insurance and asked why this was not being covered under the ACA mandate since it is related to birth control and it was because the procedure code was wrong. If I wouldn't have known this and called I'd be paying the extra $75 every 3 months.
Your diagnosis comes from a code set called ICD10(International Classification of Disease version #10), it's a bit complicated to locate your specific case but worth the effort.
tobmom · 1 points · Posted at 12:16:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Came here to say this. If you are told that insurance won’t cover something you need to know why. Ask insurance what’s missing. Often times if the medical provider hasn’t documented sufficiently the insurance company will try to get out of paying a claim.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:18:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So your saying that someone who is sick, possibly very sick, at possibly the most stressful times in their life, has to know a whole bunch of billing codes and go through every line item.
That's pretty fucked up
I go to the doctor here, I walk out paying ZERO. I don't even see a bill or have to sign anything. I walk into the doctors surgery, tell the doctor what's wrong, they write me a script, I walk out. Done.
I'll totally agree on it's a system fucked beyond any reasonable doubt. But!! On the plus you really only need to check your code on the bills as they pile in sometime for months. So there's that. /s
It’s ridiculous that this excellent information also feels like tips for dealing in the black market. They are also reminiscent of this scene from the Incredibles: https://youtu.be/_R8GtrKtrZ4. Thanks for posting OP.
It was super relevant then too. It’s just that more of the is poor now, when you consider the distance between those that can cover costs and those that can afford to feed their families.
You're really optimistic if you think Bernie is gonna be able to change that much when you consider all the assholes who are selfishly interested in hamstringing his proposed reforms.
Don't get me wrong, vote for the man. But temper your expectations, maybe.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 08:38:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah pretty much covers how insurance is one of the most gross fucking businesses models. The entire profit margin comes from not helping people in need.
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to
Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you
4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make
A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
And it was deleted. Making your comment even more accurate
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 07:24:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Is it excellent information? Or is it Hokum posted by a person only feigning to have more knowledge than the average person when it comes to navigating medical insurance claims?
OP posts in wallstreetbets and from that we can infer, with absolute certainty, two things:
OP is no older than 23
OP is the type of absolute hapless fucking idiot that posts in wsb.
Is this a person you really want to take financial advice from?
A 23 year old plumber might not know how to invest their money, but when they tell you about sewage, you listen.
It's not inconceivable that OP simultaneously has knowledge of an industry they work in and is a moron when it comes to financial planning. If you want to contradict what they're saying you'll need more than their implied skill in an unrelated field.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:27:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Source: living in the US after Singapore for 6 years and the rest of my life in Australia.
I had a spinal fusion in Singapore. 3 nights in a high dependency unit, an internationally renowned Neurosurgeon and a state of the art hospital (both selected by me) and all necessary diagnostics.
The bill was USD32k. The insurer covered 100%. I paid no premiums in addition to what my employer did.
A colleague here in the US had identical surgery. Same employer, so same level of cover. Premium is still $250 per month Leaving aside issues of network etc, he was discharged on the day of his surgery, and the total bill was USD170k. He had to cover $17k.
Assuming that this occurred after passage of the ACA, this didn't happen. Even the most expensive family plans are $15,800 out of pocket max this year. If it happened in previous years it was even lower because it adjusts each year.
Well no, if your wifes plan is an individual plan, then she'd have a $7500 deductible, sure, then her max out of pocket would be $7900. There is literally no way that your wife would be paying more than that unless she had insurance that wasn't ACA compliant in which case she'd pay a penalty for not having insurance.
If your wifes plan covers both you and her, then it would be the $15,800 out of pocket max, which still is less than the amount originally claimed. It simply didn't happen. I'm confused where I provided you proof that the original claim was false and you doubled down on saying "It could totally happen" when it simply isn't possible.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:59:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
There's still a penalty written into the law, it is just currently reduced to $0. Any future administration could, as part of a tax bill, increase that penalty amount. The penalty is still in effect for previous years however.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 14:30:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I literally provided you the maximums allowed by law. So yes, I know everyone's plan because it's the max allowed. You've now tripled down on showing that you're wrong because you literally didn't click and read the link provided. Let me post it in plain text so you can see:
See the .gov part? Meaning it is from our government? The people who wrote the law? So yes, I know you plan because it's what's allowed by law. I don't know why you commented either.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 17:13:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's for all insurance. This is how I know you didn't read the link I posted. In order to be an ACA compliant plan, it must have these caps. If not, then it's not considered adequate coverage.
both my wife and the OP are talking about employer insurance.
Which still must fall under the same ACA guidelines.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 17:51:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I literally provided you with the site that says it. You can go look at your coverage too, it will be outlined in black and white there.
I would much rather have a maximum deductible.
I don't think you know what a deductible is. There is no such thing as a "maximum deductible".
I hope your have have good insurance, too, for how angry you get when strangers are wrong on the internet.
You weren't wrong. You were intentionally being wrong. You were presented with evidence and then 3 times tried to tell me that I was wrong, despite having the evidence presented at your feet. All you had to do was read it.
You may have an aneurism.
Just like a deductible, it appears you don't know what an aneurysm is either.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 18:14:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Are you one of those people that believe they have to have the last word so they can "win"? If so go for it, I'll bow out here and you can "win" the argument your poor little ego so desperately needs.
What? Mine is like $8,000. Sometimes you just have to admit that you don't know what you're talking about.
pfabs · 2 points · Posted at 12:01:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
$8,000 might be your out of pocket max but it isn't your deductible.
A covered surgery would have a standard deductible of say $500. While a non covered surgery would have you cover a percentage.
So it's possible that someone could have to pay $17,000 for a surgery like OP claimed but something like $8,000 would be their out of pocket max. So they would pay $8,000.
It’s possible that is their deductible, but that’s not the case for most people. There are no restrictions on deductible maximums, only total out-of-pocket costs.
Under the ACA, the maximum out-of-pocket limit on all plans in 2019 is $7,900 for individuals and $15,800 for families. But for HSA-qualified plans, the out-of-pocket limits are quite a bit lower, at $6,750 for individuals, and $13,500 for families.
HOWEVER, a HDHP (high deductible health plan) that qualifies you for an HSA (health savings account) requires a minimum deductible of $1,350 for an individual or $2,700.
So, if you have a high deductible, you actually have a lower OOP maximum. For example, if you’re an individual and your annual deductible is $2000.00, you have a HDHP, which means you have an HSA qualified plan, which means your max OOP can only be as high as $6750.00.
After that: %X0 co-insurance, where X is either 1 or 2.
So you pay the full, let's say, $4,000 OoP maximum, then it switches to 20% of everything on top of that until you hit another maximum. Those are usually in the 10's of thousands. That 20% can really hurt if you have some complicated, $76,000 surgery, leaving you with ~$14k of co-insurance.
Not quite. Your OOP maximum is the maximum annual amount for all out-of-pocket costs (deductible, copay, coinsurance).
Under the ACA, the maximum out-of-pocket limit on all plans in 2019 is $7,900 for individuals and $15,800 for families. But for HSA-qualified plans, the out-of-pocket limits are quite a bit lower, at $6,750 for individuals, and $13,500 for families.
It would be extremely rare for anyone to have a $14,000 co-insurance. They’d have to have family coverage, a lower deductible, and a ridiculously high bill.
You're right. That's actually the maximum allowed Out of Pocket Maximum. So there's not a single ACA compliant plan where you can end up paying more than that for a single person. The OOP max limit does jump to just under $15k for a family plan though.
twir1s · 2 points · Posted at 07:36:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Dumb question, but does that limit just apply to marketplace plans or does it apply to plans you get through your employer/private insurers? Or are those one and the same?
It is for all plans that are ACA compliant for coverage (which is all health insurance plans at this point). Marketplace or employer, they have a max $7900 individual and $15800 for a family plan. Deductibles can be anything from $0 to the max out of pocket, but once you hit that limit, that's the limit.
If your plan has a max out of pocket above these levels, then you need to pay a penalty for not having health insurance because they wouldn't qualify as an ACA compliant plan.
gudmar · 3 points · Posted at 06:35:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I have a $6500 deductible. It all depends on the plan.
It's the same in Germany. The premiums are split 50/50 between employer and employee, I never paid for any medical treatment (surgery or else) in my entire life (I'm 30). Exception: needed a Dental filling and wanted a different filling than what the insurance covers, costs 50€.
I was an expat working for a foreign company's APAC headquarters, so whilst by no means in a majority, I was in a significant minority.
For the rest (i.e. citizens and permanent residents) there is decent health coverage under a variety of public and mandated insurance and self insurance schemes. Most major health services roll up to government owned corporations (as do many services, including various transportation and educational services).
Most expat friendly countries will i think. I live in Hong Kong and my employer pays for healthcare for me and my entire family
Grew up in Denmark. basically no private healtcare insurances, so government pays it all
xRyozuo · 2 points · Posted at 08:28:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What I’ll never understand is, if Americans are so willing to be taken all of their money if an accident happens to them, or if they pay x a month for insurance (which from these posts I gather they pay not much??) why not just vote for some god damned healthcare
So the theory is that my C5/6 disc (base of the neck, just below the shoulder line) suffered a trauma when I was playing contact sports when I was younger.
25 years later, normal age related degeneration cause those cracks to open up and sequestration of the disc. The rest of my spine is just fine other than that one disc.
I'd had the odd neck ache after travelling or sport which became more regular until the pain persisted and started down my arm as the nerve root was impinged by the disc matter. It got to the point where I couldn't get out of bed without icing and painkillers.
I tried all different sorts of treatment over a 3 month period (the recommended time to try conservative management) before going under the knife.
(As an aside, my colleague who had the surgery in the US was convinced to do so after suffering some mild tingling in his left arm which would happen after 18 holes of golf).
Now a year later I'm a little careful when lifting things over my head, and every once in a while when I'm run down it gets a little sore, but other than that, no symptoms at all.
eaglex · 2 points · Posted at 19:18:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
thanks for sharing!
I got hit by a car while on my road bike and after a while I found out I have 4 protruding discs.
I have little day-to-day pain but it's really frustrating because I can't do any sports at all without making it worse.
every doctor says it's really minor, but it's been a year and nothing really works to improve it.
I started reading about different kind of surgeries, that's why I was curious about real-world experiences, so thank you again for sharing that!
this story, along with Rosa Parks waiting 2 hours for an emergency response, and some people still furiously fight against fixing US health care. Unbelievable.
Just earlier today I was on a thread on Facebook about american health care, and I actually saw someone saying "Well MY care is free, so you're just being lazy and not trying hard enough. Just get different insurance if you pay too much. Taxes bad!"
What I’ve never understood is why people are willing to pay for insurance but not be taxed an amount? In the UK it’s clearly written out on our payslip as “National Insurance Contributions” - and what you pay is 12% of earnings, so if you make £1,000 a month you pay like £95 (due to paying nothing on the first £166 - you also pay something like 2% after earning a bit over £4k a month). It just sits in the same column as regular tax, and is adjusted based on how much you earn - I’ll take that over worrying if I have to fork out due to the insurance company rejecting my claim... my retired mother in-law just had major surgery, all sorted within a week, didn’t pay a penny because of this.
Man. That sounds like a dream. My grandmother can't even save her front two teeth after battling cancer, which put her in debt, because no one will help her cover it. She pretty much gave up after that.
This is exactly what I mean - people will explain away how the system in the US is more beneficial but then you hear so many horrible stories like this... I’m sorry for what your grandmother went through, hopefully something changes sooner rather than later.
As oppose to giving it to a large corporation? Who aren’t guaranteed to cover your expenses. If I have a heart attack today, live or die I go through that entire experience without paying a penny more; if someone has the same in the US there’s a chance they might end up in debt because of it.
Regardless of what happens to my money and what the government decide to do with it, I have the comfort of knowing the NHS is there - the only things we pay for are meds and even then, you get it for free under a lot of circumstances - I have asthma and have to buy an inhaler for like, £9 or something every 3 or so months depending on how often I use it, which is what, $15?
Trust me I don’t trust the current UK government as far as I can throw it but as long as our healthcare is nationalised I’m happy - we sold off our train services a long long time ago and a lot of people (including myself) want to see it reverted, because of the shit state our rail system is in.
Y'all are all talking like EVERYONE should foot the bills for people who live careless and unhealthy lifestyles. Costs for healthcare are inflated and CEOs of BCBS, etc, are absolutely absurd, but throwing out EVERYTHING not the answer, and socialism doesn't fix anything EVER (#BSanders).
I have asthma, so I have an inhaler - costs me £9 on NHS for a refill that lasts half a year - I’ve read that’s about $90 in the US? You can pay tens of thousands for giving birth DESPITE having insurance, it doesn’t cost a penny more than your NI contributions in the UK - and don’t get me started on bloody insulin.
US healthcare is an expensive NHS with extra steps - ALSO private firms exist if you wish to pay to slip queues.
The US are one of the few developed western countries to not have nationalised health, so the other dozens of countries must be wrong, right?
It’s just tax. You get taxed, and you get healthcare from the government. It’s that simple.
Also, allowing residents of different states to purchase plans from OTHER states would help the free market actually BE free. The first problem is the monopoly within which insurers work!
There are 2 benefits to the individual. First, insurance is often provided by an employer, so you aren't paying for it directly, unlike taxes. If they ditch insurance is it likely that money will end up going into your salary instead?
The other is that if you can afford better insurance you can choose better care. If everything is publicly funded like the NHS that ability to choose the better option goes away and the rich get stuck with the same standard of healthcare as anyone else.
We have private health care as well, we’re not restricted to the NHS - if people want to skip the queue for non-urgent care they can if they pay places like BUPA and other private firms - a few friends have done that.
First, insurance is often provided by an employer, so you aren't paying for it directly, unlike taxes. If they ditch insurance is it likely that money will end up going into your salary instead?
I'm not sure if the last sentence is an actual question, but all benefits are meticulously accounted for as part of overall employee compensation. The money to pay for your insurance, commuter benefits, gym memberships, etc doesn't come out of thin air - it's absolutely money that would otherwise be part of your salary.
The other is that if you can afford better insurance you can choose better care.
I don't know why you think that's the case. I can't think of a single example of a country with nationalized health care that doesn't also have private health care available.
I don’t think either side sees the healthcare system as working. There’s just disagreements on if socializing it in such a huge country will work. I’m prepared to be accosted but I don’t think healthcare being socialized would work in the US because it’s too big. The US government is horrible at running things effectively and efficiently so it would get even worse.
I’m not an expert but everyone looks to socialism for healthcare but I don’t think Americans have 15 tril (estimates) laying around. I mean the military budget is insane and the healthcare estimate is like 25 times bigger than that. So we would need to go more into debt and get rid of our military. Like what? How does this make sense?
Very open to discussion! Don’t be rude to me I’m just a regular person.
I’m not an expert but everyone looks to socialism for healthcare but I don’t think Americans have 15 tril (estimates) laying around.
Is this $15 trillion over 10 years or something? The US already spends over $3.5 trillion per year on healthcare, so while estimates that show 10 year costs in the double digit trillions may seem scary, realize that we're already spending much more than that currently, and total healthcare expenditure would likely go down by hundreds of billions of dollars per year under a single-payer system.
I don’t think healthcare being socialized would work in the US because it’s too big. The US government is horrible at running things effectively and efficiently so it would get even worse.
People don't have a choice with health care. There aren't enough specialists, meaning there's no real competition between providers, which in turn means the free market advantage is absent. For non-specialized care, things like antibiotics and emergency visits are also not a choice. Again, competition is absent.
When profit motive exists, money is intrinsically drained from the system. That's because people are motivated to, quite literally, take money from the system. How is incidental bureaucratic inefficiency possibly worse than intentional profit-motivated inefficiency?
Likewise, how would socialized health care possibly cause notably more than the existing insurance structure? No matter how inefficient the bureaucracy is, how could it possibly be less efficient than splitting the load for processing insurance claims through dozens of different insurance companies? And why would the government require more money than what citizens are currently paying to private insurance providers?
There's simply no capitalist argument for health care. It needs to be regulated and controlled, just like water/electricity/etc.
Not to mention that that once healthcare is single provider, that provider has a massive bargaining position with the pharma companies etc. It would require bizarre incompetence and corruption for them not to be able to negotiate a better deal for Americans.
You have to have a control over demand in free market - you must have the ability to decide if you want the product at the price being asked in the free market. You dont have that ability in healthcare. When you are sick you will get treatment for whatever it costs
As a socialist, let me assure you that single-payer healthcare is not socialism. Most or all socialists would agree that it's a good thing to have, but that's not what socialism is.
Can you explain why scaling is the problem you see with single-payer medicine? That's a common objection, but I've never gotten an explanation for why it wouldn't work for a larger population.
But we did Obamacare. Anyone on either side of the aisle will tell you in was an absolute disaster. It made healthcare more expensive for everyone on it or not on it. When I was growing up the average deductible for a family was so little no one cared now it’s on average 12k which was totally unheard of. I think it might even be higher now.
Are you with Bernie and thinking Medicare for all? Because there’s literally nothing working with Medicare now. It’s practically insolvent. Doctors don’t even want to help Medicare patients, they won’t even see them, because they don’t want to deal with it because it’s such a mess.
We can’t be like Canada or France or whatever, because we fund the national defense for allllll of them, that’s been the deal. So our money goes to that. They have more money to play with. Places in Canada are also paying like 50% in taxes. If we did that here people would maybe actually start throwing things in harbors again.
You look at Canada’s wait times in ERs. You’ll have to look it up but it’s like 30% of Canadians have spent 5 plus hours in an ER waiting room. In US that’s 5% and look at our population! That’s really good. Yeah you might go broke but I’d rather be alive and bankrupt just saying.
Isn’t 15 tril over 10 years? I found warren trying to raise that in a differing amount in taxes and Bernie’s plan costing 30 over 10. Also Americans spent 3.5 in healthcare in 2017 alone, not including expenditures on individuals who receive assistance or all med paid. We would be moving money from private business to government, I could see a problem with the startup cost inflating however people are already spending the money to go to the hospital or not able to pay and go into debt crippling their lives and input into the US economy, and insurance comps are just complicating middle men who add admins inflating costs astronomically. Americans still pay for poor kids and families through taxes right now, while spending more on healthcare than they would through the proposed plan. Now the execution has yet to be seen, but it definitely needs done. I work in material services at my local hospital and the amount individuals pay vs the cost to bring in even the most simple items is insane and wouldn’t happen when the entire country is on the same page keeping an eye on cost.
It seems you got quite a few great explanations! I hope the downvotes don't dissuade you from discussing the topic further, this was super educational for me as well.
They usually do discourage me because 90% of my opinions aren’t accepted here on reddit anymore. But I’ve had a lot worse interactions. Definitely look into the other side of things. I just can’t think of anything the government has run successfully and under budget and I already think US government has too much power, so to give them our healthcare sounds absolutely terrifying.
bkdog1 · -8 points · Posted at 07:24:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I dont think people fight against fixing healthcare , they fight against socialized/government run healthcare. Most people are unaware that most medical discoveries come from America but we allow a fee exchange of information so the rest of the world benefits. I happen to live within a couple hours from the most advanced hospital in the world where every year people come from 130 different countries around the world. It isn't uncommon for prime ministers, royalty and the dali lama to fly in to receive care. Just about every drug company has their r&d in the U.S. Many Americans are also aware of the negative aspects of single payer or nationalized healthcare systems that can be found in Canad and Britain. Need to find a way to reform the healthcare system while maintaing aspects that has made American healthcare the most advanced in the world. Do you want Trump to be in charge of your healthcare?
how are people still this uninformed? there's more US citizens going to Canada for care than the other way around, and virtually all Canadians going south are coming for plastic surgery, while American's come for cheap drugs or out of pocket surgery. Please educate yourself and stop being a dumbass.
R.e. the UK ones, it’s always blown out of proportion. If you have an emergency, you will be seen to - they prioritise people based on lives saved - whenever it says people wait 12 hours it’s because they turn up to a hospital with a rash or a cough. The NHS is definitely something that needs a lot more love and attention, I’m not saying it’s perfect, but holy shit am I glad it exists.
[deleted] · -9 points · Posted at 07:35:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Wait times for a specialist in Canada is 20 to 40 weeks. Imagine being in pain that long or your condition worsening. Scary stuff.
imagine just dying because you cant afford to see a doctor in any weeks
[deleted] · -2 points · Posted at 08:16:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Quit being dramatic. Do you honestly believe doctors are telling patients that if they don't pay they have to die? Hospitals aren't letting people just die. Research medical indigent.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:40:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
From the CNN article
These results are not meant to quantify the number of people who have died after not being able to pay for medical treatment, including prescription drugs, but rather the number of people who report knowledge of a death under such circumstances.
Canadians live literally 3 years longer than Americans and pay half as much for healthcare, this was not true before the 1970s when both countries had the same life expectancy and paid about the same amount. By virtually all measures Canadians get much better healthcare than their American counterparts.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 18:48:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I find it strange that your comment history is full of criticism about American politics and say nothing about Canadian politics. Why so obsessed with another countries policies when they don't affect you?
I am german, reading all of this is just like .. wtf do you have to do, just to not be completely bankrupt.
Meanwhile in our country, I just take the treatment and don’t pay anything.
I'm in tasmania and did the same for the same reason. I can't believe how fucked up the health care system is over there (along with a metric fuckton of other stuff too). Hobart's public hospital has one of the worst waiting lists in the country; i was on a waiting list for hernia surgery for 2 1/2 years and told I'd be waiting 4, got a call on a monday asking if I'd be available for surgery on friday, said yes, got moved next door to the private after surgery went home with abiut a months worth of dressings, had a follow up with the surgeon 2 weeks later and didn't pay a cent. I can't imagine what it would have cost me there.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 06:07:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ridiculous over here. Wish we adopted your guys practices
I'm gonna give a very specific example of a situation I encountered the most often working in anesthesia billing.
Colonoscopy screenings without any problems have one code and colonoscopy screenings with problems(polyps/etc) have a different code. They don't know the resulting code until the procedure is performed and they find whether there are problems.
Unfortunately, screenings without problems were covered entirely by insurance with little to no patient responsibility(~$26 coinsurance). However, colonoscopies with polyps usually defaulted the entire allowed amount to the patient deductible(~$232).
If a provider were to give you the code for the screening you're going in for, but it turns out there's something wrong, you'd end up with a higher charge.
So, that's one reason providers may be hesitant to provide you with the codes, but also because billing departments are different than the coders who read the medical records to translate the procedure to code. The people you've asked just may not know and the people who do know may not have that information until after the procedure.
get all of the medical billing codes associated with the services from the provider. This includes:
*Diagnosis code(s) (ICD-10) *Procedure code(s) (CPT/HCPCS) *Place of service (office, urgent care, outpatient hospital, etc.), *Provider’s taxonomy/specialty (eg. 124Q00000X is the taxonomy for a Dental Hygienist) *Modifier codes (if applicable, this is usually to indicate the location of a CPT code such as an X-ray on the left shoulder or whatever).
This is a helpful tip, but geez what a mess! Who has the presence of mind to track all this down when you’re sick and just need to get to a doctor and let them do their thing??
I feel like this is the core problem with trying to treat healthcare like a consumer-driven market. Nobody wants to deal with “shopping around” in the middle of a medical emergency. If you DO make the effort, it’s super complicated. Nothing is set up to make this easy for you. Nobody can tell you in advance what anything will cost. This advice here requires multiple kinds of obtuse codes to get specific definitions of the services you might need... but who knows what the doctor will actually recommend once you’re there?
I’m personally fortunate enough to have good insurance and mostly good experiences, but this crap is way too complicated. And we haven’t even touched on how hard it is to actually use my damn HSA....
Next time ask for a name and reference number when you call insurance. Then you can point to the exact moment you were misinformed.
It’s also ridiculous that the doctors office wouldn’t just honor a self pay rate. It’s completely arbitrary that they “already billed it”, they got no reimbursement from it anyway. If this happened in my office they would absolutely get a discount.
Usually if insurance denies something you can send in an appeal, in writing, and cite the wrong information you were given. If you had the date, time and name of the person you spoke with they should be able to find some record of it and hopefully honor what you were told. If the appeal gets denied I’d send a complaint to your states board of insurance (or whatever the regulatory office is called). They will contact the insurance company and try to get a resolution.
Alx0427 · 4 points · Posted at 06:29:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m sure they record all phone calls. You could subpoena the phone records. And then they’d have evidence and have to honor it.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:39:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
Alx0427 · 2 points · Posted at 18:22:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It’s not a criminal case. So there’s no such thing as statute of limitations
[deleted] · 77 points · Posted at 05:14:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So, what you're saying is that medical costs are 40% higher than they need to be because of insurance companies.
OK. Gotcha.
[deleted] · 61 points · Posted at 05:20:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Technically 250% higher. $100 bill for insurance is $40 but for you it’s $100.
Mitosis · 2 points · Posted at 12:25:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
While now it's largely "how things are," it came out because of group negotiating.
Insurance companies represent large numbers of people. They say hey, we represent this large number of potential customers, and if you work with us we'll say you're "in network" and refer all these customers to you, but in return we want a hefty discount. Hospital says sure we'll do that, then jacks up their "official" prices to offset the discount they just gave insurance companies.
It's also related to the fact that employers are tied into health insurance, because companies put all their employees under one easily-managed block for the insurance company to service and then use as clout in the above scenario. Since the overwhelming number of people are covered by their employer, they pay far less attention to what they're actually paying for health insurance, and that (combined with the basic need for health care at quick speeds) means there's little to no ability to shop around and let hospitals actually compete on price.
Employers are only tied into health insurance at all because of wage freezes during World War 2. A huge labor shortage arose due to the lower number of workers and higher demand for products because of the war, so wages were skyrocketing. The government froze wages as a result, but did not include fringe benefits (relatively rare at the time, or more benign things like PTO). In an attempt to attract employees companies started offering to pay for health insurance since they couldn't pay more actual cash. That's the real root of the nightmare we have today.
[deleted] · 9 points · Posted at 06:44:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But insurance also costs money. The whole insurance industry costs billions of dollars to run. That includes premiums, salaries, rents, advertising, costs of doing business, etc.
Who pays for all this? It's the consumer of course. If the consumer didn't have to pay for this, then the market should work to lower costs.
It's like when you eat at a restaurant. Instead of paying the bill, you forward the bill to your "food insurance" company who then works with the restaurant to lower your bill. But someone has to pay for this food insurance, the insurance workers' salaries, etc. Instead of the consumers just paying for their food, they have to pay for an entire industry.
This is all true, but I've never seen admin costs (all the costs you mentioned that aren't medical expenses) higher than 10% in any of the companies I've worked for.
Yes, that's why he mentioned the loss ratio. That's essentially the cut insurance companies are allowed to take to cover their own operating costs and profit.
Payments for physician services is 20%, but the average overhead ratio is 50%, so 10% of that goes to physician overhead, which is things like the rent for their office, their office staff (nurses, MAs, front desk personnel), electronic medical record system, etc. The physicians are getting about 10% of health care expenses, so even a giant 50% salary cut would be a 5% decrease in expenses.
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 07:09:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 8 points · Posted at 08:01:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Government does set prices for Medicare and Medicaid patients. The problem is that the prices they set are so low that we lose tons of money providing services to these patients. It is so bad that in my area of the country, many docs won't take Medicare, because they can't keep the doors open if they do.
Even in a large system, we have to limit the number of Medicare patients on a doctor's panel. If the ratio of Medicare to private insurance patients gets out of whack, we lose too much money. Lose too much money and we can't pay the bills and we close. Government set prices don't take those factors into account.
[deleted] · -3 points · Posted at 07:27:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is good in theory, until you consider what a GOP government would do with this power.
You think that for profit prisons are bad, imagine those same people in charge of price fixing for medical costs.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 07:59:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They already are. They're called executives and they're essentially third world dictators except with good infrastructure paid for by the public.
But didnt insurance companies start this escalating war? They needed to prove they worked so they started asking for discounts which the hospitals couldn't afford so they simply raised the prices artificially
no, they’re higher for the average consumer because of government programs meshing with an otherwise free market.
[deleted] · 8 points · Posted at 08:02:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol, like healthcare can be a "free market". Let's see you shop around for ambulance services when you fall and break your back.
I bet your aggressive cancer will be treated equally well under the cheapest possible clinic.
Healthcare is a completely captive market. And Health insurance is usually a captive market as well.
Healthcare, is infrastructure. Like roads and power and water and breathable air. It's, in my opinion, immoral to privatize and put a profit motive on that kind of thing.
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 08:23:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Maybe you should read a book, or ya know just look at the health outcomes of every developed country in the world that has a state run healthcare system.
ugh the one you google. start with The HSA Guidebook. The 13th edition is available online for free. Then I would suggest researching how medical payments work both under the primary medical plan and the pharmacy benefits. If you let me know what state you live in, I can recommend a personalized resource
edit: also make sure you read up on coordination of benefits on the statutory and federal level. pay special attention to medicare and domestic partners.
then, call a professional. because you clearly aren’t qualified to make an informed decision with the information you’ve reviewed as of this moment. they’ll help get you educated. please refer their services to others as well.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:39:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
my blood is boiling i am so frustrated at the lack of aptitude in this country. the problem is the citizens. ugh read a book.
My blood is boiling, you're acting like everyone's problems are illegitimate. You're the dumbass for supporting the FUCKING HORRIFIC status quo.
China has better free market healthcare than we do in America. We don't have a free market system of health care. The American medical system is one of the most heavily regulated systems in the country. That is one reason it is so expensive.
The idea of a free market system of healthcare in the US is a political talking point that is not based in reality.
Can you elaborate? Are you suggesting ERISA and the ACA, for example, disqualify the US healthcare system from being considered a free market? Because if so, that is insane. But if not, I’m interested to hear why you think we don’t have a free market. Is it Medicare? The IRS? Are you hung up on the word “free” and missing the definition of “free market” in this context?
My daughter went to China and bought 2 pair of glasses from a street vendor. The guy tested her, figured out her prescription, ground the lenses, and for the frames to her face. She paid the equivalent to $35 and had the glasses in under an hour.
This guy had no degree, no schooling - just equipment he was trained how to use. His advertising was word of mouth, and if he did a bad job, word gets around and he loses his business. That is free market.
Here, the same 2 pair of glasses required an optometrist with a degree and a license. The optometrist uses similar equipment to figure out the prescription, but he is not allowed to make the glasses. The prescription has to be sent to another party who is school trained and licensed to grind the glasses with the same equipment used by the Chinese guy.
If the guy grinding the glasses does a lousy job, you don't even know who did it so it is no big deal. If the optometrist does a bad job on the prescription it is OK, cause there are only 5 licensed optometrists in town, so go see the other guys and I'll still have a business 'cause I have a license and no one else can do it unless they go get the degree and license.
And since the optometrist still owes $150,000 to the university system and the guy that grinds the lenses still owes $60K to learn what the Chinese guy learned through an apprenticeship, you pay $500 for 2 pair of glasses and you have to wait 2 weeks to get them.
right and if your daughter had glaucoma, would that street vendor have caught it? diabetes? also, glasses hardware is an entirely separate issue because luxottica owns have the manufacturers and retail eyeware stores. idk where you shop but i get my glasses same-day in under two hours here in america. and to be honest, i’m not that concerned about the cost of the things i wear on my face every single day. worth it. the cost of education is also a separate issue, and irrelevant.
I didn't say anything about all that other stuff. You asked why I don't consider our healthcare system a free market. I told you. All that other stuff is the result of regulation. I didn't say it was bad, I just said it isn't "free market."
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to
Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you
4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make
A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
[deleted] · 7 points · Posted at 12:09:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This needs upvoted! From the legal side, if you absolutely just can't pay, paying only a little is a terrible idea. Your credit is already screwed but you're preventing the Statute of Limitations from possibly making the claim unenforceable after a period of time since new acknowledgements of a claim, including payment, almost always renew the SoL. That right there made me think this is not just bad advice but dangerous and even possibly malicious.
And this is why the U.S. healthcare system is a kafkaesque dystopia.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:57:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I see he deleted it so other people will likely not see your advice if they only read the original comment. I don’t think people understand how insane and bureaucratic hospital companies have become. Hospitals are overloaded with administrators whose only focus is profit.
Call your insurance first. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen billing mistakes. Do not pay any bill until you receive the EOB from insurance and can review it. You do not have to pay until you have the EOB. And if you can’t get a real explanation of why your claim was denied, escalate until you get a solid answer. Sometimes you need your doctor to do a peer review if something you really need is denied.
Payment plans are becoming less of an option. Hospitals will turn you to collections if you don’t pay the total monthly amount you agreed to if they do give you a payment option. However, I’ve seen up to 60% discounts to pay full balance with a credit card.
The point of care tests cost a hell of a lot more than $6 depending on the kind you buy. I think the cheapest test I have is $7, but that’s what I pay for it. I usually get paid about $15 for that test. That covers my managers time to order the supply, my nurse’s time/expertise to collect the sample, run it and document it, and my time to interpret the test and what to do about the result.
Same with my cheapest injectable. Probably the cheapest I could give it and not lose money would be $15, but I would not make any money for my time on deciding it was needed and determining the correct dose.
Doctors who own their own practice are not like hospitals. If you don’t pay your bill, you’re basically not paying that doctor for their work. Or you may be making them lose money, because they still had to pay for the staff/rent and buy the supply they used when they saw you. Which is why so many doctors don’t do primary care or go work for a hospital. That means all of us are seeing worsening preventative care, more serious health issues that are far more expensive to treat and increasing predatory billing practices from the large hospitals.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 21:39:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Exactly! And NEVER pay the collection agency. You're out of money now & the bill is never applied to YOUR medical bill. A fraction goes toward the hospital bill & the collection agency keeps the rest! Just walk away! ...and don't let paper ( threatening letters) scare you! They won't take you to court, it's too expensive for them. And if you get a lien on the debt, still keep walking! Most bills-gone 7 years, a lien is gone in 10. Happened to me (bad divorce) & after 7 years a $90k debt, proof! Gone! One creditor put a lien on part of it but you can't get blood from a turnip! I've since gotten credit cards, bought a home & my credit score is 700. Good enough to rebuild my life!
[deleted] · 24 points · Posted at 04:50:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I had my appendix taken out when I was younger I walked in the door with a sore stomach and was in surgery a few hours later then went home the next day and didn't really think much about it cause it was free.
It doesn't hurt you, this is how we build a sustainable society, with people looking out for each other. This will come back to repay you a hundred times over.
[deleted] · 42 points · Posted at 04:39:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I mainly meant my bonus. It’s always huge from everyone getting sick and paying too much. I’ll take a huge hit on that to make sure people feel safe and cared for. It’s what I wish others would do for me if they were in my position.
Muh Busness bad hurr durr, lets give actual billionaires who made their fortune through business, enough power to get drunk out off, they will surely only do what is best for us.
They surely wont use it for any evil, nuh uh.
Look even if Berny did mean well, he would not be able to accomplish half of what he claims.
Profit is power, companies only look for profit because its the means they have to achieve power. The government is for power and they can circumvent the means.
brb-ww2 · 21 points · Posted at 05:27:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good god, can we just fix this obviously broken medical system ffs?
You say candidates like it is plural. The Biden, Buttigieg and Warren plans are "Medicare for All (who want it)". They are a bunch of nonsense designed to make sure health insurance providers can still profit billions off of a broken system and have an implementation that makes sure it gets gutted post midterms. Their plans all start with bullshit compromise.
There is only one candidate that is advocating single payer medicare and it is Bernie Sanders.
Please stop believing candidates that make claims that people like their insurance companies.
My question is, even if we vote someone in who actually wants to make the kind of changes we need, how on earth do we actually expect them to succeed in making those changes with so many career politicians in office who just want to maintain their own personal status quo? Most politicians just want to keep their jobs. They're not interested in making anything better for anyone but themselves. Even if we all voted in a great leader, our system is so messed up, they wouldn't be able to accomplish anything.
Warren's plan is a longer medicare transition than Bernie's plan which vastly empowers the public option, unlike Biden and Buttigieg's plans which empower insurance plans vs the public option.
True. If you go to congress already at a compromising position there is no place to go in the negotiation but closer to the other side of single payer. Bernie starts out in the strong position of all private healthcare should be illegal, and will have to compromise to make a deal on healthcare, yet from a much stronger position, which in the end will get all Americans a better deal in the end.
Amen. There's only one option with integrity the last 40 years and it's a slam dunk obvious choice
12358 · 2 points · Posted at 12:53:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren's plan is proposed to be implemented in year 3. In other words, it's sure to not be implemented after the House changes hands in the midterm elections. Warren's numbers are plummeting because people are realizing that she is either naive or has become a tool of the Democratic establishment and their desire to maintain business as usual. The differences between Warren and Sanders are becoming more evident as the campaigns move on.
someone should tell the poor Germans and French that they don't have real universal healthcare because its not single payer and multi payer doesnt count
In case you weren't aware, Medicare is still costly. You have a 20% copay on nearly everything up to a certain limit. Plenty of older folks are still going broke with Medicare. A better option is socialized medicine.
No, Medicare for All is a government insurance system where the government provides insurance. Socialized medicine is a government healthcare system where the government provides healthcare.
Problem is that a decent healthcare system will take multiple administrations and presidential terms to establish. Meaning that it will be torn apart eventually.
Insurance companies etc. also seem to have their hooks deep in the U.S legislation, and people in U.S are fed a lot of propaganda on how healthcare for all is communism. It has it's flaws and weaknesses, which is why countries who deployed it have spent decades on improving their healthcare models.
No that's the long term strategy that might not work. The realistic strategy is to get yourself some kind of high-demand qualifications and move to a country with civilised healthcare.
"No one knows what they are talking about. It is complicated, there's no argument for people who REALLY understand this."
Says the fucking dude who elaborates on nothing or backs his claim up.
Fuck off. Americans have suffered for too long. There is NO debate. A single payer is literally cheaper and doesn't bankrupt 400,000 people a year. We need a single-payer.
it’s almost midnight here and i need to get back to my job as a professional consultant in the industry early in the morning. do you have specific questions you’d like me to answer in the next 10 min? i’d prefer you do a little research first, for a baseline understanding of the system so as not to waste as much of my time, in the interest of having as productive a conversation as possible if it comes to that. you’re 100% wrong in the numbers you’re throwing out there and that is absolute fact. please educate yourself a little more if you’d like to engage further. i don’t have time for this but at the same time feel the need to spend the few and far between moments i find worth it to at least spread the word that america needs to be a little less blind. everyone should be doing research, act as their own advocates, and stop with this crap
EDIT: single payer is cheaper 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 07:48:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
All I see is that you have zero arguments to back up your bullshit claim. Every single country in the world with universal healthcare pays less than the US does per capita.
ksande13 · -3 points · Posted at 08:12:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
mm yeah, quick response before i fall asleep: those countries weren’t founded on capitalism and don’t have PBMs and insurers negotiating for formulary placement and upcharging for repackaging. not absorbing the cost to stay afloat due to programs like CHIP and medicare. you cannot unravel a system as intricate as the US healthcare system and save money within the first decade at a minimum. doctors in the US are already vastly underpaid in this market in comparison to the average debt taken on to achieve the degrees and practices they’ve worked for. if they’re paid even less (guaranteed in every outline presented by future candidates), the quality of care is inevitably going to drop. we are already at a deficit and with lower pay that will only increase. also, this whole situation is a combination of cycles that aren’t factors in the other countries you reference. are you familiar with how insurers pay claims in the US? this is specific to america. for any services of decent value, it’s based on an inflated percentage of medicare because medicare is forcing providers and facilities to accept payments below what’s appropriate for the market. the private sector is keeping things afloat in the meantime, absorbing the hit to the market government programs have caused. i’m not saying government programs are bad, i’m just saying it’s more complicated than people realize and the fix isn’t what the average american believes will fix the system they don’t understand. this system is not set up like other countries and can’t just convert to other models. it would be a very rocky few decades, best case scenario, if one of the proposed single payer systems were to pass in the next few years. during that time, costs would be astronomical and the quality of care would decline
[deleted] · 7 points · Posted at 08:32:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Those countries weren't founded op capitalism? The fuck are you talking about?
You're telling me that the richest and most powerful country on earth can't effectively enact healthcare reform? Bullshit.
did i say those words in that second part of your claim? i’m quite confident i did not. also, pretty “rich” to claim the US is the richest country in earth with all this debt......
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:26:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Virtually every single country in the world has massive debt. That's just how the global economy works. The US has the highest GDP in the world.
You do realize that your pathetic stance literally kills people right? That you are supporting the death of tens of thousands just because you don't like Bernie Sanders? You do get it, don't you?
Every other country has free healthcare. It works. Grow up.
Just mad because you won't have a job shaking money from dying people anymore you scumbag. We get it. You're an insurance employee and it upsets you to know you so a pointless and useless job. Too bad kiddo
nah my job is secure either way. prob make more money if we moved to a single payer. people pay a lot for actual professionals to help fix major screw ups like that
Then you're shit at your job, pal. No other way to put it. Or maybe, giving you the benefit of the doubt, you're so used to a broken, unfair, exploiting system that you can't imagine healthcare without it. In that case open a book and study how the NHS, the SSN, the Canadian healthcare works.
noooope.
first of all, you are in no position to evaluate my proficiency or effectiveness at my job, given that you are clearly not a professional in the industry, nor do you know me.
next, what you’re missing is we have the same goal. the difference is how to effectively get there. why am i still awake? i guess i’ll admit that my ADHD (that is medically controlled during my on-call and billable hours) has me so frustrated by this. also, idk click on my shit and look at my comment that i made earlier that addresses your misguided comment. i hope you find it bc this is exhausting and a waste of my time... yes i realize i said i was going to bed earlier but ADD and insomnia changes things sometimes so cut me some slack.
also, PSA DONT go to canada for joint replacements. not only does it suck for the replacements to be delayed and inadequate...it’s EXPENSIVE and sometimes not covered by US plans (or any other major first-world country, ever) to correct (bc provider/DME error is an exclusion since it’s not ullness or injury and should be covered by malpractice insurance).
just...don’t leave the US for medical treatment unless it’s minor. or at least consult the centers for excellence first.
i mean unless you are otherwise 100% healthy and happened to shatter your knee in colombia, as a colombian citizen, or something, you make less than a decent wage, and colombia will pay to replace your knee for free... i would not recommend seeking care outside the US. (obvious other exception is if you have a rare disease and need to find a rare specialist overseas)
Of course you should not leave the US for medical treatment if you are a US citizen, what the fuck? I am talking about citizens of other countries having free healthcare, and that the US could do the same easily. But thanks to lobbying and corrupt politicians we are stuck with an inadequate, old, incredibly expensive (both for taxpayers and sick individuals!!!!!) and unfair "insurance" system.
Senator Sanders' plan is the only real plan to tackle this. Free healthcare for all. And fuck health insurance.
absolutely NOT. i want the opposite, but it’s good to receive confirmation you aren’t educated on this subject matter. research how medical services are paid for in the US between insurers, plan administrators, and government-funded programs and get back to me. good talk.
[deleted] · -3 points · Posted at 07:43:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:46:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Of course this fucking topic is political. People are going homeless or dying because of this. Your government is filled with evil or incompetent pieces of shit for letting this happen.
100% agree. if this thread is still active tomorrow, please remind me to elaborate with specifics. it’s so sad how the majority of the country doesn’t understand how the healthcare system works. and let me clarify, i’m NOT saying there isn’t a problem. i’m saying the problem won’t be properly fixed until more people understand it and can work toward a proper solution
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 08:04:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
i shouldn’t admit this right now but i agree. everything’s either free or taxed at a premium around here. 13+% income tax in CA (or even FORMERLY in CA—could be a resident of a different state for years and still required to pay CA income tax even without owning or residing in a property in CA) for some but free healthcare/health insurance for illegal aliens, yes, in many cases those not paying any taxes in CA. This is just one example in this particular state but there are similar problems across the nation. it’s not the lack of voting it’s the lack of INFORMED voting happening in this country. RESEARCH BEFORE VOTING. and i mean REALLY research. don’t just read what candidates claim or what the main media outlets publish. They publish that for the uninformed american. be an informed american.
And to clarify, I have no issues with immigrants. Happy to welcome them all. But I’m not going to favor their free healthcare over the legal tax-paying citizens who fund that in the first place. Everyone should have access to quality care, but there’s a right way to accomplish that and we aren’t headed that direction until people start to read up.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:46:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes, for 10 years. although i will admit for 5 of those years i was a supervisor/manager and the clientele was wealthy, so it might differ from a server’s experience in sandusky, OH for example
zxcsd · 1 points · Posted at 10:23:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm gonna downvote you, I don't have the time or inclination right now to explain why as I lead a busy life, but trust me you're wrong.
I’m an analyst in the healthcare sector and I hope this helps. I know every single cost associated with seeing you as a patient.
If your claim was denied by insurance as 100% patient responsibility contact the billing department and request a self pay bill. It will be roughly 30-40% of the original invoice received.
If you get labs that are denied do the same thing but contact the lab service that billed you rather than the doctors office. Self pay pay rates are about 20% of what the original invoice was.
A vast majority of medical providers will not send you to collections If you stay in contact with them. Most organizations write off all unpaid claims at 12-18 months so they will accept anything you give them.
Almost every single injection or drug administered through needle or IV will get reimbursed less than $1 by insurance unless it’s a vaccine. Fight those the hardest. Insurance pays about 2% of what was billed.
The best thing you can do is delay the payment as long as possible if you can’t afford it. This way bad debt and adjustments have been factored in and they will thank you for your payment rather than demanding it.
Supplies used on you cost roughly $6. This includes all disposables and swab tests.
Average single doctor rates are $105-$120 for an MD and $50 for an NP/PA per hour. If you get a mid level you can fight the cost more as most insurance groups already charge a discount of 15-25% for mid levels.
Front desk averages $10-$15
Clinical averages $13-$19
Factor that into your required assistance.
Please note that some providers will be different, the main point is work with them and have any denied claims billed again through self pay to drastically reduce costs. Hope this helps some people.
I know Healthcare in the US is fucked but this will help in the meantime.
Send me a direct message if you have questions on an invoice. I can help you fight it. I know every single price point out there and can give you an idea of what the things you got done were actually worth. In the end the provider only cares about EBITDA which can be offset by those covered by insurance. Please don’t feel stuck, all medical bills are 100% negotiable.
Edit: if you’ve already been to that location before you are considered an established patient and insurance will pay roughly 75% of what is normally paid. Use this to your advantage.
This post was removed because everything shared was wrong and horrible advice....
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you 4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
If your insurance only pays 10% of an out of network bill they expect the provider to forgive the rest. When the provider just bills you the remaining balance it turns into a fight
For example, if your hospital is in network, your surgeon is in network and your gas passer is not you get a nice $2k bill for the anesthesiologist that your insurance will only pay $200
“In case you weren't aware, Medicare is still costly. You have a 20% copay on nearly everything up to a certain limit. Plenty of older folks are still going broke with Medicare. A better option is socialized medicine”
I'm a physician and I agree with most of it. BUT beware, if you want to save a little money upfront seeing a midlevel (NP or PA) over a physician, you are going to get what you pay for. PAs and particularly NPs have a tiny fraction the training of a doctor. They're great for very straightforward simple cases. The problem is that it's tiny differences that often distinguish the proper workup, diagnosis, and treatment. They don't have adequate pathophysiology or pharmacology to make this distinction. Sorry you cannot cram that amount of education into a 2 year NP program that requires 500 clinical training hours (vs 4 years of medical school and 15-25000 hours training for a doctor). So again, great for straightforward stuff but hopefully it's actually straightforward. Also because they lack that training they tend to order unnecessary tests and place unnecessary consults to specialists much much more commonly than a doctor. This often defeats the purpose of trying to save money using them. There are bad doctors out there but the average doctor is way ahead of the average midlevel.
So just be aware of that possibility that you aren't getting an equivalent of a doctor for cheaper, you're paying less for a reason. There are also states that unfortunately let them practice independently without a doctor and in many situations they dont have a doctor to fall back on or won't ask for help due to being overly confident.
I work with some great midlevels but I also have serious reservations about them as someone who has gone through extensive medical education with a spouse in nursing.
Meh. I see a lot of opinion in this response being presented as fact. The statistics and research on NP care in the U.S. contradicts the claims that you've made. The truth is that there is a serious lack of providers in many countries and utilizing advanced practice providers, like NPs and PAs, would go a long way towards helping people to receive quality healthcare. I find that many MDs have no problem hiring NPs to care for patients or entering supervisory contracts in the states that require them because it earns them more money. Until we're honest about the financial stake that MDs have in preventing advanced practice providers from working independently so that more people can be helped, then we're not really going to decrease costs of care significantly in this country as they relate to health outcomes and provider costs.
As far as OP's point regarding NPs/PAs, many MD clinics use specific billing practices to ensure that they receive the same bill rate for a NP as a MD. Unless you are in a state where NPs have independent practice (as far as I know, no states allow PAs to practice independently), then this tip from the OP is unlikely to work.
The "research" that NPs provide equal care as MDs is weak, and does not hold up to any real world anecdotes.
Physicians who hire NPs for their practice are doing so because it makes them more money, not because it's the right decision for their patients.
The answer to our healthcare problems are increasing residency positions. Not a half measure of making more and more NPs. The "payroll" of physicians are a minor cost in healthcare.
Yeah but NPs usually have hours of clinical experience as nurses, so it’s not like it’s ONLY 500 clinical hours. There’s more experience behind it. I can’t speak for PAs.
They’re working directly with doctors to treat patients. They see all sorts of diagnoses and the way they present firsthand. I’m an MA but I’ve been working in the same specialty long enough that I can guess the diagnosis and treatment before the doctor comes in.
That kind of thinking is very low level though. I remember being a scribe for years before medical school. I thought the job was easy then. Now I realize how little I really knew.
I don’t mean to sound antagonistic, but I have to ask: do you make more money if PAs and NPs don’t take as many cases, and they only go to doctors? Where I’m from, it seems like the doctors are not fans of the mid levels because they view them as competition. We have issues in my country because we don’t have enough mid levels allowed to do enough jobs and therefore there are very long waiting lists. Even though mid levels seem like a logical solution, the doctors fight it.
No, I mean if we literally have the word-for-word same exact visit the physician gets compensated (and charges) more than I do. I've worked in places where an MD will pop their head in for 5 seconds with a patient seen by a PA so they can get their name on the chart and it gets paid out at the MD rate instead of the PA rate.
One of the clear benefits of productivity analysis that is based on CPT codes and RVU is that it is standardized. The work is given the same amount of credit no matter who provides the care. Therefore, physicians, NPs, and PAs are all accounted for identically when a CPT code and RVU is used to measure them. Even if reimbursement rates may be discounted for NPs and PAs, the CPT and RVU are not.
Even if the visit is word for word, it is not the same care. A residency trained physician is considering more things and has a higher level of understanding of a clinical presentation. Patients pay a premium for that care.
American doctors are generally overtrained and overqualified for what they have to do. I mean obviously it's good to have elite doctors in major hospitals, but most medical professionals do not need such a high level of expertise to provide effective care to patients.
I only use my insurance for emergencies. Screw the deductible. Literally my bill is the same if they bill my insurance or not.
So now I tell docs I am self pay, give them a story how I am working hard on my own business, but I am not rich, but can pay my bills.
The rates I get are 10X less than the insurance.
I keep my insurance in case I have to go into the hospital on a big charge and only use it this way. I even ask "what is this going to cost if I pay now".
I use medical insurance like car insurance, only if I get into something big.
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 07:49:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact that you have to do that at all is fucked up.
Meanwhile either you or your employer is spending hundreds of dollars a month on your policy.
Every time I've used my insurance I still had to pay $2-3k cause its less than my deductible.
SO WHATS THE POINT OF THE $344/MONTH AVMED YOU PIECES OF SHIT
I'd be so much better off telling insurance to fuck off and putting $344/month into a savings account to pay everything out of pocket. Except Obama forced us all to buy insurance.
What a fucked situation we got here
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 06:51:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best way to pay for health insurance is to vote for Bernie Sanders so we can get the Medicare for All act passed.
for 1 and 2, then that won't come off your insurance deductible. Depending on your future bills, you are better off not doing self-pay.
I had to pay for a ER visit, and it was a large bill but entirely deductible, so I paid it all out of pocket. The hospital refused any reduction, and refused any payment plan, because "I had insurance".
It's easier than you'd think at least and I managed to get a couple of Americans to move to live here :) To quote them recently when I jokingly asked "what's the american dream nowadays anyway?" one of them smiled and said "To live here". They seem pretty happy and there weren't that much hurdles.
Also, most hospitals provide financial assistance. Always apply if you are having a hard time paying or know you qualify. The qualifying income levels are typically on their website. Some are very generous even if you have insurance. I know someone with nearly a million dollars in medical debt erased because he had a limited income. I have gotten 50% discounts.
Should I just call and say “ hey I was wondering if I can get a self pay bill instead, as my insurance didn’t cover it?”
I have a LOT of bills my insurance didn’t cover from my pregnancy. I seriously think they make insurance so complicated on purpose!
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 04:33:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes! If your insurance denied it call them and they will rebill under self pay (cash/card rate). I’m sorry that happened to you but I hope this helps. Keep negotiating as long as you can. They’d rather receive $1 than tell their board they wrote off another claim in full.
conez4 · 3 points · Posted at 06:44:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who are the "they"s you keep referring to? Call insurance company and demand the self pay, or call the healthcare practice?
I would assume they meant the health care providers' billing department, as I take it that once your insurance claim is denied, that's pretty much them washing their hands off of your case.
I think hospital/ doctor. The insurance already said no and the one you owe money to now is the hospital. At least I am planning to call the hospital that’s charging me.
I'd call the hospital and doctor billing department(s) and say something like 'I'm wondering if you guys offer a self-pay discount for people without insurance. If so, could you refund my insurance company and reprocess as self-pay.'
Even if there's nothing to "refund" because your claim was denied, it will let the rep know you're looking to have the adjustments removed from your account for reprocessing.
Please be aware that you will need to do this for every single denial you receive. The hospital billing dept probably won't contact the provider billing departments to let them know to re-bill. As an example, when a patient would call the facility(surgical center/hospital/etc) to update their insurance with them, the facility would not contact me (offsite anesthesia group billing) to update and reprocess. This also might cause an issue if the facility has different billing practices than a provider you saw. Some hospitals offered great discounts for self-pay, but because the providers didn't have a similar fee schedule, only the facility cost would be reduced.
It may not always work, but it certainly doesn't hurt to ask. The billing department should be familiar enough with this question to give you an answer as to whether it's possible for them to do. But if your provider uses a third-party billing company, you may end up talking to someone in customer service instead of someone in the A/R department, and the customer service rep may not be able to answer your question.
Anyway, sorry for the long response. It all depends on various possibilities.
I am not sure why op deleted this entire post (apparently while I was reading it), but here is copy/paste:
I’m an analyst in the healthcare sector and I hope this helps. I know every single cost associated with seeing you as a patient.
If your claim was denied by insurance as 100% patient responsibility contact the billing department and request a self pay bill. It will be roughly 30-40% of the original invoice received.
If you get labs that are denied do the same thing but contact the lab service that billed you rather than the doctors office. Self pay pay rates are about 20% of what the original invoice was.
A vast majority of medical providers will not send you to collections If you stay in contact with them. Most organizations write off all unpaid claims at 12-18 months so they will accept anything you give them.
Almost every single injection or drug administered through needle or IV will get reimbursed less than $1 by insurance unless it’s a vaccine. Fight those the hardest. Insurance pays about 2% of what was billed.
The best thing you can do is delay the payment as long as possible if you can’t afford it. This way bad debt and adjustments have been factored in and they will thank you for your payment rather than demanding it.
Supplies used on you cost roughly $6. This includes all disposables and swab tests.
Average single doctor rates are $105-$120 for an MD and $50 for an NP/PA per hour. If you get a mid level you can fight the cost more as most insurance groups already charge a discount of 15-25% for mid levels.
Front desk averages $10-$15
Clinical averages $13-$19
Factor that into your required assistance.
Please note that some providers will be different, the main point is work with them and have any denied claims billed again through self pay to drastically reduce costs. Hope this helps some people.
I know Healthcare in the US is fucked but this will help in the meantime.
Send me a direct message if you have questions on an invoice. I can help you fight it. I know every single price point out there and can give you an idea of what the things you got done were actually worth. In the end the provider only cares about EBITDA which can be offset by those covered by insurance. Please don’t feel stuck, all medical bills are 100% negotiable.
Edit: if you’ve already been to that location before you are considered an established patient and insurance will pay roughly 75% of what is normally paid. Use this to your advantage.
I suck at formatting but that's what they wrote. I also screenshotted it but haven't put it up anywhere.
I had myocarditis and a pericardial effusion a few years ago. I needed a week in hospital, a visit to a specialised hospital for a chest MRI, a few x-rays, ultrasounds and a lot of medicine.
How much did I spend out of pocket? £0, because we have universal healthcare here. I couldn’t work for 2 months, and not having to worry about medical bills is an absolute Godsend.
There are definitely “health tourists” in the NHS. They amount to a ridiculously tiny percentage of the budget. So what if “welfare leeches”, of which there aren’t many, use universal healthcare? Why are you so opposed to your fellow man having access to healthcare without crippling bills?
Or, we can look at it as, pay for the working citizens that would either go bankrupt over their deductible because they can’t afford monthly rates without a deductible. Or families who have kids with pre existing congenital problems who struggle to get coverage. The “illegals and welfare leeches” are such a small minority of healthcare recipients.
Also, another thought is, you’re paying for them anyway. Hospitals can’t deny patients. Hospitals will charge insurances more to cover cost of loss which drives up the private insurance prices. Under even a single payer system prices would go down...way down. I’d rather pay or be taxed $200 a month and my parents taxed $200 a month for us all to have healthcare coverage... rather than my parents current $1600/month and my current $500/month with a 6k deductible. It’s really bullshit how this country handles their own citizens. We should treat ourselves better considering we are one of the leaders of worldwide economies.
bUt dA iLLeGaLz. We’d rather see them (and citizens) suffer than to see hardworking citizens not struggle amirite? Let’s stick to the petty point amirite??
Lol nobody outside America appreciates America's healthcare system.
I'm from a 3rd world country and I have to watch out not to get injured when I'm in America because of the costs. Meanwhile at home I would get treated for free and so would you.
if you’ve already been to that location before you are considered an established patient and insurance will pay roughly 75% of what is normally paid. Use this to your advantage.
Sorry, can you expand on this? So they pay less than if you're a new patient? Also thank you for this write-up. Our healthcare is fucked, but ensuring more people understand it is an important step in unfucking it and protecting themselves.
All I took from this is that health insurance companies in the US are marking everything up by between 20-40% because... they can? Apparently that's perfectly ok?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:05:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
After 20+ round of elections, not really impressed by the results lol. Really naive to think its easily fixable by voting and not by protests which cripples the govt that they accept demands. That concept is alien to Americans now
_Druss_ · 10 points · Posted at 06:09:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or vote for Bernie and catch up with the rest of the worldaa
A lot of this is incredibly generalized and very misleading.
I’d encourage readers to do some additional research before accepting this as gospel.
Source: Also in the healthcare sector.
[deleted] · 13 points · Posted at 04:45:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I agree with the more research but it’s not misleading. Bad debt is a huge part of healthcare. All of this is to be taken with a grain of salt. It all depends on how well they can work things out with the provider/Insurance.
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 06:25:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I delivered my baby early & unexpectedly at a hospital that has its own health insurance pretty much (Intermountain in Utah) and ive been assured multiple times everyone is in network.... weeks after I get a letter that the doctor who delivered is filing an appeal for me because of ALL the people in the hospital, HE wasn’t on my actual plan (he was covered by 9/10 plans offered by the insurance company/hospital except mine!) haha! But it was an emergency & it was covered but what a headache
It is misleading, though. Like saying a "swab test" costs $6 in supplies. We run all of our Flu/RSV and streps off of "swabs" (viral/bacterial transport media kits), and while THOSE might cost $6, the cartridges for the tests themselves are much, much more.
So someone gets a strep test (or a respiratory panel) done thinking it only costs six bucks because they think "Hey, all they did was take a swab!" But they have no idea that back in the lab we're running PCR on their DNA with an instrument that cost a few hundred thousand and kits that cost a few hundred to a few thousand.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 07:17:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Seems like the way the medical industry is set up is pretty misleading, considering the amount of regular people who mistake who is accountable for what
Absolutely, I agree. It's an almost insurmountable maze. I was just addressing this one point, though. (FWIW, I think we should have Healthcare for all.)
[deleted] · 5 points · Posted at 05:03:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not if you convince them to keep delaying it. Worst case ask for a payment plan with the max amount of months available. They will always work with you.
I once had a patient pay off a $500 bill in $25 monthly payments. It’s obviously different for every office but as long as you’re making payments on time and staying in contact we literally don’t care.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 10:30:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My hospital was very very different from this, and I wish that OP and you would not lead others to believe that your experiences are how it always goes.
Only if it's sent to collections. That's when it gets reported to your credit reports. This applies to any bills, such as your electric, gas, phone, etc.
As I understand it, most medical places would rather get paid something than send it to collections, where they'll get pennies on the dollar for the bill. By staying in contact with the billing department, they usually would be happy to work with you. It's when folks ignore their calls/letters is when they have no other recourse but to try and recoup their losses through a collection agency.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 10:32:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not true. My husband had a medical service that was billed to his insurance improperly. He was calling both the insurance and the hospital 2-3 × per week, constantly staying on them about fixing it. That shit got sent to collections. Nobody gave a fuck.
Sometimes it is true tho. My wife has been paying $25 a month on a $8000 hospital bill for years now, can't even remember what the bill was for now. It was all she could afford at the time. It'll never get paid off but it's not on her credit report.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:28:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wish I would’ve known some of this a couple of years ago. Have an hsa, needed surgery, cost me my 10k deductible and totally drained my hsa account. So are you saying I maybe could’ve negotiated that 10k down? Haven’t even been able to fund my hsa since. Oh and my premium is going up..again. Since I started my plan in 2009 my premium has gone up over 350%. But it’s still cheaper than what most people pay and I can’t find anything cheaper. I’ve tried. What really sucks is that beyond that one surgery, we never use our insurance. Family of four, all healthy, do one well visit a year and in ten years we’ve had one hospital visit for me and my surgery. It’s just insanity.
While I agree that healthcare needs some reform, you really can't complain about college costs here. College costs are rising higher and higher every year directly opposite to that of yearly inflation because of the proliferation of government backed loans.
Why do colleges charge such high premium for getting an education? Because they can, and government will loan you money to pay that premium price.
GegaMan · 1 points · Posted at 02:19:28 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes I can complain about both. government are also in on this. rich people and politicians are related.
What if I'm broke (but had insurance thru my job) and had to go to the ER for a broken bone and still got billed $2,600? I can't afford $200 let alone $2,600.
This will probably get buried but I wanted to note that if you are uninsured and a victim of a crime, you can apply for the federal victims of crime program (in the USA). The main requirement being that you have to have a case # from filing a police report. It can help get medical bills and sometimes other things covered.
I’m so glad I don’t live in the US, medical bills sound scary as fuck. I live in the UK, keep your hands off the NHS please!
op3l · 3 points · Posted at 08:59:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's hilarious that there needs to be an explanation about how to pay for what is basically a necessity of life.. and people still defend the system in the US like it's working fine.
Does any of this apply to dental implants and other work? I have so much dental work that needs done and I'm afraid it's going to kill me before I can even think about getting it handled.
The reason I ask is because I have heard that dental implants are considered "cosmetic" and I have 3 teeth that are broken off at the gumline - I'm terrified that the roots are infected.
Most dental is considered cosmetic. Even a root canal isn't completely covered. You still pay about $1,500-$1,800 for the endodondist & another $1,000-$1,200 for a crown. They last for 10-15 years (hopefully) then get infected & require replacement. Insurance covers about $500 for the entire process. An implant costs about $1,500-$3,000, depending on where you live & is NOT covered by insurance. I dropped dental coverage several years ago. I go to new dental clinic openings that offer newcomer specials. You can find free to $99 cleanings & screenings almost everywhere. I had 2 root canals removed & had implants put in both. I spent $3000 for both of them from a local dentist I received a mailing from. Best thing ever. Getting a full set of single implants would be expensive. Some newer versions have 4-6 teeth in each implant quadrant & are cheaper than individual implants. But doing one a year for $1,500 is very doable if you're saving the money from your canceled dental policy. See a dentist for a screening, you don't have to commit to their plan but you can get antibiotics to stop an infection. Don't let it go into an abcess. You'll need emergency treatment that involves surgery & it's not cheap! Some cheap antibiotics could literally save you thousands of dollars! Get that checked out & best of luck to you!
I have to disagree with #4. Injectables are extremely expensive. I'm in the healthcare industry as well and have a child on hemophiliac medication enrolled under a 340b pricing plan, and it's still costing the insurance plan $1.2 million annually.
Good tips, I worked in ER and hospital billing for 7 years and I'm glad to see this knowledge being spread.
This will get buried because this post has been up for so long but also keep in mind ER rates are insane and your insurance can deny emergency claims! Don't get stuck with an ER bill for something that was not an emergency! Do not go to the ER for something minor like a cold, mild injuries, etc. Make an appointment to see a doctor or go to a walk in clinic. Just because your condition was minor does not mean the bill will be. At my ER in a low income area it was $499 just to walk in the door for the lowest ESI.
Is it normal for ERs to present you with a bill and credit card machine while you're in bed waiting to be seen by a doctor but after you're in the gown and have been prepped for iv (so you can't leave at this point but they won't let you see a Dr of you don't pay)? I had my daughter (18) in there for something (I had wanted to wait for a Dr visit but my daughter insisted) and sad shocked at the insensitivity. Shouldn't the priority in an "emergency" room be on care, not getting paid?
Please understand that I'm not aiming my frustration at you. You just did your job and I'm sure you didn't deal with patients like this. I guess I'm just asking/venting.
Unfortunately that's completely normal. I can't speak to all hospitals but for ours as soon as they start that basic questionnaire you are given a room and then typically a nurse triages you. As soon as you have been triaged and you receive a preliminary once over, unless you are medically unstable you are legally able to be registered and billed. You are not legally able to be refused service though if you don't pay IF that service is deemed medically necessary. Did they use the actual wording that you would be refused treatment if you didn't pay or did they just imply it? Because if they used that actual wording that is in violation of EMTALA.
HOWEVER, if you enter the ER and the doctor deems that your reason for being there is not urgent you will be asked to sign a form saying that you need to pay if you want to continue receiving treatment. This was very rarely done in my ER, its pretty much frowned upon because it makes people angry (no suprise).
Another shitty thing is that EMTALA, while it protects patients, also prevents you from doing anything that would discourage you to seek treatment based on your ability to pay. So we legally can't go over billing in detail with the patients beforehand because it might be deemed as a deterrent. Now why can't we ask after? Well, most ERs are judged on their wait time for everything, including time you enter to time you leave the ER and metrics on how long it takes you to be registered. In my ER we were expected to see most people within 15min of them receiving the preliminary exam. If your times get too long you WILL be fired. Additionally, as soon as the doctor clears the patient the nurses are trying to get them out as fast as possible. They will not put up with a registrar slowing them down to ask billing information. I've seen nurses just send people home before we even get an address. Obviously that's not supposed to happen but it does.
So yeah, whole system is broke IMO and I'm so glad to be out of there. But it sucks because most people have no idea what they are getting into going to the ER.
Edit: I should add that I've heard of these new laws that require ERs to post the prices in clear view in the ER. I haven't looked into those at all because I left billing years ago but that might change some things.
Thank you for taking the time to reply in such detail.
It was implied that the Dr wouldn't be in until we'd taken care of the billing. It just felt wrong and if she wasn't already laying there in a gown with a tube in her arm, I would have told them we were leaving.
I gotta ask, where did you get all of the knowledge?
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 04:14:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I do all the finances for a massive healthcare firm. We talk to almost everyone in the industry and they have similar practices. It’s all private though, no public companies. Most healthcare providers are not public though for various reasons, only insurance groups are public. For reference, BCBS has a max 85% expense rate for premiums received so anything beyond that gets sent back to employers (employers keep it all, employees benefit 0% from this)
NOOOOO no no no don’t do most of these if you have private insurance. DONT DO THIS
EDIT: i cannot stress this enough but this information is so completely flawed. it may be true in certain scenarios in a small region but DO NOT follow this advice without further research. this could not be more untrue in CA, for example.
When you get the bill, call and just ask. If they say no then end the call and try again a couple weeks later. You’ll either eventually find someone willing to make the adjustment, or enough time will pass and you can just stop calling.
or enough time will pass and you can just stop calling.
as in.. you were sent to collections?
This wouldn't have worked for most of the provider groups I billed for because our system would automatically send a list of patients who hadn't paid in 90/120 days to collections. Part of my job was to go through the big list each month and pull all of the accounts that had Medicaid because we weren't allowed to send anyone with Medicaid to collections. I'm not sure if it was a state or federal policy though because my provider groups were all in-state, but every group my company billed for had the same monthly list of accounts that would either be placed into collections or, if the provider didn't have a contract with a collection agency, the account would be sent to a separate database to remove it from our list of unpaid accounts. Perhaps you dealt with a provider that didn't use a collection agency?
What seems to have happened is that as long as we stayed in contact with them they would not send us to collections. Even if they did send us to collections we’d still call the collections company and offer the same thing. Eventually they usually settle, and when we settle we asked them to remove any entries on our credit report as part of the settlement.
Has worked for us 100% of the time so far and we still have no derogatory entries on our credit reports.
If you get care at a nonprofit hospital, they’re required to provide some charity care every year. Ask for documentation on their charity program.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 05:18:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't forget to ask for detailed billing. I know of somebody who was charged for doses of insulin that was enough to kill three people and when they asked for a detailed billing they got it reduced severely.
A couple years ago I came home with pain in my groin area after hanging out with my then gf at the time and felt this sort of deep throbbing pain that wouldn't go away even after lying down for a few minutes. I panicked and googled it and thought I had testicular torsion. So in a panic I wake my parents up and have my mom drive me to the emergency room and I waited there for about 15 minutes until a nurse came out and guided me to the room. Long story short they ultrasounded my ball sack and did not find symptoms of testicular torsion. My dumb ass just had a bad case of blue balls. Anyways the question I wanted to ask was for some reason I only had to pay the doctor visit bill and they wrote off all the other expenses with some latin phrase that I forget what it was called. Is it common for this to occur for "false positives" like in this case? Also what is that called? I can only assume they took pity for my dumbass and just wrote it off.
edit: I did not have health insurance at the time.
Question for you. I got a surgery in 2016 by Cleveland Clinic. Theyve been fighting with me/my insurance over the bill since then... going on 4 years. My EOB from my insurance says I only owe $682 + $48. Cleveland Clinic says I owe the $682 + $2,260 for something or other. They did a code review and found no problems on that front. Come to find out the insurance must have denied that $2,260 bit as "cosmetic" though ABSOLUTELY NO part of that operation was cosmetic, IN THE SLIGHTEST. Beyond that, the operation fucked my situation up worse and it had to be redone with another operation a few months ago at a new surgeon. So my question is... what the fuck are they charging me a random extra 2,260 for? This surgery was preauthorized by insurance and CC Went and did something extra that the insurance NOR I consented to? What insurance and hospitals do is have contracts meaning they CANT charge me for extra shit beyond what my insurance says they can, which is called a contractual write off that I'm not responsible for. It's a mess and I dont know what my options would be aside from just never fucking paying it til they sue me because I 100% think they're being fraudulent or something. It's also been 4 years almost now and they've not yet reported the bill to the credit bureaus.
Will any of this work if the hospital sent your bill to a 3rd party? I was told by the hospital that the only way to lower my monthly payments was to go through a 3rd party billing place that they use, so my bill was sent to that place and that's who I pay every month.. I only started hearing about all the ways you can negotiate your hospital bill after I set up these payments. But I dont want to call and sound like an idiot if there is nothing this billing place can do
I fucking hate our healthcare system. I had pulmonary embolisms 2 years ago that included a 4 day hospital stay. Last year I got a respiratory virus that made me feel like I was having the same symptoms as my PE (shortness of breath, chest pains) and I got so scared and went to the ER. It thankfully ended up being just symptoms of the illness irritating my not quite 100% healed lungs.. I completely regret going in because of the bills. And even though I know how serious PE's can be, I'm seriously going to question whether I really need to go to the ER if I ever start to feel that way again because I can't freaking afford it.
I work for a revenue cycle services firm, and a big push in the industry now is helping patients understand these options. This was a really great post
Wow, thank you. You have a clear succinct way of explaining this complicated information. If you have the bandwidth, I would suggest you do an IAMA. I imagine lots of folks would have questions.
Can I ask two questions?
I’ve been told that company’s health insurance premiums skyrocket if they have too many people over the age of 50. Hence, a lot of people are let go at that age. Is this possibly correct? (As I approach 50, I am concerned about this)
is there any sort of information we, as citizens, could compile or anything else we can do to effectively reduce the cost of insurance? My thought was to create a spreadsheet with others documenting how much each of us pay on various items. This would
Demonstrate that it’s less about the actual cost and more about the organization’s ability/willingness to negotiate. But am I correct in my perspective? I’d welcome your thoughts.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 06:39:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best way to reduce your medical bills is to vote for someone who wants to pass medicare for all.
Many states also have an Ombudsman for Medical Care. They help consumers getting railroaded or ignored by hospitals and billing departments. Make sure you request your entire medical chart related to the date of service and ensure they have your signed personal guarantee and consent forms. I had an $8,000 bill completely wiped by the Ombudsman in my state because the hospital failed to bill my insurance in a timely manner and didn't have my Consents or Personal Guarantee on file.
Almost every single injection or drug administered through needle or IV will get reimbursed less than $1 by insurance unless it’s a vaccine. Fight those the hardest. Insurance pays about 2% of what was billed.
Ooh, nice, the single most effective way of delivering a drug isn't covered, and you have to fight it. /r/aboringdystopia indeed.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 07:59:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm a practice manager in Alaska and I can say that your price points might be accurate in some areas, but nowhere close in this part of the country. Some of this is good advice, but slot of it should be listed under r/ULPT.
Self pay gets a 20% discount unless you are going to a designated community health clinic where you can pay on a sliding scale based on your income. But if you already went to a regular clinic and got denied, it is too late for that.
Before calling and asking for a self-pay bill, CALL YOUR INSURANCE COMPANY! Ask why it was denied. Many times it is a matter of coding or they need the notes to say something specifically. Same for lab tests. Most labs for "screening" will be denied, but labs for "diagnosis" will be paid.
All accounts will be sent to collections. We don't write it off after 12 months, so delaying in hopes that we write it off does no good. We will gladly set up a payment system. Your account will stay in good standing even if you are only paying $10-20 a month. Your average mechanic won't do that for you, and nobody complains that they aren't fixing your car for free.
The bill is your responsibility, but many people don't want to deal with it, so they just delay and get mad that we don't provide services for free. I am personally an advocate for socialized medicine, but that is not reality right now. Trying to protest the system by not paying will just cause further headaches for you. My nurses make $40/hr and many times they spend 2-3 hours on the phone with an insurance company trying to work something out for a patient, because the patient won't complain to their insurance company, they complain to us. This is one of the reasons healthcare is so expensive - highly trained, well-paid professionals doing non-medical tasks to help a patient who refuses to help themselves.
The OP also fails to account for the room full of business professionals we have in place to work with the insurance companies trying to get your bill paid. There is more to it than just the front desk, office staff and doc, unless you are going to a mom-n-pop one-man show. Go to the small guys and pull these delays and refuse to pay, and you will put them out of business.
Finally, I don't know where he gets supplies for $6, but please send me a link. I buy the supplies, and I can hardly get a roll of kerlix for $6. OP also fails to account for the $7,000 vital sign machine, the $20,000 A1C machine, the $25,000 EKG machine, the $6,000 urinalysis machine (so I can save you money by not sending that to the lab), etc.
Bottom line - do your best to pay your bills. We depend on money to keep the doors open. None of my workers, including the docs, are independently wealthy. If you can't pay your bills, TALK TO SOMEONE. Call your insurance company. Call the business office. We will all work with you. Contrary to popular belief, most medical professionals are not trying to bankrupt people just so we can line our pockets with cash. We are trying to provide a service which costs a lot of money to provide, while keeping the doors open.
Little known fact - most larger primary care doctor offices are budgeted to lose money. We are considered feeders to the systems that make money - mostly surgical specialties, lab, and radiology. So your primary care doc is not just charging you a crazy bill because he is greedy.
Do you have any advise on ambulance charges? Particularly privately owned companies from a life threatening injury back in 2012 that is now on my credit report? I know the easiest, most effective answer is pay it off in small amounts, but I haven’t been able to bring myself to do that. Idk why, it’s just like dude...I literally almost died, had a hemorrhagic stroke, and I don’t owe those doctors anything....why is my credit shit because I didn’t pay you out if pocket to drive me to the hospital?
from 2012.. I'd just let it ride and make zero payments. your credit score may take a hit during that time it's being reported but it should bounce back..
If I recall (I'm NOT an expert, but I lived with horrible credit and repossessions etc for most of my 20's) after 7 years everything but a chpt 11? or 7? bankruptcy (which stay on for 10) will be removed from your credit score. They still have the right to try to collect the debt forever, so you may get the calls and letters until they sell the debt or give up, but after 7 it should be removed from your report. Check your report to see if it's still around. It may not have been reported to the credit agencies until a year or more after the incident, so it may be at 6 years now but your credit score (not plugging credit karma but it's free) should detail the exact number of months the debt has been reported so you can see how far along you are.
I have always understood an ambulance ride is about $800 on average (in SoAZ at least)
They may offer a settlement. FYI if you have a debt forgiven for a small percentage of the total, the difference is considered income that must be reported on your taxes. For example, if you owe 10k, and they offer to settle for 2k, that $8k is considered income that you'll have to pay taxes on.
But remember that paying a collection agency isnt the same as paying the medical bill. You're directly paying another company rather than the hospital or ambulance. If you choose to pay the collection agency, make sure you get a letter stating it was for the particular agency & service you were charged for. Otherwise, even after you've paid the collection agency the hospital can still have you on the haven't paid list... and it really does fall off your credit in 7 years. After a horrible divorce, I owed $90k in ex-husbands credit card bills. After 7 years, as god is my witness, they are gone. I've gone on to buy a house, get a car... you name it. Everything is fine. A friend who thought this was a bad idea, filed for bankruptcy. After 5 years it's still shows up & has stopped her from renting an apartment or getting a credit card. Crazy, yeah....
SOURCE: Best friend owns & runs a collection agency. They buy lists of debts from corporations & if they are able to collect ANYTHING from someone, THEY keep a very large (or all) money received & very little goes to the company owed. He told me to forget about my ambulance bill... and not to answer the phone if his debt collection agency called me, lol!
I had a former step-father angry at me for not filing for bankruptcy, which would have prevented me from later buying my home, or even getting my job which required the most invasive background checks imaginable, checks which would not have forgiven a bankruptcy ever. But because my repo's, and multiple credit card debts that had been sold from collection agency to agency (lawsuits were threatened), had all dropped from my report, they weren't even mentioned.
Thank you, that really helps put things into perspective! It’s been weighing down on me for so long and I’m finally in a position where i could start paying it off but I think I’ll let it ride one more year. I’ll just put more money into savings!
thats what I would do. After this long it can't get worse (I doubt the calls or letters could get worse, unlikely they'd actually try court after this long and such a low dollar amt). If you can deal with whatever hit it does to your credit score for a year or two longer, then you'll be fine.
Credit Karma will allow you to get an idea of what if any harm it's doing to your credit, and simulate what paying it off would do. I think it'll show you that it's not worth losing sleep over.
I do not have insurance but have pretty damn good healthcare.
For minor things and regular checkups, I subscribe to a Direct Primary Care provider. This is a doctor who does not accept insurance, and doesn't charge insurance prices. For a family of 3 we're paying 145 a month, and we can text our doctor if there's anything going on. We just recently had a kid, we're also getting vaccines with this and regular monthly checkups for the tot, and if one of the grown-ups has something they need looked at, it's covered by the monthly cost.
For major medical, we are part of a health sharing network. These prices can be a bit higher, we're paying 530 bucks a month. This provides 1,000,000 dollars worth of coverage beyond the "annual unshared amount", which is iirc 1500 (basically they don't cover the first 1500 bucks of our medical bills, this is for all bills, not each individual bill, so if you meet the AUA for the year you basically are covered for everything the rest of the year). My monthly "premiums" go to other members of the health share, to pay their medical bills.
This means that my total cost of healthcare for all three of us is about 600 bucks a month, which is lower than the insurance offered by my company, of a way way higher quality, doesn't have in-network/out-of-network doctor BS, and I can just text my doctor if there's a question.
I think this setup is going to be more common going into the future since regular insurance is such crap with all the regulations and "government fixes" to healthcare that continuously make healthcare more difficult to navigate. I opted for this instead of insurance. I feel like I'm definitely getting more bang for the buck, but get a better product at the end. It's sort of like skipping the Toyota Carolla and going for the Ferrari, except you got the Ferrari for a steal.
I wouldn't say its the only one, but it works well for me. There are other solutions that could fix healthcare. Here are a couple suggestions:
Get rid of the American Medical Association and occupational licensure for medical staff, beef up tort
Get rid of anti-competitive certificates of need that require new healthcare companies/new hospitals to get approval from existing hospitals
Eliminate drug patents so that there aren't monopolies on new medications, or at least make the period in which the monopoly is granted shorter
Abolish federal insurance standards that require insurance to cover a smorgasbord of things, allow consumers to do this on their own
Abolish medicare, medicaid, social security, and other programs that increase the price of medical care
Get rid of state subsidies for medical practices
Healthcare is the single most heavily regulated industry in the US. This is because it is an important industry, and people care more about it. However, an industry being important does not render it immune from economics, so all the more reason to not stifle it in red tape. The more regulated an industry, the worse it performs for consumers, and nowhere is this more obvious than the medical sector.
My healthcare choices work for me, and I sidestep a lot of bullshit this way. It won't work for everyone.
In its current state with no changes health share is the best option for me as well.
The fact that we have Medicare that creates a federal baseline for medical costs and then we have a free for all that is completely unregulated where health care providers and pharma companies can gouge the sick into bankruptcy is crazy.
If these people were selling a pair of AA batteries for 50.00 during a hurricane we would put them in jail. I guess it’s ok when it’s just health care.
Medicare effectively implements price controls for medical costs, which in any industry really messes with the equations. Surge pricing is an important aspect of economic allocation. The problem isn't that hospitals are greedy, the problem is the government prevents competition and subsidizes medical care to excess.
Sounds like Medicare that the rest of the developed world has, but on a smaller scale and slightly more expensive. This would be what I would try to join if I had to live there.
May sound like it, but it isn't, because I'm not forced to pay it, and I can choose other plans if I so choose. In fact, this sort of healthcare is illegal in many countries due to their government monopolies on healthcare.
There also aren't any waiting times and the quality of care itself is much higher than other countries, as it uses American doctors and technology without the government/insurance added red tape.
Yes it does work. A friend thought he was having a heart attack & went to a charity hospital using an alias, saying was homeless. He was treated & found out he had congestive heart failure. He kept going to that hospital for treatment for a year until he turned 65 & Medicare kicked in. The only issue was when he started going to the Medicare doctors he couldn't transfer his file to explain why he was taking "John Does" heart meds, lol!
And also, SLPT, just give all fake information in a case of an emergency hospital stay and you'll never hear back from them about those pesky bills.
Siluke · 2 points · Posted at 09:17:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So how does healthcare actually work here? If you’re really sick do they just let you die if you have no insurance?
merow · 1 points · Posted at 09:23:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For emergency medicine, no, thanks to EMTALA. That act declares a person cannot be turned away due to ability to pay or not. They must be medically stabilized before transferred to another facility.
Siluke · 1 points · Posted at 09:23:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Transferred to another facility ? Do you have charity hospitals or something?
merow · 1 points · Posted at 15:21:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have a city/county hospital that primarily serves under/unfunded patients
Buddy, I don't think I'll use this info soon but you are doing a very good service to people in this country. I hope you get all that you desire and deserve.
any idea on what a rheumatologist will cost without insurance or what to do to reduce the cost? I'm dreading my appointment in January but I need to see my rheumatologist in order to keep getting the medication that keeps my spine from fusing into a single bone.
I'm in Texas & have severe RA. I lost my Insurance a few years ago. I told my rheumatologist & he let me pay the Medicare fee of $120 for each visit instead of the insurance pay of $480. I used discount coupons for prescriptions & got free Humira from the pharmaceutical company. Still not free but lots cheaper. I now have Insurance that makes me pay EVERY THING up to $5k until it kicks in at 80/20. They DO NOT pay for my pain meds & I pay $1100 out of pocket each month for them, but that REALLY helps on my income taxes because I always have over $12k in medical bills. The last two years have been very bad. Eighteen hospitalizations, 13 ER visits & 13 surgeries. I've literally been bed ridden for 18 months. I couldn't deal with anything but the basic bills to live on. After $7k out of pocket each year, I owe nothing but to be perfectly honest, after my $12k is spent on meds, I don't have enough to pay the hospital bills... and still haven't. I'm a disabled retired Texas teacher & my monthly premiums are huge. The hospital bills have gone to collection but I don't care. I don't answer the phone or stress myself out with bills in the mail. My credit is still good (700 range), I've gotten credit cards & had no trouble renting or buying things. I'm going to start a payment plan of sending them $25 a month (teachers only get paid once a month).They can take that $25 for the rest of my life. I'm not eligible for Medicare for 5 more years & make $200 dollars a year TOO MUCH to qualify for any federal assistance food stamps, Medicaid or reduced prescription plans. Medical bills The system is broken. Use it to your advantage. Start paying the minimum you can towards what you owe monthly. You're probably young & will need to get a mortgage or car soon so if you're making an effort towards payment your credit will be okay. After a while the hospital or doctor will call to offer you a reduced bill to close the account. Or be proactive & call to request it Before I got REALLY sick a couple of years ago, I had a $20k bill that I paid $50 a month for 18 months & it never went to collections. Then the hospital called & said if I could pay $2500 the next month, they'd close the account as "paid in full". I was able to do that. Now that I'm better I plan to start chipping away at that $250k medical bill I've accrued in the last 2 years.
But to answer your question about your rheumatologist, explain your situation & ask for them to charge you the price he collects for Medicare or a special reduced charge that accommodates your needs. Contact the pharmaceutical company who makes your spinal meds. Most have reduced rates, some as little as a $5 copay to keep you on them. Even free clinics in your area will treat you & give you free or low cost meds. Try checking out other subs on personal finance & those on Rheumatoid Arthritis, too. Lots of good advice for people in the same situation. RA is a bitch. Get a support group, even an online one. Its good to hear from people in the same situation. Some have it so much worse. Count your blessings, not your bills 😀. You'll get through this & best of luck to you!
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:21:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A few years back my wife had a rest do e that the doctor said "would be about $100...". We said okay and then the bill was $9850. We called up the lab and said we were self pay and they volunteered $65 as a fair price for them.
Republican politicians... that fight for the Institutionalized for-profit healthcare Companies rather than for people's rights and better interests. They also fight for corporate conglomerates like Monsanto and Shell that pollute our environment, claiming that regulations that require environmental protections are too costly to these companies. So people keep getting sick and have to pay into the healthcare industry... all to keep the wheels of capitalism spinning.
Thats just part of why it's so hard to do anything that makes sense here in the good ol' USofA, but a BIG part.
My insurance rates were 1200 a month for my wife and I. We had 5k in deductibles and an 80/20 policy.
Health share is 400/ mo. 1700 deductible
Health share uses Medicare pay differential schedule to reprice all bills to the same level that is ok’d through Medicare.
Example. 1500.00 anesthesiologists Bill was reduced to 292.00
This was part of my deductible. I sent a payment for 292 to the anesthesiologist along with a repriced detail of services sheet ( provided by the health share)
Payment was approved.
We hit our deductible cap in April. I haven’t paid anything more than my premiums since.
Because of this I was able to take care of many health issues that I have been avoiding for decades because of the simple fact I couldn’t afford the steep deductible let alone worry about if the procedure was going to get rejected by the insurance company.
Health care is broken as fuck. Insurance companies do not have your best interests in mind EVER. Health care providers have to rig the system to get paid. What is left is the average person being stuck in the war zone between these two factions.
OPs post really bums me out. To have to play chicken with a medical provider over a payment vs collection shouldn’t be a way of health care cost management.
Health share has solved this for me. I have removed at least one faction from the war.
As a 17 year old i really thank you for this. I'm not entirely prepared for the mental implications of financial troubles due to medical bills so this helps a lot.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 10:27:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This post makes me thankful I was born and bred in Ireland.
This doesn't work in many places. Self pay bills violate many contracts with insurance companies as they require they be charged the same rate as patients would be charged.
Sitk042 · 2 points · Posted at 11:56:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Number 3, used to be true. Not anymore. I got a scope last year at a local hospital. I set up a payment plan, but after the second payment I sent, they sent me to collections. I WAS MAKING PAYMENTS MONTHLY. And I still got sent to collections. Our city has two major providers, the next stuff got done wasn’t much better. I was sending payments and even portions of my bills got sent to collections.
I had to stop payments that I had set up as the hospital didn’t know how to send my payments to them to the collection agency. So I’d not be getting credit for those payments. Total crap.
I'll file this, as a non-American, under cool-stuff-to-be-aware-of-but-at-the-time-appalled-to-find-out-this-is-necessary-for-some.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 12:12:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wait, people are insured and then have to pay things them self anyway. And on top of that, people have to pay more because the bill they receive is higher if they have an insurance, so if the insurance doesn't pay, you pay too much?
What is that for insane system? How are people in the USA not going on the streets revolting over stuff like this?
I remember I had a friend in the States who got sick with the common cold, used to play video games with him. He sounded like ass, and honestly I just wanted to hear him clearly, so I told him to go to the doctor. He replied with "but that costs money".
Bless Canada, I can visit any doctor any number of times I need for anything at anytime.
Do a fuckton of reading through everything you sign, every bill you receive, and fight everyone...as you're recovering from illness, surgery, or an extended hospital stay.
You know. Just do that.
niikhil · 2 points · Posted at 12:31:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Deleted wtf
uriman · 2 points · Posted at 12:33:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I know a girl who is actually an MD and was saying that she grew up in a family business and never had insurance. They would always pay in cash. Her family must be doing this, but this seems like such a headache to do every time.
Thank you so much. I broke down at the procedure center this morning because I owed my insurance company money and they weren't going to cover my surgery.
I thought I was going to have to cancel my surgery. I had a 7 mm kidney stone that had actually adhered to my ureter and was causing a kidney infection, so obviously that wasn't a good idea. It was extra frustrating because I called Ambetter yesterday to make sure my coverage was up to date.
Luckily my aunt was with me and covered the fee until I can get back to work. The registration nurse told me that self-pay would be an option, but I had no idea how much it would cost. I didn't realize it was lower than the insurance cost.
I had a full-time blown panic attack in recovery, and I'm still freaking out about how I'm going to pay for this at the same time taxes are due. This just brought me so much comfort. Thank you.
I still have anesthésia in my system, so sorry if this is jumbled or oversharing.
Please vote for healthcare coverage in 2020, y'all. We can't keep doing this. I work. I pay taxes. I'm genetically predisposed to kidney stones and it has destroyed me financially.
what kind of human would downvote this persons comment? c'mon really people.
This is an everyday thing across this country. Think it's bullshit until you're the one worrying if your full coverage insurance will even be enough to cover expenses. People fall into medical debt, that can cost them their job if they work for the USgovt or have a clearance. Lose your job because you don't have enough money to cover medical bills. Tell me thats not a kick in the nuts for someone working as a civil servant.
gladysk · 2 points · Posted at 04:29:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is great. Thank you! I imagine a lot of redditors will save your post,
mcub19 · 2 points · Posted at 04:37:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can you explain #4 a little more? Does that mean that if your insurance covers say an emergency visit to the hospital, it won't cover necessary IV drugs?
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 04:42:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It will cover it 100% if you have insurance. The main issue is if you don’t have insurance they will charge about $35 per injection alone plus the drug. The drugs given through IV are always super cheap. The only exception is narcotics which have different parameters that I can’t discuss.
I’ve been dealing with that and just getting bills and bills, all of them above 1k! I’m seriously going to call them all tomorrow. I’m not trying to get away with not paying .. just a fighting chance!!
Thank you! I’m sorry, I guess it’s clear now that I know 0 about health insurance ( or else I would’ve gotten a better one) but what do you mean by research? What should I research?
Oh, I have no idea. I just saw someone else give of smugly encourage people to use these ideas as jumping off points of things to research and I was kind of annoyed by their tone but thought they were right! I've also got some debt to figure out so I know I'm gonna look into some of these ideas tomorrow.
Ugh I didn't even get to choose mine, really. I didn't have time to shop the marketplace, so just went with what my job offered. I'll let you know if I find anything good- I just wanted to support research but in a (hopefully) positive tone! :D
revnhoj · 2 points · Posted at 04:42:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How would one use 6 - 9 to their advantage?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 04:43:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Mainly for justifying the price you’re willing to pay. It takes about 15 mins for front desk and 20 mins for clinical staff. The rest is provider/doctor
Sorry but I have to push back on you here. Providers cannot just give you a self pay or "uninsured" rate. Unless the insurance denial is specifically based on medical necessity or a billing error (not following medical policy by billing without a required diagnosis or timely filing, for example), this is called discounting and can lose you your contract and status as a credentialed provider with the healthplan. Adjusting patient responsibility is in direct violation of all contracts. You must make and document a reasonable attempt to bill patients for all copays, deductibles and coinsurance due at the time services are rendered (most ehr platforms track this for you). Insureds (patients) should also be aware that they are expected to understand and do their part (take responsibility for) things like referrals and choosing preferred providers. It's a slippery slope for those not in the biz so careful there cuz
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:12:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So they just have to find a different way of doing it to not get caught.
For clarification, I believe OP was suggesting to refund the insurance company, remove the adjustments and reprocess the claim as self-pay. I thought that discounting was the scenario where they apply discounts after your insurance company processes the claim. This isn't adjusting patient responsibility after a claim is processed, it's reprocessing a claim to 'erase' it from the insurance company system and re-billing directly to the patient with self-pay adjustments rather than insurance adjustments.
Right, which is in violation of the physicians contract with the payer. If you know that a patient has insurance, you cannot choose not to bill the payer and instead collect a reduced rate from the patient. You can take a denied claim and then reduce to self-pay rate for the patient, but you must bill! What you're saying isn't insurance fraud exactly, but it IS discounting services for one and not another. Patients that CAN pay are expected to, and that in and of itself is the problem. What you guys are suggesting is not the same thing as making payment arrangements with a patient or reducing a patient's balance that is past due after an effort to collect in full has been made. I'm not sure where you practice medical billing or how deep your knowledge goes, but this is basic and it's consistent across the board within the US healthcare system.
Right, which is in violation of the physicians contract with the payer.
Only if that physician has this specific requirement in their contract.
I worked in anesthesia billing for a fortune 15 medical billing and supply company. My department covered about 30 different in and out of state provider groups, we had an in-house legal team, a contract team and I regularly referenced the contracts my providers had with various insurance companies to process claims across the 5 different groups I was assigned to. I also mentioned in another comment that some of my groups didn't offer self-pay options, so perhaps those were the situations in which providers had an MFN clause.
It is my understanding that it's the patient's right to determine if they want a claim to be processed using their insurance and they can absolutely request to have things be processed as self-pay, covered under section 13405 of subtitle d of the hitech act (42 usc 17935). While this is an older article and HIPAA regulations are updated yearly, this specific act was merged into the HIPAA Omnibus Rule. Patients have full rights of their health information, and if they don't want their information sent to an insurance company for billing, then you're legally not allowed to, so reprocessing a claim in this scenario would be considered correcting a HIPAA violation.
Perhaps the contractual obligations between the providers and insurance companies I worked with were slightly different than the ones you've seen, which would make sense because anesthesia billing also covers a lot of services that aren't medically necessary. But that's why I was curious about specifics. No need to come at me like that.
Great advice!
We have insurance, but I'm terrified to see the bill after my wife's 5 day stay to give birth (c section) to our first child. Any specific advice for this situation?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:44:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Seeing the cost breakdown from you makes me realize that the US doesn't have an unreasonable cost when it comes to the actual healthcare, just that the problem is the suppliers and insurance companies. In fact, these prices seem pretty usual (a bit higher though) for what I pay in my country.
I mean, the doctor rate, front desk and clinical are pretty reasonable.
Yankees really need to get their shit together and fix the healthcare system, cause the basics for a good one are seemingly in place. But then y'all stack a shit ton of extra costs on top of it.
Those were the actual rates that were being quoted, what is actually billed is usually 10x the true cost. So all the middlemen can get paid.
I had a buddy have a heart attack, drove himself to the ER. Had a 3hr procedure to install a stint. Took a Dr and 2 assistants, was in and out the same day. He is employed by a Fortune100 US defense contractor working on a USAF facility with full medical insurance. He was billed $80k, insurance negotiated it down to $60k, his amount due was 10% so $6000. He had to pay $6000 out of pocket for a half day procedure. That exact same operation would cost about $6000 completely start to finish at any other high quality hospital in any other country in the world, had he needed to pay for himself (unlikely in most other developed countries) He looked at the bill and saw $30 for a saline bag that costs 50cents. Yet he votes red every time and shits on the thought of a "fuckin socialist" president. He thinks he would have had to wait 6 weeks to be seen if he was in Canada.
Our republicans show preference to corporate for-profit healthcare more than for the people they were elected to serve. it's fuckin criminal.
r/latestagecapitolism in a modern society, our sickest people shouldn't have to work harder just to pay their medical bills. Change the system!That said, thanks for advising on the system that exists...
YSK if you debt is sold to a debt collector, which it will be if you don't pay it. Do not talk to them, do not answer their calls and do not pay them a dime. They are parasites. And remember apart from those to the government, debts are only collectable for 7 years.
You honestly don't. Apparently debt collectors can report the debt to credit bureaus but that's never happened to me. Several times doctors have tried to bill hundreds for an appointment because they didn't bill my insurance right or the pcp didn't fax the referral. Okay I guess you don't want to get paid because I'm certainly not paying that much even if I could. No, I'm not jumping through these fucking OP is suggesting. Go ahead and sell it to the debt collectors for pennies on the dollar, IDGAF, I'm DEFINITELY not paying them. By some miracle my credit score is still 700+..
Damn, I've been thinking about it myself. I owe a lot of money but want to buy a house in the foreseeable future. I'll look into it. Credit scores are just another way to control the working class.
It's the only solution to give everyone affordable healthcare.
The other candidates plans are designed to still make profits off people.
SayNoob · 1 points · Posted at 08:58:20 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
I think you fundamentally lack an understanding of what single payer is a solution for. It's not a solution for healthcare prices, its a solution for health insurance. It does not change how high your hospital bill is, it changes who pays the bill.
The problem on the insurance side right now is that insurance companies have too much discretion in deciding if they want to take you on as a customer and in deciding if they think your bill falls under their plan. Both those issues can be solved with regulations.
People who say this would have never voted for bernie in the first place. Imagine the privilege you have to not vote for someone cause people were curt to you online.
Will this work for dental? My dentist literally called me today saying my pre authorization was denied. I need to have a skin graft done for my receding gums. It's about 3k for the procedure.
UPMC’s self-pay discount is 20%
They will not however change your bill to include that after an insurance denial unless the denial reason is for patient not being their insured. Definitely worth a try for other providers though!
Hi, thanks so much for your post! I have a question- I had to see an out of network plastic surgeon in the ER of an in network hospital. He was the only dr on call to treat my injury. This is the bill I am receiving from his office : http://imgur.com/a/ndWWSAb . My insurance is telling me it should be covered and I believe they are negotiating with him, but his office so far has been unreasonable about adjusting any rates. Do you have any advice based on the situation and billing codes? This was in NJ and my insurance is blue cross/ blue shield of Illinois. Thank you!
Any luck in reducing an emergency room copay. My regular doctor sent me for a test because it was late in the afternoon. I didn’t realize it would cost me 300$.
I’m a cancer patient with thousands of dollars of medical debt. My doctor’s office assigned me a financial navigator - can I call her and ask for the bills to be decreased?
I’m also paying more than $400 per month for ACA insurance, so any advice there is greatly appreciated too.
I don't understand #4... My insurance covers annual physicals, which for me include basic blood tests. This involves injecting a needle obviously... but was covered.
I was also administered fentanyl via IV (before surgery). This was also covered.
daj1798 · 1 points · Posted at 05:50:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am sharing this in every venue I have access to. Future MD hoping to save some people from overpaying the industry.
So what if I overestimated my income so I’m overpaying my premiums and copays and starting to drown?
Meeting with my CPA Friday so I have an exact number this year. And yes this means my taxes are essentially done. Pleased.
What if I accrued the bills because I had accidentally chosen the wrong insurance plan? I did not realize I'd signed up for a high deductible HSA with a $6500 deductible. I have just realized my bill is $2200 for behavioral health therapy and i feel like such an idiot because I've essentially done it to myself out of my own ignorance. I started a payment plan of $50 per month and applied for financial hardship but I dont know if I will actually qualify because I earn 39k. They expect a 10% payment of the total in 3 months. The remaining income I have after bill is about $200 a month. I am suddenly so effing effed. And I did it to myself.
You didn't do it to yourself, American"healthcare" system did it to you! America desperately needs single payer Universal Healthcare for all American citizens!
Saving this. I'll be finding out soon if I'm about to have to pay out of pocket for a procedure... or if I just need antibiotics. I have a strong feeling it's going to be the procedure. Thanks for sharing.
I just got my medical bills for an allergic reaction. I don't have health insurance so I am scared to open it. However, your post has given me courage.
A vast majority of medical providers will not send you to collections If you stay in contact with them. Most organizations write off all unpaid claims at 12-18 months so they will accept anything you give them.
Weird because the hospital I had to go to before I had health insurance sent me to collections as fast as they possibly could. Like the minute they were able to, that was it for me. $4k in debt to collectors now.
I recently quit my job and immediately the day after (Thanksgiving, lucky me) I became gravely ill with what i thought was the flu but turned out to be a lot worse and had to go to the hospital and get multiple tests done to determine what was wrong with me. The entire time I had no idea how long my employee insurance lasted post termination. I ended up just using my employee insurance anyway and am praying that it holds up for a little while. In case it doesnt, you have given me huge presence of mind on how to deal with the potential monetary fallout as I look for another job. You have done a lot for me even if I never end up using this advice, thank you for posting it.
I think insurance is usually good for the month. Then you need to sign up and pay Cobra rates if you want your coverage to continue. But cobra rates are high since you are paying the entire premium without employer assistance. But depending on your income you might qualify for Medicaid or ACA subsidy for insurance.
I was just thinking about a question related to this: How does this work from someone from a foreign nation? Let's say some tourist got into an accident and needed to stay in a hospital for a week. Will they have to pay thousands of dollars due to hugely inflated prices as they don't have any insurance?
KKlear · 1 points · Posted at 10:42:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You should always have travel insurance when going abroad, same goes for travelling to the USA.
I did a quick check just now and getting covered for a 7 days trip to USA costs roughly 4x as much as the same trip within EU, but it's not very pricey.
prnorm · 1 points · Posted at 06:33:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any suggestions for when you get balance billed after your insurance already paid? Long story, but the hospital was out of network but verbally (I know) agreed they wouldn't balance bill us as long as our insurance paid their in network rate, which they did.
They won't budge an inch, even though they already got paid as much or more than they would with a contracted insurance company so now we owe over $10k. Yay.
Nogias · 1 points · Posted at 06:34:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Hi there, I get a depot lupron shot every five years for endometriosis. This last round cost $6000 out of pocket. I see your suggestion on 4, but can you explain a bit more about fighting the bill?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:52:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Nogias · 1 points · Posted at 07:08:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, unfortunately. Fun fact, my colleague in Brisbane pays $40 out of pocket for the entire series and all six units.
One of the largest independent lab companies in the US does not offer a standard self pay rate. Only services are discounted for limited
Reasons and customer service has no ability to negotiate.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:35:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s the most helpful thing I’ve read in my entire life. Wow.
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 06:35:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I work in a pharmacy. The BIGGEST thing that you need to know about: manufacturer discount cards.
Let’s say a doctor writes you a brand name drug. Let’s say Advair. You get the script, and the pharmacy bills it to insurance, and your copay is $150.
You don’t actually have to pay $150
Go to advair.com, and find the savings offer/discount card. Put in your info, and it’ll spit out a discount card with billing information.
We at the pharmacy then bill the COPAY of $150 to that card, and those cards usually pick up $100+ (with a minimum pay)
A) So let’s say that the terms of the card cover an unlimited amount with a $10 minimum. When we bill it, it will shell out $140, completely free of charge, free of contract, etc. Your copay is then $10.
B) let’s say the card covers $100 max. (The most common “maximum limit”). When we bill it, it will shell out the $100, leaving you with $50 for the copay.
Either way, YOURE NOT PAYING THE $150
Keep in mind: these cars aren’t available in generics. Also, manufacturer discount cards are not the same as a normal discount card, like a GoodRX.
This advice is great, and useful because the system is totally broken.
And that's precisely why it's so valuable. Heath care reform based upon "i don't care about the details, just do it" will only result in a new set of problems. You need to pay attention to the specific details to make sure that reform will actually do what you want it to (whatever result you want). There are active and deliberate attempts to prevent you from understanding how things actually work.
It's fucking ridiculous that it's this complex and annoying to deal with to begin with. Can we join the rest of the civilized world with single payer healthcare already?
the problem is no one actually gets how this sick cycle works. it needs to be simplified, and/or consumers need to be educated. these suggestions feed the cycle and that money needs to be made up elsewhere and THESE ARE NOT SOLUTIONS
Which is why I immigrated to Canada in 2014 instead of the US. I have a job with plenty of experience that is in HUGE demand in both countries, and both countries basically rolled out the red carpet for me. I even could have earned 20% more in the US plus enjoy the nicer climate, but there is absolutely zero way I could live in a country that does not consider free healthcare for all a basic human right.
I’m sure I’m not the only one thinking this way, and I really hope for the awesome people of the US that they will be able to change this.
It is a fucking travesty that this post is needed at all.
I'm an American living in Japan, which has socialized health care. You know how much it took me to take my daughter to the emergency room in the middle of the night when she had a reaction to a vaccination? 100 yen (less than 1 USD) and that was only because my wife and my combined income exceeded some arbitrary threshold--normally kids get medical care for free.
Meanwhile, my co-pay for most doctor visits for myself is anywhere from 20-40 USD depending on whether I had bloodwork done or not. My prescription thyroid medication is less than $10 for 90 days worth.
Anybody who has lived abroad in a first-world country knows that health care in the U.S. is just fucked. I cannot for the life of me understand why Americans are not outside the White House and Capitol Building night and day with torches and pitchforks demanding reform.
I'm 27 and don't get sick. For decent insurance I'm going to pay roughly 375 per month next year and probably only go to the doctor once if it all. Insurance is new to me but are there any plans that would allow me to use self pay for the doctor visits, and have good coverage for unexpected high cost procedures/treatments? Also, would it be more cost effective? Off the top of my head I believe it's $400 emergency room, $15 generic prescription, $30 doctor visits, and $55 specialists. I think it's $2500 deductible with a $8000 out of pocket maximum roughly. It's late at night and I don't have my computer next to me to get exact numbers.
Can someone explain what is in-patient and out-patient and who decides this? I have doctor visit, anesthesia considered as in-patient (lower cost) however room services out-patient (higher cost) , ridiculous.
fuser_ · 1 points · Posted at 07:30:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In California negotiating "self pay" is nearly impossible given their reluctance to send to collections. There, they impose interest which accrues and again , non negotiable. So ya pretty much effed.
I went to the doctor in college with no insurance. After moving and missing the bill sent to my old apartment, they called me a year later saying they’d be willing to accept $25 before sending it to collections. The original visit was suppose to be $200.
I'm curious about legality of balance billing. I had an anesthesia bill for $1600 that they called "balance billing" bc it was the remainder that I owed after my insurance paid their contracted amount. So the anesthesia provider got paid by my insurance and by me. And they would NOT work with us in any way. It went on for a year before we finally paid.
I have recently went to an ER for a really awful sciatica pain. My insurance didn’t cover it and I had to pay about $1,600 for the visit. The only thing the ER doctor do for me is prescribe oral steroids.
I got reffered to a oral surgeon that was out of network for a root canal while a tooth of my was abscessing. Aetna has told me twice now that "we'll call you back" when trying to get them to pay at least the in-network rate. Looks like i'll have to foot the $1,200 for the root canal :/
I wish.. Expatriating from America is nearly as difficult as getting citizenship. If you don't renounce your American citizenship entirely, uncle sam still charges you taxes.
This'll probably get lost, but I'm really curious if this applies to dialysis as well? I've been on it for three years and am literally drowning in medical debt (probably half a million by now- my "share" is about 12k a month just for dialysis, so not including any surgeries or hospitalizations).
I've also been super confused on this one, I have private insurance and medicare because of ESRD. I had been referred to the access center, they did an ultrasound, found a blood clot, removed it from my chest, ballooned my fistula. Medicare denied all of it. Every. Single. Bit.
How is it that I am required to carry medicare as a secondary insurance (or primary now as I've completed my 30 month coordination of benefits) for this condition, but they are able to deny every claim filed directly related to said condition? They've denied paying a portion of my dialysis, flat out denied all procedures related to keeping my access viable, hospitalizations due to access issues, everything. So, just... what gives? What's the point of it?
Main point is you shouldn't need to be a masters in maths and analysis to go to hospital it should be free or paid for by the system you have by everyone so that when you need it it's there not if
ozcholo · 1 points · Posted at 08:08:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How to reduce medical bills in the US: find a way to unite the American people without politics. Overthrow government. Get Medicare.
Wow! Reading this post and all the related comments makes me very thankful for the NHS we have in the UK. Any treatment I need - whether just a chat with a doctor or major surgery - costs me precisely nothing... Unless I need prescription medication, in which case it costs me about £8 (haven't used it in a while - can't remember the exact amount) for each prescription. People with chronic conditions don't even pay for prescriptions.
I recently got some labs done (a blood test, a urine test, and a strep swab) and I was charged for 12 labs. Why does this happen and how do I fight it?
I also got an (ultra expensive) ultrasound and got very little information and no treatment.
My bills total in the thousands and I'm stuck here, not wanting to get more "care" because I can't afford it. Any advice would be very much appreciated.
I received a bill for over a thousand dollars for a simple allergy test for my daughter. The bill Is incorrect and I’ve been calling the hospital over and over for the last 2 months.
They kept saying someone will call me back or the supervisor is busy. But no one ever call me back. Yet, I kept receiving the bill demanding payment.
If they won’t even respond to me, what else could I do? It’s almost as if they one they can keep ignoring me and later send me to collection.
Average single doctor rates are $105-$120 for an MD and $50 for an NP/PA per hour. If you get a mid level you can fight the cost more as most insurance groups already charge a discount of 15-25% for mid levels.
This isn't really good advice because extremely rarely is anyone doing time based billing. It's almost always going to be based on CPT code, which can be qualified regardless of how long it takes.
Your reimbursement numbers are also off considerably, a Physician or midlevel is bringing far more than that in an hour. Salary is not the same thing as reimbursement.
I appreciate your post; is there a similarly cheap way to visit a doctor for a check up? Can I just go and get a diagnosis then act surprised when my card gets declined or call and use your tips to negotiate down the bill? And if they discover an expensive disease does that mean I can't get insurance anymore?
I just turned 26 and I am in the wage-worker pool of unaffordable uninsurables. I don't want to die of something stupid and preventable because I never have enough disposable income for a doctor visit.
Thanks again!
IronGin · 1 points · Posted at 08:37:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Isn't it easier to vote in a person that isn't a total jerk about free medical healthcare?
Lmao I’m so behind on medical debt and it’s just all petty shit. H&R accounts calls me daily. Shits so stressful I just ignore it. Only like 3-6k atm but I have no idea how much now. All because I needed to get a sleep apnea machine. We need NHC so bad lol.
The fact that this exists is scary. Being in the UK I have no clue how everyone in the US isn't in crippling debt which I get most are but I mean literally everyone.
same. I think it's criminal to subject citizens to the daily stress of worrying constantly what life may randomly bring, when there are clearly valid options available to us that are just being shat upon by a small percentage of industry funded, loud lawmakers. How anyone can claim the US is the "greatest" anything is beyond me... like we've got everything figured out here.
The only way to permanently decrease medical bills in the United States is to finally end this corrupt casino we call our health system and adopt a system proven to work in every first world country. Your advice, though helpful, only means to extend the broken system rather than actually address the problem at hand.
I wish I would have known this before, or at least been able to try it. I ended up in the ER after an accident in a 3 month window I was not insured. I had just graduated college and had not started my job. I remember asking for an itemized bill and they charged me $200 for a dose of Tylenol, among other things. The full bill was thousands. I called numerous times and tried to talk it down, but the hospital wouldn't work with me, and did indeed send me to collections, because I did not live in that county. They suggested I get assistance where I lived, but I couldn't because I was single and without kids. If I had a kid they would have taken care of it. I ended up opening a credit card just to pay it off because they bullied me so much for not paying it all down fast enough.
We had a blood test done for a pregnancy (checks for defects with baby and gender reveal). The lab that did the testing has poor reviews.
Before the testing, we needed to find out if her insurance covered it. While waiting for confirmation, she gets an email from the company stating that they confirmed we were covered and it would only cost us $100. We took that at face value and went with the testing. Found out that no one contacted the insurance company, and they denied the claim by the lab. Now they want $10,000+. We asked the doctor about it, and they said they'd "take care of it". And was told they couldn't charge us more then $500 for the testing. Which is still 400 more then what we expected. We still have the email and a bill every month saying what we owe. Any advice?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 10:39:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
!remindme 1 week
45KA · 1 points · Posted at 10:41:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
See, this is one of properties of what patriot is: Patriotism is not waving flag and singing patriotic songs but it is work, help and advice that is done selflessly for other people in country.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 10:42:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
USA healthcare is very unreasonable because it's cheaper if you don't get insurance.
So you're telling me if I get in a car wreck and end up with a $200k bill from the emergency room I can get it down to 60-80k? Gee golly they are so swell for doing that :D maybe if I move back in with my parents I can save up all my paychecks for 3 years to pay it off.
Wow, america is so fucked up. I had a full blown ACL knee reconstruction, overnight stay in the hospital, got given 2 weeks worth of medical supplies, and hobbled out 24 hours later on the free crutches. Total cost was 16 dollars for parking, and the 8.95 for 6 days worth of Endone. (australian)
This was done in one of the best hospitals in Queensland too (Prince Charles).
Honestly, i could say (anywhere else in the world). Its only the USA that seems to hang onto this this bizarre fucked up system.
I asked for a self pay bill and was told because my shit insurance had already “been applied” there was no way to revert to self pay. So they found out I had insurance and refused to let me be self pay.
Remember that you can and vote for the presidential candidate who wants to make healthcare as good as free in the upcoming primaries and presidential election (Sanders).
"free"... Another voter that doesn't know how any of this works. Your candidate is fixing the symptom and not the problem. When you tell these crooks that the government HAS to pay for medical you think they are going to LOWER there prices. This ends one of two ways, them charging 5k for 400mg of ibuprofen, or it's going to be a national VA where people are literally dying over the course of a year because of an untreated eye infection.
What if you have an HDHP before you meet your deductible? Do providers usually bill you the self-pay rate without you having to ask?
naJm- · 1 points · Posted at 11:03:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Probably varies depending on where you're from, but in the emergency department I work in (which is in a rural-ish city of 50k pop.) the midlevels and physicians make over twice those rates.
MNCPA · 1 points · Posted at 11:05:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This really depends on the healthcare provider. I guess these are averages which makes sense. Anecdotally, these are vastly underestimated for my employer.
Source: I'm also a healthcare analyst. Also, some of this is public information by the federal government.
n0obie · 1 points · Posted at 11:09:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Saving this post if the time ever comes. Thanks, OP!
If insurance only pays 2% of some medical expenses, it kinda sucks that they still charge astronomical premiums. Cause those premiums are based on kinda being a fraction of the super high 100% prices.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:12:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What about the cost of school to become an MD? YSK that student loans for new doctors can amount to half a million dollars.
You're talking about the two most fucked up systems... Health care and college, both need a complete hard reset.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Agreed. But I think that the barrier to entry to the medical field (financially) should be lowered before the compensation is decreased because then new MD’s won’t be able to pay of the enormous debt. Decreasing the compensation for physicians first without addressing the cost of medical school in addition to other schooling will be disastrous for new physicians. Right now, for example, pediatricians make a baseline salary of around 100k. This is after 4 years of college, 4 years of medical school, and a minimum of 3 years of residency (resident physician salary is on average 50,000 a year and residents work 80+ hours a week) so it definitely needs to change
wish you didnt have to do this but you are doing god's work here. thank you
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:18:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
request a self pay bill. It will be roughly 30-40% of the original invoice received.
Hey, guys... I have this idea. Let's make everyone buy insurance and call it "affordable" and tack on the words "health care" because we all know that affording insurance isn't the same as affording actual health care.
And what we get is a lot of people confusing the money side of it with the actual "care" part of it and then people scrabbling to defend insurance. Edit: Just like this guy and upvoters here
This is why I get tired of people talking about "omg, health care premiums and denial". NO. You're complaining about companies whose only way of making money is to deny you coverage for your care.
And those people going on about how making it affordable means that it's actually health care: NO. You're trying to drum up support for group of companies whose only way of making money is to deny coverage of a procedure.
Lynda73 · 1 points · Posted at 11:18:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact that this post even exists is horrifying. If you're not fighting for socialised medical care, you're off your heads. Please, America, the world follows you by example.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:29:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Supplies used on you cost roughly $6
I work in healthcare supply and this is false. Some items used cost thousands, even tens of thousands of dollars. Patients don't know that there are different brands of supplies and have zero control over this cost. It's entirely up to the discretion of the hospital to choose what they use, even if it costs 8x more than another perfectly acceptable brand.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:33:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
America, the place where you basically need to be an accountant to see if you can afford to not die and go to hospital.
Wish I had seen this three years ago. We paid a $3k lab bill with a credit card during a one month period my husband (then bf) happened to not have insurance...
What if you have s bill that's already gone to collections? Had a charge for nearly 600 for going to urgent care for 30 minutes.. I honestly had no clue about how to proceed with that and didn't manage to pay it off in time...
Seems US individuals have to fight this stuff personally each time. Why isn't there a 'Mutual society' where members can assign a single non-profit membership agency to get them the best deals, whether or not they're insured too? Many other countries have something similar, many such mutuals add 'cover' for things even mainstream insurers don't pay. In a few countries, the 'Mutuals' have taken over the whole reimbursement system, and developed cost-containment teeth of their own.
What is your best recommendation for getting care for someone who doesn't have healthcare?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:51:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why do we have to do this at all when some of us are working the middle class workday plus evening? Why are we expected to sort out and correct for the failed medical insurance industry? These tips are great but it just makes me realize more we don't need to live like this
LPT: Travel to eastern european countries with your serious or semi-serious illnesses, even with the Luxury Accomodation, you’ll pay 10-20% of what you’d pay in the US.
Yes. Providers that offer a self pay option do so to help patients without insurance. They know you can’t pay what they charge to insurance companies. There is no pay rate scale for patients that choose self pay with insurance vs people that choose self pay without. OP was just suggesting that people with insurance denials use the option available to people without insurance.
YumiRae · 1 points · Posted at 12:31:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I got a stat CT scan for intractable headache. My PCP is a clinic and they called the hospital and sent me over. I got a letter saying it was approved (after the fact) and then looked at my online summary of claims and it says partially denied. It says I get the "plan discount" ($40) but they won't pay anything else. What should I do?
Well, I'd say with Universal Health Care, like in every single developed country. I'd even say that UHC is a hall mark and no country without it can be considered as 'developed'.
What the fuck where did this go I was about to send it to my friend who is having surgery this week!! Do any reddit wizards know how to get this back??
Mugnath · 4 points · Posted at 14:08:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
OP deleted because it appears to be innacurate information.
not any blue will do. only one of the presidential candidates is serious about fixing this. House and senate democrats made chuck and Nancy their leaders, and they are not serious about fixing this.
step one is vote in the democratic primaries for progressive candidates that don't take bribe money from big money interests or oligarchs.
We have to try something else now. We keep trying the same things expecting different results. That IS crazy. Trying something new might have an okay outcome. We never know unless we try.
I rather have the taxes I pay go to healthcare than military. 70billion could help here better than any future defense especially since our future wars are online now. It is true that the government needs to step out of health care as I can’t even get help with chronic pain. I had to get my medical marijuana card to help with that. We the people should try to help people more.
My wife broke a bone in her foot a while back that required surgery. I have excellent health insurance on my family. They did the surgery and sent me a bill for a little over a million dollars. Yup. I went up to the hospital and told the doctor she was fucking retarded and handed her the bill back. I never paid a dime out of pocket besides the copays for office visits. Who knows what my insurance paid. It's been about a year and I've not gotten any notices about not paying. I won't pay any of it.
Just because you have insurance doesn't mean you have great benefits. Sucks you would hand a physician who saved your family member's foot and tell her she is "retarted," also pretty lame to use that word in general. I can tell you based on your post that you are the exact kind of patient that make physicians want to quit medicine and commit suicide.
Most doctors have no idea how much the hospitals are charging patients. Often, they're even different organizations -- a provider group and the hospital. If you got a $1m bill for foot surgery, then absolutely talk to the doctor about it. The doc knows it's a racket with the insurance, but they have no idea how much the bill is, if the insurance paid it, or what the impact is on the patient. If it takes getting upset to prevent a bill from ruining your life, then so be it. (BTW, I work in healthcare. I don't want you at my clinic yelling at the front desk, but if you get a $1m bill, I'll understand.)
There was a bill from the hospital, the anesthesiologist and another one from the doctor's private practice. The one from the doctor was the outrageous one. She had us go to a hospital to do the surgery. I went to her office and spoke with her in person, not the receptionist. And I didn't yell.
Jesus h christ. I do have great benefits. I saw the "amount you may owe" letter, insurance apparently covered it. And fuck you, it's just a word. I would never call a disabled person that, you call someone retarded when they're being fucking retarded. It has nothing to do with a disability. Stop getting offended over fucking words. And I doubt very seriously that any doctor that made it through med school and residency would have skin so thin that they would want to commit suicide. Stop projecting your weaknesses onto other people. "I can tell you that based on your post you're a whiny little pussy that gets offended about everything."
Specifically, ask if the person denying the claim is a doctor. Do you want a Jr Executive denying your appendectomy? Only a doctor can decide what treatment is medically necessary. If its still denied ask for a peer review. Your doctor discussing your treatment with the Insurance companies doctor. That works many times if you're able to get an actual doctor on the phone from the insurance company.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:08:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's also good to know that the bactrim antibiotics you can get for a horse at a local co-op (or whatever they call farmer stores where you live) with no prescription, is the same exact bactrim antibiotics you get from the doctor with a prescription.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:13:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or you could demand your government just fix your totally fucked health care system...
But that would mean your politicians would have to enact legislation that is detrimental to their primary sources of income which will never happen.
Bottom line... If your in 'merica and get sick, your fucked.
Saving this comment. As someone who struggled tremendously in the past with medical debt from this f’ed up healthcare system, I am so thankful for your kindness in reaching out to help others going through the same thing. Bless you, friend.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 12:18:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You should honestly start a company where I pay $40 for you to tell me/us how to fight a medical bill. We show you bills and our finances and you tell us who to call for what or what to do/not to do
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 12:27:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No questions yet, but I think you should know how incredibly helpful and selfless it is to post an answer like this and offer to assist people.
Thank you!
Malinut · -1 points · Posted at 12:58:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For comparison: How to reduced medical bills in the UK significantly:- (It's topical in the UK right now.)
See a doctor promptly.
Don't miss appointments.
Don't waste prescriptions and make sure you take what you've been prescribed.
See a pharmacist for minor ailments.
Go to a minor injuries unit rather than A&E if you can.
Get vaccinated. Get your children vaccinated.
Don't mess about with antibiotics.
Don't smoke.
Don't drink too much.
Don't eat too much and avoid sugar.
Take at least some moderate exercise once or twice a week, like a good walk.
...Just these (and there's more) will save the NHS £Billions.
Better yet, vote for people who want to eliminate private insurance companies so that all of America can be part of one risk pool. The shit in this thread is absolutely insane and the only real solution is Medicare for all.
afcagroo · 1043 points · Posted at 04:02:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What is a "self pay bill"? (I'm guessing I know what it is from context, but I'd like to be sure.)
[deleted] · 954 points · Posted at 04:06:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Self pay usually means straight out of pocket with no insurance involved. We require soooo much less from that. It can also mean insurance paid some but not all. The provider will charge you the balance without applying a multiplier discount so ask for the self pay after the insurance payment. It will be much less.
afcagroo · 265 points · Posted at 04:22:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks!
So to make sure I understand this right: If you have insurance, they will bill you at an inflated rate. If the insurance won't pay all of that inflated rate, you can ask for the "self pay" rate and they'll just change the bill?
[deleted] · 322 points · Posted at 04:31:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They will bill you at the charged rate which the main insurance groups only pay at roughly 40%. Never ever pay the denied insurance rate. It’s inflated to ensure we receive the max amount possible depending on contracted rates.
Bornagainchola · 193 points · Posted at 05:32:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Also worth mentioning, if you take the “Self Pay” route it will not go towards your deductible. This is a good alternative when you have a high deductible that you will most likely not reach.
wronginreterosect · 91 points · Posted at 06:17:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That should be its own LPT. If you're getting a procedure late in the calendar year and can find out the hospital rates (which, if the courts allow it, will soon be published information), you would be able to make an educated decision as to whether out of pocket costs would be lower via self-pay or insurance due to the ever-increasing deductibles and co-pays (and coinsurance!). Don't do this for routine visits and preventative care, or normal Rx.
srsly_its_so_ez · 402 points · Posted at 06:49:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Here's the real life pro-tip for good healthcare: vote for Bernie Sanders in the primaries. He's the only candidate that I believe will get universal healthcare for all Americans. He has a track record of fighting for everyone and doing the right thing.
Bernie is the only 2020 candidate who cautioned us about the war in Iraq, and he was absolutely right.
He also raised awareness of the dangers of climate change more than 30 years ago, and he was absolutely right again.
In fact, his message has been incredibly consistent for decades.
He has demonstrated that he will do the right thing and fight for people, whether it's easy or hard. From protesting segregation to fighting for LGBT rights, he was on the right side even when everyone warned him that it could end his political career. He has shown that he genuinely cares about people and he has shown that he will stand on his principles. There's no other candidate who has a record like him and there's no other candidate who deserves our trust as much as he does. Bernie has been fighting for us every day of his life since before most of us were born, and he has a long list of accomplishments.
The fact that he's such a good candidate makes it even more upsetting that the media constantly makes baseless attacks on his character, or omits him from coverage altogether. Someone put the data together recently and the news mentions Biden four times as much as Bernie despite similar polling numbers. They also mention Warren more than twice as much and they even mention Buttigieg more often despite the fact that he's polling in single digits. Mainstream media is giving him such bad coverage that Fox News viewers are more likely to support Bernie than MSNBC viewers are. There's actually a great wikipedia page that provides lots of information about media bias, and there's also a great subreddit called r/BernieBlindness.
It's pretty clear, the establishment is trying to rig this election just like the last one. So of course they'll do their best to downplay the fact that Bernie has the most supporters by far, he's surging in the polls and he has overwhelming support amongst young voters. And they're definitely not going to tell you that a recent Emerson poll found that Bernie is the only candidate beating Trump in a nationwide head-to-head.
The other candidates just don't stack up.
If anyone wants to learn more about Bernie I would recommend watching a speech or an interview, and I'd definitely suggest that you read his campaign plans. I'd also recommend checking out the Bernie subreddits, r/SandersForPresident, r/WayOfTheBern and r/OurPresident, as well as r/MobilizedMinds.
The media won't give Bernie fair coverage, so we have to. Support Bernie in any way you can, and get the word out as much as possible. Let people know that the media is covering him up, and tell them who he really is. Get people registered to vote and remind them to vote in the primaries. If we all work together we can do this!
• • • • • • •
If anyone would like to copy this post, here's a pastebin link :)
dJe781 · 98 points · Posted at 08:06:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As someone who doesn't live in the US, please do something bold for the upcoming election.
The world is watching from a distance. We don't like what we see and we can't do anything about it.
branchbranchley · 44 points · Posted at 08:35:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
that's how it kinda feels in America sometimes
even when we do vote for Hope and Change (because we don't want Romney's plans) we ended up with....... Romneycare
not to mention continued Military Imperialism and refusals for anyone in that Administration to call for prosecution of Wall Street
guess that woulda made Obama's dinners with rich donors kinda awkward. the same ones where he takes a massive dump on the "far left" that helped him get elected in the first place
Okipro19 · 6 points · Posted at 09:26:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The left and right are all playing a game dude. We all forget that the people hold the power in the US. We have the amendments to protect us from them. The 2nd one allows us to remove corruption and restore our republic. I'm not some crazy far right dude. I'm a Democrat that's tired of my party and the other party and I know alot of you are as well. No matter who we vote for they all are in on it and are together making themselves more powerful. It doesnt matter anymore who we vote for that's the issue. We can fix it but they have us stuck thinking we have to vote red or blue to do so. It's not true, we can change and help America but only we can do it.
Goondor · 7 points · Posted at 09:52:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is Defeatism and it has no place in a thread with Bernie Sanders above it in the thread. He's been for the people from the start, look at his record and vote. And vote in your local elections, that's where this all starts.
iHateReddit_srsly · 5 points · Posted at 10:15:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If you think voting for him will give any chance for him to win, you haven't been paying attention.
RetreadRoadRocket · 3 points · Posted at 12:11:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He hasn't, he still thinks whoever is in the Oval Office can actually do anything major besides write an EO that gets an injunction slapped on it.
Head_Northman · 21 points · Posted at 08:52:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We can upvote every Bernie post and share every positive story. We can help to spread the truth and to call out lies on social media.
ChadMcRad · 1 points · Posted at 12:41:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Like 2016...
AKAG8493 · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Neither can we
skz129 · 1 points · Posted at 09:15:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I live here and I don't like what I see and also can't do anything about it. Most people in this country are playing team blue vs team red and are absolutely too stupid to see that we're all losing until the two party system is destroyed and our entire approach is significantly overhauled.
DragonflyGrrl · 0 points · Posted at 10:07:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If the system weren't rigged, Sanders would have been our president for the last three years. We are trying. I'm sincerely hoping that the last election was enough of a wakeup call to the younger generation on how important voting actually is, so that Trump will lose (to whoever.. hopefully Bernie) by a wide enough margin that they can't jack it again. That is the only way any Republican has won for the past few decades.
[deleted] · -11 points · Posted at 08:13:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So you speak for the entire world? Wow, bold...
roslatts · 13 points · Posted at 08:28:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well, they certainly speak for me and my family, as well as a lot of people I know here.
[deleted] · 9 points · Posted at 08:42:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They share the same opinions as everyone I know in my corner of the world... of course they can't know if they speak for every single person, but they definitely speak for a lot of us.
Jushak · 5 points · Posted at 08:59:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They speak for most sane people honestly.
paristexashilton · 3 points · Posted at 09:13:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I thought he was great on the Rogan podcast
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 09:52:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
You don't even see bernie in the media but he has the largest donor base the people with money sure as hell don't want him to win as he will change things. He has shown that throughout his lifetime fighting for the middle class and unjust laws. They want someone like biden who I can't morally justify he reminds me of hillary nothing will change. The same status quo for the rich keep the poor poor. I wonder how many millions our for profit healthcare system has killed so far.. I liked that sleep now in the fire trump for president sign! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w211KOQ5BMI good video and song
cara27hhh · 9 points · Posted at 09:35:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
you guys could have had him for the last 4 years if it wasn't for the rigged election
Could have turned this shit around back in 2016
Gumorak · 1 points · Posted at 12:34:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Could have had him if he didn't get backstabbed by his own party.
nipslipbrokenhip · 1 points · Posted at 12:37:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What happened with the DNC makes me realize there's more corruption than I knew about. I'm really hoping for Bernie and no one else seems as genuine as him . I cannot wait for the chance to vote for him again
4dollaFromDaScreets · 2 points · Posted at 16:21:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a Trump supporter, Bernie Sanders is the only Democrat candidate I respect. I may not agree with his stances on a vast majority of subjects, but he's the only Democrat candidate I feel actually believes in what he's trying to get implemented and the only one I believe would do it the way his supporters want it done.
FrostyFeet82 · 12 points · Posted at 07:35:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don't believe Bernie is the ONLY one. Check out Andrew Yang.
branchbranchley · 48 points · Posted at 07:45:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
not against Yang or the Gang, but for us we are really trying to do the Mass Movement thing right now that Bernie is still capable of leading it and strike while the iron is hot and the Establishment is scared
although it is certainly refreshing to see someone not ordained by our Corporate Overlords getting lots of support
Almost makes the race feel like an actual democracy
keep fighting, YangGang
Ariadnepyanfar · 14 points · Posted at 09:41:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Keep fighting, team Sanders
love from YangGang.
srsly_its_so_ez · 2 points · Posted at 10:53:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you :)
I like Yang. I don't agree with him on everything, but I think he's running a genuine campaign for the right reasons. He's smart, he's passionate, and he has real grassroots support. I'd like to see him and Bernie work together, I feel like they could both learn a lot from each other. Quite frankly, I think Yang should endorse Bernie at the next debate. Yang has ran a great campaign but I don't think he will have enough of a surge to become a top tier candidate, especially because the media won't give him fair coverage. I think it would be better for everyone if he throws his lot in with Bernie. It would give Bernie's campaign a huge boost and I think it will work well for Yang too, I believe that Bernie would be very open to working together and potentially creating the Department Of Technology that Yang has talked about. And if Yang Gangers and Bernard Brethren joined forces, we would be combining the two strongest groups of the democratic election.
Cheers :)
Okipro19 · 0 points · Posted at 09:27:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have a Republic.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:01:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have a Democratic Republic.
Even the party of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, the predecessor of our two modern major parties, was the Democratic-Republican Party.
HelperBot_ · 1 points · Posted at 11:02:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Desktop link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic-Republican_Party
/r/HelperBot_ Downvote to remove. Counter: 292082. Found a bug?
SJDuckRescuer · 34 points · Posted at 07:55:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie has a way longer track record and more political experience to accomplish his goals, but id be stoked for Yang if it comes to it. Hoping 0ne of the two gets the nomination for sure
Zuwxiv · 8 points · Posted at 08:26:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren, too. I know she's Diet Bernie but people get more caught up on arguing the (comparatively) small differences that they forget we're on the same side.
GuiltySparklez0343 · 3 points · Posted at 10:14:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren changed her healthcare plan to a public option that she plans to enact 3 years into her term.
The presidents political party almost always loses seats in the election following their nomination. Warren is suggesting we wait to push m4a through a most likely Republican controlled Congress or senate.
Tesserae626 · 5 points · Posted at 08:51:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In this particular situation, while talking about healthcare, I dont think she's entirely relevant. She backtracked on her healthcare stance pretty quick.
Wasn't she previously a republican also?
Stranex · 2 points · Posted at 11:56:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
less than a minute on google shows that she was registered as a republican almost 30 years ago. is this supposed to reflect negatively on her?
ElJonJon86 · 3 points · Posted at 07:40:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
RemindMe! November 4th 2020
Edit on Nov 4: This aged well /s
WholesomeWhole · 3 points · Posted at 10:24:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As someone who gets excellent health insurance from work tha would almost certainly be worse under Bernie, pays 40-50% taxes because I live in the Bay Area (which judging by the fact there’s a homeless guy in front of my apartment building who blasts music all day when all restaurants nearby have hiring signs, isn’t being spent wisely), and has high employment mobility, why should I vote for Bernie? Honest question. Because my understanding is my taxes would go up even more to 60%+, I would lose healthcare benefits, and the useless bum in front of my building would get free healthcare.
Carla809 · 7 points · Posted at 11:25:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Visit BernieSanders.com to see what the payroll tax deduction would be. 3% for every dollar above $29,000 I believe. See any doctor or specialist. Any hospital. Includes dental, eyeglasses and hearing aids. Also mental health. Leave your job if you don’t like it. Your insurance does not depend on your employer. No premiums, deductibles or co-pays. Free at point of service. So what if your local bum has healthcare? Does he deserve to die because he is not as fortunate as you?
ValeriaSimone · 4 points · Posted at 11:23:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For starters, that "useless bum" (and the rest of "useless bums", uninsured, and underinsured people you and your family may come into contact with) won't be at risk of contracting and transmit infectious diseases.
On the other hand, even though your taxes would go up, since your company doesn't have to pay any healthcare insurance for you, that money should go directly to you, increasing your salary.
nikon1123 · 0 points · Posted at 11:35:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
LOL. Because historically that's how most businesses work...
ValeriaSimone · 2 points · Posted at 11:36:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's what unions are for ;)
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 11:59:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
His plan requires it, if I'm not mistaken
bonafart · 1 points · Posted at 08:10:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sounds like corbyn over here not that I want to vote for him
pradgun · 1 points · Posted at 08:38:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What are the chances of a universal healthcare bill getting passed by both the house and the senate under Bernie ?
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:03:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Depends on how many seats get flipped and how scared of being primaried from the left the corporate democrats get. If Sanders becomes PotUS they damn better be scared if they go against overwhelmingly popular changes.
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 10:04:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or move to Europe - it's mostly free.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:12:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 23:13:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Free at the point of use. And people don't own our hospitals - that's kinda the point. They're publically owned and non profit making.
Saw a really interesting analysis recently comparing tax. You Americans actually pay more tax than the UK overall. So why don't you have free healthcare when you pay more? You also get less paid vacation, fewer workers rights, next to no maternity/paternity leave, no sick pay - what are all your taxes being used for?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 02:34:06 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 08:43:25 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
The phrase is free at the point of use.
When I need a GPs appointment I am charged - nothing. When my daughter was born I was charged - nothing. When my wife needed an emergency C section for my son, and more medical staff than i've ever seen before swarmed the room, I was charged - nothing. When my mum had breast cancer (fully recovered) and the best option drug was 20k a dose she was charged - nothing.
The government uses tax revenue to fund the NHS. Yes i know you're trying to claim that that makes it not free to make yourself feel better about your shitty overpriced health system, but like i said - Americans pay more tax and get less for it. Why is that?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:37:40 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 13:18:51 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Except it is. Free at point of use.
So given the US pays more tax than the UK, how much are you paying for your healthcare again.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:39:03 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 14:42:01 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Free at the point of use. Free at the point of use. Free at the point of use.
My taxes fund a whole range of things nationally. Some of my taxes may be spent on the NHS - but that is not my call, nor do I know where my taxes go. If i didn't pay any taxes it would still be free at the point of use. Not that any hospital or doctor i attended would have a way of charging - see that's another thing we don't have in our free at the point of use NHS - a billing department.
So why are Americans paying more tax, getting less for it, and having to pay exhorbitant medical costs too?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:23:15 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 15:28:59 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Nope - what you have is insurance to pay for the cost of healthcare. Or in most cases some of the costs of healthcare, for some conditions.
Why aren't your taxes that are higher than countries with real free healthcare not paying for your healthcare? What are they paying for?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:31:55 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 15:33:43 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
So turn up to the hospital without your paid for medical insurance. Still free is it?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:41:47 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
BellendicusMax · 1 points · Posted at 08:42:16 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
It also changes the nature of what gets paid for and to whom.
Insurance/medicare pays for what you can afford - the more you pay for insurance the better the treatment you get. On the NHS you get the best option for what you need - cost is not a factor.
The US system is a business - it's not about care, it's about making money. The NHS is about patient care first.
As a yank you could take a visit to the UK, take a walk around a city centre and trip over a kerb and break your leg. Your ambulance and treatment, including recovery physiotherapy, would cost you nothing.
Free to access socialised medical care is just better. Which is why all measurements do not place the USA near the top - https://fr.april-international.com/en/healthcare-expatriates/which-countries-have-best-healthcare-systems
So why do you pay more tax and get less?
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 10:46:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Nah he's got way too many wacko policies. His tax plans alone are fucking nuts
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 11:48:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Name one, any one.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 21:14:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
His medicare for all tax plan for one. Here are list of tax hikes that are spelled out in his policy to pay for medicare for all.
A 4% employee payroll tax
7% employer payroll tax
77 % death tax on inheritances
And then the obvious wealth and bank taxes. And the self employment taxes on top of it.
Like yes, there are nuances to this, like the death tax kicking in at 3.5 mil at 45% and all that shit, I get it.
But fuck's sake that's waaaay too many taxes for a single plan.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 00:50:53 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
" that's waaaay too many taxes for a single plan "... according to who Lol? The way you generate revenue is by raising taxes. These aren't pie in the sky proposals, they require taxes be raised and the bulk of the taxes will be paid by those who can afford it the most, everyone receives the healthcare WE pay for. I don't mind helping out my fellow American, what's the problem?
While our taxes will be raised a little (our being people who make less than $300,000 a year), our overall savings will be much greater in comparison . Here's a simple breakdown of what the current brackets look like as of right now. https://i.imgur.com/tWH8hq4.png
Almost every legitimate study ever done on the savings provided by moving to a single payer system has us saving money not spending more for healthcare. Bernies plan would see us saving 2 trillion dollars over a 10 year period and that's from a conservative Koch funded study. People cry over Bernie proposing a bill that would cost 32 trillion over a 10 year period but don't bother asking what the current systems costs us, more than 34 trillion over the same period, some estimates have it much higher than that.
Remember who you're crying over https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/02/silicon-valley-giants-accused-of-avoiding-100-billion-in-taxes.html
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 01:10:24 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
According to me. You asked so I named one lol. You admit it
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:16:37 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Weak ass rebuttal. I was hoping you understood that your premise was a faulty one to begin with but I guess it's too much for you to admit you know nothing John Snow.
Don't worry though, when we finally get medicare for all and you see your fellow Americans lives improving before your eyes, you'll come around, I have hope for you yet.
Nebor_ · 1 points · Posted at 01:20:14 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
No wasn't looking to debate the merits of the crazy tax plan. Just simply state that it exists. You acknowledged that it does. To you its worth it. Cool.
The_Dung_Beetle · 1 points · Posted at 12:05:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That Pete guy is such a hack.
RetreadRoadRocket · 1 points · Posted at 12:08:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie isn't going to fix healthcare any more than President Obama did because a President cannot do it alone and the Democratic party is not only unlikely to have the necessary votes in Congress to do so, even when they've had them for short periods they cannot get a noncompromised bill through due to disagreements within their own party.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:29:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Look I'm a Bernie supported but stop plastering this shit everywhere. It's Reddit, we get it, stop posting his shit in every thread.
triclops6 · 1 points · Posted at 12:47:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Please keep posting this, it's a service
stupidfatamerican · 1 points · Posted at 13:39:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But I wanna vote for another democrat
PippyNomNom · 1 points · Posted at 08:11:11 on December 9, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't get me wrong here because I am part of the buerocracy, but bernie can't get the "damn bill" passed now as a senater... he wont be able to do anything as president as long as Mitch controls the Senate... flip that shit or there is no chance.
thecoyote23 · 1 points · Posted at 09:19:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Obama made a lot of if promises then ran weapons to Syria and Ukraine, funded mercenaries in Libya and forced everyone to buy into the broken healthcare system. Bernie also rolled over and endorsed Hillary after the DNC completely shafted him and I honestly don’t believe he has the balls do jack in Washington.
golieman9 · 2 points · Posted at 12:11:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Obviously Bernie didn’t want Trump to be president.
No, he can’t take on the system alone but he has inspired hundreds of progressive candidates, who otherwise would not have run for office, to get involved. It’s a movement towards taking control back from corporations and the political elites they have purchased.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 00:55:09 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're a moron. Bernie stayed true to his word. He said if and when he lost during the debates, he would support whoever won the nomination. But you don't care about facts.
GorillaX · 1 points · Posted at 10:58:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Honestly, I'm planning on voting Bernie solely because there's a sliver of a chance he'll forgive my student loan debt. I don't care if the chance is miniscule, or if I'm being naive believing that there's a chance at all. I owe over $450k, for that amount of money, I would be stupid not to vote for that.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 09:39:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Honestly just vote for anyone that isn't a Republican.
mrbungl · 0 points · Posted at 11:11:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any rational person realizes that there is no way to pay for all his "free" shit.
golieman9 · 2 points · Posted at 12:06:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Have you ever looked into the how? It’s not free, he has been planning this stuff probably for decades.
“We can guarantee higher education as a right for all and cancel all student debt for an estimated $2.2 trillion. To pay for this, we will impose a tax of a fraction of a percent on Wall Street speculators who nearly destroyed the economy a decade ago. This Wall Street speculation tax will raise $2.4 trillion over the next ten years. It works by placing a 0.5 percent tax on stock trades – 50 cents on every $100 of stock – a 0.1 percent fee on bond trades, and a 0.005 percent fee on derivative trades.
If Wall Street can be bailed out for several trillion dollars, 45 million Americans can and will be bailed out of the $1.6 trillion burden of student loan debt and we can provide free college for all. Some 40 countries throughout the world have imposed a similar tax, including Britain, South Korea, Hong Kong, Brazil, Germany, France, Switzerland and China.”
Source: BernieSanders.com
eorabs · -11 points · Posted at 07:26:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"his message has been consistent for decades" and yet he hasn't gotten shit done. You should maybe downplay his long history of being an ineffective politician who only has pie-in-the-sky for sale to idiots. He is the left version of Trump. No plans, no compromises, no hope of healing a national divide. Just empty rhetoric. Bernie is not a savior, he's a rich fox in the poor henhouse.
squirtle43 · 15 points · Posted at 07:33:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You know why right? Because you propose a plan, congress MAYBE votes on it, then it gets shot down and never comes to fruition.
See; the current situation of the House proposing HUNDREDS of plans/bills and the Senate(Mitch McConnell) REFUSES to even have the bills be voted on.
Fuck off.
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 07:31:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
He has plenty of plans tho ya dingdong. It was pretty hard being a socialist for like, oh, 8 decades but its swinging around now and Bernie is building quite the movement.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:14:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:25:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He's worked his entire life, what else is he going to do with the money.
everyones-a-robot · 11 points · Posted at 07:32:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is such an amazingly ignorant statement... Bravo.
DragonflyGrrl · 1 points · Posted at 10:11:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's incredible the level of idiocy that still allows a human to function. I wonder if they can walk and talk at the same time?
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:01:10 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Except for the simple fact that Universal Healthcare wasn't even in the political conversation until Bernie ran on it in 2015. Now, almost every Democrat in one way or another supports a single payer system model, while many others running for President have backed Bernie's proposals before running themselves.
The fact that he has held firm on his positions after all these years despite his proposals not being popular at the time isn't a knock against him you dam fool. All that means is that he's ahead of the curve on every damn issue, everyone is playing catchup to Bernie. He's an OG.
eorabs · 0 points · Posted at 03:09:18 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow, the amount of ignorance and boot-licking in this comment would be hilarious if not for the fact that this is really what Bernie's supporters think. You genuinely think that he was the first to propose the idea of Universal Healthcare in this country? An OG, eh? Bernie is a do-nothing candidate who has all you fools thinking you're going to be walking around in free tuition and universal healthcare. You all apparently have no idea of the limited scope of executive power, and since Bernie is allergic to compromise you will never have these things. Words and ideas are nice, but they are promises for empty headed fools.
hitmanjustin · -2 points · Posted at 08:56:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can post all the links to how much you love the guy, but I mean.. come on the man is 78 years old! He’ll be 79 when it comes time to vote, I’m sorry but I just don’t think it’s sane to vote for someone that old. Sure he seems to be more sound of mind that Biden.. but it’s just insane to me the the top democratic candidates are older than Trump, when we all thought he was too old
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:06:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lifestyle means a shitton more than age. Sanders is visibly much more healthy than most people decades younger than him.
hitmanjustin · 1 points · Posted at 12:35:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
“Visibly much more healthy than most people decades younger than him” boy those rose colored glasses are incredible Edit: Dude just had a fucking heart attack!
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 12:41:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He works harsher schedule both before and after said "heart attack" (which isn't exactly correct term for what happened, but I digress) than any other candidate and keeps on going.
Calling it "rose tinted glasses" does nothing to discredit objective reality.
hitmanjustin · 1 points · Posted at 18:18:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We’re just not gonna have the same opinion of the man, what you see as hard work, I see as pulling the wool over peoples eyes, spouting an Agenda promising free everything around the country isnt very hard work imo. But like I said our opinions are like assholes, everyone has one and they usually stink
Okipro19 · 0 points · Posted at 09:30:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Because he has his millions of dollars lol
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:39:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Hasn't helped Biden nor Trump. Both of them are much more wealthy, but showing very obvious signs of mental degradation.
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 08:08:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
dvlpr404 · 5 points · Posted at 08:44:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Could I have sources please?
Jushak · 2 points · Posted at 09:07:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He ain't got shit.
dvlpr404 · 1 points · Posted at 10:25:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I know. These type of people watch fix news and eat up whatever their minds make up.
ItzHymn · 1 points · Posted at 01:04:10 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're a moron. Bernie stayed true to his word. He said if and when he lost during the debates, he would support whoever won the nomination. But you don't care about facts.
DragonflyGrrl · 1 points · Posted at 10:09:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Shut your lying whore mouth.
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 08:22:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Remember folks, the US has the greatest doctors in the world because of how expensive healthcare is here. Canada has universal healthcare and most end up coming down here for serious procedures due to either lower skill doctors or long wait times.
Not commenting on the state of our healthcare system as it pertains to every single citizen, but just be thankful you have so many great doctors to choose from.
My concern with Bernie is he will reduce incentives for US doctors, causing some to straight up deny insurance and raise their premiums so only the ultra rich can actually afford their services. He also strongly believes in heavy government spending which will be funded by the highest tax rates our country has ever seen, just something to keep in mind.
eliz3_duboi3 · 4 points · Posted at 09:11:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is plain wrong. The Toronto general hospital is on the top 10 world wide list, while being the largest transplant centre in north America. 400 000 a year is a perfectly acceptable wage for a doctor. It is revolting to think financial incentive is the only thing that would drive people to work in American hospitals.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:49:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
not Canada, but an example where US “financial incentive” saved someones life in Germany.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/aohegg/genetically_modified_tcells_hunting_down_and/eg1hv8e/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:17:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I never said Canada doesn’t have good hospitals....Im sure Toronto General is a fantastic hospital. But financial incentive is what drives doctors to work in the US whether you agree with it or not. Financial incentive dictates almost every single decision made. Im sure when you search for doctors in the US, the cost of the procedure is going to play a factor in where you go (aka financial incentive to pay less)
Jushak · 3 points · Posted at 09:01:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Such a load of bull on every regard in your post. Read up on some history on US taxation and educate yourself.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:14:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
please tell me whats bull, i’m very interested.
EDIT: If your going to throw figures from over 100 years ago then don’t even bother. 50% tax on $2m+ income is just insane. paying an extra $100k in taxes because you made $2m instead of $1.99m is not something most entrepreneurs are going to be happy about. Why give the government an interest free loan? The government is wildly notorious for being extremely inefficient. Ask literally anyone in a government office how long it takes for things to be done. Why would we want to bank the future of our healthcare on a government that spends $640 on plastic toilet seats?
ajdeemo · 2 points · Posted at 09:45:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Who has argued for having an exact tax bracket jump like that? If anything it would work exactly like progressive tax brackets do now: you would only pay 50% tax for all income after 2m. I've never seen him advocate for the exact situation you describe.
EDIT: Here is a link to the proposal which definitively states that it's progressive tax.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:54:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
thank you for actually providing facts and links and not personal attacks. Im glad to hear this is a progressive tax. Thank you!
ajdeemo · 1 points · Posted at 10:05:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Glad I could help. There's a lot of misinformation out there around taxes, a lot of people purposely leave out the "progressive" part when talking about tax changes, either to trick people or because they assume everyone knows it's progressive. It's usually safe to assume that proposed changes are still progressive, because flat tax brackets are complete trash for the reasons you listed, and not just for corporations but people too. (I'd still recommend checking just in case)
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 09:43:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Try this for size.
There is no reason why anyone should have that much money anyway. I couldn't give a fuck about whether rich people like it or not either. They can suck it up and pay back to the society that makes their riches possible in the first place.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:52:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
how did that taxation work out for the US?
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 10:50:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not sure what you are trying to insinuate with that question.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:08:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
literally asking if that tax was successful or not
Jushak · 1 points · Posted at 13:18:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Considering it is sometimes called the golden age of US I would say it was pretty fucking successful.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:53:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
LOL
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:05:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who gives a damn if we have the greatest doctors when most people can't afford them without going bankrupt?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:07:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
because they are alive and not dead
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 16:16:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
... yet. Poverty kills too.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 22:48:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
seems we are at an impasse
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 23:04:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's ok, let's stop here. Not every difference has to be resolved. Situations can change, and Sanders may not even get the nomination. Everybody should just vote with their own conscience. Good day to you.
branchbranchley · -2 points · Posted at 07:03:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
wouldn't you prefer "Medicare for All Who Want Not That Much, But Only After Three Years After We Gamble On A Midterm?"
dacoobob · 1 points · Posted at 07:00:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
my prescription medications are always cheaper via self-pay than going through my insurance. and I never meet my yearly deductible so it would be out of my pocket either way.
Jushak · 2 points · Posted at 09:08:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Doesn't that defeat the point of insurance? Man the US system sucks.
dacoobob · 2 points · Posted at 09:23:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes. yes it does.
dvlpr404 · 1 points · Posted at 08:40:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Random, but I have a genetics test done on my unborn daughter and through insurance (0% paid) it's $650. Cash is $250. Our yearly deductible resets in mid June. The baby is due before that. I think we should do nearly all out of pocket payments as the delivery will 100% cost more than our out of pocket cost.
wronginreterosect · 1 points · Posted at 09:05:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Somewhat confusing comment, but if the test is covered by insurance I would think you'd go through insurance and pay toward the deductible bec you know you're definitely going to eclipse it within the plan year, so it's money you'd pay anyway later. You'd pay 650 up front but recover it later and save 250 on the back end. Unless your deductible is obscenely high. Maybe I'm missing something.
dvlpr404 · 1 points · Posted at 10:24:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We haven't hit our deductible. It's ($3250) for family. We're maybe $500 into it, so no help from insurance. Our next daughter will 100% be born before our plan "renews". Our last kid was $9,000 after insurance, if which we only had to reach our out of pocket ($6500).
We'd save money now by just doing the self pay. Or am I missing something?
LizLemon_015 · 0 points · Posted at 08:23:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
has there ever been a time someone called their doctor, or hospital before hand (when applicable) to find out the cost of their procedures and weren't given an estimate of the costs and their portion?
the provider does know what they charge, and patients can ask - and should!
my office policy is to notify patients as soon as possible (like a week or two) before their surgery of what their costs are - and to collect the patient share about 90% of the time (90% or more of the estimate we give over 90% or more of the patients who have share of costs).
We would rather you don't come, or find somewhere cheaper, than to come, be seen, then have to waste time trying to collect what a patient owes, when they don't want to pay. Not to mention, information provided timely and accurately is just good costumer service and patient care.
mbthursday · 1 points · Posted at 11:11:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Also be aware that some offices may not give you the self pay option if they know you have insurance. And some offices may just refuse you an appointment.
foxbase · 16 points · Posted at 05:45:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Damn I could have really used this information a few months ago. My insurance denied my claim and I ended up having to pay almost triple what I was quoted with insurance. I always thought that billing departments weren’t allowed to bill self-pay rates if you had insurance.
Nocleverresponse · 5 points · Posted at 09:50:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The last few places that I worked would not bill as self-pay if a person has insurance.
foxbase · 2 points · Posted at 14:18:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s always the policy I’ve been told. I’ve been told they can’t bill self pay if the person has insurance for legal (?) reasons. I guess they’ll get in trouble if they do.
petkoala · 1 points · Posted at 00:56:21 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Probably only if it’s a state or federal insurance like medicaid! There’s no legal implication otherwise- if insurance doesn’t pay any on the claim at all, they should be able to give a self pay discount. If insurance has made any adjustment at all they really can’t because of a contractual agreement with that insurance company that a patient is responsible for the amount left after insurance adjustment.
foxbase · 1 points · Posted at 02:27:26 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Interesting, not sure where mine falls under, I have private health insurance through my work. That last part makes sense though, because my instance did adjust the end bill, it was just much higher than what I was quoted originally. I didn’t really understand that part though because they denied the claim, but adjusted the bill anyway, weird.
mind_walker_mana · 2 points · Posted at 12:15:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't know where you are, but Duke med let's you self pay even when they know you have insurance. I asked for both prices because I have noticed that sometimes even with insurance the out of pocket cost is higher than w/o it. The worst thing that happens if you ask is they say no... But I think if I recall they said they knock about 75% of costs if you go non insurance.
So the insurance costs as far as I can tell are inflated but sometimes do help for bigger procedures like MRI's and such if you've met the deductible. Idk, bit what I know for sure is that medical billing seems unnecessarily complicated!
foxbase · 1 points · Posted at 14:23:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah I’m not near Duke, I’ve never had a place tell me they allowed self pay if I was on insurance unfortunately. I think it has to do with the contracts hospitals have with insurance companies, so a lot of places err on the side of caution and don’t let you self pay in case they might be in violation of their contract. At least that’s what I’ve been told when I asked about this before.
AlfieTheThird · 1 points · Posted at 15:45:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
self-pay should also apply for MRIs as well! It's usually a 3-4x markup especially in hospitals for MRI than if you were to go self-pay. The outpatient is the way to go there if you have that available in your area. Most of the large machine sit idle 50% of the time, so the outpatient places are willing to negotiate rates. Im working to make this process more transparent but only in NYC right now.
PippyNomNom · 20 points · Posted at 06:00:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
To be clear, this process is called "balance billing" and may be illegal in your state.
FitLotus · 5 points · Posted at 06:20:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In a lot of states providers have to “opt in” to balance billing as far as I know. It’s common for Medicare plans with poor reimbursement.
ezone2kil · 24 points · Posted at 06:16:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why is it illegal? I'm surprised at how much the US hate its own citizens.
twir1s · 20 points · Posted at 06:37:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m confused by your statement. Balance billing is a way to price gouge the patient. Making it illegal protects u.s. citizens/patients. How does making balance billing illegal mean the US hates its own citizens? Making it illegal is a form of consumer protection.
HumanInternetPerson · 24 points · Posted at 06:48:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They probably misunderstood the comment. I did too, until you clarified. I read that as balance billing is the same as self pay. For us novices, we have never heard these terms so it’s all new information.
PippyNomNom · 2 points · Posted at 08:18:06 on December 9, 2019 · (Permalink)
Apologies for not completely explaining. "Balance billing" is the practice where the insurance denies the claim and then the provider (hospital/doctor) Bill's you for the total/gross/charge amount without an appropriate "self-pay discount" which could be well over 50% of charges.... it is confusing.
ezone2kil · 21 points · Posted at 06:49:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No I'm confused by the term. It should be illegal for the insurance companies to charge the inflated rates in the first place.
rebelx · 2 points · Posted at 09:42:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's not the insurances companies that charge so much. It's the healthcare provider charging so much to the insurance company/you.
ezone2kil · 1 points · Posted at 10:12:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ah yeah I got it switched around. Thank you for the correction
sk8brdr540 · 1 points · Posted at 10:58:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance companies don't charge rates. Your medical provider does.
BagOnuts · 1 points · Posted at 11:44:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance doesn’t charge you anything, what are you talking about?
Wohowudothat · 1 points · Posted at 12:12:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There are many contracts with insurance companies that will never pay more than 50% of the billed price. If your cost of doing the procedure is $800, and you bill $800, then you're going to get $400 and actually lose money on caring for that patient. So you have to bill $1600 so you can get $800.
RetreadRoadRocket · 1 points · Posted at 12:25:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah, and it should be illegal for insurers to say "I have a load of patients with you, give me a 30% discount or I'll remove you from the list of places they can go for care". How do you think we got here in the first place? Insurers demanded a discount, hospitals and doctors and such need to pay bills, so they've been going back and forth for decades of complying with demands for steep discounts one year and raising prices next year to cover it. Somewhere early on they realized there were no organized or standardized pricing rules so they could gouge each orher back and forth and somewhere in the middle the system of medical coders, claims adjusters, control documentation providers, and negotiaters became a self sustaining nightmare.
nobollocks22 · 1 points · Posted at 12:28:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lobbyists.
Skilol · 1 points · Posted at 09:35:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Especially when they can leave the deductible so high that the inflated cost ends up as mostly not being covered anyway. Pay monthly insurance that's already higher than in 100% of the developed world, just to then pay more for actual medical services than without insurance. What the fuck, America?
FreeSpeechIsARight · 1 points · Posted at 06:40:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Always looking to exceed expectations aren’t we
Truffle_Shuffle_85 · 1 points · Posted at 12:13:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You wouldn't be surprised at all if you truly understood how much US companies want more money/profits.
PUTINS_PORN_ACCOUNT · 2 points · Posted at 13:02:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This insurance system in the US is the most venal and corrupt institution short of the Oval Office. The sooner the insurance business is brought to heel, the better.
eonimmurphy · 5 points · Posted at 08:09:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No offence to you personally, but that's just straight garbage, Disney villain type shit. I'm actually astonished at how corrupt your system is.
magenta_mojo · 1 points · Posted at 12:06:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This sounds like you’re almost better off not having insurance. My husband pays like $550/mo for the both of us and we have a 3k deductible per year (aside from preventative visits). So that’s already $9,900 per year we pay before seeing much in benefits. Then the stuff that’s actually covered isn’t even covered 100%, usually 65-75%. So we pay out of pocket that 25-35%. Which you’re telling me now seems to be the cost of the self-pay rate, anyway?
Ecstatic_Carpet · 1 points · Posted at 12:30:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How is this not fraud?
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 06:23:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m guessing that they bill the insurance an inflated rate to offset the cost of people’s bills that have been written off due to inability to pay?
diablette · 2 points · Posted at 08:46:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance Co. A will give you $2 for a certain procedure. Insurance Co. B will give you $5. How high will they go? If it’s your job to negotiate the highest payments, and there’s no downside, you can just set the rate at $1000 and see what you get.
This is why I don’t see any good in forcing hospitals to reveal their rates. They’re all just inflated nonsense numbers.
DragonflyGrrl · 1 points · Posted at 10:15:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wouldn't they be likely to jump them up even more before revealing them?
hmstd · 1 points · Posted at 08:48:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's because insurance companies want to haggle/bargain with doctors/hospitals and with each other. I just went through a small ordeal where my insurance wouldn't pay for a procedure until I provided them with a notice of if I had any other insurance plans.
They want to know if someone else will pay for anything before paying any themselves. I can't haggle or change my insurance premiums, I have to pay the same no matter what, why should they care or be able to change what they pay based on what else another insurance might pay.
It's a bunch of bullshit that's a result of trying to run healthcare like a business.
bonafart · 1 points · Posted at 08:08:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sounds like it and there's your poeblem. Some big entity that can pay oooo we shall charge them double
alexkapone · 1 points · Posted at 11:35:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
essentially insurance companies have bargained to pay certain rates due to their bringing in a certain amount of ”business”.
this is like you being the biggest seller and thus purchaser of tires in town and going to the suppliers or rather manufacturers and saying ”i sell all the f’ing tires in town okay and so im only going to pay 40 cents on the dollar compared to if those suckers actually just bought from you guys directly. you guys charge too much anyways.” now this sort of bargaining might work if there werent only a few insurance companies left in most areas. more and more people are on government insurance anyways which also pays a cut rate and from my understanding takes longer to pay. As a result it seems to me certain healthcare providers are ”medicare/medicaid” designed while others dont accept it and thus provide a higher level of service. So now what we essentially have is a two tiered system where poorer people have ”public healthcare” on the ”free market” but really dont access the same class of services so its like we have two healthcare systems.
From what I’ve seen health insurance is getting so expensive it is single handedly pushing many young individuals and familys to either choose between medicaid territory or trying to fight out of there with no health coverage. This is increasingly difficult if not merely because well if you have any issues like for instance mental health issues due to stress (surprise) you may become essentially debilitated and or practically and really suicidal (hence the drug overdose epidemic.) It’s really hard to exist in a hopeless bind. I think many people are choosing drug overdose even subconsciously. Affording, for instance, the leading drug for treating opiate addiction will put you into needing probably gold tier insurance in most states (~$500/month)
It is completely screwed and all of congress is to blame. they passed a healthcare bill with unrealistic optimism it would catch on but in reality the other side was so hell bent on destroying it (it was sort of forced down their throats, up for debate as to whether that was neccessary) its been so unsupported that its gotten so expensive and thus received such bad PR that its only a matter of time before healthcare gets so expensive we have a crisis and essentially chaos and possibly a healthcare inspired revolutionairy uprising. only so many people are going to tolerate having their kids die of overdoses because doctors choose to perscribe instead of treat since its more profitable and less legally risky. only so many people are going to tolerate that one medical issue they have in life-crushing their dreams of upward mobility completely.
insurance in general is a social (dare i say socialist) policy that is meant to spread risk among the population and give us all a way to depend on the community for support when we have bad luck. people have forgotten this and its become a place for profit, period.
thats my prediction and understanding at least.
over 30 of my friends from high school and young adulthood have died of overdoses and i dont come from a typically economically challenged area. many of them were well educated and come from good families.
SweetnessTheWarlock · 45 points · Posted at 06:00:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I discovered self pay recently.
When I went to my 20 week ultrasound appt my bill was $500 because my insurance wouldn't cover it until the deductible was met ($5,000). When I asked them if that was the only option, they told me about a self pay option which would cost $240 😑
[deleted] · 24 points · Posted at 07:12:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
obeagle24 · 23 points · Posted at 08:46:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not pregnancy/birth related, but my father was diagnosed with bowel cancer after a routine FREE bowel cancer screening test, having recently moved to Australia from NZ within the previous 12 months.
The colonoscopy, pathology, surgery, chemotherapy have all been $0 out of pocket. He has a team of Dr’s he meets with fortnightly to discuss how things are going and has a nurse on call 24/7 for any emergencies/questions etc.
This was all put together within a week of the initial screening positive. I will take this “socialised medicine” any day of the week.
wcdma · 3 points · Posted at 09:18:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Kia ora bro, Glad to hear. You only get one whanau - Kia Kaha my bro
WKGokev · 5 points · Posted at 10:55:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yet, I will have to wait until April to see a dermatologist to have a melanoma looked at, but republicans swear that everyone else waits while we just roll in and get taken care of.
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 18:55:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m no doctor but isn’t that the kind of thing that needs to be actioned as a priority? Is there not any provision for medical necessity to determine the wait list order?
WKGokev · 1 points · Posted at 20:05:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Nope, my sister in law had to wait 6 months for a colonoscopy, her mom died from colo-rectal cancer.
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 12:15:23 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jeez. I’m sorry to hear that. I’d like to think it’ll all change one day there. I just hope it’s still uncorruptible. There is far too much money and politics in that business
WKGokev · 1 points · Posted at 12:43:07 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah, I was talking to a guy said he knows a dermatologist who does some rare procedure, charges 15k, keeps 12k for himself. That's a 400% profit margin, which should be criminal and would have been in 1972.
mind_walker_mana · 2 points · Posted at 12:24:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Fuck, yes!! Please! So tired of this bullshit weighing whether to get care or wait til it might be an emergency that kills me. I've had chest pains and headaches for the longest time. I put off seeing anyone for so long (years) but I honestly thought I had some sort of tumor or maybe I was developing aneurysms that any day would take me out of this world. Headaches would last for days and sometimes months. I troopered along until I finally got a job that let me be able to pay for the huge deductible and out of pocket costs to find out. Turns out it's not cancer and not aneurysms. But what if it had been...?
And it's not like if you go they just can identify what's wrong immediately. No they have to run tests and each test costs. And most people just can't afford it even with insurance.
And I hear people from countries ask about why more people in the US don't get STD screenings? It costs like almost 400 if not through planned Parenthood. And then you get harassed by evangelicals at the door it's just not worth it to a lot of people.
And I can go on and on, so yes!! Please can we get some universal healthcare?? Ffs!
budshitman · 2 points · Posted at 12:26:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My US colonoscopy, just the colonoscopy, will cost over $3,000 with insurance that I've already paid over $4,000 for this year.
count_frightenstein · 2 points · Posted at 12:53:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm in Canada and have to get multiple colonoscopies a year. Like one year I had to get one every other month. Reading Reddit has made me grateful for our healthcare here because I couldn't imagine having to worry about whether insurance would cover or deductibles or whatnot. I just go, check in, get my stuff done and leave, never thinking about the bill or the cost. In fact, I don't get anything from the hospital, ever.
DragonflyGrrl · 1 points · Posted at 10:18:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Anecdotally.. when I had my first child in the US, the pregnancy, birth and aftercare were completely covered by Medicaid. He was born prematurely, was in the NICU for a long time, and it was expensive... I didn't ever get asked for a dime. And it was first-rate care.
poopyhelicopterbutt · 2 points · Posted at 18:57:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good to hear. That’s the way it should be for everyone regardless of age or income.
DragonflyGrrl · 2 points · Posted at 23:27:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Absolutely! Couldn't agree more.
Helmet_Here_Level_3 · 0 points · Posted at 08:38:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don’t they also pay more in taxes?
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 09:04:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, we pay a little more in taxes but the US government spends far more on healthcare per person than the Australian government. Your system is well and truly set up to benefit the rich.
shitloadofbooks · 3 points · Posted at 09:42:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
24.6% in 2018, compared with the OECD average of 25.5% and the American average of 23.8%.
Median wage is $ $65kAUD (45k USD) vs 46k USD.
So the tax difference is about $3-400 per year.
Certainly less than what most Americans pay in Health Insurance.
Australians also get minimum 4 weeks annual leave each year, paid sick leave, paid parental leave (2 weeks for the father and up to 16 weeks for the mother).
Many business also have additional incentives, (especially around parental leave).
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:53:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
poopyhelicopterbutt · 2 points · Posted at 19:01:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I always preferred going to work on my birthday. Better to be around colleagues who are into it rather just just chilling at home solo
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:58:13 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 12:13:15 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
And rework your birthday to make it a Friday
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 19:03:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When I told my American wife about Long Service Leave she thought I was joking.
Also worth noting our annual and sick leave rolls over into the next year. That’s not common in America
Water2B · 1 points · Posted at 12:20:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, I found that shopping around for image services is very helpful, I was charged $800 for a mammogram, that's via insurance before I met the deductible, when the doctor said everything looks good but i need another memo in a few weeks, just to make sure, i just didnt go to a doctor for a few years.. f*ck that, I have other bills to pay.. so eventually I needed to do another memo, I called a few places, good references, etc, 1 hour schlep, $120 mamo Really?? $620 difference? They bloody scare you senseless and rob you blind..
gotmyidentitystolen · 12 points · Posted at 05:16:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this only apply to doctors and hospitals or dental situations too?
[deleted] · 20 points · Posted at 05:18:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Doctors, unfortunately I don’t know dental.
bonafart · 9 points · Posted at 08:12:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Which should be the fucking same
hackandsash · 3 points · Posted at 08:19:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It is the same, fee for service versus insurance is usually adjusted accordingly
Lawlsagna · 2 points · Posted at 09:01:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I used to work as an AR specialist in a medical billing department that handled billing for multiple provider groups. I was the one who sent the claims to the insurance company and contacted the patient for the remaining balance. This is somewhat accurate but I’m careful not to mention it as a blanket resolution because some providers don’t offer a self pay discount. You need to talk to the billing department to determine if the option is available, I sometimes had to refuse negotiations like this because it wasn’t in the contract we had with that specific care provider. I could only process the request about 60-70% of the time.
Also, keeping in contact with us didn’t help at all unless you were making payment that actually impacted your bill. I heard my coworkers scoff over the phone plenty of times at patients saying things like “if you continue to make payments in that amount, it’ll take you 20 years to pay off the bill,” which would then impact my coworkers stats, so they’d send them to collections. It was all about getting payments and clearing old accounts so that our overall numbers were optimal.
Anyway, it was a pretty toxic environment which is why I left but a lot of providers are no longer using in-house billing departments, which seriously impacts the quality of service.
sufferin_succatash · 15 points · Posted at 05:51:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, most dental offices will have lower rates for self pay.
StrangeDrivenAxMan · 22 points · Posted at 05:46:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
the system is so broken it's pretzel
Amphibionomus · 13 points · Posted at 07:09:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Having seperate tariffs for insurance companies and private persons isn't even legal where I live. That said, most people here never see a medical bill in their life as those are send from the hospital to the health insurer directly.
Damn socialist country taking care of all people. /s
YoroSwaggin · 2 points · Posted at 09:55:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Seriously, people love complaining about "What is this Socialist Sweden" or "It will never work this is America!" but whatever the fuck happened to American exceptionalism, can do attitude and hatred of terrible rules? The healthcare system is just a thinly veiled free for all, hidden by bullshit that most folks can't see through. Get rid of all the fucking BS, and suddenly the system will work. Even if the new system somehow fucks up, we can't do worse than this.
Amphibionomus · 1 points · Posted at 10:01:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I hope you guys really get your shit together. I don't know what the bookmakers do at the moment, but it seems a 50/50 bet if the US makes it back to democracy or slides further down the slope to totalitarian rule. Which would be exceptional for a developed country, but not in the good way.
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 19:30:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I just looked it up. Bookmakers here in Australia are favouring Dems (1.72) over GOP (2).
As for individual candidates Trump is the favourite (2.25) over the nearest rival Biden (6.50)
Explanation for U.S gamblers: Our odds work differently to yours. We use decimal odds rather than moneyline odds. If you bet $1 on Trump for example you give your $1 away and receive $2.25 if you win, a profit of $1.25
https://i.imgur.com/IJ8HCea.jpg
shroomawayer · 1 points · Posted at 10:27:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"We can't do worse than this" is actually a really good motivator to make shit happen at this point. It's THAT fucked up.
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 05:43:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How do I get a self-pay discount if I've already gotten a contractual adjustment due to my insurance?
PippyNomNom · 6 points · Posted at 06:02:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can sometimes negotiate a prompt pay discount or something like that, but if the balance due is because of your deductible/copay/coinsurance, this is money that you agreed to pay when you signed up for your insurance plan. Either way, call the billing office and see if they can work with you.
Olookasquirrel87 · 1 points · Posted at 12:30:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can also ask for financial aid. Works better in big nonprofit hospitals but I’ve gotten 70% off my bill and I make ok money. Best part is as far as the insurance company is concerned you paid 100% of what they charged you initially and it can max your deductible.
borndigger · 5 points · Posted at 05:57:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This. I want to know this too!
call_me_cookie · 10 points · Posted at 07:49:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This seems like an egregious acknowledgement that this "insurance" service is just an exercise in bureaucracy.
ButterflyCatastrophe · 4 points · Posted at 11:14:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Healthcare runs a Black Friday pricing model all year long. The insurance companies think they can use their size to pressure providers into accepting lower payment, so the providers jack up their billing amount, then "discount" it for the insurers. This, on top of the price bump to account for non-payers.
Universal coverage with a single payer, and we could discover how much health care actually costs, without the layers of bickering bureaucrats, fake discounts and exaggerated sticker prices.
call_me_cookie · 1 points · Posted at 12:08:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Whole system is fucked. Chuck it out and try a better one.
Thoughtsonrocks · 8 points · Posted at 07:19:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Here's an example for people.
I went to several dermatologists in a major US city, got different estimates on a routine, non-emergency outpatient procedure. I tried to get cost estimates, I got none.
When I picked the office I went with, I asked how much the procedure would be if I didn't have insurance. They panic-asked to make sure I did, but I wanted to get the worst of the damage. She said she couldn't give it to me, but guessed it would be ~$700. Ok, that's my ceiling I thought.
After the procedure, my portion (after insurance) was $1500. Why? Well given my insurance, they charged ~$3200, and my insurance covered ~$1700, leaving me with the balance.
I argued for months and months and eventually settled to pay some portion of the OoP bill, which was around $700. Had I known to ask for that, it would've saved me time and frustration.
roguediamond · 6 points · Posted at 07:04:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This. I had a medical emergency that turned into a two week hospital stay (massive cluster of pulmonary emboli exacerbated by pneumonia - had to be resuscitated twice) and I had no insurance. Setting it up as self-pay saved me around $60,000, taking my total bill to around $20,000. This was ten years ago, mind you, but it took me from filing bankruptcy to something I was able to pay over time.
dano8801 · 2 points · Posted at 09:23:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
$80,000 for 2 weeks? Sounds cheap.
roguediamond · 2 points · Posted at 09:24:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It certainly didn’t feel cheap at the time, but it was ten years ago, as well.
dano8801 · 2 points · Posted at 09:57:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh I know. I said it half in jest, as tough it does sound like a low price it's still exorbitantly expensive. I feel like it would be double that now if not over 200,000.
roguediamond · 1 points · Posted at 10:03:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Absolutely - I’d definitely be looking at bankruptcy over that now if I didn’t have insurance. I was surprised it was as cheap as it was then. Didn’t mind paying it a bit - those folks literally saved my life.
luck_panda · 5 points · Posted at 08:29:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't forget that a lot of community clinics and FQHC will have a sliding fee scale and can work with you on a price point to be basically $0 if you are low income as they get paid per patient seen instead of percentages based on service rendered!
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 07:24:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is it possible to 'self pay' and then pass the bill/receipt onto your insurance company for a rebate?
herendethelesson · 1 points · Posted at 08:28:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this mean medical costs are default cheaper if you don't have insurance at all?
dushbagery · 1 points · Posted at 09:39:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
sorry to rain on your parade but its breach of contract for providers to provide self pay after insurance adjustment.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:54:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you believe this system is one that works? Obviously your job is in this field but doesn't it seem completely unnecessary that we need an anonymous user to tell us how not to get scammed out of our money?
HookersAreTrueLove · 1 points · Posted at 12:21:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I know that this practice is the norm, but I've always wondered why it isn't considered insurance fraud.
dida2010 · 1 points · Posted at 14:33:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It’s a great information, but the system is flawed, shouldn’t be like this. This is a horrible system, can’t believe people has to try to find all kind of ways to lower their bills, it’s like a medieval market where people negotiates for things, crazy!
Skystrike7 · 9 points · Posted at 05:21:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Anecdotally, the companies I've dealt with literally charge you less if they know you don't have insurance. Instead of ~600 bucks for my dental visit, I only paid about 120 because I asked the lady at the desk what they could do to reduce the bill so I didn't have insurance.
Revenge_of_the_Khaki · 61 points · Posted at 04:51:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's the real reason health care is broken in America. A lot of blame goes on the insurance companies, but the reality is that health care providers show us exactly what they could be charging and still stay in business. Health insurance is a bargain considering what they're charged for a claim.
[deleted] · 76 points · Posted at 04:55:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For real, fuck insurance. They have a “glitch” in their system every few months causing everything to drop to patient responsibility. There’s a reason why their stock prices continue to climb no matter the economic environment.
PippyNomNom · 18 points · Posted at 06:05:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So much this... you want to know where the money is going? Commercial insurance companies, pharma companies and medical device companies.
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 07:03:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's also a well known fact that a huge percentage of all Healthcare spend is just administration. These intentionally complicated insurance policies require literal armies to work through claims.
ingen-eer · 1 points · Posted at 10:59:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s why single payer or Medicare for all is such a nightmare. How many tens of thousands stand to lose their jobs if it happens? These are difficult, intellectual and high skill jobs, but they were deliberately created by an intentionally confusing system. The system was created to foster an environment that allows a man in the middle (the insurance) to suck up money like there’s no tomorrow.
BagOnuts · 2 points · Posted at 11:55:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m not sure why you’re getting downvoted. 2.9 million people work in the insurance sector. There are 900 health insurance companies in the US. You can’t just make an intire industry disappear through legislation. The lobbying to keep it would be massive.
You could elect Bernie, but there is no way single payer is passing congress or the judicial system.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:37:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's going to be a painful transition, but the job shouldn't be necessary so in a sense they aren't economically productive. We'd have to give the insurance and medical administration professionals an increased and prolonged unemployment in the event that 80% of their jobs evaporate over a few months.
PippyNomNom · 1 points · Posted at 06:05:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So much this... you want to know where the money is going? Commercial insurance companies, pharma companies and medical device companies.
MosquitoRevenge · 1 points · Posted at 08:03:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
True though stock seems to always go down during summer but bounces back in autumn and winter to a net positive.
conscwp · 20 points · Posted at 05:43:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's more complicated than that. Insurance companies aren't actually paying those crazy high bills, either. A hospital will send a bill for, say, $10,000 to an insurance company because they know that the insurance company has an entire department of negotiators that will find a reason to knock the bill to only $5,000. When sending it to an individual without insurance, they know that the individual has less power to negotiate so they have to put less of a buffer on it.
The reason that providers are able to charge less to non-insured patients is because they are subsidized by the high payments from insured patients.
LurkingLouise · 22 points · Posted at 07:04:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As someone not in the US, that still sounds insane to me. Healthcare should not be some yard sale where you're expected to haggle and it's entirely on you if you pay the asking price.
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 07:43:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yep. The US government is absolute fucking garbage. They let corporation and insurance companies fuck their citizens all over the place.
The weirdest part is how many Americans defend this trash system. I've literally had multiple people tell me they wouldn't want universal healthcare, even if it costs far less for the same or better care, just because some of their money would go to somebody else who they consider undeserving.
Sometimes I feel like they have the government they deserve. But then I remember that the vast majority of US citizens are kind decent people who do want a better system that helps everybody.
It's just that the republican party is either grossly incompetent or downright evil. And the democrats are definitely incompetent.
LurkingLouise · 7 points · Posted at 08:05:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's what I don't get, either. Like, how do these people think their car insurance or homeowner insurance or whatever works? You put money in a pot and (ideally) it's there when you need it, even if what you need is more than you've put in.
ebethGott5 · 2 points · Posted at 11:07:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Your car insurance doesn't pay for new tires, or oil changes, or new wiper blades. Your HO insurance pays for catastrophic damage from fires, thefts, etc, but NOT for the cleaning lady, the new carpet you want when the old stuff is worn out, or when a major appliance needs to be replaced. Americans expect healthcare insurance to pay for routine maintenance as well as for the big stuff, and face it, we don't take responsibility for BAD lifestyle health choices! Obesity, alcoholism, smoking, etc, take a toll on a body, and the expenses to care for the people who abuse their own health are passed to everyone in a single-payer system. I'm NOT talking about children who need life-saving operations, or victims of accidents or cancers that devastate lives and finances. But don't lump it all together, and it's NOT as simple as blaming "capitalism" for everything we don't like in our country.
LurkingLouise · 2 points · Posted at 13:05:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I was trying to point out how insurance works in general, not what insurance covers. But I am actually very glad that my health insurance (in my capitalist home country, since we seem to be talking about that now) pays for my six-monthly or 12-monthly checkup at my dentist and ob/gyn - those have helped detect a few issues early on. Would I go if insurance didn't cover those checkups? Probably not. So why do they cover it if they could just save that money? I know it's not out of the goodness of their heart, duh. It's because they are clever enough to know that spending a little on "maintenance" goes a long way when you're trying to detect and avoid any issues that might become a very expensive problem later, and their calculations have confirmed that.
Now about those "bad lifestyle health choices" - I agree, it bugs me to know that I'm paying for the cancer treatment of people who smoke like chimneys and drink like fish. But most health choices are not black and white, there're almost always pros and cons. A tradesman who busts his back lifting has not made a better health choice than a desk worker who ruins his back sitting. Is it a bad choice not to be a vegetarian? Not to run 5k every day? To play football because that might cause a whole lot of injuries? No country is made up of health nuts and couch potatoes alone, it's mostly reasonably healthy people with maybe a few bad habits (or genetic predispositions that are not their fault).
What I'm trying to say is, it's not super-healthy people literally pulling the weight of super-unhealthy people, it's a few bad apples benefiting from a system that benefits many, many others. Why would I want to punish the majority to weed out a handful of assholes?
Hope I made my point clear. I'm not trying to insult your country, or you, or your opinion.
FragrantBleach · 1 points · Posted at 08:11:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don't think either party is incompetent. I think they're doing exactly what they're paid to do. Which is create a show, a distraction, so the populace doesn't realize that their pocket is being silently picked a nickel at a time.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:30:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That just depends on what you consider their job to be. If their job is to take care of their citizens and to pass legislation that has been proven to work in other countries, then they're some of the most incompetent pieces of garbage on this planet.
FragrantBleach · 1 points · Posted at 08:36:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Based on that job description, you're 100% correct
TheNoxx · 2 points · Posted at 07:40:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Also, currently, hospitals have to eat the cost of people without health insurance. Any time a homeless person has a heart attack or cancer, or someone struggling to get by that can't afford any insurance has a life-threatening car crash or disease, the hospitals are required by law to save their lives.
This is another big reason why costs are inflated: they have to make up for everyone that comes in that can't pay their bill.
dushbagery · 2 points · Posted at 09:52:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
no its even more complicated than that. hospital charges $10,000 because they have to charge every insurance company the same price, per every contract including Medicare. And, Insurance company A might pay 8,000 and company B $5,000. But if you charge company A only $6,000, you are leaving money (2,000) on the table. Hospital might theoretically need only $5,000 to stay in the black and pay their doctors, so you might wonder, well fucking hospital don't be a dick and just charge $5,000. Well, thats more complicated too. If every bill was paid, then they would. But for every 10 visits they see, 2 might have come in with no insurance to the ER, and some states require (and many hospitals policy), is to treat first, and try to bill later. but for the poor, its virtually always a write off. So now the hospital is 10k in the hole. Another 2 get fully denied from insurance for some shaaaaadddy reason (or sometimes legit) , usually a retired doctor on payroll at the company that sends a letter saying "in my professional estimation, this was not medically necessary". Hospitals can then start the 3 month appeals process. any business types reading this already thought about the major cash flow problems this creates. so now hospital 20k in the hole. for good measure, not unlikely, a 5th gets partially denied, so now a 22k hole. For the remaining 5 patients, they need as much as they can get.
So, your big bill is partially subsidizing a strangers free care.
We can solve this mess, surprisingly, if the government outlawed claim denials and paid for poor care better, in exchange for insurance companies forcing providers to post price averages for diagnoses. the market would work then
BagOnuts · 1 points · Posted at 12:11:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
THANK YOU. You’re the first person I’ve seen ITT accurately explaining why bills are so high. Providers are required to charge all parties the same amount for the same services BY LAW, regardless of what they actually EXPECT to be paid.
They might expect $100 from Medicaid for a service, but $1,000 from commercial insurance, but they can’t bill them different amounts, so they bill $1,000 (or more) for the so they don’t lose money.
It’s also important to remember that contracted and government payers process claims differently, so the provider has to account for that as well. It’s ridiculously complicated, but just understanding the basics would clear up a lot of misunderstandings I see constantly posted all over Reddit.
1982000 · 29 points · Posted at 05:43:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance companies are entirely unnecessary. If we had group non-profit insurance, our Bill's would be so much lower. Insurance companies not only have to pay all of their employees, but the CEO's make obscene amounts of money. Like $22,000 a day. Look it up. Then they have to pay their shareholders. It's a FOR PROFIT business. They're not interested in you. They exist to make money. Why do you think they shit their pants when Bernie wants to get rid of them and expand Medicare. I have a disabled brother, and getting treatment for him is like a 20 hour a job week for my mom, filling out paperwork and trying to justify why he needs a surgical procedure. Smh.
sk8brdr540 · 1 points · Posted at 11:06:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Got any sources on 22k per day salary?
casce · 1 points · Posted at 12:09:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
22k per day is about 8m per year which isn’t unreasonable for CEOs of companies with upwards of 50 billion in sales per year.
1982000 · 1 points · Posted at 01:35:26 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Look up pay for pharmaceuticals CEO' pay. I'm not Google.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 06:41:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[removed]
sgkorina · 4 points · Posted at 07:50:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't compare insurance companies and unions. While you pay dues to be in a union, the increase in pay and benefits because of the union greatly outweigh the cost of union dues. Insurance and insurance companies don't benefit anyone but the insurance companies. If healthcare was nationalized the government and all but a tiny portion of Americans would save a ton of money
[deleted] · 44 points · Posted at 04:53:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yep. That is why for profit healthcare should not be legal.
I_hate_usernamez · 4 points · Posted at 07:55:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most hospitals are non-profit
[deleted] · 5 points · Posted at 08:01:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most insurance companies aren’t.
ThereInSquatsTheToad · 2 points · Posted at 11:49:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I had $1300 bill after insurance, I called billing and asked if they have a discount for paying in full. She took off $600 like it was nothing.
It doesn’t hurt to ask.
MedicalInsuranceQA · 1 points · Posted at 11:39:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sorry to hijack,,,,
Wow.
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you 4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
herselfonline · 1 points · Posted at 12:02:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am going to look into this at work, but I have been told that self pay and its discount is for people who do not have insurance. I can't just remove a person's insurance from the hospital account and say they dont have insurance, just because their insurance company is not covering a visit or procedure. Its insurance fraud, or so I have been told. I can help get the bill covered by proving the visit or imaging was medically necessary by sending in office notes, a letter of medical necessity, etc.
the_man_beast · 1 points · Posted at 12:02:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
While we are the topic of self pay, for prescription medication, check out blinkhealth.com. GoodRx also helps you get medication for reduced prices.
hawg_farmer · 353 points · Posted at 04:03:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Check every and I do mean every billing code. Most of my insurance rejected claims were somebody else sent in the wrong code.
cobainbc15 · 79 points · Posted at 06:16:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As someone who used to work in healthcare on the financial side, I absolutely agree. Many times the wrong thing gets booked and no one catches it until way too late.
sarahlucky14 · 47 points · Posted at 06:56:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yup this happened to me. Went to the ER for a migraine (had them since I was 3 years old) but because I was pregnant they coded it as pregnancy related and it wasn’t covered on the insurance and I noticed too late so nothing they can do. Meanwhile it’s fucking up my credit score, since I just left it go to collections. I’m just waiting for it to drop off my record in like 7/8 more years 😑😢
hypatiaspasia · 17 points · Posted at 07:24:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Pregnancy-related issues aren't covered by your insurance?? Wtf?
DoverBoys · 14 points · Posted at 07:32:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance generally covers "shit happens" stuff. Pregnancy is viewed as a choice to medical insurance, so you have to make sure you have insurance that specifically covers it.
GuineaPigBikini · 34 points · Posted at 08:09:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A choice, while meanwhile states continue to ban and put restriction on abortions...
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 09:55:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
Notterts · -1 points · Posted at 11:35:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Please remind us what contraception is 100% effective bar abstinence?
Unlike you, the rest of us don't have the privilege of involuntary abstinence
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 11:46:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
Notterts · 6 points · Posted at 12:01:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's not 100% though is it? Even if it's 1 out of 10,000 people still getting pregnant. It's unfair on that 1 person who doesn't have the option of abortion.
imsquaresoimnotthere · 1 points · Posted at 13:59:26 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
'abstinence is 100% effective' what about the virgin mary
Greenzoid2 · 14 points · Posted at 07:50:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That is so so so so so so fucked up
KonigderWasserpfeife · 6 points · Posted at 11:37:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Get this. My vasectomy was 100% covered. I never even saw a bill. About a year later, my wife had to have a uterine ablation, but we couldn’t find a doctor willing to do one unless she also had her tubes tied, removed, or some sort of permanent birth control. It increases the chances of ectopic pregnancy, and the doc’s logic (which I do understand) is that just because your husband had a vasectomy, you can still get knocked up. Vasectomies occasionally fail, people cheat, etc.
But, they deemed her salpingectomy was considered “elective,” and it wasn’t covered. Thanks, insurance!
Joo_Unit · 2 points · Posted at 12:51:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Pregnancy is covered as an essential heath benefit, so that is not the case since the ACA was passed. Just guessing here, but they probably sought out insurance after getting pregnant, preACA. Unless large group and self insured plans are underwritten (extremely rare), this is something that hasn’t been a thing for years. All health insurance plans are required to be aca Compliant (cover pregnancy and natal care).
bmess216 · 1 points · Posted at 17:32:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It seems to me that pregnancy could very much be a “shit happens”issue.
sarahlucky14 · 1 points · Posted at 04:33:26 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
At the time I was still on my parents insurance as a dependent and they don’t cover pregnancy for dependents. Got married and switched to my husband’s insurance but couldn’t change anything for that ER bill
[deleted] · 43 points · Posted at 07:13:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 07:35:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Conservatives, fuck yeah, such great people
BagOnuts · 1 points · Posted at 12:13:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
TIL conservatives have controlled the government for the last half century.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 09:19:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 10:15:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 11:30:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most voters have been brainwashed into thinking we woyld only get the worst parts of universal healthcare.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 16:47:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The hospital basically scammed the insurance by providing wrong code. In medicare-for-all insurance would just pay scammers with your taxes, basically saying them they can continue. How is this ok and when insurance doesn't pay scammers it is "fuck yeah murika"? I feel for the situation the lady ended up in, but it's a hospital scam, fraud, not different from any other.
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 13:29:41 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
I know it’s a separate point you’re making here but I’ll jump in on the Medicare-for-all part. Depending on how it is implemented, the system could sidestep this issue entirely. In a public hospital the patient doesn’t get a bill nor do they have an insurance company. The staff and doctors in the hospital are employed in that capacity by the government’s health department and provide whatever services are needed.
For foreigners who aren’t covered by Medicare, their bill is comprised of bill codes of a set and pre-determined value that are arrived at by a non-commercial non-political board of experts. Bill codes are all on the website. That’s how it works where I am
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 17:15:55 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)*
That would mean the government needs to directly own a lot of hospitals and directly employ all doctors, nurses, physicians in physician offices, their helpers, everyone basically who does medicine and accepts this government insurance, making all of them federal workers.
Sounds like an even worser scenario if you know what I mean.
And the question of private practitioners would be left wide open. What happens if I only have govt. insurance, but private doctor treated me? Will he bill government for this? If so what stops them from billing the wrong code? (back to square 1)
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 19:55:54 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good points.
I can only really speak from the experience of what we have here in Australia but I’m sure you’d find other implementations and opinions from various countries.
We have a bit of a hybrid system of public and private here. The government (State, not Federal) owns the public hospitals and employs the staff. Many doctors will work partially in the public system and also do private work either in hospital or clinical practice. No one in medicine is forced to work for the government.
Public hospitals are generally bigger, have many departments, and have Emergency. Private is more for scheduled elective day-surgery.
The objection to government run healthcare is largely cultural from what I can tell. Americans tend not to like it (and I’ve been to a few USPS centres so I think I know why) but we don’t have an issue with these sorts of things in principal. It’s more common and normalised. It also means there’s better transparency, accountability, and a formalised complaint process.
You’re not going to run into the issue of being billed by a private practitioner in a public hospital because they don’t work there. Anything you had done there including anesthetists is not billed at all so there are no surprises. You will however get billed with those billing codes if you’re a foreigner and it’d be up to you to get reimbursed by your travel insurance.
Private surgeons can set their own prices but they must get Informed Financial Consent from their patients. You’ll get a quote in advance for surgery from the doctor and your private insurance will also tell you in advance how much they’ll pay. There’s often an out of pocket cost with private surgery but the advantage is you choose your doctor, have shorter wait times, and more luxurious facilities. If it’s not worth it to you then you can go have it done in a public hospital and not pay anything if you choose to.
The billing codes are used in outpatient clinical consultations which are largely private practices. They are mostly small businesses or individual doctors working for themselves. To your point, yes, it’d certainly be possible for an admin person to get it wrong and submit the wrong code but it’s less likely as the codes in outpatient work are very straightforward, they use the same ones all the time, and there aren’t nearly as many codes as there are in America. There might be one for “15 minute GP consultation” or “throat endoscopy” instead of the very granular ones you get in the American system. Again, you’ll get all this cost information in advance when you call to make an appointment. They’ll tell you exactly how much the doctor charges (if they do charge) for each item and also the Medicare rebate for each item (or ‘bill code’ if you want to call it that). You pay the doctor in full on the spot then Medicare sends you the money to your bank account of the value of that bill code. This is the same rate for everyone except those in poverty with serious medical issues get more reimbursement as does any household of any income who has exceeded ~$1200 USD per year in out of pocket costs. Many doctors don’t charge at all and are happy to simply accept the payment of that biller code amount from the government directly to them without the patient being involved. Specialists rarely do that but GPs (same thing as PCPs) often do. Some will do it as standard practice for all patients where as some may charge most patients but not charge some based on their personal circumstances. In those cases the doctor still gets paid by Medicare but they make less without the patient also paying a chunk.
I’ve always thought our implementation of Medicare would appeal a lot to Americans compared to other countries’ systems. Doctors can set their own prices if they don’t want to work in public health, patients have the choice of going public or private, and costs are agreed upon in advance and if you don’t like it you can take your business elsewhere. A lot of that gels well with American capitalism as far as I can tell.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 03:24:02 on December 7, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! This is exactly the system I imaged as the best case scenario for US, mixed with private option, and even including the Consent part! I had no idea that I basically imagined already working Australia's system! Thanks a lot for writing such a descriptive commentary!
poopyhelicopterbutt · 1 points · Posted at 19:19:06 on December 19, 2019 · (Permalink)
You’re welcome! Yes it’s not a bad implementation. There are always improvements to be made but on the whole it works well. Hopefully America does something similar.
Tattycakes · 3 points · Posted at 07:53:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
That’s such bullshit that it wouldn’t be covered. As a coder (in the UK) there are rules about how to code conditions during pregnancy and a lot of the time you have to use a code from the obstetrics chapter instead of the usual body system code. However I don’t think a migraine would fall into that category unless it was caused by or aggravated by the pregnancy or it was complicating the pregnancy in some way.
StackKong · 2 points · Posted at 08:12:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am curious, can't the hospital send new bill to your insurance company with correct code?
Also, how much does it pull down your credit score? And, Can collections take from your earnings?
sarahlucky14 · 1 points · Posted at 04:37:54 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
They normally could within a certain amount of days but it had passed by that time. And no they can’t take from anyone’s earnings
Champigne · 2 points · Posted at 23:40:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's 7 years. If it's still on there by then, contact the credit bureau and they can manually remove it. I've had to do that for a loan that I paid off and still showed up afterwards.
sarahlucky14 · 2 points · Posted at 04:38:40 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! I have a few more years to go but I’ll keep an eye on that
HalalWeed · 1 points · Posted at 09:52:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol arent you americans finish colleges to do that shit right? Super shitty if you ask me. They should hire responsible people. Health is no joke.
FitLotus · 10 points · Posted at 06:21:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I would especially do this if you have a high deductible just so you know what to expect to pay OOP. Ask the doctor for a list of all possible procedure and diagnosis codes and call your insurance company and ask about each one.
instantrobotwar · 11 points · Posted at 07:51:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So if I have a huge bill, how would I even know if the codes are wrong? I gave birth recently and it was complicated and I asked for an itemized bill and it was miles long. I ask what certain charges are and they get annoyed. I can't do that for all 300 items on there, I literally do not have time. Also I was kind of out of it and don't remember exactly what happened a lot of the time.
Also, can I dispute charges after I've already paid? I honestly don't have time to dispute the bills now since the baby gives me almost no time to myself, so I just paid them rather than worry about them going to collections and hoped maybe I could look at them more thoroughly later.
hawg_farmer · 5 points · Posted at 11:09:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When I had to have two major surgeries back to back I asked my doctor for what codes they usually billed that procedure under. They sent me a list. Not perfect but I caught a lot of mistakes.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 06:32:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
othsoul · 3 points · Posted at 07:13:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In my case, the hospital had multiple National Provider Numbers (NPI) but only one NPI was registered in my insurance. The claiming dept in the hospital were incompetent enough to not check which NPI is covered. As a foreigner, it took me way too long to figure this out myself and let the hospital know.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 11:15:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yup. I have ADHD and was on stimulant medication when I started considering trying to get pregnant. I made an appointment with an OB to talk about his thoughts on my medication while trying to conceive and while pregnant. I think it was coded as something fertility related, which insurance said “yeah fuck no”. Called billing and explained what the appointment was actually about and the gal said they would change it to something like “medication consultation” since fertility was never really part of the conversation. Viola, insurance now covered.
Also, a fun fact, you’d be surprised how specific medical billing codes get. My mom originally went to school for medical billing and they have codes for damn near everything you can think of, even “injury due to turkey attack” lol
BigDew · 2 points · Posted at 11:15:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Imagine if health insurance wasn’t a thing and you just got healthcare regardless of a clerk entering the wrong number
anxiousbarista · 1 points · Posted at 11:03:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes! I was getting billed for a nurse's visit to get birth control injections. I called insurance and asked why this was not being covered under the ACA mandate since it is related to birth control and it was because the procedure code was wrong. If I wouldn't have known this and called I'd be paying the extra $75 every 3 months.
BABYEATER1012 · 1 points · Posted at 11:56:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How do I get the right code? I am trying to submit for reimbursement but the insurance tells me I’m using the wrong code?
yeahmaybe2 · 3 points · Posted at 13:02:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Try starting here: https://www.icd10data.com/ICD10CM/Index
Your diagnosis comes from a code set called ICD10(International Classification of Disease version #10), it's a bit complicated to locate your specific case but worth the effort.
The procedure or service you received comes from CPT codes(Current Procedural Terminology), start here: https://www.aapc.com/resources/medical-coding/cpt.aspx
tobmom · 1 points · Posted at 12:16:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Came here to say this. If you are told that insurance won’t cover something you need to know why. Ask insurance what’s missing. Often times if the medical provider hasn’t documented sufficiently the insurance company will try to get out of paying a claim.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:18:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So your saying that someone who is sick, possibly very sick, at possibly the most stressful times in their life, has to know a whole bunch of billing codes and go through every line item.
That's pretty fucked up
I go to the doctor here, I walk out paying ZERO. I don't even see a bill or have to sign anything. I walk into the doctors surgery, tell the doctor what's wrong, they write me a script, I walk out. Done.
You poor bastards.
hawg_farmer · 1 points · Posted at 17:38:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'll totally agree on it's a system fucked beyond any reasonable doubt. But!! On the plus you really only need to check your code on the bills as they pile in sometime for months. So there's that. /s
mjcanfly · 1 points · Posted at 06:33:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That shit happens all time how is that not some sort of fraud
PaulClifford · 430 points · Posted at 04:27:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It’s ridiculous that this excellent information also feels like tips for dealing in the black market. They are also reminiscent of this scene from the Incredibles: https://youtu.be/_R8GtrKtrZ4. Thanks for posting OP.
SoulShack · 59 points · Posted at 04:48:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow!! I had forgotten about that scene. It's so poignant now.
Tima_At_Rest · 8 points · Posted at 10:07:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It was super relevant then too. It’s just that more of the is poor now, when you consider the distance between those that can cover costs and those that can afford to feed their families.
TechnicallyAnIdiot · 6 points · Posted at 09:28:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You could even call it incredible.
chazmagic · 18 points · Posted at 05:47:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Truth in art
[deleted] · 85 points · Posted at 06:40:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The real tip for drastically reducing health care costs is to vote for Sanders so we can burn this shitty system to the ground
Kestrel21 · 12 points · Posted at 08:29:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're really optimistic if you think Bernie is gonna be able to change that much when you consider all the assholes who are selfishly interested in hamstringing his proposed reforms.
Don't get me wrong, vote for the man. But temper your expectations, maybe.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 08:38:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
straight_to_10_jfc · 4 points · Posted at 08:52:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No doubt he will be poisoned to mimic a death that lines up with heart problems like he had a spell with recently.
HonoraryMancunian · 10 points · Posted at 09:46:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm not particularly au fait with US politics, but isn't the standard MO to have a VP who is even more 'extreme' to discourage such things?
RichGirlThrowaway_ · -1 points · Posted at 10:02:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh he'll just die of those heart problems because he's old as fuck, in the most stressful job in the world, and has fucking heart problems.
HalalWeed · -1 points · Posted at 09:54:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Clintons will ground that old poor bugger. Rip burning sanding paper. We wil miss syou.
hairyforehead · 1 points · Posted at 14:45:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Never gonna have a better chance with a dem house and possible dem senate soon
mon0theist · -2 points · Posted at 12:23:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie's not going to change anything, and if he does they'll just kill him like they did Kennedy
St_SiRUS · 5 points · Posted at 08:50:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah pretty much covers how insurance is one of the most gross fucking businesses models. The entire profit margin comes from not helping people in need.
no_thks_havin_butter · 2 points · Posted at 10:51:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They’re PENETRATING the BUREAUCRACY!!
MedicalInsuranceQA · 2 points · Posted at 11:40:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sorry to hijack.....but
Wow.
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you 4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
HoboWhiz · 1 points · Posted at 12:02:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Exactly my experience as well
DemIce · 1 points · Posted at 11:53:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can we start r/YSKbsht ?
It'd double for both a YSK that is bad info, and for YSK (but shouldn't have to), like this one.
megatronny · 1 points · Posted at 19:42:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was it deleted
Donoteatpeople · 1 points · Posted at 07:37:40 on December 11, 2019 · (Permalink)
And it was deleted. Making your comment even more accurate
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 07:24:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Is it excellent information? Or is it Hokum posted by a person only feigning to have more knowledge than the average person when it comes to navigating medical insurance claims?
OP posts in wallstreetbets and from that we can infer, with absolute certainty, two things:
OP is no older than 23
OP is the type of absolute hapless fucking idiot that posts in wsb.
Is this a person you really want to take financial advice from?
ThaumRystra · 7 points · Posted at 07:42:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A 23 year old plumber might not know how to invest their money, but when they tell you about sewage, you listen.
It's not inconceivable that OP simultaneously has knowledge of an industry they work in and is a moron when it comes to financial planning. If you want to contradict what they're saying you'll need more than their implied skill in an unrelated field.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:27:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Uhhhh nah lol
maccaroneski · 209 points · Posted at 04:57:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This country's health system is a circus.
Source: living in the US after Singapore for 6 years and the rest of my life in Australia.
I had a spinal fusion in Singapore. 3 nights in a high dependency unit, an internationally renowned Neurosurgeon and a state of the art hospital (both selected by me) and all necessary diagnostics.
The bill was USD32k. The insurer covered 100%. I paid no premiums in addition to what my employer did.
A colleague here in the US had identical surgery. Same employer, so same level of cover. Premium is still $250 per month Leaving aside issues of network etc, he was discharged on the day of his surgery, and the total bill was USD170k. He had to cover $17k.
Scrantonstrangla · 26 points · Posted at 05:39:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Was 17k his plan’s max out of pocket?
Ask OP mentioned, ask for a self pay bill and the cost you have to pay is usually 40% cheaper
Lagkiller · 7 points · Posted at 07:25:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Assuming that this occurred after passage of the ACA, this didn't happen. Even the most expensive family plans are $15,800 out of pocket max this year. If it happened in previous years it was even lower because it adjusts each year.
BagOnuts · 0 points · Posted at 12:16:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Gotta love when people post bullshit exaggerated stories to get internet points, and everyone just automatically believes them.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:25:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Scrantonstrangla · 2 points · Posted at 14:01:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s a horribly high deductible, why did she choose that plan? That’s my annual out of pocket
Lagkiller · 0 points · Posted at 14:20:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well no, if your wifes plan is an individual plan, then she'd have a $7500 deductible, sure, then her max out of pocket would be $7900. There is literally no way that your wife would be paying more than that unless she had insurance that wasn't ACA compliant in which case she'd pay a penalty for not having insurance.
If your wifes plan covers both you and her, then it would be the $15,800 out of pocket max, which still is less than the amount originally claimed. It simply didn't happen. I'm confused where I provided you proof that the original claim was false and you doubled down on saying "It could totally happen" when it simply isn't possible.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:59:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 2 points · Posted at 15:08:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There's still a penalty written into the law, it is just currently reduced to $0. Any future administration could, as part of a tax bill, increase that penalty amount. The penalty is still in effect for previous years however.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 14:30:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 14:41:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I literally provided you the maximums allowed by law. So yes, I know everyone's plan because it's the max allowed. You've now tripled down on showing that you're wrong because you literally didn't click and read the link provided. Let me post it in plain text so you can see:
https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/
See the .gov part? Meaning it is from our government? The people who wrote the law? So yes, I know you plan because it's what's allowed by law. I don't know why you commented either.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 17:13:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 17:17:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's for all insurance. This is how I know you didn't read the link I posted. In order to be an ACA compliant plan, it must have these caps. If not, then it's not considered adequate coverage.
Which still must fall under the same ACA guidelines.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 17:51:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 18:00:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I literally provided you with the site that says it. You can go look at your coverage too, it will be outlined in black and white there.
I don't think you know what a deductible is. There is no such thing as a "maximum deductible".
You weren't wrong. You were intentionally being wrong. You were presented with evidence and then 3 times tried to tell me that I was wrong, despite having the evidence presented at your feet. All you had to do was read it.
Just like a deductible, it appears you don't know what an aneurysm is either.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 18:14:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 18:29:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm so glad that you added this thoughtful and detailed reply. I accept your apology.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 18:39:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 18:42:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Are you one of those people that believe they have to have the last word so they can "win"? If so go for it, I'll bow out here and you can "win" the argument your poor little ego so desperately needs.
maccaroneski · 1 points · Posted at 05:42:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I believe that it was the deductible - not sure if the rest of the details. Accordingly the OP's adviice unfortunately doesn't apply.
Scrantonstrangla · -2 points · Posted at 05:44:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No way that’s his deductible. A large deductible is like $2,500 dollars
[deleted] · 8 points · Posted at 06:02:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Scrantonstrangla · 0 points · Posted at 14:01:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Which are never really more than 6-7,000 total
ZivH08ioBbXQ2PGI · 6 points · Posted at 06:12:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What? Mine is like $8,000. Sometimes you just have to admit that you don't know what you're talking about.
pfabs · 2 points · Posted at 12:01:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
$8,000 might be your out of pocket max but it isn't your deductible.
A covered surgery would have a standard deductible of say $500. While a non covered surgery would have you cover a percentage.
So it's possible that someone could have to pay $17,000 for a surgery like OP claimed but something like $8,000 would be their out of pocket max. So they would pay $8,000.
NHToStay · 1 points · Posted at 12:03:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Deductible is 5k here, 10k family, and OOPM is 15k per person.
BagOnuts · 1 points · Posted at 12:28:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It’s possible that is their deductible, but that’s not the case for most people. There are no restrictions on deductible maximums, only total out-of-pocket costs.
Under the ACA, the maximum out-of-pocket limit on all plans in 2019 is $7,900 for individuals and $15,800 for families. But for HSA-qualified plans, the out-of-pocket limits are quite a bit lower, at $6,750 for individuals, and $13,500 for families.
HOWEVER, a HDHP (high deductible health plan) that qualifies you for an HSA (health savings account) requires a minimum deductible of $1,350 for an individual or $2,700.
So, if you have a high deductible, you actually have a lower OOP maximum. For example, if you’re an individual and your annual deductible is $2000.00, you have a HDHP, which means you have an HSA qualified plan, which means your max OOP can only be as high as $6750.00.
Thoughtsonrocks · 2 points · Posted at 07:24:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A lot of plans are something like:
$X,000 deductible
After that: %X0 co-insurance, where X is either 1 or 2.
So you pay the full, let's say, $4,000 OoP maximum, then it switches to 20% of everything on top of that until you hit another maximum. Those are usually in the 10's of thousands. That 20% can really hurt if you have some complicated, $76,000 surgery, leaving you with ~$14k of co-insurance.
BagOnuts · 3 points · Posted at 12:44:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not quite. Your OOP maximum is the maximum annual amount for all out-of-pocket costs (deductible, copay, coinsurance).
Under the ACA, the maximum out-of-pocket limit on all plans in 2019 is $7,900 for individuals and $15,800 for families. But for HSA-qualified plans, the out-of-pocket limits are quite a bit lower, at $6,750 for individuals, and $13,500 for families.
It would be extremely rare for anyone to have a $14,000 co-insurance. They’d have to have family coverage, a lower deductible, and a ridiculously high bill.
maccaroneski · 1 points · Posted at 05:51:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Would it be possible that it's a sum of deductibles across a number of different services (e.g. surgery, anaesthesia, radiology)?
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 06:27:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No. Deductibles, if they’re split at all, are split per “industry” (like, hospital, dental, pharmacy, and standard doctor would be separate)
They wouldn’t split it up like that for things WITHIN a hospital, for example.
Even the drugs you take at the hospital are billed to your medical, not your pharmacy.
Scrantonstrangla · 1 points · Posted at 05:55:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Perhaps if that was a long time ago, but even then they would be consolidated. I think he got an improper bill (happens all the time) but idk
bookloverdm · 1 points · Posted at 05:51:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No a deductible for a bronze plan under Obama care is $7500 per person.
Scrantonstrangla · 0 points · Posted at 05:56:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
..... no it’s not
AcceptableTale · 3 points · Posted at 06:26:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're right. That's actually the maximum allowed Out of Pocket Maximum. So there's not a single ACA compliant plan where you can end up paying more than that for a single person. The OOP max limit does jump to just under $15k for a family plan though.
bookloverdm · 1 points · Posted at 02:22:48 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
It is in San Diego California. I can’t speak to any other areas.
Alx0427 · 0 points · Posted at 06:25:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s the premium, not the deductible.
Alx0427 · -3 points · Posted at 06:25:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There’s no way. The largest I’ve ever heard of was $5k per person.
twir1s · 5 points · Posted at 06:44:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My OOPM is 7.5k. So, yeah, now you’ve heard of it.
I’ve seen some family deductibles around 10K but never 17.
Lagkiller · 3 points · Posted at 07:27:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Because it's not allowed to be that high
twir1s · 2 points · Posted at 07:36:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Dumb question, but does that limit just apply to marketplace plans or does it apply to plans you get through your employer/private insurers? Or are those one and the same?
Lagkiller · 1 points · Posted at 07:48:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It is for all plans that are ACA compliant for coverage (which is all health insurance plans at this point). Marketplace or employer, they have a max $7900 individual and $15800 for a family plan. Deductibles can be anything from $0 to the max out of pocket, but once you hit that limit, that's the limit.
If your plan has a max out of pocket above these levels, then you need to pay a penalty for not having health insurance because they wouldn't qualify as an ACA compliant plan.
gudmar · 3 points · Posted at 06:35:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I have a $6500 deductible. It all depends on the plan.
maccaroneski · 1 points · Posted at 06:41:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As I say, not sure if the details, but that's what he claimed his total out of pocket expenses were. I was just assuming that it was a deductible/s.
Even after 15 months here, your medical system confuses and frightens me.
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 18:23:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you know if he hopped years during that time (like was he in the hospital from December until like February of the next year?
Because then you have to pay 2 deductibles.
myalias1 · 3 points · Posted at 06:23:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just to check: you're saying, in Singapore, employers pay health insurance premiums for employees?
EL___POLLO___DiABLO · 4 points · Posted at 08:07:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's the same in Germany. The premiums are split 50/50 between employer and employee, I never paid for any medical treatment (surgery or else) in my entire life (I'm 30). Exception: needed a Dental filling and wanted a different filling than what the insurance covers, costs 50€.
maccaroneski · 3 points · Posted at 06:39:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I was an expat working for a foreign company's APAC headquarters, so whilst by no means in a majority, I was in a significant minority.
For the rest (i.e. citizens and permanent residents) there is decent health coverage under a variety of public and mandated insurance and self insurance schemes. Most major health services roll up to government owned corporations (as do many services, including various transportation and educational services).
NicolajN · 1 points · Posted at 10:50:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most expat friendly countries will i think. I live in Hong Kong and my employer pays for healthcare for me and my entire family
Grew up in Denmark. basically no private healtcare insurances, so government pays it all
xRyozuo · 2 points · Posted at 08:28:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What I’ll never understand is, if Americans are so willing to be taken all of their money if an accident happens to them, or if they pay x a month for insurance (which from these posts I gather they pay not much??) why not just vote for some god damned healthcare
LucyLilium92 · 2 points · Posted at 12:21:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Because socialism is bad
eaglex · 2 points · Posted at 12:18:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
off-topic, but was the spinal fusion because of disc herniation?
if yes, did your life improve afterwards?
maccaroneski · 2 points · Posted at 15:34:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So the theory is that my C5/6 disc (base of the neck, just below the shoulder line) suffered a trauma when I was playing contact sports when I was younger.
25 years later, normal age related degeneration cause those cracks to open up and sequestration of the disc. The rest of my spine is just fine other than that one disc.
I'd had the odd neck ache after travelling or sport which became more regular until the pain persisted and started down my arm as the nerve root was impinged by the disc matter. It got to the point where I couldn't get out of bed without icing and painkillers.
I tried all different sorts of treatment over a 3 month period (the recommended time to try conservative management) before going under the knife.
(As an aside, my colleague who had the surgery in the US was convinced to do so after suffering some mild tingling in his left arm which would happen after 18 holes of golf).
Now a year later I'm a little careful when lifting things over my head, and every once in a while when I'm run down it gets a little sore, but other than that, no symptoms at all.
eaglex · 2 points · Posted at 19:18:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
thanks for sharing!
I got hit by a car while on my road bike and after a while I found out I have 4 protruding discs.
I have little day-to-day pain but it's really frustrating because I can't do any sports at all without making it worse.
every doctor says it's really minor, but it's been a year and nothing really works to improve it.
I started reading about different kind of surgeries, that's why I was curious about real-world experiences, so thank you again for sharing that!
maccaroneski · 2 points · Posted at 19:27:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Think of it as an absolute last resort. It's not much fun, and it was bad enough with a single disc let alone 4.
It was the toughest experience if my life and would do almost anything to avoid it happening again.
mon0theist · 2 points · Posted at 12:24:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I really wish I could figure out a way to leave the US and go somewhere else
nicebutcrippled · 233 points · Posted at 04:57:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
im in canada, but i upvoted anyways so that hopefully my american neighbours can see this
arachnidtree · 60 points · Posted at 05:10:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
this story, along with Rosa Parks waiting 2 hours for an emergency response, and some people still furiously fight against fixing US health care. Unbelievable.
SharpieScentedSoap · 27 points · Posted at 06:25:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just earlier today I was on a thread on Facebook about american health care, and I actually saw someone saying "Well MY care is free, so you're just being lazy and not trying hard enough. Just get different insurance if you pay too much. Taxes bad!"
BeardsBearsBeers · 17 points · Posted at 08:47:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What I’ve never understood is why people are willing to pay for insurance but not be taxed an amount? In the UK it’s clearly written out on our payslip as “National Insurance Contributions” - and what you pay is 12% of earnings, so if you make £1,000 a month you pay like £95 (due to paying nothing on the first £166 - you also pay something like 2% after earning a bit over £4k a month). It just sits in the same column as regular tax, and is adjusted based on how much you earn - I’ll take that over worrying if I have to fork out due to the insurance company rejecting my claim... my retired mother in-law just had major surgery, all sorted within a week, didn’t pay a penny because of this.
ionicshoe · 19 points · Posted at 08:51:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Propaganda by healthcare companies and all the surrounding interest groups will do that for you
PM_ME_NEW_VEGAS_MODS · 4 points · Posted at 11:47:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Man. That sounds like a dream. My grandmother can't even save her front two teeth after battling cancer, which put her in debt, because no one will help her cover it. She pretty much gave up after that.
BeardsBearsBeers · 1 points · Posted at 11:55:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is exactly what I mean - people will explain away how the system in the US is more beneficial but then you hear so many horrible stories like this... I’m sorry for what your grandmother went through, hopefully something changes sooner rather than later.
PM_ME_NEW_VEGAS_MODS · 2 points · Posted at 12:31:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We'll get there. Thanks for the sympathies.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:12:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Mostly because I don’t want the government to tax me because I don’t trust where they will use it.
BeardsBearsBeers · 1 points · Posted at 15:37:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As oppose to giving it to a large corporation? Who aren’t guaranteed to cover your expenses. If I have a heart attack today, live or die I go through that entire experience without paying a penny more; if someone has the same in the US there’s a chance they might end up in debt because of it.
Regardless of what happens to my money and what the government decide to do with it, I have the comfort of knowing the NHS is there - the only things we pay for are meds and even then, you get it for free under a lot of circumstances - I have asthma and have to buy an inhaler for like, £9 or something every 3 or so months depending on how often I use it, which is what, $15?
Trust me I don’t trust the current UK government as far as I can throw it but as long as our healthcare is nationalised I’m happy - we sold off our train services a long long time ago and a lot of people (including myself) want to see it reverted, because of the shit state our rail system is in.
ebethGott5 · 0 points · Posted at 18:27:17 on January 21, 2020 · (Permalink)
Y'all are all talking like EVERYONE should foot the bills for people who live careless and unhealthy lifestyles. Costs for healthcare are inflated and CEOs of BCBS, etc, are absolutely absurd, but throwing out EVERYTHING not the answer, and socialism doesn't fix anything EVER (#BSanders).
BeardsBearsBeers · 1 points · Posted at 18:54:30 on January 21, 2020 · (Permalink)
I have asthma, so I have an inhaler - costs me £9 on NHS for a refill that lasts half a year - I’ve read that’s about $90 in the US? You can pay tens of thousands for giving birth DESPITE having insurance, it doesn’t cost a penny more than your NI contributions in the UK - and don’t get me started on bloody insulin.
US healthcare is an expensive NHS with extra steps - ALSO private firms exist if you wish to pay to slip queues.
The US are one of the few developed western countries to not have nationalised health, so the other dozens of countries must be wrong, right?
It’s just tax. You get taxed, and you get healthcare from the government. It’s that simple.
ebethGott5 · 0 points · Posted at 18:29:17 on January 21, 2020 · (Permalink)
Also, allowing residents of different states to purchase plans from OTHER states would help the free market actually BE free. The first problem is the monopoly within which insurers work!
onemanandhishat · -1 points · Posted at 11:05:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There are 2 benefits to the individual. First, insurance is often provided by an employer, so you aren't paying for it directly, unlike taxes. If they ditch insurance is it likely that money will end up going into your salary instead?
The other is that if you can afford better insurance you can choose better care. If everything is publicly funded like the NHS that ability to choose the better option goes away and the rich get stuck with the same standard of healthcare as anyone else.
BeardsBearsBeers · 2 points · Posted at 11:07:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have private health care as well, we’re not restricted to the NHS - if people want to skip the queue for non-urgent care they can if they pay places like BUPA and other private firms - a few friends have done that.
manafount · 2 points · Posted at 12:24:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm not sure if the last sentence is an actual question, but all benefits are meticulously accounted for as part of overall employee compensation. The money to pay for your insurance, commuter benefits, gym memberships, etc doesn't come out of thin air - it's absolutely money that would otherwise be part of your salary.
I don't know why you think that's the case. I can't think of a single example of a country with nationalized health care that doesn't also have private health care available.
Tralalaladey · -10 points · Posted at 06:32:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don’t think either side sees the healthcare system as working. There’s just disagreements on if socializing it in such a huge country will work. I’m prepared to be accosted but I don’t think healthcare being socialized would work in the US because it’s too big. The US government is horrible at running things effectively and efficiently so it would get even worse.
I’m not an expert but everyone looks to socialism for healthcare but I don’t think Americans have 15 tril (estimates) laying around. I mean the military budget is insane and the healthcare estimate is like 25 times bigger than that. So we would need to go more into debt and get rid of our military. Like what? How does this make sense?
Very open to discussion! Don’t be rude to me I’m just a regular person.
crash_test · 7 points · Posted at 07:37:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is this $15 trillion over 10 years or something? The US already spends over $3.5 trillion per year on healthcare, so while estimates that show 10 year costs in the double digit trillions may seem scary, realize that we're already spending much more than that currently, and total healthcare expenditure would likely go down by hundreds of billions of dollars per year under a single-payer system.
MagicGin · 9 points · Posted at 06:55:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
People don't have a choice with health care. There aren't enough specialists, meaning there's no real competition between providers, which in turn means the free market advantage is absent. For non-specialized care, things like antibiotics and emergency visits are also not a choice. Again, competition is absent.
When profit motive exists, money is intrinsically drained from the system. That's because people are motivated to, quite literally, take money from the system. How is incidental bureaucratic inefficiency possibly worse than intentional profit-motivated inefficiency?
Likewise, how would socialized health care possibly cause notably more than the existing insurance structure? No matter how inefficient the bureaucracy is, how could it possibly be less efficient than splitting the load for processing insurance claims through dozens of different insurance companies? And why would the government require more money than what citizens are currently paying to private insurance providers?
There's simply no capitalist argument for health care. It needs to be regulated and controlled, just like water/electricity/etc.
DemosthenesOG · 6 points · Posted at 07:04:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not to mention that that once healthcare is single provider, that provider has a massive bargaining position with the pharma companies etc. It would require bizarre incompetence and corruption for them not to be able to negotiate a better deal for Americans.
Gornarok · 4 points · Posted at 07:34:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Healthcare isnt free market period.
You have to have a control over demand in free market - you must have the ability to decide if you want the product at the price being asked in the free market. You dont have that ability in healthcare. When you are sick you will get treatment for whatever it costs
batmansleftnut · 6 points · Posted at 07:08:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a socialist, let me assure you that single-payer healthcare is not socialism. Most or all socialists would agree that it's a good thing to have, but that's not what socialism is.
Can you explain why scaling is the problem you see with single-payer medicine? That's a common objection, but I've never gotten an explanation for why it wouldn't work for a larger population.
Tralalaladey · 1 points · Posted at 17:43:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But we did Obamacare. Anyone on either side of the aisle will tell you in was an absolute disaster. It made healthcare more expensive for everyone on it or not on it. When I was growing up the average deductible for a family was so little no one cared now it’s on average 12k which was totally unheard of. I think it might even be higher now.
Are you with Bernie and thinking Medicare for all? Because there’s literally nothing working with Medicare now. It’s practically insolvent. Doctors don’t even want to help Medicare patients, they won’t even see them, because they don’t want to deal with it because it’s such a mess.
We can’t be like Canada or France or whatever, because we fund the national defense for allllll of them, that’s been the deal. So our money goes to that. They have more money to play with. Places in Canada are also paying like 50% in taxes. If we did that here people would maybe actually start throwing things in harbors again.
You look at Canada’s wait times in ERs. You’ll have to look it up but it’s like 30% of Canadians have spent 5 plus hours in an ER waiting room. In US that’s 5% and look at our population! That’s really good. Yeah you might go broke but I’d rather be alive and bankrupt just saying.
MyMcLovin · 3 points · Posted at 07:40:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Isn’t 15 tril over 10 years? I found warren trying to raise that in a differing amount in taxes and Bernie’s plan costing 30 over 10. Also Americans spent 3.5 in healthcare in 2017 alone, not including expenditures on individuals who receive assistance or all med paid. We would be moving money from private business to government, I could see a problem with the startup cost inflating however people are already spending the money to go to the hospital or not able to pay and go into debt crippling their lives and input into the US economy, and insurance comps are just complicating middle men who add admins inflating costs astronomically. Americans still pay for poor kids and families through taxes right now, while spending more on healthcare than they would through the proposed plan. Now the execution has yet to be seen, but it definitely needs done. I work in material services at my local hospital and the amount individuals pay vs the cost to bring in even the most simple items is insane and wouldn’t happen when the entire country is on the same page keeping an eye on cost.
Edit:words
TheOneShorter · 1 points · Posted at 09:29:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It seems you got quite a few great explanations! I hope the downvotes don't dissuade you from discussing the topic further, this was super educational for me as well.
Tralalaladey · 1 points · Posted at 17:22:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They usually do discourage me because 90% of my opinions aren’t accepted here on reddit anymore. But I’ve had a lot worse interactions. Definitely look into the other side of things. I just can’t think of anything the government has run successfully and under budget and I already think US government has too much power, so to give them our healthcare sounds absolutely terrifying.
bkdog1 · -8 points · Posted at 07:24:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I dont think people fight against fixing healthcare , they fight against socialized/government run healthcare. Most people are unaware that most medical discoveries come from America but we allow a fee exchange of information so the rest of the world benefits. I happen to live within a couple hours from the most advanced hospital in the world where every year people come from 130 different countries around the world. It isn't uncommon for prime ministers, royalty and the dali lama to fly in to receive care. Just about every drug company has their r&d in the U.S. Many Americans are also aware of the negative aspects of single payer or nationalized healthcare systems that can be found in Canad and Britain. Need to find a way to reform the healthcare system while maintaing aspects that has made American healthcare the most advanced in the world. Do you want Trump to be in charge of your healthcare?
https://fortune.com/2015/11/03/us-europe-healthcare-gdp/
https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2011/03/23/the-most-innovative-countries-in-biology-and-medicine/#3f2b3e01a714
https://www.voanews.com/europe/britains-national-health-service-engulfed-crisis
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/world/europe/uk-national-health-service.html
https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/report/london-calling-dont-commit-nationalized-health-care
https://www.ibtimes.com/how-us-subsidizes-cheap-drugs-europe-2112662
Meche__Colomar · 6 points · Posted at 08:26:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
how are people still this uninformed? there's more US citizens going to Canada for care than the other way around, and virtually all Canadians going south are coming for plastic surgery, while American's come for cheap drugs or out of pocket surgery. Please educate yourself and stop being a dumbass.
BeardsBearsBeers · 4 points · Posted at 08:51:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
R.e. the UK ones, it’s always blown out of proportion. If you have an emergency, you will be seen to - they prioritise people based on lives saved - whenever it says people wait 12 hours it’s because they turn up to a hospital with a rash or a cough. The NHS is definitely something that needs a lot more love and attention, I’m not saying it’s perfect, but holy shit am I glad it exists.
[deleted] · -9 points · Posted at 07:35:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Wait times for a specialist in Canada is 20 to 40 weeks. Imagine being in pain that long or your condition worsening. Scary stuff.
*https://www.fraserinstitute.org/studies/waiting-your-turn-wait-times-for-health-care-in-canada-2016
HRCfanficwriter · 8 points · Posted at 07:45:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
imagine just dying because you cant afford to see a doctor in any weeks
[deleted] · -2 points · Posted at 08:16:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Quit being dramatic. Do you honestly believe doctors are telling patients that if they don't pay they have to die? Hospitals aren't letting people just die. Research medical indigent.
Fraser Institute where I got the wait times. It's a Canadian site.
HRCfanficwriter · 4 points · Posted at 08:31:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Couple dead in apparent murder-suicide left notes saying they couldn’t afford medical care, police say
13% of Americans say they know someone who died after they couldn't afford health care, survey says
they must be making it up
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:40:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
From the CNN article
I don't know why you posted the other link
HRCfanficwriter · 1 points · Posted at 08:44:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes, thanks I read the article. I know that's in there, why don't you actually say something about it
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:59:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
143 people claim they know someone who died waiting on treatment.
The article says those stats do not determine the number of people that died die to lack of healthcare.
That's not helpful information for anyone
HRCfanficwriter · 1 points · Posted at 18:39:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So youre saying that all those people are lying?
Meche__Colomar · 3 points · Posted at 08:30:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Canadians live literally 3 years longer than Americans and pay half as much for healthcare, this was not true before the 1970s when both countries had the same life expectancy and paid about the same amount. By virtually all measures Canadians get much better healthcare than their American counterparts.
arachnidtree · 2 points · Posted at 14:41:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
stop posting lies.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 16:12:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When did I post lies?
arachnidtree · 2 points · Posted at 16:23:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You are telling a Canadian what their wait ties are. It's wrong.
Stop this political bullshit posting, you only embarrass yourself.
Frankly, I think it is hilarious that the republican talking point has regressed all the way to "wait times are long".
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 16:53:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Your not canadian.
When grow up I hope you become a mature adult or the real world will chew you up and spit you out.
Good luck kiddo.
arachnidtree · 1 points · Posted at 18:29:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sorry, but I am.
Stop lying.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 18:48:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I find it strange that your comment history is full of criticism about American politics and say nothing about Canadian politics. Why so obsessed with another countries policies when they don't affect you?
arachnidtree · 1 points · Posted at 18:52:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
what makes you think it is another country?
lol, I love how you wasted your day with RESEARCH! and ended up completely wrong.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:00:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
America and Canada are different countries.
It took 5 mins to find that article.
arachnidtree · 1 points · Posted at 19:25:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
the article is crap. That's the point.
you can find a flat earth article in less than 5 minutes.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 19:32:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Things will get better for you. I sincerely wish you the best.
arachnidtree · 1 points · Posted at 19:39:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
fyi, you have rambled way off point. Presumably because you realize that facts will not avail you, so you are staying away from them.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 08:23:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Moving to Canada might as well be included in the list.
nebola77 · 6 points · Posted at 09:23:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am german, reading all of this is just like .. wtf do you have to do, just to not be completely bankrupt. Meanwhile in our country, I just take the treatment and don’t pay anything.
burnalicious111 · 1 points · Posted at 10:48:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Be rich and/or avoid going to the doctor. If you get lucky you may find an employer that provides actually decent insurance.
jeetkunedont · 5 points · Posted at 07:19:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm in tasmania and did the same for the same reason. I can't believe how fucked up the health care system is over there (along with a metric fuckton of other stuff too). Hobart's public hospital has one of the worst waiting lists in the country; i was on a waiting list for hernia surgery for 2 1/2 years and told I'd be waiting 4, got a call on a monday asking if I'd be available for surgery on friday, said yes, got moved next door to the private after surgery went home with abiut a months worth of dressings, had a follow up with the surgeon 2 weeks later and didn't pay a cent. I can't imagine what it would have cost me there.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 06:07:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ridiculous over here. Wish we adopted your guys practices
TheLazyVeganGardener · 2 points · Posted at 12:38:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well it’s been deleted now :(
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:11:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wish it hadn’t been deleted. We could all use this sort of advice.
SquattingWalrus · 3 points · Posted at 06:47:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What a good guy. Thanks buddy
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 07:06:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He's not your buddy, guy
nicebutcrippled · 1 points · Posted at 07:03:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
girl actually but i'll take it haha, n no worries we'll always be looking out for ya
Alx0427 · 2 points · Posted at 06:28:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
HEYO there BUD.
Whatcha doin bud?
nicebutcrippled · 3 points · Posted at 06:59:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
ay buddy, it's cold as tabernak here eh? was about to go to town to grab some timmies, double double good for ya there? also happy cake day bud
Alx0427 · 2 points · Posted at 18:25:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks a million there bud. Cake days the best day. My buds always grab up some Tim’s coffee for me. They’re some good buds, bud.
[deleted] · -5 points · Posted at 08:31:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
jsparker89 · 3 points · Posted at 08:40:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They live longer and pay half as much, fuck off and get educated.
[deleted] · -2 points · Posted at 10:17:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Telling someone to "fuck off" isn't going to encourage them to "get educated" now is it?
[deleted] · -2 points · Posted at 10:40:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
jsparker89 · 1 points · Posted at 11:11:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm actually an anarcho socialist, also your wrong about health tourism it usually goes the other way.
[deleted] · 72 points · Posted at 04:58:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 06:17:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Did you tell them that you wouldn't be able to pay anything if they couldn't adjust it?
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 06:33:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 06:51:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ahh... yeah, that definitely didn't help. If it's "something or nothing", that changes the entire conversation.
[deleted] · 22 points · Posted at 06:16:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 06:38:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Lawlsagna · 2 points · Posted at 16:43:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I'm gonna give a very specific example of a situation I encountered the most often working in anesthesia billing.
Colonoscopy screenings without any problems have one code and colonoscopy screenings with problems(polyps/etc) have a different code. They don't know the resulting code until the procedure is performed and they find whether there are problems. Unfortunately, screenings without problems were covered entirely by insurance with little to no patient responsibility(~$26 coinsurance). However, colonoscopies with polyps usually defaulted the entire allowed amount to the patient deductible(~$232). If a provider were to give you the code for the screening you're going in for, but it turns out there's something wrong, you'd end up with a higher charge.
So, that's one reason providers may be hesitant to provide you with the codes, but also because billing departments are different than the coders who read the medical records to translate the procedure to code. The people you've asked just may not know and the people who do know may not have that information until after the procedure.
BlessedChalupa · 2 points · Posted at 07:51:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is a helpful tip, but geez what a mess! Who has the presence of mind to track all this down when you’re sick and just need to get to a doctor and let them do their thing??
I feel like this is the core problem with trying to treat healthcare like a consumer-driven market. Nobody wants to deal with “shopping around” in the middle of a medical emergency. If you DO make the effort, it’s super complicated. Nothing is set up to make this easy for you. Nobody can tell you in advance what anything will cost. This advice here requires multiple kinds of obtuse codes to get specific definitions of the services you might need... but who knows what the doctor will actually recommend once you’re there?
I’m personally fortunate enough to have good insurance and mostly good experiences, but this crap is way too complicated. And we haven’t even touched on how hard it is to actually use my damn HSA....
filemeaway · 1 points · Posted at 07:19:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks I need to cancel my health insurance this is fucking shit
FitLotus · 15 points · Posted at 06:24:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Next time ask for a name and reference number when you call insurance. Then you can point to the exact moment you were misinformed.
It’s also ridiculous that the doctors office wouldn’t just honor a self pay rate. It’s completely arbitrary that they “already billed it”, they got no reimbursement from it anyway. If this happened in my office they would absolutely get a discount.
TitsForLife · 4 points · Posted at 07:01:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Usually if insurance denies something you can send in an appeal, in writing, and cite the wrong information you were given. If you had the date, time and name of the person you spoke with they should be able to find some record of it and hopefully honor what you were told. If the appeal gets denied I’d send a complaint to your states board of insurance (or whatever the regulatory office is called). They will contact the insurance company and try to get a resolution.
Alx0427 · 4 points · Posted at 06:29:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m sure they record all phone calls. You could subpoena the phone records. And then they’d have evidence and have to honor it.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:39:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
Alx0427 · 2 points · Posted at 18:22:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It’s not a criminal case. So there’s no such thing as statute of limitations
[deleted] · 77 points · Posted at 05:14:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So, what you're saying is that medical costs are 40% higher than they need to be because of insurance companies.
OK. Gotcha.
[deleted] · 61 points · Posted at 05:20:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Technically 250% higher. $100 bill for insurance is $40 but for you it’s $100.
pizzafourlife · 10 points · Posted at 05:39:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So to be lower for them it has to be higher?
Buying a car is sounding straightforward
Mitosis · 2 points · Posted at 12:25:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
While now it's largely "how things are," it came out because of group negotiating.
Insurance companies represent large numbers of people. They say hey, we represent this large number of potential customers, and if you work with us we'll say you're "in network" and refer all these customers to you, but in return we want a hefty discount. Hospital says sure we'll do that, then jacks up their "official" prices to offset the discount they just gave insurance companies.
It's also related to the fact that employers are tied into health insurance, because companies put all their employees under one easily-managed block for the insurance company to service and then use as clout in the above scenario. Since the overwhelming number of people are covered by their employer, they pay far less attention to what they're actually paying for health insurance, and that (combined with the basic need for health care at quick speeds) means there's little to no ability to shop around and let hospitals actually compete on price.
Employers are only tied into health insurance at all because of wage freezes during World War 2. A huge labor shortage arose due to the lower number of workers and higher demand for products because of the war, so wages were skyrocketing. The government froze wages as a result, but did not include fringe benefits (relatively rare at the time, or more benign things like PTO). In an attempt to attract employees companies started offering to pay for health insurance since they couldn't pay more actual cash. That's the real root of the nightmare we have today.
[deleted] · 9 points · Posted at 06:44:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
sighs__unzips · 12 points · Posted at 07:39:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But insurance also costs money. The whole insurance industry costs billions of dollars to run. That includes premiums, salaries, rents, advertising, costs of doing business, etc.
Who pays for all this? It's the consumer of course. If the consumer didn't have to pay for this, then the market should work to lower costs.
It's like when you eat at a restaurant. Instead of paying the bill, you forward the bill to your "food insurance" company who then works with the restaurant to lower your bill. But someone has to pay for this food insurance, the insurance workers' salaries, etc. Instead of the consumers just paying for their food, they have to pay for an entire industry.
tromboner378 · 3 points · Posted at 12:09:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is all true, but I've never seen admin costs (all the costs you mentioned that aren't medical expenses) higher than 10% in any of the companies I've worked for.
HoboWhiz · 1 points · Posted at 12:10:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, that's why he mentioned the loss ratio. That's essentially the cut insurance companies are allowed to take to cover their own operating costs and profit.
deadpear · 7 points · Posted at 07:33:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Doctor salaries are less than 20% of health care expenditures in the US. Doctors could be paid 0$ and healthcare costs would drop ~15% or so.
Wohowudothat · 2 points · Posted at 12:26:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Payments for physician services is 20%, but the average overhead ratio is 50%, so 10% of that goes to physician overhead, which is things like the rent for their office, their office staff (nurses, MAs, front desk personnel), electronic medical record system, etc. The physicians are getting about 10% of health care expenses, so even a giant 50% salary cut would be a 5% decrease in expenses.
[deleted] · 10 points · Posted at 07:09:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 8 points · Posted at 08:01:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
but muh free market
Amon-Re-72 · 1 points · Posted at 09:11:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Government does set prices for Medicare and Medicaid patients. The problem is that the prices they set are so low that we lose tons of money providing services to these patients. It is so bad that in my area of the country, many docs won't take Medicare, because they can't keep the doors open if they do.
Even in a large system, we have to limit the number of Medicare patients on a doctor's panel. If the ratio of Medicare to private insurance patients gets out of whack, we lose too much money. Lose too much money and we can't pay the bills and we close. Government set prices don't take those factors into account.
[deleted] · -3 points · Posted at 07:27:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is good in theory, until you consider what a GOP government would do with this power.
You think that for profit prisons are bad, imagine those same people in charge of price fixing for medical costs.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 07:59:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They already are. They're called executives and they're essentially third world dictators except with good infrastructure paid for by the public.
MosquitoRevenge · 1 points · Posted at 08:14:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And the nurses etc who work in the hospital never see all that extra money. Is my guess.
MY-SECRET-REDDIT · 1 points · Posted at 10:47:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But didnt insurance companies start this escalating war? They needed to prove they worked so they started asking for discounts which the hospitals couldn't afford so they simply raised the prices artificially
ksande13 · -7 points · Posted at 07:06:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
no, they’re higher for the average consumer because of government programs meshing with an otherwise free market.
[deleted] · 8 points · Posted at 08:02:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol, like healthcare can be a "free market". Let's see you shop around for ambulance services when you fall and break your back.
I bet your aggressive cancer will be treated equally well under the cheapest possible clinic.
Healthcare is a completely captive market. And Health insurance is usually a captive market as well.
Healthcare, is infrastructure. Like roads and power and water and breathable air. It's, in my opinion, immoral to privatize and put a profit motive on that kind of thing.
[deleted] · -7 points · Posted at 08:23:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
jsparker89 · 3 points · Posted at 08:45:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Maybe you should read a book, or ya know just look at the health outcomes of every developed country in the world that has a state run healthcare system.
Prefrontal_Cortex · 2 points · Posted at 08:50:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What book do you recommend and why? Which book(s) did you read to get your information?
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 09:18:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
ugh the one you google. start with The HSA Guidebook. The 13th edition is available online for free. Then I would suggest researching how medical payments work both under the primary medical plan and the pharmacy benefits. If you let me know what state you live in, I can recommend a personalized resource
edit: also make sure you read up on coordination of benefits on the statutory and federal level. pay special attention to medicare and domestic partners.
then, call a professional. because you clearly aren’t qualified to make an informed decision with the information you’ve reviewed as of this moment. they’ll help get you educated. please refer their services to others as well.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:39:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My blood is boiling, you're acting like everyone's problems are illegitimate. You're the dumbass for supporting the FUCKING HORRIFIC status quo.
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 20:46:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
i’m not supporting the status quo. i’m just saying the proposed solutions will make it even worse.
glodime · 1 points · Posted at 09:04:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm sorry you're too dumb to understand the problem. Stop actively making it worse.
ksande13 · -1 points · Posted at 10:02:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
may god have mercy on your sweet, innocent, crippled soul
glodime · 1 points · Posted at 10:18:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Still can't figure it out? Keep at it, I'm sure you can catch up.
Amon-Re-72 · 0 points · Posted at 09:15:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
China has better free market healthcare than we do in America. We don't have a free market system of health care. The American medical system is one of the most heavily regulated systems in the country. That is one reason it is so expensive.
The idea of a free market system of healthcare in the US is a political talking point that is not based in reality.
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 09:44:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can you elaborate? Are you suggesting ERISA and the ACA, for example, disqualify the US healthcare system from being considered a free market? Because if so, that is insane. But if not, I’m interested to hear why you think we don’t have a free market. Is it Medicare? The IRS? Are you hung up on the word “free” and missing the definition of “free market” in this context?
Amon-Re-72 · 2 points · Posted at 10:41:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My daughter went to China and bought 2 pair of glasses from a street vendor. The guy tested her, figured out her prescription, ground the lenses, and for the frames to her face. She paid the equivalent to $35 and had the glasses in under an hour.
This guy had no degree, no schooling - just equipment he was trained how to use. His advertising was word of mouth, and if he did a bad job, word gets around and he loses his business. That is free market.
Here, the same 2 pair of glasses required an optometrist with a degree and a license. The optometrist uses similar equipment to figure out the prescription, but he is not allowed to make the glasses. The prescription has to be sent to another party who is school trained and licensed to grind the glasses with the same equipment used by the Chinese guy.
If the guy grinding the glasses does a lousy job, you don't even know who did it so it is no big deal. If the optometrist does a bad job on the prescription it is OK, cause there are only 5 licensed optometrists in town, so go see the other guys and I'll still have a business 'cause I have a license and no one else can do it unless they go get the degree and license.
And since the optometrist still owes $150,000 to the university system and the guy that grinds the lenses still owes $60K to learn what the Chinese guy learned through an apprenticeship, you pay $500 for 2 pair of glasses and you have to wait 2 weeks to get them.
That's not free market. That's insanity.
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 20:43:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
right and if your daughter had glaucoma, would that street vendor have caught it? diabetes? also, glasses hardware is an entirely separate issue because luxottica owns have the manufacturers and retail eyeware stores. idk where you shop but i get my glasses same-day in under two hours here in america. and to be honest, i’m not that concerned about the cost of the things i wear on my face every single day. worth it. the cost of education is also a separate issue, and irrelevant.
Amon-Re-72 · 1 points · Posted at 06:07:38 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
I didn't say anything about all that other stuff. You asked why I don't consider our healthcare system a free market. I told you. All that other stuff is the result of regulation. I didn't say it was bad, I just said it isn't "free market."
SmoothOctopus · 13 points · Posted at 07:17:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a non-American this post made me sad
MedicalInsuranceQA · 13 points · Posted at 11:33:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Wow.
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
Same as above
False and dangerous advice. From my experience, especially recently, they often send you to Collections as soon as 2-4 months. Because it's a lost cheaper to sell your bill forn30% of its value to a collection agency than have it sit around fighting with you 4: WHAT?! many injection and infusions costs tens of thousands of dollars. Even a bag of simple saline cost $30-$50
Is this guy trying to wreck your credit?? Never ignore a medical bill. Negotiate and make A payment plan because if it goes to collection, your credit is destroyed
This post should be reported and removed immediately. It is patently false and very very financially damaging
[deleted] · 7 points · Posted at 12:09:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This needs upvoted! From the legal side, if you absolutely just can't pay, paying only a little is a terrible idea. Your credit is already screwed but you're preventing the Statute of Limitations from possibly making the claim unenforceable after a period of time since new acknowledgements of a claim, including payment, almost always renew the SoL. That right there made me think this is not just bad advice but dangerous and even possibly malicious.
FblthpLives · 3 points · Posted at 11:41:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And this is why the U.S. healthcare system is a kafkaesque dystopia.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:57:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I see he deleted it so other people will likely not see your advice if they only read the original comment. I don’t think people understand how insane and bureaucratic hospital companies have become. Hospitals are overloaded with administrators whose only focus is profit.
Call your insurance first. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen billing mistakes. Do not pay any bill until you receive the EOB from insurance and can review it. You do not have to pay until you have the EOB. And if you can’t get a real explanation of why your claim was denied, escalate until you get a solid answer. Sometimes you need your doctor to do a peer review if something you really need is denied.
Payment plans are becoming less of an option. Hospitals will turn you to collections if you don’t pay the total monthly amount you agreed to if they do give you a payment option. However, I’ve seen up to 60% discounts to pay full balance with a credit card.
The point of care tests cost a hell of a lot more than $6 depending on the kind you buy. I think the cheapest test I have is $7, but that’s what I pay for it. I usually get paid about $15 for that test. That covers my managers time to order the supply, my nurse’s time/expertise to collect the sample, run it and document it, and my time to interpret the test and what to do about the result.
Same with my cheapest injectable. Probably the cheapest I could give it and not lose money would be $15, but I would not make any money for my time on deciding it was needed and determining the correct dose.
Doctors who own their own practice are not like hospitals. If you don’t pay your bill, you’re basically not paying that doctor for their work. Or you may be making them lose money, because they still had to pay for the staff/rent and buy the supply they used when they saw you. Which is why so many doctors don’t do primary care or go work for a hospital. That means all of us are seeing worsening preventative care, more serious health issues that are far more expensive to treat and increasing predatory billing practices from the large hospitals.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 21:39:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Artcat58 · 0 points · Posted at 00:54:25 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Exactly! And NEVER pay the collection agency. You're out of money now & the bill is never applied to YOUR medical bill. A fraction goes toward the hospital bill & the collection agency keeps the rest! Just walk away! ...and don't let paper ( threatening letters) scare you! They won't take you to court, it's too expensive for them. And if you get a lien on the debt, still keep walking! Most bills-gone 7 years, a lien is gone in 10. Happened to me (bad divorce) & after 7 years a $90k debt, proof! Gone! One creditor put a lien on part of it but you can't get blood from a turnip! I've since gotten credit cards, bought a home & my credit score is 700. Good enough to rebuild my life!
[deleted] · 24 points · Posted at 04:50:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
SmoothOctopus · 4 points · Posted at 07:20:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I had my appendix taken out when I was younger I walked in the door with a sore stomach and was in surgery a few hours later then went home the next day and didn't really think much about it cause it was free.
ihopethisisvalid · 3 points · Posted at 08:06:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That sucks dude the shitty thing about an appendectomy shouldn't be the cost lol
ambarcapoor · 74 points · Posted at 04:11:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wish I had real physical gold to give you. You're an angel.
[deleted] · 66 points · Posted at 04:19:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No worries, Save the money. I only posted this to help others, not myself. This actually hurts me lol but I choose others over myself
ambarcapoor · 42 points · Posted at 04:34:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It doesn't hurt you, this is how we build a sustainable society, with people looking out for each other. This will come back to repay you a hundred times over.
[deleted] · 42 points · Posted at 04:39:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I mainly meant my bonus. It’s always huge from everyone getting sick and paying too much. I’ll take a huge hit on that to make sure people feel safe and cared for. It’s what I wish others would do for me if they were in my position.
ambarcapoor · 8 points · Posted at 04:43:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can't argue with that... 😉 Except maybe the warm fuzzy feeling of doing something good 😊
emPtysp4ce · 1 points · Posted at 06:42:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's how you build a society.
sixblackgeese · 0 points · Posted at 07:35:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's just not true for everyone. Op is likely going to suffer more harm than good, but decided to do it anyway.
[deleted] · 14 points · Posted at 04:34:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Dude I'm calling this now reddit is going to gild the hell out of you.
Seriously, thank you for this.
Scrantonstrangla · 2 points · Posted at 05:40:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How do you suggest we make this common knowledge is society?
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:27:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Copy all of it, print like 20 copies and next time you hear about someone going to the doctor give them a couple copies and tell them to pass it along
anewchapteroflife · 1 points · Posted at 12:40:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m late to the party and now the post is deleted.... I really need this info. How can I get it? Thanks
meteorprime · 59 points · Posted at 07:57:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I have a much better idea.
Ban private insurance and pay for it like we pay for our military.
Vote Bernie
MidTownMotel · 2 points · Posted at 11:33:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! Nobody should profit from denying healthcare.
Dwolfknight · 0 points · Posted at 14:24:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh my sweet summer child...
MidTownMotel · 0 points · Posted at 14:41:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What? The monetization of suffering is evil.
Dwolfknight · 0 points · Posted at 14:53:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You assume it will stop if you give it to the government? You are way too naive.
MohitGo · 1 points · Posted at 15:06:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
muh gobernent bad hurr durr
Dwolfknight · 1 points · Posted at 15:33:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Muh Busness bad hurr durr, lets give actual billionaires who made their fortune through business, enough power to get drunk out off, they will surely only do what is best for us. They surely wont use it for any evil, nuh uh.
Look even if Berny did mean well, he would not be able to accomplish half of what he claims.
thenamesnic · 2 points · Posted at 15:53:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They never do. Too much spite on both sides.
MidTownMotel · 0 points · Posted at 15:37:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The government isn’t driven by a profit motive so it will absolutely be an improvement. Kind of like every other developed nation on earth does it.
I’m not half as naive as you are backwards.
Dwolfknight · 1 points · Posted at 15:47:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Profit is power, companies only look for profit because its the means they have to achieve power. The government is for power and they can circumvent the means.
brb-ww2 · 21 points · Posted at 05:27:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good god, can we just fix this obviously broken medical system ffs?
finallyfreedmyself · 3 points · Posted at 11:43:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sure. Vote Bernie.
Maldovar · 92 points · Posted at 05:21:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Best strategy is to vote for candidates who want Medicare For All and just get rid of all this shit
residentrecalcitrant · 50 points · Posted at 07:30:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You say candidates like it is plural. The Biden, Buttigieg and Warren plans are "Medicare for All (who want it)". They are a bunch of nonsense designed to make sure health insurance providers can still profit billions off of a broken system and have an implementation that makes sure it gets gutted post midterms. Their plans all start with bullshit compromise.
There is only one candidate that is advocating single payer medicare and it is Bernie Sanders.
Please stop believing candidates that make claims that people like their insurance companies.
JustMedoingthethings · 1 points · Posted at 12:42:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My question is, even if we vote someone in who actually wants to make the kind of changes we need, how on earth do we actually expect them to succeed in making those changes with so many career politicians in office who just want to maintain their own personal status quo? Most politicians just want to keep their jobs. They're not interested in making anything better for anyone but themselves. Even if we all voted in a great leader, our system is so messed up, they wouldn't be able to accomplish anything.
Maldovar · 1 points · Posted at 17:40:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I mostly meant voting in lower races as well, for candidates like Shahid Buttar, AOC, Ilhan Omar etc.
TheWillRogers · 1 points · Posted at 07:45:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren's plan is a longer medicare transition than Bernie's plan which vastly empowers the public option, unlike Biden and Buttigieg's plans which empower insurance plans vs the public option.
meteorprime · 25 points · Posted at 07:54:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren changed her plan recently.
We dont need worry if we can trust her we can just vote bernie.
Ya know, the guy who on stage says he wants to make private insurance illegal.
Vote for that guy.
Casual_Loop · 2 points · Posted at 11:30:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
True. If you go to congress already at a compromising position there is no place to go in the negotiation but closer to the other side of single payer. Bernie starts out in the strong position of all private healthcare should be illegal, and will have to compromise to make a deal on healthcare, yet from a much stronger position, which in the end will get all Americans a better deal in the end.
KindlyWarthog · 1 points · Posted at 12:33:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Amen. There's only one option with integrity the last 40 years and it's a slam dunk obvious choice
12358 · 2 points · Posted at 12:53:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Warren's plan is proposed to be implemented in year 3. In other words, it's sure to not be implemented after the House changes hands in the midterm elections. Warren's numbers are plummeting because people are realizing that she is either naive or has become a tool of the Democratic establishment and their desire to maintain business as usual. The differences between Warren and Sanders are becoming more evident as the campaigns move on.
HRCfanficwriter · -5 points · Posted at 07:59:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
someone should tell the poor Germans and French that they don't have real universal healthcare because its not single payer and multi payer doesnt count
emPtysp4ce · 24 points · Posted at 06:46:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Best strategy is to eat the rich and burn insurance companies to the ground.
yaaahweh · 2 points · Posted at 15:34:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm hungry
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 21:37:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sounds good.
scarysnake333 · 2 points · Posted at 09:21:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you actually think anything along those lines would be beneficial?
Pleaseexcuseyou · 2 points · Posted at 11:38:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most insurance companies offer other types of insurance. They will still be around
W_OMEGALUL_W · 2 points · Posted at 10:34:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I do
kylepierce11 · 3 points · Posted at 10:34:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You’re right, we could use those buildings for housing for the poor. Good thinking.
Reddit-phobia · 16 points · Posted at 06:34:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Feel the Bern.
Amon-Re-72 · 4 points · Posted at 08:39:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In case you weren't aware, Medicare is still costly. You have a 20% copay on nearly everything up to a certain limit. Plenty of older folks are still going broke with Medicare. A better option is socialized medicine.
Maldovar · 1 points · Posted at 17:39:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thats what M4A is
Amon-Re-72 · 1 points · Posted at 06:09:46 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
No, Medicare for All is a government insurance system where the government provides insurance. Socialized medicine is a government healthcare system where the government provides healthcare.
Hegeteus · 1 points · Posted at 08:37:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Problem is that a decent healthcare system will take multiple administrations and presidential terms to establish. Meaning that it will be torn apart eventually.
Insurance companies etc. also seem to have their hooks deep in the U.S legislation, and people in U.S are fed a lot of propaganda on how healthcare for all is communism. It has it's flaws and weaknesses, which is why countries who deployed it have spent decades on improving their healthcare models.
W_OMEGALUL_W · 2 points · Posted at 10:35:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Doesn't mean you yanks shouldn't try
Hegeteus · 0 points · Posted at 15:01:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm not actually an american. These are observations from my own and neighbour countries.
karl_w_w · 0 points · Posted at 08:39:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No that's the long term strategy that might not work. The realistic strategy is to get yourself some kind of high-demand qualifications and move to a country with civilised healthcare.
SMc-Twelve · 0 points · Posted at 11:36:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Medicare is shit, though. While single payer would be good, it should absolutely not just be an expansion of Medicare.
[deleted] · -10 points · Posted at 07:06:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
WhaT505 · 3 points · Posted at 07:19:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Fuck outta here.
[deleted] · -3 points · Posted at 07:21:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
RB5Network · 3 points · Posted at 07:31:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"No one knows what they are talking about. It is complicated, there's no argument for people who REALLY understand this."
Says the fucking dude who elaborates on nothing or backs his claim up.
Fuck off. Americans have suffered for too long. There is NO debate. A single payer is literally cheaper and doesn't bankrupt 400,000 people a year. We need a single-payer.
Bernie 2020.
ksande13 · -3 points · Posted at 07:40:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
it’s almost midnight here and i need to get back to my job as a professional consultant in the industry early in the morning. do you have specific questions you’d like me to answer in the next 10 min? i’d prefer you do a little research first, for a baseline understanding of the system so as not to waste as much of my time, in the interest of having as productive a conversation as possible if it comes to that. you’re 100% wrong in the numbers you’re throwing out there and that is absolute fact. please educate yourself a little more if you’d like to engage further. i don’t have time for this but at the same time feel the need to spend the few and far between moments i find worth it to at least spread the word that america needs to be a little less blind. everyone should be doing research, act as their own advocates, and stop with this crap
EDIT: single payer is cheaper 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 07:48:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
All I see is that you have zero arguments to back up your bullshit claim. Every single country in the world with universal healthcare pays less than the US does per capita.
ksande13 · -3 points · Posted at 08:12:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
mm yeah, quick response before i fall asleep: those countries weren’t founded on capitalism and don’t have PBMs and insurers negotiating for formulary placement and upcharging for repackaging. not absorbing the cost to stay afloat due to programs like CHIP and medicare. you cannot unravel a system as intricate as the US healthcare system and save money within the first decade at a minimum. doctors in the US are already vastly underpaid in this market in comparison to the average debt taken on to achieve the degrees and practices they’ve worked for. if they’re paid even less (guaranteed in every outline presented by future candidates), the quality of care is inevitably going to drop. we are already at a deficit and with lower pay that will only increase. also, this whole situation is a combination of cycles that aren’t factors in the other countries you reference. are you familiar with how insurers pay claims in the US? this is specific to america. for any services of decent value, it’s based on an inflated percentage of medicare because medicare is forcing providers and facilities to accept payments below what’s appropriate for the market. the private sector is keeping things afloat in the meantime, absorbing the hit to the market government programs have caused. i’m not saying government programs are bad, i’m just saying it’s more complicated than people realize and the fix isn’t what the average american believes will fix the system they don’t understand. this system is not set up like other countries and can’t just convert to other models. it would be a very rocky few decades, best case scenario, if one of the proposed single payer systems were to pass in the next few years. during that time, costs would be astronomical and the quality of care would decline
[deleted] · 7 points · Posted at 08:32:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Those countries weren't founded op capitalism? The fuck are you talking about?
You're telling me that the richest and most powerful country on earth can't effectively enact healthcare reform? Bullshit.
KindlyWarthog · 3 points · Posted at 12:35:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
He means slavery. America was founded on slavery so it must be what he's talking about. Something about necessary slavery and he's a quack
ksande13 · -1 points · Posted at 08:39:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
did i say those words in that second part of your claim? i’m quite confident i did not. also, pretty “rich” to claim the US is the richest country in earth with all this debt......
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:26:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Virtually every single country in the world has massive debt. That's just how the global economy works. The US has the highest GDP in the world.
ksande13 · 0 points · Posted at 09:45:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
okay goodnight 😂 i think we are done here
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:46:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're done because you're an idiot. The US is indisputably the richest country on earth.
Saying that it's not because it has debt just shows that you have no clue what the hell you're talking about.
Which country do you think is richer than the US?
ksande13 · 0 points · Posted at 09:50:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
can you please define “rich”? i’ll happily proceed after you provide your definition of “rich” for america
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 10:22:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Highest GDP in the world.
sleezestack · -2 points · Posted at 10:16:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're wasting your time arguing with Bernie bros. They are fanatics.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 10:21:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm not even from the US you idiot. What the fuck does Bernie sanders even have to do with what I'm talking about? Literally nothing.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 11:03:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[removed]
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:20:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How is that flattering myself? Do you even know what that means?
SirCaesar29 · 3 points · Posted at 07:56:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You do realize that your pathetic stance literally kills people right? That you are supporting the death of tens of thousands just because you don't like Bernie Sanders? You do get it, don't you?
Every other country has free healthcare. It works. Grow up.
ksande13 · 2 points · Posted at 08:15:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
you do realize you’re wrong, right? this is literally my profession. see my other comment if you’re interested in learning
KindlyWarthog · 2 points · Posted at 12:37:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just mad because you won't have a job shaking money from dying people anymore you scumbag. We get it. You're an insurance employee and it upsets you to know you so a pointless and useless job. Too bad kiddo
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 20:45:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
nah my job is secure either way. prob make more money if we moved to a single payer. people pay a lot for actual professionals to help fix major screw ups like that
KindlyWarthog · 1 points · Posted at 22:32:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That's exactly why you would be out a job bub
SirCaesar29 · 3 points · Posted at 08:49:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Then you're shit at your job, pal. No other way to put it. Or maybe, giving you the benefit of the doubt, you're so used to a broken, unfair, exploiting system that you can't imagine healthcare without it. In that case open a book and study how the NHS, the SSN, the Canadian healthcare works.
ksande13 · 0 points · Posted at 09:16:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
noooope. first of all, you are in no position to evaluate my proficiency or effectiveness at my job, given that you are clearly not a professional in the industry, nor do you know me.
next, what you’re missing is we have the same goal. the difference is how to effectively get there. why am i still awake? i guess i’ll admit that my ADHD (that is medically controlled during my on-call and billable hours) has me so frustrated by this. also, idk click on my shit and look at my comment that i made earlier that addresses your misguided comment. i hope you find it bc this is exhausting and a waste of my time... yes i realize i said i was going to bed earlier but ADD and insomnia changes things sometimes so cut me some slack.
also, PSA DONT go to canada for joint replacements. not only does it suck for the replacements to be delayed and inadequate...it’s EXPENSIVE and sometimes not covered by US plans (or any other major first-world country, ever) to correct (bc provider/DME error is an exclusion since it’s not ullness or injury and should be covered by malpractice insurance).
just...don’t leave the US for medical treatment unless it’s minor. or at least consult the centers for excellence first.
i mean unless you are otherwise 100% healthy and happened to shatter your knee in colombia, as a colombian citizen, or something, you make less than a decent wage, and colombia will pay to replace your knee for free... i would not recommend seeking care outside the US. (obvious other exception is if you have a rare disease and need to find a rare specialist overseas)
SirCaesar29 · 1 points · Posted at 10:57:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Of course you should not leave the US for medical treatment if you are a US citizen, what the fuck? I am talking about citizens of other countries having free healthcare, and that the US could do the same easily. But thanks to lobbying and corrupt politicians we are stuck with an inadequate, old, incredibly expensive (both for taxpayers and sick individuals!!!!!) and unfair "insurance" system.
Senator Sanders' plan is the only real plan to tackle this. Free healthcare for all. And fuck health insurance.
Mark_Bastard · 1 points · Posted at 10:42:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're a fucking leach hoping the blood supply doesn't run out.
WhaT505 · 4 points · Posted at 07:22:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So you want to keep the poor and sick just the way they are. Gotcha. Good talk.
ksande13 · -3 points · Posted at 07:29:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
absolutely NOT. i want the opposite, but it’s good to receive confirmation you aren’t educated on this subject matter. research how medical services are paid for in the US between insurers, plan administrators, and government-funded programs and get back to me. good talk.
[deleted] · -3 points · Posted at 07:43:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:46:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Of course this fucking topic is political. People are going homeless or dying because of this. Your government is filled with evil or incompetent pieces of shit for letting this happen.
ksande13 · -1 points · Posted at 07:59:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
100% agree. if this thread is still active tomorrow, please remind me to elaborate with specifics. it’s so sad how the majority of the country doesn’t understand how the healthcare system works. and let me clarify, i’m NOT saying there isn’t a problem. i’m saying the problem won’t be properly fixed until more people understand it and can work toward a proper solution
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 08:04:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
ksande13 · 3 points · Posted at 08:38:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
i shouldn’t admit this right now but i agree. everything’s either free or taxed at a premium around here. 13+% income tax in CA (or even FORMERLY in CA—could be a resident of a different state for years and still required to pay CA income tax even without owning or residing in a property in CA) for some but free healthcare/health insurance for illegal aliens, yes, in many cases those not paying any taxes in CA. This is just one example in this particular state but there are similar problems across the nation. it’s not the lack of voting it’s the lack of INFORMED voting happening in this country. RESEARCH BEFORE VOTING. and i mean REALLY research. don’t just read what candidates claim or what the main media outlets publish. They publish that for the uninformed american. be an informed american. And to clarify, I have no issues with immigrants. Happy to welcome them all. But I’m not going to favor their free healthcare over the legal tax-paying citizens who fund that in the first place. Everyone should have access to quality care, but there’s a right way to accomplish that and we aren’t headed that direction until people start to read up.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:46:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
ksande13 · 2 points · Posted at 08:56:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes, for 10 years. although i will admit for 5 of those years i was a supervisor/manager and the clientele was wealthy, so it might differ from a server’s experience in sandusky, OH for example
zxcsd · 1 points · Posted at 10:23:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm gonna downvote you, I don't have the time or inclination right now to explain why as I lead a busy life, but trust me you're wrong.
HereForGames · 18 points · Posted at 12:58:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
This is what the post said.
CriticalGeode · 4 points · Posted at 13:03:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you so much!
jayray013 · 32 points · Posted at 04:31:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
r/humansbeingbros
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:02:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
r/verycoolbutletsalsotryandfixtherootcausetoo
MedicalInsuranceQA · 9 points · Posted at 14:36:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This post was removed because everything shared was wrong and horrible advice....
As someone who has worked for health insurance for nearly 30 years, almost everything this user posted is wrong.
If your claim is denied 100% your responsibility do not call to pay. Call the insurance company to find out why it was denied and work from there. 85% of denied claims are ultimately paid upon review or appeal
KnocDown · 3 points · Posted at 20:47:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Requesting a self pay bill is great advice
If your insurance only pays 10% of an out of network bill they expect the provider to forgive the rest. When the provider just bills you the remaining balance it turns into a fight
For example, if your hospital is in network, your surgeon is in network and your gas passer is not you get a nice $2k bill for the anesthesiologist that your insurance will only pay $200
This post should not have been removed
GlassArmShattered · 41 points · Posted at 05:28:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Point zero - start voting for people who want to introduce public healthcare. Don’t worry, it won’t turn you into communist.
batmansleftnut · 9 points · Posted at 07:10:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can I still be a communist if I want to be one?
SmoothOctopus · 6 points · Posted at 07:18:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
DEMOCRACY IS NON-NEGOTIABLE
batmansleftnut · 2 points · Posted at 08:04:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Agreed, comrade.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:34:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
WE can still be a communist if WE want to be one?
chemicalsam · 33 points · Posted at 05:51:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Medicare for All.
Mark_Bastard · 3 points · Posted at 10:34:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best thing you can do is vote for Bernie.
chemicalsam · 2 points · Posted at 19:12:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Have and will continue to
pfabs · -2 points · Posted at 12:04:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The guy that has never passed a single bill while in Congress, is suddenly going to pass the largest healthcare reform in American history?
chemicalsam · 0 points · Posted at 19:11:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Might wanna check that again
Pleaseexcuseyou · 1 points · Posted at 11:39:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
“In case you weren't aware, Medicare is still costly. You have a 20% copay on nearly everything up to a certain limit. Plenty of older folks are still going broke with Medicare. A better option is socialized medicine”
chemicalsam · 1 points · Posted at 19:11:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s what Medicare for all is. Its not the exact same as Medicare is now for everyone. Its just they name.
1992_ · 25 points · Posted at 05:52:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Look at all this. It's insane that this is needed because we're at the whim of insurance companies. I'm done.
Vote Bernie if you want anything done to improve this.
NZNoldor · 7 points · Posted at 09:08:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
10) change the system.
docnotsopc · 18 points · Posted at 06:04:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I'm a physician and I agree with most of it. BUT beware, if you want to save a little money upfront seeing a midlevel (NP or PA) over a physician, you are going to get what you pay for. PAs and particularly NPs have a tiny fraction the training of a doctor. They're great for very straightforward simple cases. The problem is that it's tiny differences that often distinguish the proper workup, diagnosis, and treatment. They don't have adequate pathophysiology or pharmacology to make this distinction. Sorry you cannot cram that amount of education into a 2 year NP program that requires 500 clinical training hours (vs 4 years of medical school and 15-25000 hours training for a doctor). So again, great for straightforward stuff but hopefully it's actually straightforward. Also because they lack that training they tend to order unnecessary tests and place unnecessary consults to specialists much much more commonly than a doctor. This often defeats the purpose of trying to save money using them. There are bad doctors out there but the average doctor is way ahead of the average midlevel.
So just be aware of that possibility that you aren't getting an equivalent of a doctor for cheaper, you're paying less for a reason. There are also states that unfortunately let them practice independently without a doctor and in many situations they dont have a doctor to fall back on or won't ask for help due to being overly confident.
I work with some great midlevels but I also have serious reservations about them as someone who has gone through extensive medical education with a spouse in nursing.
MsTinyWiney · 5 points · Posted at 07:29:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Meh. I see a lot of opinion in this response being presented as fact. The statistics and research on NP care in the U.S. contradicts the claims that you've made. The truth is that there is a serious lack of providers in many countries and utilizing advanced practice providers, like NPs and PAs, would go a long way towards helping people to receive quality healthcare. I find that many MDs have no problem hiring NPs to care for patients or entering supervisory contracts in the states that require them because it earns them more money. Until we're honest about the financial stake that MDs have in preventing advanced practice providers from working independently so that more people can be helped, then we're not really going to decrease costs of care significantly in this country as they relate to health outcomes and provider costs.
As far as OP's point regarding NPs/PAs, many MD clinics use specific billing practices to ensure that they receive the same bill rate for a NP as a MD. Unless you are in a state where NPs have independent practice (as far as I know, no states allow PAs to practice independently), then this tip from the OP is unlikely to work.
LebronMVP · -1 points · Posted at 12:13:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The "research" that NPs provide equal care as MDs is weak, and does not hold up to any real world anecdotes.
Physicians who hire NPs for their practice are doing so because it makes them more money, not because it's the right decision for their patients.
The answer to our healthcare problems are increasing residency positions. Not a half measure of making more and more NPs. The "payroll" of physicians are a minor cost in healthcare.
theLaugher · 2 points · Posted at 12:47:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You make it sound like MDs know what they are doing, that's the other horror story about the Healthcare industry..
FitLotus · 3 points · Posted at 06:32:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah but NPs usually have hours of clinical experience as nurses, so it’s not like it’s ONLY 500 clinical hours. There’s more experience behind it. I can’t speak for PAs.
LebronMVP · 1 points · Posted at 12:10:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How does working as a nurse prepare to be a doctor? Specifically
FitLotus · 1 points · Posted at 16:15:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They’re working directly with doctors to treat patients. They see all sorts of diagnoses and the way they present firsthand. I’m an MA but I’ve been working in the same specialty long enough that I can guess the diagnosis and treatment before the doctor comes in.
LebronMVP · 1 points · Posted at 16:52:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That kind of thinking is very low level though. I remember being a scribe for years before medical school. I thought the job was easy then. Now I realize how little I really knew.
Frazzle-bazzle · 2 points · Posted at 06:49:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don’t mean to sound antagonistic, but I have to ask: do you make more money if PAs and NPs don’t take as many cases, and they only go to doctors? Where I’m from, it seems like the doctors are not fans of the mid levels because they view them as competition. We have issues in my country because we don’t have enough mid levels allowed to do enough jobs and therefore there are very long waiting lists. Even though mid levels seem like a logical solution, the doctors fight it.
Optimal_Towel · -3 points · Posted at 07:41:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, physicians get compensated more than PAs and NPs for doing the same thing.
Full disclosure: I'm a PA.
amwalker707 · 1 points · Posted at 11:55:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah, because one hour of a doctor's time is worth more than an hour of a PA. The post you're replying to pretty much says why.
LebronMVP · 1 points · Posted at 12:14:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Except you don't "do the same thing".
Optimal_Towel · 3 points · Posted at 14:27:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No, I mean if we literally have the word-for-word same exact visit the physician gets compensated (and charges) more than I do. I've worked in places where an MD will pop their head in for 5 seconds with a patient seen by a PA so they can get their name on the chart and it gets paid out at the MD rate instead of the PA rate.
Here is a good paper that explains productivity and RVUs.
LebronMVP · 0 points · Posted at 14:50:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Even if the visit is word for word, it is not the same care. A residency trained physician is considering more things and has a higher level of understanding of a clinical presentation. Patients pay a premium for that care.
tehbored · 1 points · Posted at 12:38:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
American doctors are generally overtrained and overqualified for what they have to do. I mean obviously it's good to have elite doctors in major hospitals, but most medical professionals do not need such a high level of expertise to provide effective care to patients.
CZReality · 12 points · Posted at 05:00:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is a post I'll save and hope to never need to look at
ChilrenOfAnEldridGod · 13 points · Posted at 05:12:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I only use my insurance for emergencies. Screw the deductible. Literally my bill is the same if they bill my insurance or not.
So now I tell docs I am self pay, give them a story how I am working hard on my own business, but I am not rich, but can pay my bills.
The rates I get are 10X less than the insurance.
I keep my insurance in case I have to go into the hospital on a big charge and only use it this way. I even ask "what is this going to cost if I pay now".
I use medical insurance like car insurance, only if I get into something big.
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 07:49:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact that you have to do that at all is fucked up.
ChilrenOfAnEldridGod · 4 points · Posted at 08:08:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Right?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 17:12:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Interesting though you don't expect car insurance to pay for all car breaks, or to have "Medicar for all" payed by taxes....
BaptizedInBlood666 · 1 points · Posted at 12:02:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Meanwhile either you or your employer is spending hundreds of dollars a month on your policy.
Every time I've used my insurance I still had to pay $2-3k cause its less than my deductible.
SO WHATS THE POINT OF THE $344/MONTH AVMED YOU PIECES OF SHIT
I'd be so much better off telling insurance to fuck off and putting $344/month into a savings account to pay everything out of pocket. Except Obama forced us all to buy insurance.
What a fucked situation we got here
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 06:51:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best way to pay for health insurance is to vote for Bernie Sanders so we can get the Medicare for All act passed.
arachnidtree · 11 points · Posted at 05:08:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
for 1 and 2, then that won't come off your insurance deductible. Depending on your future bills, you are better off not doing self-pay.
I had to pay for a ER visit, and it was a large bill but entirely deductible, so I paid it all out of pocket. The hospital refused any reduction, and refused any payment plan, because "I had insurance".
FitLotus · 1 points · Posted at 06:27:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Refused a payment plan? What the hell is wrong with people
shmohan1 · 1 points · Posted at 15:05:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Given the choice between getting paid something or nothing, one would think they’d be willing to work with someone
jmr3184 · 9 points · Posted at 05:30:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Medicare for all
the_geth · 10 points · Posted at 08:49:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or move to Europe and start enjoying being treated like a human being.
brokkoli · 1 points · Posted at 10:57:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can't just move to Europe, it's not that easy.
the_geth · 1 points · Posted at 17:56:15 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's easier than you'd think at least and I managed to get a couple of Americans to move to live here :) To quote them recently when I jokingly asked "what's the american dream nowadays anyway?" one of them smiled and said "To live here". They seem pretty happy and there weren't that much hurdles.
atilteddude · 4 points · Posted at 04:55:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this apply to emergency ambulance?
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 05:00:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Depends on coverage for ambulance (I don’t know too much about ambulances). It’s applies to ER though.
[deleted] · 5 points · Posted at 12:34:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Right when i clicked on it disappeared
pdxchris · 9 points · Posted at 04:29:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Also, most hospitals provide financial assistance. Always apply if you are having a hard time paying or know you qualify. The qualifying income levels are typically on their website. Some are very generous even if you have insurance. I know someone with nearly a million dollars in medical debt erased because he had a limited income. I have gotten 50% discounts.
acinom92 · 9 points · Posted at 04:29:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Should I just call and say “ hey I was wondering if I can get a self pay bill instead, as my insurance didn’t cover it?”
I have a LOT of bills my insurance didn’t cover from my pregnancy. I seriously think they make insurance so complicated on purpose!
[deleted] · 12 points · Posted at 04:33:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes! If your insurance denied it call them and they will rebill under self pay (cash/card rate). I’m sorry that happened to you but I hope this helps. Keep negotiating as long as you can. They’d rather receive $1 than tell their board they wrote off another claim in full.
conez4 · 3 points · Posted at 06:44:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who are the "they"s you keep referring to? Call insurance company and demand the self pay, or call the healthcare practice?
immanewb · 1 points · Posted at 07:57:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I would assume they meant the health care providers' billing department, as I take it that once your insurance claim is denied, that's pretty much them washing their hands off of your case.
Starfish93486 · 1 points · Posted at 06:53:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Call the insurance or hospital/doctor and ask to rebill?
acinom92 · 3 points · Posted at 07:13:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I think hospital/ doctor. The insurance already said no and the one you owe money to now is the hospital. At least I am planning to call the hospital that’s charging me.
( if I’m wrong please someone correct me)
Lawlsagna · 1 points · Posted at 15:41:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'd call the hospital and doctor billing department(s) and say something like 'I'm wondering if you guys offer a self-pay discount for people without insurance. If so, could you refund my insurance company and reprocess as self-pay.'
Even if there's nothing to "refund" because your claim was denied, it will let the rep know you're looking to have the adjustments removed from your account for reprocessing.
Please be aware that you will need to do this for every single denial you receive. The hospital billing dept probably won't contact the provider billing departments to let them know to re-bill. As an example, when a patient would call the facility(surgical center/hospital/etc) to update their insurance with them, the facility would not contact me (offsite anesthesia group billing) to update and reprocess. This also might cause an issue if the facility has different billing practices than a provider you saw. Some hospitals offered great discounts for self-pay, but because the providers didn't have a similar fee schedule, only the facility cost would be reduced.
It may not always work, but it certainly doesn't hurt to ask. The billing department should be familiar enough with this question to give you an answer as to whether it's possible for them to do. But if your provider uses a third-party billing company, you may end up talking to someone in customer service instead of someone in the A/R department, and the customer service rep may not be able to answer your question.
Anyway, sorry for the long response. It all depends on various possibilities.
trumpisstillacuck · 12 points · Posted at 05:26:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is utter bullshit. Fuck this broken America.
VoxMendax · 8 points · Posted at 08:09:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
YSK that we can should have free health care, like the rest of the civilised world, if we elect non-shills.
[deleted] · 5 points · Posted at 08:15:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's sad to see this when sorting by controversial
moemoe111 · 7 points · Posted at 12:38:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I am not sure why op deleted this entire post (apparently while I was reading it), but here is copy/paste:
I suck at formatting but that's what they wrote. I also screenshotted it but haven't put it up anywhere.
seedyweedy · 1 points · Posted at 12:42:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Inb4 u/moemoe111 gets deleted too
moemoe111 · 1 points · Posted at 12:55:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Should I, uh, start packing and planning a trip to the hills?
seedyweedy · 1 points · Posted at 13:00:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
ight, imma head out
moemoe111 · 1 points · Posted at 13:01:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
NIce knowin' ya
shiitakefuckrooms · 1 points · Posted at 12:45:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
THANK YOU!
JustMedoingthethings · 0 points · Posted at 12:53:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Probably getting death threats from insurance companies. Thanks for reposting.
[deleted] · 19 points · Posted at 05:28:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
10.) vote for Bernie Sanders and fight for a single payer universal healthcare system.
[deleted] · -12 points · Posted at 06:31:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Dannypan · 4 points · Posted at 07:49:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I had myocarditis and a pericardial effusion a few years ago. I needed a week in hospital, a visit to a specialised hospital for a chest MRI, a few x-rays, ultrasounds and a lot of medicine.
How much did I spend out of pocket? £0, because we have universal healthcare here. I couldn’t work for 2 months, and not having to worry about medical bills is an absolute Godsend.
There are definitely “health tourists” in the NHS. They amount to a ridiculously tiny percentage of the budget. So what if “welfare leeches”, of which there aren’t many, use universal healthcare? Why are you so opposed to your fellow man having access to healthcare without crippling bills?
BazOnReddit · 3 points · Posted at 07:48:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And here we see the need for universal mental healthcare as well.
branchbranchley · 2 points · Posted at 07:09:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
meanwhile most people don't even have the option of waiting for guaranteed care no matter how sick they are
pfabs · 1 points · Posted at 12:06:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Took me 7 years to get a much needed MRI at the VA.
I've had 5 in that time through private doctors.
I agree our healthcare system is flawed, but the government would only make it worse.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 07:25:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
BaptizedInBlood666 · 0 points · Posted at 11:56:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You missed the point.
ashwheee · 1 points · Posted at 07:25:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or, we can look at it as, pay for the working citizens that would either go bankrupt over their deductible because they can’t afford monthly rates without a deductible. Or families who have kids with pre existing congenital problems who struggle to get coverage. The “illegals and welfare leeches” are such a small minority of healthcare recipients.
Also, another thought is, you’re paying for them anyway. Hospitals can’t deny patients. Hospitals will charge insurances more to cover cost of loss which drives up the private insurance prices. Under even a single payer system prices would go down...way down. I’d rather pay or be taxed $200 a month and my parents taxed $200 a month for us all to have healthcare coverage... rather than my parents current $1600/month and my current $500/month with a 6k deductible. It’s really bullshit how this country handles their own citizens. We should treat ourselves better considering we are one of the leaders of worldwide economies.
bUt dA iLLeGaLz. We’d rather see them (and citizens) suffer than to see hardworking citizens not struggle amirite? Let’s stick to the petty point amirite??
krazy_86 · 1 points · Posted at 08:11:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol ten months?
Santi871 · 1 points · Posted at 10:19:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol nobody outside America appreciates America's healthcare system.
I'm from a 3rd world country and I have to watch out not to get injured when I'm in America because of the costs. Meanwhile at home I would get treated for free and so would you.
clouds31 · -2 points · Posted at 07:14:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or just come to California where, if you have CC, Doctors will give you half-assed care because they're being paid peanuts.
ReeperbahnPirat · 4 points · Posted at 05:31:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sorry, can you expand on this? So they pay less than if you're a new patient? Also thank you for this write-up. Our healthcare is fucked, but ensuring more people understand it is an important step in unfucking it and protecting themselves.
Nivlac024 · 4 points · Posted at 08:03:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
or we could vote Bernie in as president....
CatJongUn · 4 points · Posted at 08:17:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Having to find loopholes to minimize your already inflated medical bills in the US sounds like r/aboringdystopia to me
Harvee_Normarn · 4 points · Posted at 08:17:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
All I took from this is that health insurance companies in the US are marking everything up by between 20-40% because... they can? Apparently that's perfectly ok?
MidgardDragon · 4 points · Posted at 12:29:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Fight your ass off for Medicare For All.
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 12:47:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Aaaand it’s gone
Rockoll · 5 points · Posted at 16:16:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What did it say? I was reading it when it got deleted.
Jammiie23 · 4 points · Posted at 17:59:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why has this been deleted? It was very helpful. Does anyone know where I can find a back up of it?
immanewb · 2 points · Posted at 00:29:12 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Some commenters are saying there's a lot of false information, so take it with a grain of salt. But here ya go:
https://removeddit.com/r/YouShouldKnow/comments/e5t9ia/ysk_how_to_decrease_medical_bills_in_the_us
NotSlimJustShady · 10 points · Posted at 04:55:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The correct answer is by voting
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:05:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
After 20+ round of elections, not really impressed by the results lol. Really naive to think its easily fixable by voting and not by protests which cripples the govt that they accept demands. That concept is alien to Americans now
_Druss_ · 10 points · Posted at 06:09:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or vote for Bernie and catch up with the rest of the worldaa
MultiPass21 · 29 points · Posted at 04:39:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A lot of this is incredibly generalized and very misleading.
I’d encourage readers to do some additional research before accepting this as gospel.
Source: Also in the healthcare sector.
[deleted] · 13 points · Posted at 04:45:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I agree with the more research but it’s not misleading. Bad debt is a huge part of healthcare. All of this is to be taken with a grain of salt. It all depends on how well they can work things out with the provider/Insurance.
[deleted] · 11 points · Posted at 06:25:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
ilikerosiepugs · 2 points · Posted at 16:53:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I delivered my baby early & unexpectedly at a hospital that has its own health insurance pretty much (Intermountain in Utah) and ive been assured multiple times everyone is in network.... weeks after I get a letter that the doctor who delivered is filing an appeal for me because of ALL the people in the hospital, HE wasn’t on my actual plan (he was covered by 9/10 plans offered by the insurance company/hospital except mine!) haha! But it was an emergency & it was covered but what a headache
Amon-Re-72 · 0 points · Posted at 09:18:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What he said. ^
ifyouhaveany · 8 points · Posted at 06:17:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
It is misleading, though. Like saying a "swab test" costs $6 in supplies. We run all of our Flu/RSV and streps off of "swabs" (viral/bacterial transport media kits), and while THOSE might cost $6, the cartridges for the tests themselves are much, much more.
So someone gets a strep test (or a respiratory panel) done thinking it only costs six bucks because they think "Hey, all they did was take a swab!" But they have no idea that back in the lab we're running PCR on their DNA with an instrument that cost a few hundred thousand and kits that cost a few hundred to a few thousand.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 07:17:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
ifyouhaveany · 2 points · Posted at 07:26:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What's your point? I don't work in pharmacy.
SmokinGrunts · 1 points · Posted at 11:10:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Seems like the way the medical industry is set up is pretty misleading, considering the amount of regular people who mistake who is accountable for what
ifyouhaveany · 1 points · Posted at 16:06:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Absolutely, I agree. It's an almost insurmountable maze. I was just addressing this one point, though. (FWIW, I think we should have Healthcare for all.)
thatguyonthecouch · 5 points · Posted at 05:00:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Won't that ruin your credit rating?
[deleted] · 5 points · Posted at 05:03:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not if you convince them to keep delaying it. Worst case ask for a payment plan with the max amount of months available. They will always work with you.
thatguyonthecouch · 3 points · Posted at 05:09:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good to know, thanks.
FitLotus · 4 points · Posted at 06:28:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I once had a patient pay off a $500 bill in $25 monthly payments. It’s obviously different for every office but as long as you’re making payments on time and staying in contact we literally don’t care.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 10:30:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My hospital was very very different from this, and I wish that OP and you would not lead others to believe that your experiences are how it always goes.
FitLotus · 1 points · Posted at 16:11:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s why I said “it’s obviously different for every office”.
Alx0427 · 2 points · Posted at 06:31:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah...”convincing them” doesn’t exactly sound like a bulletproof strategy to me...
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 10:28:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"They will always work with you".
This is a lie. Not every hospital or physician office is willing to work with you.
haugen76 · 2 points · Posted at 10:35:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They are rare? I’ve avoided me.
immanewb · 0 points · Posted at 07:48:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Only if it's sent to collections. That's when it gets reported to your credit reports. This applies to any bills, such as your electric, gas, phone, etc.
As I understand it, most medical places would rather get paid something than send it to collections, where they'll get pennies on the dollar for the bill. By staying in contact with the billing department, they usually would be happy to work with you. It's when folks ignore their calls/letters is when they have no other recourse but to try and recoup their losses through a collection agency.
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 10:32:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Not true. My husband had a medical service that was billed to his insurance improperly. He was calling both the insurance and the hospital 2-3 × per week, constantly staying on them about fixing it. That shit got sent to collections. Nobody gave a fuck.
llamallama-dingdong · 1 points · Posted at 18:13:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sometimes it is true tho. My wife has been paying $25 a month on a $8000 hospital bill for years now, can't even remember what the bill was for now. It was all she could afford at the time. It'll never get paid off but it's not on her credit report.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:28:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
StringerBallond · 0 points · Posted at 06:48:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You spent 15 years as a fraud? Nice.
cloud_throw · 14 points · Posted at 06:11:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Step 1. Vote Bernie
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 05:08:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this apply to a dental office?
just-another-amy · 3 points · Posted at 05:16:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wish I would’ve known some of this a couple of years ago. Have an hsa, needed surgery, cost me my 10k deductible and totally drained my hsa account. So are you saying I maybe could’ve negotiated that 10k down? Haven’t even been able to fund my hsa since. Oh and my premium is going up..again. Since I started my plan in 2009 my premium has gone up over 350%. But it’s still cheaper than what most people pay and I can’t find anything cheaper. I’ve tried. What really sucks is that beyond that one surgery, we never use our insurance. Family of four, all healthy, do one well visit a year and in ten years we’ve had one hospital visit for me and my surgery. It’s just insanity.
UnlubricatedUnicorn · 3 points · Posted at 07:21:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jeez, US seems like a good place to live until you get injured or sick.
RB5Network · 3 points · Posted at 07:33:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Vote for Bernie Sanders!
thewayitis · 3 points · Posted at 07:36:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
MEDICARE FOR ALL. Let's end the middleman madness.
foster_remington · 3 points · Posted at 07:36:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
also vote Bernie Sanders
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:38:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or we could just have M4A like a normal developed country.
The USA fucking sucks.
GegaMan · 3 points · Posted at 07:40:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
fuck that bullshit people need a fucking uprising. fuck college and healthcare costs
tritter211 · 1 points · Posted at 14:07:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
While I agree that healthcare needs some reform, you really can't complain about college costs here. College costs are rising higher and higher every year directly opposite to that of yearly inflation because of the proliferation of government backed loans.
Why do colleges charge such high premium for getting an education? Because they can, and government will loan you money to pay that premium price.
GegaMan · 1 points · Posted at 02:19:28 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes I can complain about both. government are also in on this. rich people and politicians are related.
jamminjon82 · 3 points · Posted at 07:50:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks for all of these tips, but honestly fuck the American medical system and all of the insurance companies.
TransmutedHydrogen · 3 points · Posted at 07:54:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
holy shit, what a broken medical system
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:54:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
1) Vote Bernie Sanders
popeislove · 3 points · Posted at 08:05:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Number 10: vote for Bernie Sanders
Vanillathunder80 · 3 points · Posted at 08:06:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The US health care system is a total clusterfuck. So glad I don’t have to deal with it
TheOnlyArs · 3 points · Posted at 08:16:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is this some kind of American joke that i'm too european to understand?
CloudyMN1979 · 2 points · Posted at 08:37:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's not very funny is it?
Blasphemy4kidz · 3 points · Posted at 08:44:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What if I'm broke (but had insurance thru my job) and had to go to the ER for a broken bone and still got billed $2,600? I can't afford $200 let alone $2,600.
Nikerbocker · 3 points · Posted at 08:50:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This will probably get buried but I wanted to note that if you are uninsured and a victim of a crime, you can apply for the federal victims of crime program (in the USA). The main requirement being that you have to have a case # from filing a police report. It can help get medical bills and sometimes other things covered.
https://www.ovc.gov/about/victimsfund.html
R4ggaMuffin · 3 points · Posted at 08:55:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m so glad I don’t live in the US, medical bills sound scary as fuck. I live in the UK, keep your hands off the NHS please!
op3l · 3 points · Posted at 08:59:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's hilarious that there needs to be an explanation about how to pay for what is basically a necessity of life.. and people still defend the system in the US like it's working fine.
VirtualKeenu · 3 points · Posted at 09:11:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 09:48:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact the bill magically gets smaller when it's self pay just goes to show you how fucked up there system is.
Z0MGbies · 3 points · Posted at 10:13:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[Laughs in new Zealandish]
TheGroovyTurt1e · 3 points · Posted at 10:20:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good advice sad it needs to be given
lookslikeyoureSOL · 3 points · Posted at 11:53:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does any of this apply to dental implants and other work? I have so much dental work that needs done and I'm afraid it's going to kill me before I can even think about getting it handled.
The reason I ask is because I have heard that dental implants are considered "cosmetic" and I have 3 teeth that are broken off at the gumline - I'm terrified that the roots are infected.
Artcat58 · 1 points · Posted at 23:48:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most dental is considered cosmetic. Even a root canal isn't completely covered. You still pay about $1,500-$1,800 for the endodondist & another $1,000-$1,200 for a crown. They last for 10-15 years (hopefully) then get infected & require replacement. Insurance covers about $500 for the entire process. An implant costs about $1,500-$3,000, depending on where you live & is NOT covered by insurance. I dropped dental coverage several years ago. I go to new dental clinic openings that offer newcomer specials. You can find free to $99 cleanings & screenings almost everywhere. I had 2 root canals removed & had implants put in both. I spent $3000 for both of them from a local dentist I received a mailing from. Best thing ever. Getting a full set of single implants would be expensive. Some newer versions have 4-6 teeth in each implant quadrant & are cheaper than individual implants. But doing one a year for $1,500 is very doable if you're saving the money from your canceled dental policy. See a dentist for a screening, you don't have to commit to their plan but you can get antibiotics to stop an infection. Don't let it go into an abcess. You'll need emergency treatment that involves surgery & it's not cheap! Some cheap antibiotics could literally save you thousands of dollars! Get that checked out & best of luck to you!
Cinamunch · 3 points · Posted at 12:15:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I have to disagree with #4. Injectables are extremely expensive. I'm in the healthcare industry as well and have a child on hemophiliac medication enrolled under a 340b pricing plan, and it's still costing the insurance plan $1.2 million annually.
Veraladain · 3 points · Posted at 12:28:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good tips, I worked in ER and hospital billing for 7 years and I'm glad to see this knowledge being spread. This will get buried because this post has been up for so long but also keep in mind ER rates are insane and your insurance can deny emergency claims! Don't get stuck with an ER bill for something that was not an emergency! Do not go to the ER for something minor like a cold, mild injuries, etc. Make an appointment to see a doctor or go to a walk in clinic. Just because your condition was minor does not mean the bill will be. At my ER in a low income area it was $499 just to walk in the door for the lowest ESI.
JustMedoingthethings · 1 points · Posted at 12:51:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is it normal for ERs to present you with a bill and credit card machine while you're in bed waiting to be seen by a doctor but after you're in the gown and have been prepped for iv (so you can't leave at this point but they won't let you see a Dr of you don't pay)? I had my daughter (18) in there for something (I had wanted to wait for a Dr visit but my daughter insisted) and sad shocked at the insensitivity. Shouldn't the priority in an "emergency" room be on care, not getting paid?
Please understand that I'm not aiming my frustration at you. You just did your job and I'm sure you didn't deal with patients like this. I guess I'm just asking/venting.
Veraladain · 1 points · Posted at 15:11:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Unfortunately that's completely normal. I can't speak to all hospitals but for ours as soon as they start that basic questionnaire you are given a room and then typically a nurse triages you. As soon as you have been triaged and you receive a preliminary once over, unless you are medically unstable you are legally able to be registered and billed. You are not legally able to be refused service though if you don't pay IF that service is deemed medically necessary. Did they use the actual wording that you would be refused treatment if you didn't pay or did they just imply it? Because if they used that actual wording that is in violation of EMTALA.
HOWEVER, if you enter the ER and the doctor deems that your reason for being there is not urgent you will be asked to sign a form saying that you need to pay if you want to continue receiving treatment. This was very rarely done in my ER, its pretty much frowned upon because it makes people angry (no suprise).
Another shitty thing is that EMTALA, while it protects patients, also prevents you from doing anything that would discourage you to seek treatment based on your ability to pay. So we legally can't go over billing in detail with the patients beforehand because it might be deemed as a deterrent. Now why can't we ask after? Well, most ERs are judged on their wait time for everything, including time you enter to time you leave the ER and metrics on how long it takes you to be registered. In my ER we were expected to see most people within 15min of them receiving the preliminary exam. If your times get too long you WILL be fired. Additionally, as soon as the doctor clears the patient the nurses are trying to get them out as fast as possible. They will not put up with a registrar slowing them down to ask billing information. I've seen nurses just send people home before we even get an address. Obviously that's not supposed to happen but it does.
So yeah, whole system is broke IMO and I'm so glad to be out of there. But it sucks because most people have no idea what they are getting into going to the ER.
Edit: I should add that I've heard of these new laws that require ERs to post the prices in clear view in the ER. I haven't looked into those at all because I left billing years ago but that might change some things.
JustMedoingthethings · 2 points · Posted at 17:59:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you for taking the time to reply in such detail.
It was implied that the Dr wouldn't be in until we'd taken care of the billing. It just felt wrong and if she wasn't already laying there in a gown with a tube in her arm, I would have told them we were leaving.
Veraladain · 1 points · Posted at 00:12:19 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
I hear you, it's a hustle and everyone is in on it. A complete overhaul is the only thing I can see fixing the issue unfortunately
uvwxyz00 · 3 points · Posted at 13:05:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why is this deleted?
QueasyDuff · 3 points · Posted at 14:27:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Because it was not accurate and OP got called out.
uvwxyz00 · 1 points · Posted at 14:50:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ohoho... The Account also shows deleted. Are they banned or sth?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:29:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Conspiracy
CaesarInAFreezer · 3 points · Posted at 16:07:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was this deleted?
Siluke · 3 points · Posted at 16:38:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was this deleted
DJ-Gonk · 3 points · Posted at 18:07:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Whoa. Literally tapped the post (on mobile) to read and saw the post and user gets thanos snapped
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 05:57:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
YSK how to decrease medical bills in the US significantly:
Step 1: Vote for Bernie Sanders
There is no step 2.
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 12:38:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who deleted the content of this post?
justastrang3r · 5 points · Posted at 03:50:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
love u for this
lostfly · 4 points · Posted at 04:03:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is extraordinary helpful!
Hunter0674 · 4 points · Posted at 04:11:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I gotta ask, where did you get all of the knowledge?
[deleted] · 18 points · Posted at 04:14:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I do all the finances for a massive healthcare firm. We talk to almost everyone in the industry and they have similar practices. It’s all private though, no public companies. Most healthcare providers are not public though for various reasons, only insurance groups are public. For reference, BCBS has a max 85% expense rate for premiums received so anything beyond that gets sent back to employers (employers keep it all, employees benefit 0% from this)
Hunter0674 · 7 points · Posted at 04:16:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well shit
Very informative
I’ve learn more in this lost and from that comment than I have in my school career
So thanks!
Scrantonstrangla · 2 points · Posted at 05:43:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You’re based in Chicago, aren’t you?
ksande13 · 3 points · Posted at 07:04:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
NOOOOO no no no don’t do most of these if you have private insurance. DONT DO THIS
EDIT: i cannot stress this enough but this information is so completely flawed. it may be true in certain scenarios in a small region but DO NOT follow this advice without further research. this could not be more untrue in CA, for example.
storm_of_fist · 1 points · Posted at 08:55:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why? Can you elaborate
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 09:19:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yeah but i’m tired, can you reference my other comment? or remind me tomorrow and i will have a cohesive write—up to elaborate
shmohan1 · 1 points · Posted at 15:15:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can you please elaborate?
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 20:47:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
post was deleted is there a bot or screenshot that captures it so i can address each point? probably will be able to get to that later
intentionallyawkward · 4 points · Posted at 04:20:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Even after our insurance pays we negotiate down bills for patient responsibility. Often up to 50%.
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 04:54:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
.... really? Can you tell me more about how to go about this?
arachnidtree · 2 points · Posted at 05:13:19 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
be broke, don't pay.
[deleted] · 6 points · Posted at 05:17:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Always an option unless, unfortunately, you have to care about your credit. The whole system is a scam.
intentionallyawkward · 1 points · Posted at 12:27:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When you get the bill, call and just ask. If they say no then end the call and try again a couple weeks later. You’ll either eventually find someone willing to make the adjustment, or enough time will pass and you can just stop calling.
Lawlsagna · 1 points · Posted at 16:01:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
as in.. you were sent to collections?
This wouldn't have worked for most of the provider groups I billed for because our system would automatically send a list of patients who hadn't paid in 90/120 days to collections. Part of my job was to go through the big list each month and pull all of the accounts that had Medicaid because we weren't allowed to send anyone with Medicaid to collections. I'm not sure if it was a state or federal policy though because my provider groups were all in-state, but every group my company billed for had the same monthly list of accounts that would either be placed into collections or, if the provider didn't have a contract with a collection agency, the account would be sent to a separate database to remove it from our list of unpaid accounts. Perhaps you dealt with a provider that didn't use a collection agency?
intentionallyawkward · 1 points · Posted at 16:49:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What seems to have happened is that as long as we stayed in contact with them they would not send us to collections. Even if they did send us to collections we’d still call the collections company and offer the same thing. Eventually they usually settle, and when we settle we asked them to remove any entries on our credit report as part of the settlement.
Has worked for us 100% of the time so far and we still have no derogatory entries on our credit reports.
spellicy3 · 2 points · Posted at 05:03:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is really relevant to me right now, so i DM'd you.
ALinIndy · 2 points · Posted at 05:12:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Good on ya man, for sharing this info.
losdosme · 2 points · Posted at 05:12:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You are a saint! Thank you for this.
echobase_2000 · 2 points · Posted at 05:15:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If you get care at a nonprofit hospital, they’re required to provide some charity care every year. Ask for documentation on their charity program.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 05:18:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't forget to ask for detailed billing. I know of somebody who was charged for doses of insulin that was enough to kill three people and when they asked for a detailed billing they got it reduced severely.
saltycoke · 2 points · Posted at 05:29:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A couple years ago I came home with pain in my groin area after hanging out with my then gf at the time and felt this sort of deep throbbing pain that wouldn't go away even after lying down for a few minutes. I panicked and googled it and thought I had testicular torsion. So in a panic I wake my parents up and have my mom drive me to the emergency room and I waited there for about 15 minutes until a nurse came out and guided me to the room. Long story short they ultrasounded my ball sack and did not find symptoms of testicular torsion. My dumb ass just had a bad case of blue balls. Anyways the question I wanted to ask was for some reason I only had to pay the doctor visit bill and they wrote off all the other expenses with some latin phrase that I forget what it was called. Is it common for this to occur for "false positives" like in this case? Also what is that called? I can only assume they took pity for my dumbass and just wrote it off.
edit: I did not have health insurance at the time.
moranchula · 2 points · Posted at 05:33:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this apply to therapy and psychiatric care as well? Insurance picks up most of my bill but it is still $50 out of pocket ever session
FitLotus · 2 points · Posted at 06:30:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The self pay session rate is probably higher than $50 but it never hurts to ask
throwawayawayawayy6 · 2 points · Posted at 05:34:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Question for you. I got a surgery in 2016 by Cleveland Clinic. Theyve been fighting with me/my insurance over the bill since then... going on 4 years. My EOB from my insurance says I only owe $682 + $48. Cleveland Clinic says I owe the $682 + $2,260 for something or other. They did a code review and found no problems on that front. Come to find out the insurance must have denied that $2,260 bit as "cosmetic" though ABSOLUTELY NO part of that operation was cosmetic, IN THE SLIGHTEST. Beyond that, the operation fucked my situation up worse and it had to be redone with another operation a few months ago at a new surgeon. So my question is... what the fuck are they charging me a random extra 2,260 for? This surgery was preauthorized by insurance and CC Went and did something extra that the insurance NOR I consented to? What insurance and hospitals do is have contracts meaning they CANT charge me for extra shit beyond what my insurance says they can, which is called a contractual write off that I'm not responsible for. It's a mess and I dont know what my options would be aside from just never fucking paying it til they sue me because I 100% think they're being fraudulent or something. It's also been 4 years almost now and they've not yet reported the bill to the credit bureaus.
BeautifulSoul28 · 2 points · Posted at 05:34:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Will any of this work if the hospital sent your bill to a 3rd party? I was told by the hospital that the only way to lower my monthly payments was to go through a 3rd party billing place that they use, so my bill was sent to that place and that's who I pay every month.. I only started hearing about all the ways you can negotiate your hospital bill after I set up these payments. But I dont want to call and sound like an idiot if there is nothing this billing place can do
I fucking hate our healthcare system. I had pulmonary embolisms 2 years ago that included a 4 day hospital stay. Last year I got a respiratory virus that made me feel like I was having the same symptoms as my PE (shortness of breath, chest pains) and I got so scared and went to the ER. It thankfully ended up being just symptoms of the illness irritating my not quite 100% healed lungs.. I completely regret going in because of the bills. And even though I know how serious PE's can be, I'm seriously going to question whether I really need to go to the ER if I ever start to feel that way again because I can't freaking afford it.
Scrantonstrangla · 2 points · Posted at 05:35:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I work for a revenue cycle services firm, and a big push in the industry now is helping patients understand these options. This was a really great post
dca_user · 2 points · Posted at 05:44:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow, thank you. You have a clear succinct way of explaining this complicated information. If you have the bandwidth, I would suggest you do an IAMA. I imagine lots of folks would have questions.
Can I ask two questions?
I’ve been told that company’s health insurance premiums skyrocket if they have too many people over the age of 50. Hence, a lot of people are let go at that age. Is this possibly correct? (As I approach 50, I am concerned about this)
is there any sort of information we, as citizens, could compile or anything else we can do to effectively reduce the cost of insurance? My thought was to create a spreadsheet with others documenting how much each of us pay on various items. This would Demonstrate that it’s less about the actual cost and more about the organization’s ability/willingness to negotiate. But am I correct in my perspective? I’d welcome your thoughts.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 06:39:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best way to reduce your medical bills is to vote for someone who wants to pass medicare for all.
Vegasrealtor · 2 points · Posted at 06:44:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Many states also have an Ombudsman for Medical Care. They help consumers getting railroaded or ignored by hospitals and billing departments. Make sure you request your entire medical chart related to the date of service and ensure they have your signed personal guarantee and consent forms. I had an $8,000 bill completely wiped by the Ombudsman in my state because the hospital failed to bill my insurance in a timely manner and didn't have my Consents or Personal Guarantee on file.
exploding_cat_wizard · 2 points · Posted at 07:41:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ooh, nice, the single most effective way of delivering a drug isn't covered, and you have to fight it. /r/aboringdystopia indeed.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 07:59:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For a moment I thought this was /r/ABoringDystopia
King_of_Dew · 2 points · Posted at 08:07:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ok so there is a 30-40% markup that exists for no good reason? What am I missing?
Atrainlan · 2 points · Posted at 08:09:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're missing nothing that is entirely by design.
EdmundGerber · 2 points · Posted at 08:14:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What a fucking joke. You people would rather jump through these hoops, and call it a win - rather than universal health care?
Weird.
Amon-Re-72 · 2 points · Posted at 08:33:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm a practice manager in Alaska and I can say that your price points might be accurate in some areas, but nowhere close in this part of the country. Some of this is good advice, but slot of it should be listed under r/ULPT.
Self pay gets a 20% discount unless you are going to a designated community health clinic where you can pay on a sliding scale based on your income. But if you already went to a regular clinic and got denied, it is too late for that.
Before calling and asking for a self-pay bill, CALL YOUR INSURANCE COMPANY! Ask why it was denied. Many times it is a matter of coding or they need the notes to say something specifically. Same for lab tests. Most labs for "screening" will be denied, but labs for "diagnosis" will be paid.
All accounts will be sent to collections. We don't write it off after 12 months, so delaying in hopes that we write it off does no good. We will gladly set up a payment system. Your account will stay in good standing even if you are only paying $10-20 a month. Your average mechanic won't do that for you, and nobody complains that they aren't fixing your car for free.
The bill is your responsibility, but many people don't want to deal with it, so they just delay and get mad that we don't provide services for free. I am personally an advocate for socialized medicine, but that is not reality right now. Trying to protest the system by not paying will just cause further headaches for you. My nurses make $40/hr and many times they spend 2-3 hours on the phone with an insurance company trying to work something out for a patient, because the patient won't complain to their insurance company, they complain to us. This is one of the reasons healthcare is so expensive - highly trained, well-paid professionals doing non-medical tasks to help a patient who refuses to help themselves.
The OP also fails to account for the room full of business professionals we have in place to work with the insurance companies trying to get your bill paid. There is more to it than just the front desk, office staff and doc, unless you are going to a mom-n-pop one-man show. Go to the small guys and pull these delays and refuse to pay, and you will put them out of business.
Finally, I don't know where he gets supplies for $6, but please send me a link. I buy the supplies, and I can hardly get a roll of kerlix for $6. OP also fails to account for the $7,000 vital sign machine, the $20,000 A1C machine, the $25,000 EKG machine, the $6,000 urinalysis machine (so I can save you money by not sending that to the lab), etc.
Bottom line - do your best to pay your bills. We depend on money to keep the doors open. None of my workers, including the docs, are independently wealthy. If you can't pay your bills, TALK TO SOMEONE. Call your insurance company. Call the business office. We will all work with you. Contrary to popular belief, most medical professionals are not trying to bankrupt people just so we can line our pockets with cash. We are trying to provide a service which costs a lot of money to provide, while keeping the doors open.
Little known fact - most larger primary care doctor offices are budgeted to lose money. We are considered feeders to the systems that make money - mostly surgical specialties, lab, and radiology. So your primary care doc is not just charging you a crazy bill because he is greedy.
Master_McKnowledge · 2 points · Posted at 08:36:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m genuinely surprised that there’s a self-pay rate and an insurance-paid rate. It sounds pretty scammy.
Trollwake · 2 points · Posted at 08:44:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
_Yeah_Well_Im_Drunk_ · 2 points · Posted at 08:48:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you have any advise on ambulance charges? Particularly privately owned companies from a life threatening injury back in 2012 that is now on my credit report? I know the easiest, most effective answer is pay it off in small amounts, but I haven’t been able to bring myself to do that. Idk why, it’s just like dude...I literally almost died, had a hemorrhagic stroke, and I don’t owe those doctors anything....why is my credit shit because I didn’t pay you out if pocket to drive me to the hospital?
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 2 points · Posted at 10:36:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
from 2012.. I'd just let it ride and make zero payments. your credit score may take a hit during that time it's being reported but it should bounce back..
If I recall (I'm NOT an expert, but I lived with horrible credit and repossessions etc for most of my 20's) after 7 years everything but a chpt 11? or 7? bankruptcy (which stay on for 10) will be removed from your credit score. They still have the right to try to collect the debt forever, so you may get the calls and letters until they sell the debt or give up, but after 7 it should be removed from your report. Check your report to see if it's still around. It may not have been reported to the credit agencies until a year or more after the incident, so it may be at 6 years now but your credit score (not plugging credit karma but it's free) should detail the exact number of months the debt has been reported so you can see how far along you are.
I have always understood an ambulance ride is about $800 on average (in SoAZ at least)
They may offer a settlement. FYI if you have a debt forgiven for a small percentage of the total, the difference is considered income that must be reported on your taxes. For example, if you owe 10k, and they offer to settle for 2k, that $8k is considered income that you'll have to pay taxes on.
good luck!
Artcat58 · 2 points · Posted at 13:43:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
But remember that paying a collection agency isnt the same as paying the medical bill. You're directly paying another company rather than the hospital or ambulance. If you choose to pay the collection agency, make sure you get a letter stating it was for the particular agency & service you were charged for. Otherwise, even after you've paid the collection agency the hospital can still have you on the haven't paid list... and it really does fall off your credit in 7 years. After a horrible divorce, I owed $90k in ex-husbands credit card bills. After 7 years, as god is my witness, they are gone. I've gone on to buy a house, get a car... you name it. Everything is fine. A friend who thought this was a bad idea, filed for bankruptcy. After 5 years it's still shows up & has stopped her from renting an apartment or getting a credit card. Crazy, yeah.... SOURCE: Best friend owns & runs a collection agency. They buy lists of debts from corporations & if they are able to collect ANYTHING from someone, THEY keep a very large (or all) money received & very little goes to the company owed. He told me to forget about my ambulance bill... and not to answer the phone if his debt collection agency called me, lol!
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 2 points · Posted at 14:39:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
yes to all of this.
I had a former step-father angry at me for not filing for bankruptcy, which would have prevented me from later buying my home, or even getting my job which required the most invasive background checks imaginable, checks which would not have forgiven a bankruptcy ever. But because my repo's, and multiple credit card debts that had been sold from collection agency to agency (lawsuits were threatened), had all dropped from my report, they weren't even mentioned.
_Yeah_Well_Im_Drunk_ · 2 points · Posted at 21:40:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you, that really helps put things into perspective! It’s been weighing down on me for so long and I’m finally in a position where i could start paying it off but I think I’ll let it ride one more year. I’ll just put more money into savings!
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 2 points · Posted at 21:48:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
thats what I would do. After this long it can't get worse (I doubt the calls or letters could get worse, unlikely they'd actually try court after this long and such a low dollar amt). If you can deal with whatever hit it does to your credit score for a year or two longer, then you'll be fine.
Credit Karma will allow you to get an idea of what if any harm it's doing to your credit, and simulate what paying it off would do. I think it'll show you that it's not worth losing sleep over.
good luck!
JobDestroyer · 2 points · Posted at 08:50:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I do not have insurance but have pretty damn good healthcare.
For minor things and regular checkups, I subscribe to a Direct Primary Care provider. This is a doctor who does not accept insurance, and doesn't charge insurance prices. For a family of 3 we're paying 145 a month, and we can text our doctor if there's anything going on. We just recently had a kid, we're also getting vaccines with this and regular monthly checkups for the tot, and if one of the grown-ups has something they need looked at, it's covered by the monthly cost.
For major medical, we are part of a health sharing network. These prices can be a bit higher, we're paying 530 bucks a month. This provides 1,000,000 dollars worth of coverage beyond the "annual unshared amount", which is iirc 1500 (basically they don't cover the first 1500 bucks of our medical bills, this is for all bills, not each individual bill, so if you meet the AUA for the year you basically are covered for everything the rest of the year). My monthly "premiums" go to other members of the health share, to pay their medical bills.
This means that my total cost of healthcare for all three of us is about 600 bucks a month, which is lower than the insurance offered by my company, of a way way higher quality, doesn't have in-network/out-of-network doctor BS, and I can just text my doctor if there's a question.
I think this setup is going to be more common going into the future since regular insurance is such crap with all the regulations and "government fixes" to healthcare that continuously make healthcare more difficult to navigate. I opted for this instead of insurance. I feel like I'm definitely getting more bang for the buck, but get a better product at the end. It's sort of like skipping the Toyota Carolla and going for the Ferrari, except you got the Ferrari for a steal.
morganamp · 1 points · Posted at 09:46:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This.
In our current broken system this is the only workable solution.
JobDestroyer · 1 points · Posted at 13:46:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wouldn't say its the only one, but it works well for me. There are other solutions that could fix healthcare. Here are a couple suggestions:
Get rid of the American Medical Association and occupational licensure for medical staff, beef up tort
Get rid of anti-competitive certificates of need that require new healthcare companies/new hospitals to get approval from existing hospitals
Eliminate drug patents so that there aren't monopolies on new medications, or at least make the period in which the monopoly is granted shorter
Abolish federal insurance standards that require insurance to cover a smorgasbord of things, allow consumers to do this on their own
Abolish medicare, medicaid, social security, and other programs that increase the price of medical care
Get rid of state subsidies for medical practices
Healthcare is the single most heavily regulated industry in the US. This is because it is an important industry, and people care more about it. However, an industry being important does not render it immune from economics, so all the more reason to not stifle it in red tape. The more regulated an industry, the worse it performs for consumers, and nowhere is this more obvious than the medical sector.
My healthcare choices work for me, and I sidestep a lot of bullshit this way. It won't work for everyone.
morganamp · 1 points · Posted at 14:06:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I agree.
In its current state with no changes health share is the best option for me as well.
The fact that we have Medicare that creates a federal baseline for medical costs and then we have a free for all that is completely unregulated where health care providers and pharma companies can gouge the sick into bankruptcy is crazy.
If these people were selling a pair of AA batteries for 50.00 during a hurricane we would put them in jail. I guess it’s ok when it’s just health care.
JobDestroyer · 1 points · Posted at 17:00:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Medicare effectively implements price controls for medical costs, which in any industry really messes with the equations. Surge pricing is an important aspect of economic allocation. The problem isn't that hospitals are greedy, the problem is the government prevents competition and subsidizes medical care to excess.
ComplainyGuy · 1 points · Posted at 11:11:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sounds like Medicare that the rest of the developed world has, but on a smaller scale and slightly more expensive. This would be what I would try to join if I had to live there.
JobDestroyer · 1 points · Posted at 13:32:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
May sound like it, but it isn't, because I'm not forced to pay it, and I can choose other plans if I so choose. In fact, this sort of healthcare is illegal in many countries due to their government monopolies on healthcare.
There also aren't any waiting times and the quality of care itself is much higher than other countries, as it uses American doctors and technology without the government/insurance added red tape.
Slayer_Tip · 2 points · Posted at 08:51:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
or just dont get sick, dont know know that americans are fit and strong and never are sick?
for shame.
SoundSalad · 2 points · Posted at 08:55:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How about just giving them fake info at the Emergency Room? Will that work?
Artcat58 · 2 points · Posted at 13:26:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes it does work. A friend thought he was having a heart attack & went to a charity hospital using an alias, saying was homeless. He was treated & found out he had congestive heart failure. He kept going to that hospital for treatment for a year until he turned 65 & Medicare kicked in. The only issue was when he started going to the Medicare doctors he couldn't transfer his file to explain why he was taking "John Does" heart meds, lol!
shendrad · 1 points · Posted at 09:04:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Depends on how serious your ailment is, how long you need to stay, what kind of followup is required, along with prescriptions.
Daedeluss · 2 points · Posted at 08:57:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is the most American thread in history. What a shit show. You poor suckers.
Irksomefetor · 2 points · Posted at 09:08:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And also, SLPT, just give all fake information in a case of an emergency hospital stay and you'll never hear back from them about those pesky bills.
Siluke · 2 points · Posted at 09:17:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So how does healthcare actually work here? If you’re really sick do they just let you die if you have no insurance?
merow · 1 points · Posted at 09:23:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For emergency medicine, no, thanks to EMTALA. That act declares a person cannot be turned away due to ability to pay or not. They must be medically stabilized before transferred to another facility.
Siluke · 1 points · Posted at 09:23:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Transferred to another facility ? Do you have charity hospitals or something?
merow · 1 points · Posted at 15:21:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have a city/county hospital that primarily serves under/unfunded patients
trumpisbadperson · 2 points · Posted at 09:18:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Buddy, I don't think I'll use this info soon but you are doing a very good service to people in this country. I hope you get all that you desire and deserve.
TroubadourCeol · 2 points · Posted at 09:19:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
any idea on what a rheumatologist will cost without insurance or what to do to reduce the cost? I'm dreading my appointment in January but I need to see my rheumatologist in order to keep getting the medication that keeps my spine from fusing into a single bone.
Artcat58 · 1 points · Posted at 13:09:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I'm in Texas & have severe RA. I lost my Insurance a few years ago. I told my rheumatologist & he let me pay the Medicare fee of $120 for each visit instead of the insurance pay of $480. I used discount coupons for prescriptions & got free Humira from the pharmaceutical company. Still not free but lots cheaper. I now have Insurance that makes me pay EVERY THING up to $5k until it kicks in at 80/20. They DO NOT pay for my pain meds & I pay $1100 out of pocket each month for them, but that REALLY helps on my income taxes because I always have over $12k in medical bills. The last two years have been very bad. Eighteen hospitalizations, 13 ER visits & 13 surgeries. I've literally been bed ridden for 18 months. I couldn't deal with anything but the basic bills to live on. After $7k out of pocket each year, I owe nothing but to be perfectly honest, after my $12k is spent on meds, I don't have enough to pay the hospital bills... and still haven't. I'm a disabled retired Texas teacher & my monthly premiums are huge. The hospital bills have gone to collection but I don't care. I don't answer the phone or stress myself out with bills in the mail. My credit is still good (700 range), I've gotten credit cards & had no trouble renting or buying things. I'm going to start a payment plan of sending them $25 a month (teachers only get paid once a month).They can take that $25 for the rest of my life. I'm not eligible for Medicare for 5 more years & make $200 dollars a year TOO MUCH to qualify for any federal assistance food stamps, Medicaid or reduced prescription plans. Medical bills The system is broken. Use it to your advantage. Start paying the minimum you can towards what you owe monthly. You're probably young & will need to get a mortgage or car soon so if you're making an effort towards payment your credit will be okay. After a while the hospital or doctor will call to offer you a reduced bill to close the account. Or be proactive & call to request it Before I got REALLY sick a couple of years ago, I had a $20k bill that I paid $50 a month for 18 months & it never went to collections. Then the hospital called & said if I could pay $2500 the next month, they'd close the account as "paid in full". I was able to do that. Now that I'm better I plan to start chipping away at that $250k medical bill I've accrued in the last 2 years.
But to answer your question about your rheumatologist, explain your situation & ask for them to charge you the price he collects for Medicare or a special reduced charge that accommodates your needs. Contact the pharmaceutical company who makes your spinal meds. Most have reduced rates, some as little as a $5 copay to keep you on them. Even free clinics in your area will treat you & give you free or low cost meds. Try checking out other subs on personal finance & those on Rheumatoid Arthritis, too. Lots of good advice for people in the same situation. RA is a bitch. Get a support group, even an online one. Its good to hear from people in the same situation. Some have it so much worse. Count your blessings, not your bills 😀. You'll get through this & best of luck to you!
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 09:21:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A few years back my wife had a rest do e that the doctor said "would be about $100...". We said okay and then the bill was $9850. We called up the lab and said we were self pay and they volunteered $65 as a fair price for them.
It was a real WTF moment for us.
MattyDxx · 2 points · Posted at 09:29:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
America, what the fuck, bro? Why is this so complicated? Damn.
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 1 points · Posted at 10:23:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Republican politicians... that fight for the Institutionalized for-profit healthcare Companies rather than for people's rights and better interests. They also fight for corporate conglomerates like Monsanto and Shell that pollute our environment, claiming that regulations that require environmental protections are too costly to these companies. So people keep getting sick and have to pay into the healthcare industry... all to keep the wheels of capitalism spinning.
Thats just part of why it's so hard to do anything that makes sense here in the good ol' USofA, but a BIG part.
morganamp · 2 points · Posted at 09:32:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Join a health share instead of insurance.
My insurance rates were 1200 a month for my wife and I. We had 5k in deductibles and an 80/20 policy.
Health share is 400/ mo. 1700 deductible
Health share uses Medicare pay differential schedule to reprice all bills to the same level that is ok’d through Medicare.
Example. 1500.00 anesthesiologists Bill was reduced to 292.00
This was part of my deductible. I sent a payment for 292 to the anesthesiologist along with a repriced detail of services sheet ( provided by the health share)
Payment was approved.
We hit our deductible cap in April. I haven’t paid anything more than my premiums since.
Because of this I was able to take care of many health issues that I have been avoiding for decades because of the simple fact I couldn’t afford the steep deductible let alone worry about if the procedure was going to get rejected by the insurance company.
Health care is broken as fuck. Insurance companies do not have your best interests in mind EVER. Health care providers have to rig the system to get paid. What is left is the average person being stuck in the war zone between these two factions.
OPs post really bums me out. To have to play chicken with a medical provider over a payment vs collection shouldn’t be a way of health care cost management.
Health share has solved this for me. I have removed at least one faction from the war.
cara27hhh · 2 points · Posted at 09:33:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
step 0 - eradicate medicine-for-profit in the first place
DavidDann437 · 2 points · Posted at 09:34:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What do you think the UK chances are of avoiding this kinda shit after Briexit?
slipknot400 · 2 points · Posted at 10:02:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or government policy change
Blovnt · 2 points · Posted at 10:07:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What a fucked up system
tiger203 · 2 points · Posted at 10:16:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a 17 year old i really thank you for this. I'm not entirely prepared for the mental implications of financial troubles due to medical bills so this helps a lot.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 10:27:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This post makes me thankful I was born and bred in Ireland.
Mr-Klaus · 2 points · Posted at 10:34:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or just get universal healthcare like the rest of the sane developed world.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 10:54:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Healthcare in America is a sick joke.
spunjbaf · 2 points · Posted at 10:57:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This should be required reading for every American.
bigpapasmurf12 · 2 points · Posted at 10:57:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow I'm from the UK, this is some dystopian shit. Soon to hit our shores too thanks to the fuckwit we have in power and Brexit.
TurfDerguson · 2 points · Posted at 11:00:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Mr. Incredible got fired for this sort of thing.
Hrmpfreally · 2 points · Posted at 11:25:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Elect officials who seek to make this less confusing, not more convoluted. This is asinine.
Chanandlerbong88 · 2 points · Posted at 11:42:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Universal healthcare is a better option lol
JayneJay · 2 points · Posted at 11:46:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a Canadian, I salute the bravery of Americans who have to nitpick and argue for the medical attention to stay alive.
ragn4rok234 · 2 points · Posted at 11:54:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This doesn't work in many places. Self pay bills violate many contracts with insurance companies as they require they be charged the same rate as patients would be charged.
Sitk042 · 2 points · Posted at 11:56:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Number 3, used to be true. Not anymore. I got a scope last year at a local hospital. I set up a payment plan, but after the second payment I sent, they sent me to collections. I WAS MAKING PAYMENTS MONTHLY. And I still got sent to collections. Our city has two major providers, the next stuff got done wasn’t much better. I was sending payments and even portions of my bills got sent to collections.
I had to stop payments that I had set up as the hospital didn’t know how to send my payments to them to the collection agency. So I’d not be getting credit for those payments. Total crap.
Gredenis · 2 points · Posted at 12:06:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'll file this, as a non-American, under cool-stuff-to-be-aware-of-but-at-the-time-appalled-to-find-out-this-is-necessary-for-some.
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 12:12:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wait, people are insured and then have to pay things them self anyway. And on top of that, people have to pay more because the bill they receive is higher if they have an insurance, so if the insurance doesn't pay, you pay too much?
What is that for insane system? How are people in the USA not going on the streets revolting over stuff like this?
Valiantay · 2 points · Posted at 12:14:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jesus Christ, this is insane.
I remember I had a friend in the States who got sick with the common cold, used to play video games with him. He sounded like ass, and honestly I just wanted to hear him clearly, so I told him to go to the doctor. He replied with "but that costs money".
Bless Canada, I can visit any doctor any number of times I need for anything at anytime.
K1nd4Weird · 2 points · Posted at 12:27:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do a fuckton of reading through everything you sign, every bill you receive, and fight everyone...as you're recovering from illness, surgery, or an extended hospital stay.
You know. Just do that.
niikhil · 2 points · Posted at 12:31:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Deleted wtf
uriman · 2 points · Posted at 12:33:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I know a girl who is actually an MD and was saying that she grew up in a family business and never had insurance. They would always pay in cash. Her family must be doing this, but this seems like such a headache to do every time.
Irksomefetor · 2 points · Posted at 12:37:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
RIP OP's career.
Eviscerator28 · 2 points · Posted at 16:09:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wait a minute, where did OP go?
Highplowp · 2 points · Posted at 16:15:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was this deleted?
PeterPanLives · 2 points · Posted at 19:50:17 on December 9, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh no, they deleted the info. Anyone got a copy of it?
Jaschoid · 3 points · Posted at 05:41:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
fuck, this is disgusting. so fucking glad I live in europe
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:25:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 07:39:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A vote for Bernie Sanders can end this inhumane madness once and for all.
Hackerboy603 · 3 points · Posted at 08:29:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jesus fuck, I am really starting to loathe this country. Land of the free...loading corporations, and fuck individual
NativeAmericans.Dqnijel · 2 points · Posted at 08:50:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or vote for Bernie and have all your medical debt paid off
El_Muerte95 · 3 points · Posted at 09:12:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or vote for someone who will rid us of this ridiculous system and bring forth a new one.
damrider · 3 points · Posted at 10:03:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
LPT : vote for the only candidate disgusted by this, Bernard Sanders
BryceCanYawn · 3 points · Posted at 09:36:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Thank you so much. I broke down at the procedure center this morning because I owed my insurance company money and they weren't going to cover my surgery.
I thought I was going to have to cancel my surgery. I had a 7 mm kidney stone that had actually adhered to my ureter and was causing a kidney infection, so obviously that wasn't a good idea. It was extra frustrating because I called Ambetter yesterday to make sure my coverage was up to date.
Luckily my aunt was with me and covered the fee until I can get back to work. The registration nurse told me that self-pay would be an option, but I had no idea how much it would cost. I didn't realize it was lower than the insurance cost.
I had a full-time blown panic attack in recovery, and I'm still freaking out about how I'm going to pay for this at the same time taxes are due. This just brought me so much comfort. Thank you.
I still have anesthésia in my system, so sorry if this is jumbled or oversharing.
Please vote for healthcare coverage in 2020, y'all. We can't keep doing this. I work. I pay taxes. I'm genetically predisposed to kidney stones and it has destroyed me financially.
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 4 points · Posted at 10:08:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
what kind of human would downvote this persons comment? c'mon really people.
This is an everyday thing across this country. Think it's bullshit until you're the one worrying if your full coverage insurance will even be enough to cover expenses. People fall into medical debt, that can cost them their job if they work for the USgovt or have a clearance. Lose your job because you don't have enough money to cover medical bills. Tell me thats not a kick in the nuts for someone working as a civil servant.
Michalusmichalus · 1 points · Posted at 11:57:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Get well soon!
ItalianQueen8831 · 2 points · Posted at 03:59:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you for sharing this knowledge
gladysk · 2 points · Posted at 04:29:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is great. Thank you! I imagine a lot of redditors will save your post,
mcub19 · 2 points · Posted at 04:37:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can you explain #4 a little more? Does that mean that if your insurance covers say an emergency visit to the hospital, it won't cover necessary IV drugs?
[deleted] · 4 points · Posted at 04:42:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It will cover it 100% if you have insurance. The main issue is if you don’t have insurance they will charge about $35 per injection alone plus the drug. The drugs given through IV are always super cheap. The only exception is narcotics which have different parameters that I can’t discuss.
acinom92 · 2 points · Posted at 04:41:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’ve been dealing with that and just getting bills and bills, all of them above 1k! I’m seriously going to call them all tomorrow. I’m not trying to get away with not paying .. just a fighting chance!!
Seriously, thank you!
Blundergruff · 2 points · Posted at 04:49:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Don't forget to do your research first! :) Good luck! You got this.
acinom92 · 2 points · Posted at 04:55:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! I’m sorry, I guess it’s clear now that I know 0 about health insurance ( or else I would’ve gotten a better one) but what do you mean by research? What should I research?
Blundergruff · 3 points · Posted at 05:15:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh, I have no idea. I just saw someone else give of smugly encourage people to use these ideas as jumping off points of things to research and I was kind of annoyed by their tone but thought they were right! I've also got some debt to figure out so I know I'm gonna look into some of these ideas tomorrow.
Ugh I didn't even get to choose mine, really. I didn't have time to shop the marketplace, so just went with what my job offered. I'll let you know if I find anything good- I just wanted to support research but in a (hopefully) positive tone! :D
revnhoj · 2 points · Posted at 04:42:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How would one use 6 - 9 to their advantage?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 04:43:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Mainly for justifying the price you’re willing to pay. It takes about 15 mins for front desk and 20 mins for clinical staff. The rest is provider/doctor
hi_im_snowman · 2 points · Posted at 04:55:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A true hero doesn’t need a cape. Well done, OP, well done.
knewitfirst · 2 points · Posted at 05:57:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sorry but I have to push back on you here. Providers cannot just give you a self pay or "uninsured" rate. Unless the insurance denial is specifically based on medical necessity or a billing error (not following medical policy by billing without a required diagnosis or timely filing, for example), this is called discounting and can lose you your contract and status as a credentialed provider with the healthplan. Adjusting patient responsibility is in direct violation of all contracts. You must make and document a reasonable attempt to bill patients for all copays, deductibles and coinsurance due at the time services are rendered (most ehr platforms track this for you). Insureds (patients) should also be aware that they are expected to understand and do their part (take responsibility for) things like referrals and choosing preferred providers. It's a slippery slope for those not in the biz so careful there cuz
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 13:12:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So they just have to find a different way of doing it to not get caught.
knewitfirst · 1 points · Posted at 13:20:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No, we need real reform.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 15:05:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah... good luck with that.
Lawlsagna · 1 points · Posted at 16:12:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
For clarification, I believe OP was suggesting to refund the insurance company, remove the adjustments and reprocess the claim as self-pay. I thought that discounting was the scenario where they apply discounts after your insurance company processes the claim. This isn't adjusting patient responsibility after a claim is processed, it's reprocessing a claim to 'erase' it from the insurance company system and re-billing directly to the patient with self-pay adjustments rather than insurance adjustments.
knewitfirst · 1 points · Posted at 17:12:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Right, which is in violation of the physicians contract with the payer. If you know that a patient has insurance, you cannot choose not to bill the payer and instead collect a reduced rate from the patient. You can take a denied claim and then reduce to self-pay rate for the patient, but you must bill! What you're saying isn't insurance fraud exactly, but it IS discounting services for one and not another. Patients that CAN pay are expected to, and that in and of itself is the problem. What you guys are suggesting is not the same thing as making payment arrangements with a patient or reducing a patient's balance that is past due after an effort to collect in full has been made. I'm not sure where you practice medical billing or how deep your knowledge goes, but this is basic and it's consistent across the board within the US healthcare system.
Lawlsagna · 1 points · Posted at 18:37:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
Only if that physician has this specific requirement in their contract.
I worked in anesthesia billing for a fortune 15 medical billing and supply company. My department covered about 30 different in and out of state provider groups, we had an in-house legal team, a contract team and I regularly referenced the contracts my providers had with various insurance companies to process claims across the 5 different groups I was assigned to. I also mentioned in another comment that some of my groups didn't offer self-pay options, so perhaps those were the situations in which providers had an MFN clause.
It is my understanding that it's the patient's right to determine if they want a claim to be processed using their insurance and they can absolutely request to have things be processed as self-pay, covered under section 13405 of subtitle d of the hitech act (42 usc 17935). While this is an older article and HIPAA regulations are updated yearly, this specific act was merged into the HIPAA Omnibus Rule. Patients have full rights of their health information, and if they don't want their information sent to an insurance company for billing, then you're legally not allowed to, so reprocessing a claim in this scenario would be considered correcting a HIPAA violation.
Perhaps the contractual obligations between the providers and insurance companies I worked with were slightly different than the ones you've seen, which would make sense because anesthesia billing also covers a lot of services that aren't medically necessary. But that's why I was curious about specifics. No need to come at me like that.
beer_baron · 2 points · Posted at 06:37:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Great advice! We have insurance, but I'm terrified to see the bill after my wife's 5 day stay to give birth (c section) to our first child. Any specific advice for this situation?
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 08:44:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Seeing the cost breakdown from you makes me realize that the US doesn't have an unreasonable cost when it comes to the actual healthcare, just that the problem is the suppliers and insurance companies. In fact, these prices seem pretty usual (a bit higher though) for what I pay in my country.
I mean, the doctor rate, front desk and clinical are pretty reasonable.
Yankees really need to get their shit together and fix the healthcare system, cause the basics for a good one are seemingly in place. But then y'all stack a shit ton of extra costs on top of it.
Probably because people keep voting Republican.
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 1 points · Posted at 10:48:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Those were the actual rates that were being quoted, what is actually billed is usually 10x the true cost. So all the middlemen can get paid.
I had a buddy have a heart attack, drove himself to the ER. Had a 3hr procedure to install a stint. Took a Dr and 2 assistants, was in and out the same day. He is employed by a Fortune100 US defense contractor working on a USAF facility with full medical insurance. He was billed $80k, insurance negotiated it down to $60k, his amount due was 10% so $6000. He had to pay $6000 out of pocket for a half day procedure. That exact same operation would cost about $6000 completely start to finish at any other high quality hospital in any other country in the world, had he needed to pay for himself (unlikely in most other developed countries) He looked at the bill and saw $30 for a saline bag that costs 50cents. Yet he votes red every time and shits on the thought of a "fuckin socialist" president. He thinks he would have had to wait 6 weeks to be seen if he was in Canada.
Our republicans show preference to corporate for-profit healthcare more than for the people they were elected to serve. it's fuckin criminal.
NakedNude17 · 2 points · Posted at 09:19:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sucks to be a sick American 🤣
ShopLifeHurts2599 · 2 points · Posted at 09:43:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Vote in someone who wants to reform health care!
Wow! What a simple idea.
Wingless27 · 2 points · Posted at 09:51:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
r/latestagecapitolism in a modern society, our sickest people shouldn't have to work harder just to pay their medical bills. Change the system!That said, thanks for advising on the system that exists...
Doubleb409 · 2 points · Posted at 12:33:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was this deleted?
Artcat58 · 2 points · Posted at 23:22:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Because Epstein committed suicide.....
blazer243 · 1 points · Posted at 18:39:06 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Inaccurate information.
Champigne · 2 points · Posted at 12:44:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
YSK if you debt is sold to a debt collector, which it will be if you don't pay it. Do not talk to them, do not answer their calls and do not pay them a dime. They are parasites. And remember apart from those to the government, debts are only collectable for 7 years.
Irksomefetor · 2 points · Posted at 14:37:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Right? why are we all pretending we gotta pay this shit when rich people routinely file for bankruptcy.
Lemme get in on that, too.
Champigne · 2 points · Posted at 23:37:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You honestly don't. Apparently debt collectors can report the debt to credit bureaus but that's never happened to me. Several times doctors have tried to bill hundreds for an appointment because they didn't bill my insurance right or the pcp didn't fax the referral. Okay I guess you don't want to get paid because I'm certainly not paying that much even if I could. No, I'm not jumping through these fucking OP is suggesting. Go ahead and sell it to the debt collectors for pennies on the dollar, IDGAF, I'm DEFINITELY not paying them. By some miracle my credit score is still 700+..
Irksomefetor · 2 points · Posted at 23:41:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I figured out all that shit was BULLSHIT when my mom went through bankruptcy.
Within a year of it, she had a new house, a new car, and none of the debt that had been killing her for a decade.
what the fuck are credit scores even for
Champigne · 1 points · Posted at 00:01:55 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Damn, I've been thinking about it myself. I owe a lot of money but want to buy a house in the foreseeable future. I'll look into it. Credit scores are just another way to control the working class.
notthepig · 2 points · Posted at 12:55:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
RIP Does anyone have a copy of the LPT?
FvHound · 2 points · Posted at 13:00:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Someone just posted it, sort by new.
DorkyDisneyDad · 3 points · Posted at 05:57:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The actual best way to reduce medical bills is Medicare for All. Find out more over at /r/SandersForPresident
[deleted] · 3 points · Posted at 07:02:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
10: Bernie Sanders
SayNoob · -1 points · Posted at 07:32:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
or literally any other Democratic candidate
nomad1c23 · 2 points · Posted at 11:12:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Their other plans arent advocating for single payer healthcare like Bernies does.
SayNoob · 1 points · Posted at 13:02:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Single payer is a solution but not the only solution.
nomad1c23 · 1 points · Posted at 08:44:54 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's the only solution to give everyone affordable healthcare.
The other candidates plans are designed to still make profits off people.
SayNoob · 1 points · Posted at 08:58:20 on December 6, 2019 · (Permalink)
I think you fundamentally lack an understanding of what single payer is a solution for. It's not a solution for healthcare prices, its a solution for health insurance. It does not change how high your hospital bill is, it changes who pays the bill.
The problem on the insurance side right now is that insurance companies have too much discretion in deciding if they want to take you on as a customer and in deciding if they think your bill falls under their plan. Both those issues can be solved with regulations.
nomad1c23 · 1 points · Posted at 03:18:18 on December 7, 2019 · (Permalink)
No
SayNoob · 1 points · Posted at 09:34:37 on December 7, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie supporters are really ruining Bernie for me.
nomad1c23 · 1 points · Posted at 22:37:15 on December 9, 2019 · (Permalink)
People who say this would have never voted for bernie in the first place. Imagine the privilege you have to not vote for someone cause people were curt to you online.
RedofPaw · 1 points · Posted at 08:46:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
These are great tips. To add to that:
GummyBearFighter · 1 points · Posted at 05:17:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thanks for posting you a real 1
acinom92 · 1 points · Posted at 05:18:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It was! :) thank you! Hopefully we both can do something with that debt, it doesn’t hurt to try right? Maybe we’ll get someone in the holiday spirit!
Durden11 · 1 points · Posted at 05:24:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this include dental/specialist bills as well? (Root canal, crown, etc?)
PTBunneh · 1 points · Posted at 05:27:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm going in for revisionary surgery next year, 100% self pay. Pre-op is next week. May I message you after we get the preliminary bill?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 05:30:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
They will knock off 10-20% on damn near anything if you are will to pay it now.
Source: had the cancer$
BleakAce · 1 points · Posted at 05:31:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Will this work for dental? My dentist literally called me today saying my pre authorization was denied. I need to have a skin graft done for my receding gums. It's about 3k for the procedure.
kailsbabbydaddy · 1 points · Posted at 05:37:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
UPMC’s self-pay discount is 20% They will not however change your bill to include that after an insurance denial unless the denial reason is for patient not being their insured. Definitely worth a try for other providers though!
mothershabooboo · 1 points · Posted at 05:38:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Hi, thanks so much for your post! I have a question- I had to see an out of network plastic surgeon in the ER of an in network hospital. He was the only dr on call to treat my injury. This is the bill I am receiving from his office : http://imgur.com/a/ndWWSAb . My insurance is telling me it should be covered and I believe they are negotiating with him, but his office so far has been unreasonable about adjusting any rates. Do you have any advice based on the situation and billing codes? This was in NJ and my insurance is blue cross/ blue shield of Illinois. Thank you!
carmencarp · 1 points · Posted at 05:39:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any luck in reducing an emergency room copay. My regular doctor sent me for a test because it was late in the afternoon. I didn’t realize it would cost me 300$.
adavadas · 1 points · Posted at 05:39:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You are the hero that this country needs right now.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 05:40:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sad thing is, some of us might refer to this comment in the future. Thanks for the info.
Scrantonstrangla · 1 points · Posted at 05:41:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If we go to single payer do you lose your job OP?
SunflowerMusic · 1 points · Posted at 05:45:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m a cancer patient with thousands of dollars of medical debt. My doctor’s office assigned me a financial navigator - can I call her and ask for the bills to be decreased?
I’m also paying more than $400 per month for ACA insurance, so any advice there is greatly appreciated too.
ricksteer_p333 · 1 points · Posted at 05:47:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don't understand #4... My insurance covers annual physicals, which for me include basic blood tests. This involves injecting a needle obviously... but was covered.
I was also administered fentanyl via IV (before surgery). This was also covered.
daj1798 · 1 points · Posted at 05:50:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am sharing this in every venue I have access to. Future MD hoping to save some people from overpaying the industry.
Meekly_a_Minotaur · 1 points · Posted at 05:52:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Are #1 and #2 still applicable in the same way if you are on Medicare?
brandnewdayinfinity · 1 points · Posted at 05:53:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So what if I overestimated my income so I’m overpaying my premiums and copays and starting to drown? Meeting with my CPA Friday so I have an exact number this year. And yes this means my taxes are essentially done. Pleased.
stitches_x · 1 points · Posted at 05:54:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What if it’s already been sent to collections? Am I fucked?
Wuxian · 1 points · Posted at 05:56:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And I thought this would be a "don't vote X" joke.
Mycarman · 1 points · Posted at 05:59:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Save this, even if you think/know you’re covered. Shit happens!
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:00:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jesus Christ. Just vote in a real leftist and let’s abolish this draconian system
agatesharing · 1 points · Posted at 06:01:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What if I accrued the bills because I had accidentally chosen the wrong insurance plan? I did not realize I'd signed up for a high deductible HSA with a $6500 deductible. I have just realized my bill is $2200 for behavioral health therapy and i feel like such an idiot because I've essentially done it to myself out of my own ignorance. I started a payment plan of $50 per month and applied for financial hardship but I dont know if I will actually qualify because I earn 39k. They expect a 10% payment of the total in 3 months. The remaining income I have after bill is about $200 a month. I am suddenly so effing effed. And I did it to myself.
NameLily · 1 points · Posted at 07:23:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You didn't do it to yourself, American"healthcare" system did it to you! America desperately needs single payer Universal Healthcare for all American citizens!
BloodHunterBob · 1 points · Posted at 06:03:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank god I'm Canadian
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 06:48:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Very informative contribution to the discussion.
Synical603 · 1 points · Posted at 06:03:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you for this info
DocDankage · 1 points · Posted at 06:06:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you! I’ve been reading up as much as I can on this. You provide some good info here.
dishwasherphobia · 1 points · Posted at 06:13:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Saving this. I'll be finding out soon if I'm about to have to pay out of pocket for a procedure... or if I just need antibiotics. I have a strong feeling it's going to be the procedure. Thanks for sharing.
unknown_creator · 1 points · Posted at 06:20:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I just got my medical bills for an allergic reaction. I don't have health insurance so I am scared to open it. However, your post has given me courage.
Alternate_Supply · 1 points · Posted at 06:22:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Reading this later
iSYan1995 · 1 points · Posted at 06:22:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
laughs in Canada
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 07:29:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wouldn't be laughing if I had to suffer 20-40 weeks while waiting on a specialist.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:22:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Did this before. Saved me more than 40%. I wish more people knew this. Thanks for sharing.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:24:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Is this possible even after your bill already went to collections?
godrestsinreason · 1 points · Posted at 06:24:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Weird because the hospital I had to go to before I had health insurance sent me to collections as fast as they possibly could. Like the minute they were able to, that was it for me. $4k in debt to collectors now.
crapmonkey86 · 1 points · Posted at 06:25:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I recently quit my job and immediately the day after (Thanksgiving, lucky me) I became gravely ill with what i thought was the flu but turned out to be a lot worse and had to go to the hospital and get multiple tests done to determine what was wrong with me. The entire time I had no idea how long my employee insurance lasted post termination. I ended up just using my employee insurance anyway and am praying that it holds up for a little while. In case it doesnt, you have given me huge presence of mind on how to deal with the potential monetary fallout as I look for another job. You have done a lot for me even if I never end up using this advice, thank you for posting it.
NameLily · 1 points · Posted at 07:12:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I think insurance is usually good for the month. Then you need to sign up and pay Cobra rates if you want your coverage to continue. But cobra rates are high since you are paying the entire premium without employer assistance. But depending on your income you might qualify for Medicaid or ACA subsidy for insurance.
asian_identifier · 1 points · Posted at 06:28:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Does this apply to dental?
KawaiiClown · 1 points · Posted at 06:29:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I dont have insurance but I have horrible anxiety. How do I get help?
Torodong · 1 points · Posted at 06:31:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can't you just paint yourself orange and declare bankruptcy ever few years?
backFromTheBed · 1 points · Posted at 06:32:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I was just thinking about a question related to this: How does this work from someone from a foreign nation? Let's say some tourist got into an accident and needed to stay in a hospital for a week. Will they have to pay thousands of dollars due to hugely inflated prices as they don't have any insurance?
KKlear · 1 points · Posted at 10:42:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You should always have travel insurance when going abroad, same goes for travelling to the USA.
I did a quick check just now and getting covered for a 7 days trip to USA costs roughly 4x as much as the same trip within EU, but it's not very pricey.
prnorm · 1 points · Posted at 06:33:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any suggestions for when you get balance billed after your insurance already paid? Long story, but the hospital was out of network but verbally (I know) agreed they wouldn't balance bill us as long as our insurance paid their in network rate, which they did.
They won't budge an inch, even though they already got paid as much or more than they would with a contracted insurance company so now we owe over $10k. Yay.
Nogias · 1 points · Posted at 06:34:05 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Hi there, I get a depot lupron shot every five years for endometriosis. This last round cost $6000 out of pocket. I see your suggestion on 4, but can you explain a bit more about fighting the bill?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:52:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
Nogias · 1 points · Posted at 07:08:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes, unfortunately. Fun fact, my colleague in Brisbane pays $40 out of pocket for the entire series and all six units.
mckelbow · 1 points · Posted at 06:34:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
One of the largest independent lab companies in the US does not offer a standard self pay rate. Only services are discounted for limited Reasons and customer service has no ability to negotiate.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 06:35:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
That’s the most helpful thing I’ve read in my entire life. Wow.
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 06:35:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I work in a pharmacy. The BIGGEST thing that you need to know about: manufacturer discount cards.
Let’s say a doctor writes you a brand name drug. Let’s say Advair. You get the script, and the pharmacy bills it to insurance, and your copay is $150.
You don’t actually have to pay $150
Go to advair.com, and find the savings offer/discount card. Put in your info, and it’ll spit out a discount card with billing information.
We at the pharmacy then bill the COPAY of $150 to that card, and those cards usually pick up $100+ (with a minimum pay)
A) So let’s say that the terms of the card cover an unlimited amount with a $10 minimum. When we bill it, it will shell out $140, completely free of charge, free of contract, etc. Your copay is then $10.
B) let’s say the card covers $100 max. (The most common “maximum limit”). When we bill it, it will shell out the $100, leaving you with $50 for the copay.
Either way, YOURE NOT PAYING THE $150
Keep in mind: these cars aren’t available in generics. Also, manufacturer discount cards are not the same as a normal discount card, like a GoodRX.
Soluscor · 1 points · Posted at 07:20:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Happy Cake Day!
Alx0427 · 1 points · Posted at 18:26:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Same to you!!!
justsomeph0t0n · 1 points · Posted at 06:39:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This advice is great, and useful because the system is totally broken.
And that's precisely why it's so valuable. Heath care reform based upon "i don't care about the details, just do it" will only result in a new set of problems. You need to pay attention to the specific details to make sure that reform will actually do what you want it to (whatever result you want). There are active and deliberate attempts to prevent you from understanding how things actually work.
gothsurf · 1 points · Posted at 06:41:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wish this applied to my prescription
unitedbk · 1 points · Posted at 06:43:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What the fuck america
HungryHornyHigh · 1 points · Posted at 06:44:22 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow saved for later. Many blessing your way
DaFreakingFox · 1 points · Posted at 06:45:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Damn. Glad I am in Europe and get charged 4$ for extra bandages I requested after a big surgery without any other issue or payment.
insipidgoose · 1 points · Posted at 06:48:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's fucking ridiculous that it's this complex and annoying to deal with to begin with. Can we join the rest of the civilized world with single payer healthcare already?
PUSHTONZ · 1 points · Posted at 06:53:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Fuck this whole system. Can people just not die from preventable things? That just seems like an obligatory thing going into 20-fucking-20.
Cucamongaman · 1 points · Posted at 06:53:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can anyone help me understand point #4?
thearmchairredditor · 1 points · Posted at 07:02:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
When medicare for all passes it would be you should have known
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 07:08:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
the problem is no one actually gets how this sick cycle works. it needs to be simplified, and/or consumers need to be educated. these suggestions feed the cycle and that money needs to be made up elsewhere and THESE ARE NOT SOLUTIONS
TimGLong · 1 points · Posted at 07:08:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Another tip is to not live in the USA. Your health system is ridiculous. The land of the free they say.....
Coookiedeluxe · 2 points · Posted at 07:25:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Which is why I immigrated to Canada in 2014 instead of the US. I have a job with plenty of experience that is in HUGE demand in both countries, and both countries basically rolled out the red carpet for me. I even could have earned 20% more in the US plus enjoy the nicer climate, but there is absolutely zero way I could live in a country that does not consider free healthcare for all a basic human right.
I’m sure I’m not the only one thinking this way, and I really hope for the awesome people of the US that they will be able to change this.
SDGundamX · 1 points · Posted at 07:12:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It is a fucking travesty that this post is needed at all.
I'm an American living in Japan, which has socialized health care. You know how much it took me to take my daughter to the emergency room in the middle of the night when she had a reaction to a vaccination? 100 yen (less than 1 USD) and that was only because my wife and my combined income exceeded some arbitrary threshold--normally kids get medical care for free.
Meanwhile, my co-pay for most doctor visits for myself is anywhere from 20-40 USD depending on whether I had bloodwork done or not. My prescription thyroid medication is less than $10 for 90 days worth.
Anybody who has lived abroad in a first-world country knows that health care in the U.S. is just fucked. I cannot for the life of me understand why Americans are not outside the White House and Capitol Building night and day with torches and pitchforks demanding reform.
dgarcia19931 · 1 points · Posted at 07:14:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This guy knows how to ford the river
noteducatedenough · 1 points · Posted at 07:15:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Do you have any timeframe of when you will be serving your sentence? I would like to pay you a visit. /s. Honestly, thank you.
HolierMonkey586 · 1 points · Posted at 07:16:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm 27 and don't get sick. For decent insurance I'm going to pay roughly 375 per month next year and probably only go to the doctor once if it all. Insurance is new to me but are there any plans that would allow me to use self pay for the doctor visits, and have good coverage for unexpected high cost procedures/treatments? Also, would it be more cost effective? Off the top of my head I believe it's $400 emergency room, $15 generic prescription, $30 doctor visits, and $55 specialists. I think it's $2500 deductible with a $8000 out of pocket maximum roughly. It's late at night and I don't have my computer next to me to get exact numbers.
timbaisbimba · 1 points · Posted at 07:16:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can someone explain what is in-patient and out-patient and who decides this? I have doctor visit, anesthesia considered as in-patient (lower cost) however room services out-patient (higher cost) , ridiculous.
badabingbadabang · 1 points · Posted at 07:17:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is obviously useful but it's also quite sad that it's needed.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 07:23:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Legendary post. Could have used this advice a couple years ago. Thanks for it now!
mufasana1 · 1 points · Posted at 07:23:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So what’s the point of even having health insurance?
KVirello · 1 points · Posted at 07:26:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you for doing this, but it shouldn't be necessary.
America should stop being such a shit show.
Americans should rise up and demand that their interests are put ahead of profits and not the other way around.
KorvisKhan · 1 points · Posted at 07:27:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Finally YSK that isn't something blatantly obvious 5hst everyone already knows
fuser_ · 1 points · Posted at 07:30:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In California negotiating "self pay" is nearly impossible given their reluctance to send to collections. There, they impose interest which accrues and again , non negotiable. So ya pretty much effed.
SoldierandSaint · 1 points · Posted at 07:33:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I went to the doctor in college with no insurance. After moving and missing the bill sent to my old apartment, they called me a year later saying they’d be willing to accept $25 before sending it to collections. The original visit was suppose to be $200.
geared4war · 1 points · Posted at 07:33:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You need and deserve more than just platinum. You deserve a real medal.
dbgprint · 1 points · Posted at 07:36:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Imagine having to do this
Johqnq · 1 points · Posted at 07:36:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can also try asking for Medicaid rates which is the lowest a provider will go.
sickoffacebookrn · 1 points · Posted at 07:39:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm curious about legality of balance billing. I had an anesthesia bill for $1600 that they called "balance billing" bc it was the remainder that I owed after my insurance paid their contracted amount. So the anesthesia provider got paid by my insurance and by me. And they would NOT work with us in any way. It went on for a year before we finally paid.
APrioriGoof · 1 points · Posted at 07:39:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Cursed thread
victorag96 · 1 points · Posted at 07:40:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The best method to have cheap healthcare in the US... is to move to a country with NHS
_Loup_Garou_ · 1 points · Posted at 07:41:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
r/bestof
RevvyDesu · 1 points · Posted at 07:42:55 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If I have recently been to a hospital and have started paying a bill, is it too late to negotiate?
dark_knight_rayleigh · 1 points · Posted at 07:44:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I’m saving this post. Will probably come back later and be like “help me pls.”
IsaacW122 · 1 points · Posted at 07:46:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And in the UK soon
UrbanSoot · 1 points · Posted at 07:46:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I have recently went to an ER for a really awful sciatica pain. My insurance didn’t cover it and I had to pay about $1,600 for the visit. The only thing the ER doctor do for me is prescribe oral steroids.
Is it possible to reduce bills like these?
TheWillRogers · 1 points · Posted at 07:47:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I got reffered to a oral surgeon that was out of network for a root canal while a tooth of my was abscessing. Aetna has told me twice now that "we'll call you back" when trying to get them to pay at least the in-network rate. Looks like i'll have to foot the $1,200 for the root canal :/
FarSpeed · 1 points · Posted at 07:52:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
bluemnm001 · 1 points · Posted at 07:55:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Isn't it easier and cheaper to just move to Canada or another first world country?
CloudyMN1979 · 1 points · Posted at 08:43:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wish.. Expatriating from America is nearly as difficult as getting citizenship. If you don't renounce your American citizenship entirely, uncle sam still charges you taxes.
bluemnm001 · 1 points · Posted at 08:44:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
ouch... that sucks :(
Mikkle80 · 1 points · Posted at 07:56:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Fuck all that. Just move or vote for a system not totally geared to fisting you as badly as possible
TheSeekerUnchained · 1 points · Posted at 08:00:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or come live in like every other first world country
summitrock · 1 points · Posted at 08:01:48 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
All this work and stress to lower bills will kill you too...
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:04:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I am confused what to do first.
scrtskwirel · 1 points · Posted at 08:06:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This'll probably get lost, but I'm really curious if this applies to dialysis as well? I've been on it for three years and am literally drowning in medical debt (probably half a million by now- my "share" is about 12k a month just for dialysis, so not including any surgeries or hospitalizations).
I've also been super confused on this one, I have private insurance and medicare because of ESRD. I had been referred to the access center, they did an ultrasound, found a blood clot, removed it from my chest, ballooned my fistula. Medicare denied all of it. Every. Single. Bit.
How is it that I am required to carry medicare as a secondary insurance (or primary now as I've completed my 30 month coordination of benefits) for this condition, but they are able to deny every claim filed directly related to said condition? They've denied paying a portion of my dialysis, flat out denied all procedures related to keeping my access viable, hospitalizations due to access issues, everything. So, just... what gives? What's the point of it?
bonafart · 1 points · Posted at 08:07:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Main point is you shouldn't need to be a masters in maths and analysis to go to hospital it should be free or paid for by the system you have by everyone so that when you need it it's there not if
ozcholo · 1 points · Posted at 08:08:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How to reduce medical bills in the US: find a way to unite the American people without politics. Overthrow government. Get Medicare.
Hilazing · 1 points · Posted at 08:10:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow! Reading this post and all the related comments makes me very thankful for the NHS we have in the UK. Any treatment I need - whether just a chat with a doctor or major surgery - costs me precisely nothing... Unless I need prescription medication, in which case it costs me about £8 (haven't used it in a while - can't remember the exact amount) for each prescription. People with chronic conditions don't even pay for prescriptions.
IuseWindows95 · 1 points · Posted at 08:10:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How to decrease your medical bills even more significantly:
Step 1. Dont be american
SeeSickCrocodile · 1 points · Posted at 08:13:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You should start an advice show on YouTube.
Goaskyourdad00 · 1 points · Posted at 08:14:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is extremely timely advice. I've been fighting a bill for a year because they told me it would be covered. Spoiler: It was not covered.
coffeebeard · 1 points · Posted at 08:15:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Stay away from doctors and die quickly.
lifehacks
randilicious14 · 1 points · Posted at 08:19:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I recently got some labs done (a blood test, a urine test, and a strep swab) and I was charged for 12 labs. Why does this happen and how do I fight it?
I also got an (ultra expensive) ultrasound and got very little information and no treatment.
My bills total in the thousands and I'm stuck here, not wanting to get more "care" because I can't afford it. Any advice would be very much appreciated.
Jetstreamisgone · 1 points · Posted at 08:20:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Everyone should stop paying their medical bills. Fuck for profit healthcare and insurance companies
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 08:20:09 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or just be so poor and neglected that you can never get medical care.
darkstriders · 1 points · Posted at 08:22:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I received a bill for over a thousand dollars for a simple allergy test for my daughter. The bill Is incorrect and I’ve been calling the hospital over and over for the last 2 months.
They kept saying someone will call me back or the supervisor is busy. But no one ever call me back. Yet, I kept receiving the bill demanding payment.
If they won’t even respond to me, what else could I do? It’s almost as if they one they can keep ignoring me and later send me to collection.
16semesters · 1 points · Posted at 08:27:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This isn't really good advice because extremely rarely is anyone doing time based billing. It's almost always going to be based on CPT code, which can be qualified regardless of how long it takes.
Your reimbursement numbers are also off considerably, a Physician or midlevel is bringing far more than that in an hour. Salary is not the same thing as reimbursement.
sonsingrua · 1 points · Posted at 08:33:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I appreciate your post; is there a similarly cheap way to visit a doctor for a check up? Can I just go and get a diagnosis then act surprised when my card gets declined or call and use your tips to negotiate down the bill? And if they discover an expensive disease does that mean I can't get insurance anymore?
I just turned 26 and I am in the wage-worker pool of unaffordable uninsurables. I don't want to die of something stupid and preventable because I never have enough disposable income for a doctor visit.
Thanks again!
IronGin · 1 points · Posted at 08:37:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Isn't it easier to vote in a person that isn't a total jerk about free medical healthcare?
scarypriest · 1 points · Posted at 08:46:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm ok, but thank you for doing this. I know this is a major issues with a lot of people.
Jungchida · 1 points · Posted at 09:04:38 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You better get a notorized affidavit declaring you would never consider suicide.
Trashy_Daddy · 1 points · Posted at 09:06:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Tldr:m4a
BAAM19 · 1 points · Posted at 09:06:59 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It seems that people are “free” to scam in the US.
Guntown_mountain · 1 points · Posted at 09:08:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you!!
NewPemmie · 1 points · Posted at 09:13:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
As a Brit this will come in very handy soon
scumRebel · 1 points · Posted at 09:22:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Quicker thing is get Cáncer a few times. 100% fee health insurance
Slednvrfed · 1 points · Posted at 09:28:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lmao I’m so behind on medical debt and it’s just all petty shit. H&R accounts calls me daily. Shits so stressful I just ignore it. Only like 3-6k atm but I have no idea how much now. All because I needed to get a sleep apnea machine. We need NHC so bad lol.
hedonisticathiest · 1 points · Posted at 09:32:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It sucks that your country has to look on reddit to get affordable healthcare, but good on you for putting this out here.
242proMorgan · 1 points · Posted at 09:33:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact that this exists is scary. Being in the UK I have no clue how everyone in the US isn't in crippling debt which I get most are but I mean literally everyone.
pleurial_gust0 · 1 points · Posted at 09:33:39 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Richest country in the world.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:35:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 1 points · Posted at 10:15:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
same. I think it's criminal to subject citizens to the daily stress of worrying constantly what life may randomly bring, when there are clearly valid options available to us that are just being shat upon by a small percentage of industry funded, loud lawmakers. How anyone can claim the US is the "greatest" anything is beyond me... like we've got everything figured out here.
thereverendpuck · 1 points · Posted at 09:41:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just this alone makes you a miracle worker and thank you for it.
ksande13 · 1 points · Posted at 09:53:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
PSA: follow these instructions if you want to rob Peter to pay Paul and continue to do so.
If you want to help the economy or do your part to fix our broken system, let me know.
ugh
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:57:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You are a an absolute hero
karguy91 · 1 points · Posted at 09:58:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you so much for doing this. Knowledge is power and the more you know and all that jazz. But really, thank you.
jmdugan · 1 points · Posted at 10:01:04 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
welp. time to kill them
corporation as broken machinery. disassemble, part out, repurpose
MiamiPower · 1 points · Posted at 10:04:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The should be the poster hanging up in health class. Hanging up in elementary middle school, high school universities and colleges campuses.
sp00dynewt · 1 points · Posted at 10:10:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance providers be out here slugging for the company lol It's an absolute shitshow
luxtabula · 1 points · Posted at 10:27:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The only way to permanently decrease medical bills in the United States is to finally end this corrupt casino we call our health system and adopt a system proven to work in every first world country. Your advice, though helpful, only means to extend the broken system rather than actually address the problem at hand.
JellyfishJellyfish · 1 points · Posted at 10:33:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I wish I would have known this before, or at least been able to try it. I ended up in the ER after an accident in a 3 month window I was not insured. I had just graduated college and had not started my job. I remember asking for an itemized bill and they charged me $200 for a dose of Tylenol, among other things. The full bill was thousands. I called numerous times and tried to talk it down, but the hospital wouldn't work with me, and did indeed send me to collections, because I did not live in that county. They suggested I get assistance where I lived, but I couldn't because I was single and without kids. If I had a kid they would have taken care of it. I ended up opening a credit card just to pay it off because they bullied me so much for not paying it all down fast enough.
Kam2Scuzzy · 1 points · Posted at 10:36:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We had a blood test done for a pregnancy (checks for defects with baby and gender reveal). The lab that did the testing has poor reviews.
Before the testing, we needed to find out if her insurance covered it. While waiting for confirmation, she gets an email from the company stating that they confirmed we were covered and it would only cost us $100. We took that at face value and went with the testing. Found out that no one contacted the insurance company, and they denied the claim by the lab. Now they want $10,000+. We asked the doctor about it, and they said they'd "take care of it". And was told they couldn't charge us more then $500 for the testing. Which is still 400 more then what we expected. We still have the email and a bill every month saying what we owe. Any advice?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 10:39:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
!remindme 1 week
45KA · 1 points · Posted at 10:41:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ill check this out.
pppjurac · 1 points · Posted at 10:41:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Have an upvote.
See, this is one of properties of what patriot is: Patriotism is not waving flag and singing patriotic songs but it is work, help and advice that is done selflessly for other people in country.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 10:42:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
USA healthcare is very unreasonable because it's cheaper if you don't get insurance.
ban_me_daddyy · 1 points · Posted at 10:48:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So you're telling me if I get in a car wreck and end up with a $200k bill from the emergency room I can get it down to 60-80k? Gee golly they are so swell for doing that :D maybe if I move back in with my parents I can save up all my paychecks for 3 years to pay it off.
rainwulf · 1 points · Posted at 10:53:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wow, america is so fucked up. I had a full blown ACL knee reconstruction, overnight stay in the hospital, got given 2 weeks worth of medical supplies, and hobbled out 24 hours later on the free crutches. Total cost was 16 dollars for parking, and the 8.95 for 6 days worth of Endone. (australian)
This was done in one of the best hospitals in Queensland too (Prince Charles).
Honestly, i could say (anywhere else in the world). Its only the USA that seems to hang onto this this bizarre fucked up system.
PookieBearTum · 1 points · Posted at 10:55:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
I asked for a self pay bill and was told because my shit insurance had already “been applied” there was no way to revert to self pay. So they found out I had insurance and refused to let me be self pay.
FugheddaboudaShrimp · 1 points · Posted at 10:56:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Remember that you can and vote for the presidential candidate who wants to make healthcare as good as free in the upcoming primaries and presidential election (Sanders).
TRanatza · 1 points · Posted at 11:30:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"free"... Another voter that doesn't know how any of this works. Your candidate is fixing the symptom and not the problem. When you tell these crooks that the government HAS to pay for medical you think they are going to LOWER there prices. This ends one of two ways, them charging 5k for 400mg of ibuprofen, or it's going to be a national VA where people are literally dying over the course of a year because of an untreated eye infection.
rajohns08 · 1 points · Posted at 10:57:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What if you have an HDHP before you meet your deductible? Do providers usually bill you the self-pay rate without you having to ask?
naJm- · 1 points · Posted at 11:03:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Probably varies depending on where you're from, but in the emergency department I work in (which is in a rural-ish city of 50k pop.) the midlevels and physicians make over twice those rates.
MNCPA · 1 points · Posted at 11:05:27 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This really depends on the healthcare provider. I guess these are averages which makes sense. Anecdotally, these are vastly underestimated for my employer.
Source: I'm also a healthcare analyst. Also, some of this is public information by the federal government.
n0obie · 1 points · Posted at 11:09:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Saving this post if the time ever comes. Thanks, OP!
FridaysonThursday · 1 points · Posted at 11:10:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Any experience with a non-US citizen who is uninsured? Do these tips still apply, or would it be treated differently?
lessfrictionless · 1 points · Posted at 11:12:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
If insurance only pays 2% of some medical expenses, it kinda sucks that they still charge astronomical premiums. Cause those premiums are based on kinda being a fraction of the super high 100% prices.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:12:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What about the cost of school to become an MD? YSK that student loans for new doctors can amount to half a million dollars.
TRanatza · 1 points · Posted at 11:23:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You're talking about the two most fucked up systems... Health care and college, both need a complete hard reset.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Agreed. But I think that the barrier to entry to the medical field (financially) should be lowered before the compensation is decreased because then new MD’s won’t be able to pay of the enormous debt. Decreasing the compensation for physicians first without addressing the cost of medical school in addition to other schooling will be disastrous for new physicians. Right now, for example, pediatricians make a baseline salary of around 100k. This is after 4 years of college, 4 years of medical school, and a minimum of 3 years of residency (resident physician salary is on average 50,000 a year and residents work 80+ hours a week) so it definitely needs to change
Lurkwurst · 1 points · Posted at 11:16:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
wish you didnt have to do this but you are doing god's work here. thank you
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:18:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Hey, guys... I have this idea. Let's make everyone buy insurance and call it "affordable" and tack on the words "health care" because we all know that affording insurance isn't the same as affording actual health care.
And what we get is a lot of people confusing the money side of it with the actual "care" part of it and then people scrabbling to defend insurance. Edit: Just like this guy and upvoters here
This is why I get tired of people talking about "omg, health care premiums and denial". NO. You're complaining about companies whose only way of making money is to deny you coverage for your care.
And those people going on about how making it affordable means that it's actually health care: NO. You're trying to drum up support for group of companies whose only way of making money is to deny coverage of a procedure.
Lynda73 · 1 points · Posted at 11:18:52 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Around here, it's 80% off without insurance.
bitcheslovereptar · 1 points · Posted at 11:19:16 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Techpaste · 1 points · Posted at 11:19:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The fact that this post even exists is horrifying. If you're not fighting for socialised medical care, you're off your heads. Please, America, the world follows you by example.
Justmerightnowtoday · 1 points · Posted at 11:21:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In France you wouldn't need all this inside information even if you had the 50 most deadly diseases in you and a broken arm.
Lets_not__ · 1 points · Posted at 11:22:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lol murrica
616mushroomcloud · 1 points · Posted at 11:27:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Move to the U.K
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:29:00 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I work in healthcare supply and this is false. Some items used cost thousands, even tens of thousands of dollars. Patients don't know that there are different brands of supplies and have zero control over this cost. It's entirely up to the discretion of the hospital to choose what they use, even if it costs 8x more than another perfectly acceptable brand.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:33:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
America, the place where you basically need to be an accountant to see if you can afford to not die and go to hospital.
shablagoo14 · 1 points · Posted at 11:35:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The hero we need
iamrhinoceros · 1 points · Posted at 11:36:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Wish I had seen this three years ago. We paid a $3k lab bill with a credit card during a one month period my husband (then bf) happened to not have insurance...
bananas21 · 1 points · Posted at 11:38:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What if you have s bill that's already gone to collections? Had a charge for nearly 600 for going to urgent care for 30 minutes.. I honestly had no clue about how to proceed with that and didn't manage to pay it off in time...
TonyMatter · 1 points · Posted at 11:39:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Seems US individuals have to fight this stuff personally each time. Why isn't there a 'Mutual society' where members can assign a single non-profit membership agency to get them the best deals, whether or not they're insured too? Many other countries have something similar, many such mutuals add 'cover' for things even mainstream insurers don't pay. In a few countries, the 'Mutuals' have taken over the whole reimbursement system, and developed cost-containment teeth of their own.
jwch20025013 · 1 points · Posted at 11:39:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
or just leave america to stop being scammed by the government
jujusisi · 1 points · Posted at 11:40:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You’re an awesome person for sharing your knowledge here !!
wisdom_power_courage · 1 points · Posted at 11:48:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What is your best recommendation for getting care for someone who doesn't have healthcare?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:51:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why do we have to do this at all when some of us are working the middle class workday plus evening? Why are we expected to sort out and correct for the failed medical insurance industry? These tips are great but it just makes me realize more we don't need to live like this
thenoelist329 · 1 points · Posted at 11:52:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
LPT: Travel to eastern european countries with your serious or semi-serious illnesses, even with the Luxury Accomodation, you’ll pay 10-20% of what you’d pay in the US.
Meattickler · 1 points · Posted at 11:55:46 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
So if you're an established patient insurance will pay less? Why is that?
Zelda_Mudkip · 1 points · Posted at 11:58:13 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
"Move out of the US"
Gbark10 · 1 points · Posted at 11:58:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Remember this
Jaba01 · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:14 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My tip: Leave the US.
aquadirect · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
This is important
Saintviscious · 1 points · Posted at 12:01:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
How do I save a post. This is awesome
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:12:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Man, the healthcare system in the US is fucked.
JameTrain · 1 points · Posted at 12:15:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Vote Bernie!
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 12:15:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most people just get insurance through their work and pay their deductible each year and nothing else
jaybercrow · 1 points · Posted at 12:15:57 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
PhaedraSky · 1 points · Posted at 12:18:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank you for this
Swagglette · 1 points · Posted at 12:30:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Will the self pay rate be the same if they know I don’t have insurance
Lawlsagna · 1 points · Posted at 14:33:11 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes. Providers that offer a self pay option do so to help patients without insurance. They know you can’t pay what they charge to insurance companies. There is no pay rate scale for patients that choose self pay with insurance vs people that choose self pay without. OP was just suggesting that people with insurance denials use the option available to people without insurance.
Swagglette · 1 points · Posted at 19:22:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Ahhh thank you
YumiRae · 1 points · Posted at 12:31:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I got a stat CT scan for intractable headache. My PCP is a clinic and they called the hospital and sent me over. I got a letter saying it was approved (after the fact) and then looked at my online summary of claims and it says partially denied. It says I get the "plan discount" ($40) but they won't pay anything else. What should I do?
NimishOjale · 1 points · Posted at 12:37:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why is this deleted? Does anything have access to the post?
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:35:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can someone fill me in on why this was deleted?
AHeroBlade · 1 points · Posted at 14:38:37 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What did they post? It’s deleted
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 14:40:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why did this get deleted?
CodeBreaker_666 · 1 points · Posted at 14:45:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why the hell is it deleted
Soviet_habibi_smurf · 1 points · Posted at 14:53:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Why was it deleted?
BeerIsTheMindSpiller · 1 points · Posted at 14:56:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What why was this deleted???
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 16:09:58 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Posting to record post
MellowG420 · 1 points · Posted at 23:49:56 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Commented, couldn’t upvote
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 18:26:37 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
waffleman911 · 1 points · Posted at 18:30:52 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Lmao for reallllll. I didn't have time read it and was going to when I have time (now) and op went and deleted all of it
Buzzkill_13 · 1 points · Posted at 08:59:58 on December 8, 2019 · (Permalink)
Well, I'd say with Universal Health Care, like in every single developed country. I'd even say that UHC is a hall mark and no country without it can be considered as 'developed'.
Badidzetai · 1 points · Posted at 09:45:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You can do that, or vote for the candidate that will make Medicare for All a reality
quick20minadventure · 1 points · Posted at 09:57:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Where's 'vote bernie' option?
arrezzo · 1 points · Posted at 09:42:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Thank God for the NHS.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 11:11:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yeah, I feel lucky as fuck to not have to pay a penny for this stuff.
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 09:49:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
dont get sick
Rooster_Ties · 1 points · Posted at 10:05:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
TIL
RedditModsBlowmen · 1 points · Posted at 11:48:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Reddit is gonna hate this post, they love bitching about the expensive healthcare bills they don’t actually have to pay
yjiro · 1 points · Posted at 12:32:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
who the fuck deleted this
insideoutpotato · 1 points · Posted at 13:27:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What the fuck where did this go I was about to send it to my friend who is having surgery this week!! Do any reddit wizards know how to get this back??
Mugnath · 4 points · Posted at 14:08:06 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
OP deleted because it appears to be innacurate information.
insideoutpotato · 2 points · Posted at 15:39:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Oh it’s not legit? Dang thanks for letting me know
[deleted] · 1 points · Posted at 13:28:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sort by new, it’s the third comment
klinch3R · 1 points · Posted at 13:34:21 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Rofl it got deleted the second i opened it... Hmm i live in Europe anyways 🤷
blazer243 · 0 points · Posted at 05:08:18 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Read this to my wife, billing manager. Had to pause several times for her laughter to subside so I could continue.
nsetser · 0 points · Posted at 05:27:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or just don't pay...
devilwarier9 · 0 points · Posted at 11:51:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Alternatively, stop being a dumb American and voting regards into office.
music3k · -4 points · Posted at 09:43:17 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Step 10: Vote Democrat.
StormalongJuan · 2 points · Posted at 10:26:25 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
not any blue will do. only one of the presidential candidates is serious about fixing this. House and senate democrats made chuck and Nancy their leaders, and they are not serious about fixing this.
step one is vote in the democratic primaries for progressive candidates that don't take bribe money from big money interests or oligarchs.
OMightyBuggy · -1 points · Posted at 10:54:36 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie.
Edit: Vote
MobiusCube · 1 points · Posted at 12:16:02 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Bernie plans to make private insurance illegal. Idk how a monopoly will fix anything.
OMightyBuggy · 1 points · Posted at 18:32:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Can’t have a monopoly without insurance altogether. Better than our duopoly in most places.
MobiusCube · 1 points · Posted at 18:36:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
In what world is a monopoly good for consumers?
OMightyBuggy · 1 points · Posted at 18:43:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
We have to try something else now. We keep trying the same things expecting different results. That IS crazy. Trying something new might have an okay outcome. We never know unless we try.
MobiusCube · 1 points · Posted at 19:01:44 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
The issue is people thinking it's the government's role to provide healthcare. Get the government out of my doctor's office.
OMightyBuggy · 2 points · Posted at 20:58:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I rather have the taxes I pay go to healthcare than military. 70billion could help here better than any future defense especially since our future wars are online now. It is true that the government needs to step out of health care as I can’t even get help with chronic pain. I had to get my medical marijuana card to help with that. We the people should try to help people more.
MobiusCube · 1 points · Posted at 23:02:50 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Sure, but forcing people to "help" under threat of violence isn't actually helping.
jdangel83 · -7 points · Posted at 04:40:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
My wife broke a bone in her foot a while back that required surgery. I have excellent health insurance on my family. They did the surgery and sent me a bill for a little over a million dollars. Yup. I went up to the hospital and told the doctor she was fucking retarded and handed her the bill back. I never paid a dime out of pocket besides the copays for office visits. Who knows what my insurance paid. It's been about a year and I've not gotten any notices about not paying. I won't pay any of it.
DeejayeB · 8 points · Posted at 04:58:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just because you have insurance doesn't mean you have great benefits. Sucks you would hand a physician who saved your family member's foot and tell her she is "retarted," also pretty lame to use that word in general. I can tell you based on your post that you are the exact kind of patient that make physicians want to quit medicine and commit suicide.
ryan_in_la · 7 points · Posted at 05:13:40 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Most doctors have no idea how much the hospitals are charging patients. Often, they're even different organizations -- a provider group and the hospital. If you got a $1m bill for foot surgery, then absolutely talk to the doctor about it. The doc knows it's a racket with the insurance, but they have no idea how much the bill is, if the insurance paid it, or what the impact is on the patient. If it takes getting upset to prevent a bill from ruining your life, then so be it. (BTW, I work in healthcare. I don't want you at my clinic yelling at the front desk, but if you get a $1m bill, I'll understand.)
swapsrox · 3 points · Posted at 06:21:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Who is charging a million for orthopedic surgery?
jdangel83 · 1 points · Posted at 20:53:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
A private practice in Houston...
youngandfit2000 · 1 points · Posted at 12:10:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No one. It’s a made up story.
jdangel83 · 1 points · Posted at 20:53:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No it's not. Fuck off.
youngandfit2000 · 1 points · Posted at 00:54:54 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Yes it fucking is. Fuck off.
jdangel83 · 1 points · Posted at 20:52:47 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
There was a bill from the hospital, the anesthesiologist and another one from the doctor's private practice. The one from the doctor was the outrageous one. She had us go to a hospital to do the surgery. I went to her office and spoke with her in person, not the receptionist. And I didn't yell.
jdangel83 · 0 points · Posted at 20:49:03 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Jesus h christ. I do have great benefits. I saw the "amount you may owe" letter, insurance apparently covered it. And fuck you, it's just a word. I would never call a disabled person that, you call someone retarded when they're being fucking retarded. It has nothing to do with a disability. Stop getting offended over fucking words. And I doubt very seriously that any doctor that made it through med school and residency would have skin so thin that they would want to commit suicide. Stop projecting your weaknesses onto other people. "I can tell you that based on your post you're a whiny little pussy that gets offended about everything."
DeejayeB · 1 points · Posted at 21:02:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Confirmed, you are the patient we all hate
jdangel83 · 1 points · Posted at 22:14:32 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
😉
exh78 · 0 points · Posted at 08:34:51 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Dang reading through all this kinda makes me glad I haven’t had health insurance in years... sounds like a nightmare and a money pit
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 10:38:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
OMightyBuggy · 2 points · Posted at 10:52:42 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Truth.
slipko · 1 points · Posted at 10:51:43 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Newsflash: the affordable healthcare act was improperly named.
TheBaltimoron · 0 points · Posted at 11:21:24 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
And I'm out. Limping out, but still...
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 11:35:29 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
[deleted] · 2 points · Posted at 12:12:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Call your insurance company and ask for the credentials of the people that are denying your service.
Artcat58 · 2 points · Posted at 00:03:28 on December 5, 2019 · (Permalink)
Specifically, ask if the person denying the claim is a doctor. Do you want a Jr Executive denying your appendectomy? Only a doctor can decide what treatment is medically necessary. If its still denied ask for a peer review. Your doctor discussing your treatment with the Insurance companies doctor. That works many times if you're able to get an actual doctor on the phone from the insurance company.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:08:34 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
It's also good to know that the bactrim antibiotics you can get for a horse at a local co-op (or whatever they call farmer stores where you live) with no prescription, is the same exact bactrim antibiotics you get from the doctor with a prescription.
[deleted] · 0 points · Posted at 12:13:01 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or you could demand your government just fix your totally fucked health care system...
But that would mean your politicians would have to enact legislation that is detrimental to their primary sources of income which will never happen.
Bottom line... If your in 'merica and get sick, your fucked.
Your a sick fuck
Elvis_Take_The_Wheel · 0 points · Posted at 12:16:41 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Saving this comment. As someone who struggled tremendously in the past with medical debt from this f’ed up healthcare system, I am so thankful for your kindness in reaching out to help others going through the same thing. Bless you, friend.
michigan_redittor · 0 points · Posted at 12:30:10 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
😳 thank you
Wet_Pillow · 0 points · Posted at 12:38:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
RIP to OP. Any conspiracy theorist out there?
[deleted] · -2 points · Posted at 08:45:30 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
[deleted]
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 1 points · Posted at 10:38:23 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
uh, *eat.
and no, don't kill people. jesus dude, no.
ComplainyGuy · 1 points · Posted at 11:13:07 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Just kill Murdoch and other media owners. Nothing drastic. It's their propaganda keeping corruption from the eyes of uneducated citizens.
InspiringMilk · 2 points · Posted at 11:43:45 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Or don't kill anyone?
ComplainyGuy · 1 points · Posted at 13:38:33 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No it's ok we can kill Rupert Murdoch.
SHUTxxYOxxFACE · 1 points · Posted at 14:40:15 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I'm in the "It's not cool to kill people" camp with you.
[deleted] · -4 points · Posted at 07:49:49 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)*
[deleted]
SmokinGrunts · 1 points · Posted at 11:14:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
selfish. not a team-player attitude
bigboiharrison · -1 points · Posted at 08:29:35 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No. 10: Vote liberal
ComplainyGuy · 1 points · Posted at 11:08:08 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
I don't think you understand what liberal means
CloudyMN1979 · 1 points · Posted at 08:34:26 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Vote progressive.
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 12:18:12 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
You should honestly start a company where I pay $40 for you to tell me/us how to fight a medical bill. We show you bills and our finances and you tell us who to call for what or what to do/not to do
[deleted] · -1 points · Posted at 12:27:28 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
No questions yet, but I think you should know how incredibly helpful and selfless it is to post an answer like this and offer to assist people.
Thank you!
Malinut · -1 points · Posted at 12:58:31 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
For comparison: How to reduced medical bills in the UK significantly:- (It's topical in the UK right now.)
See a doctor promptly.
Don't miss appointments.
Don't waste prescriptions and make sure you take what you've been prescribed.
See a pharmacist for minor ailments.
Go to a minor injuries unit rather than A&E if you can.
Get vaccinated. Get your children vaccinated.
Don't mess about with antibiotics.
Don't smoke.
Don't drink too much.
Don't eat too much and avoid sugar.
Take at least some moderate exercise once or twice a week, like a good walk.
...Just these (and there's more) will save the NHS £Billions.
TrikkyMakk · -2 points · Posted at 12:30:54 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Insurance is like this because of govt. Stop calling for govt to fix govt. The real fix is to remove govt from healthcare.
Vanderpewt · -9 points · Posted at 07:27:20 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
What you really should know is just get rid of Obamacare - its a continuous high-value raping for everyone who buys insurance.
Obamacare hiked participating Americans a minimum of 800% more now than when Obamacare took over.
Prior Obamacare, premiums went up 3%-8% per year. Obamacare averages over 100% per year. That's right PER year.
TMYK
APrioriGoof · 8 points · Posted at 07:38:53 on December 4, 2019 · (Permalink)
Better yet, vote for people who want to eliminate private insurance companies so that all of America can be part of one risk pool. The shit in this thread is absolutely insane and the only real solution is Medicare for all.