[MCPE-8101] Oak trees do not replace grass with dirt

Giant oak trees do not replace the grass blocks they are spawned on with dirt.
Tested in creative and survival with saplings grown both with and without bonemeal, and with naturally grown trees.

Linked Issues

relates to4

MCPE-7848Grass does not grow on dirt under fences or cobblestone wallsFixed

MCPE-26215Coarse dirt reverts to regular dirt after a tree is grown on itFixed

MCPE-126849Growing trees other than spruce on moss block will turn the moss block to dirtConfirmed

MCPE-20944Trees Can Generate on Incorrect BlocksCannot Reproduce

Attachments4

B6921869-598E-4084-AC00-383B45B700D5.png

george Lafeen

2022-07-16, 12:56:36 AM

image.jpg

Katten

2015-03-23, 08:16:46 PM

image-2024-08-15-01-07-56-543.png

[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO

2024-08-14, 10:07:57 PM

screenshot-1.png

[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO

2024-08-14, 10:07:35 PM

Comments30

AMAN4700 2015-03-23, 10:47:41 PM

Confirmed on Samsung Galaxy Note 3

migrated 2015-03-23, 11:38:46 PM

Restricted to secret

e041f7c9-eb8a-4e40-b714-71ce3fbe0bdf

Kumasasa 2015-03-24, 06:38:46 AM

Restricted to global-moderators

@AMAN4700: Please set CHK to the current date when you confirm a ticket (for any confirmation than "Unconfirmed").
That field means "This ticket was handled / updated by a mod" and hides this ticket from various filters.

Michael Tan 2015-03-25, 05:51:09 PM

Confirmed on IOS 8.2, ipad 3

rplatham 2016-05-12, 09:19:26 PM

confirmed on Samsung Galaxy S6 (SM-G920W8), Android 5.1.1, MCPE 0.14.2

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) 2016-05-23, 08:55:05 AM

edited 2016-06-28, 06:54:02 AM

~~Fixed in 0.14.3~~

I mistakenly read the description as dark oak trees, sorry! This does still affect Giant Oaks..

kaleb418 2016-05-23, 10:19:45 PM

@Mega_Spud Ahh...missed it.

kaleb418 2016-05-23, 10:20:42 PM

Please comment below if you still experience this issue on 0.14.3, or any other later versions.

kaleb418 2016-05-23, 11:08:38 PM

Reopening via confirmation from AMAN4700.

Zeb 2016-06-14, 01:33:42 AM

Confirmed for 0.15.0. (Using Windows 10.)

Zeb 2016-06-28, 01:18:16 AM

edited 2016-06-28, 01:20:05 AM

Affects 0.15.1. (Tested on Windows 10.)

Zeb 2016-08-11, 06:15:16 PM

Confirmed for 0.15.6. (Tested on Windows 10.)

rplatham 2016-09-13, 04:12:35 PM

Reconfirmed on Samsung Galaxy S6 (SM-G920W8), Android 6.0.1 MCPE 0.15.90.2

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-10-13, 02:55:30 AM

Restricted to secret

02d28ae6-d6ab-47be-b58e-bb27087f3061

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-10-13, 09:55:30 AM

Restricted to staff

Reported to VSO: 36224

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-10-13, 09:55:36 AM

This bug has been reported to our internal bug tracker for further testing and a fix. It is scheduled to be fixed in one of the future updates (no specific date can be provided).

Connor Steppie 2018-03-08, 11:13:11 AM

Confirmed on 1.2.10

[Mod] GoldenHelmet 2020-02-27, 10:28:33 PM

edited 2020-02-28, 02:33:32 PM

~~Tested in 1.14.30 and confirmed was fixed at some point.~~

Nevermind, it's not fixed. It appears that one giant tree variant does convert grass to dirt, or maybe it was just coincidental the first time I tested. With more testing, many oak tree forms did not convert grass to dirt, including one that was just a 5-block trunk with no branches.