[MCPE-7979] Bonemeal-ing any flower gives you the generic dandelion and poppy flower

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable (limited resource within a limited space) with the exception of the ploppy and dandelion.
To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower.

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

Update by [Mojang] Adrian Östergård
This bug has been reported to our internal bug tracker for further testing and a fix. It is scheduled to be fixed in one of the future updates (no specific date can be provided).
Please avoid duplicated comments. Post only NEW information regarding this bug.

Linked Issues

is duplicated by1

MCPE-16034Bonemealing flowers only spawn dandelions or ploppiesDuplicate

relates to5

MCPE-7537BONE MEAL - MUSROOMSCannot Reproduce

MCPE-7735Bugs for Bone MealInvalid

MCPE-7778Bone meal with MushroomsFixed

MCPE-7801Bone meal doesn't generate flowers which added in PE 0.9.0Invalid

MCPE-13304Double Flower Duplication BugFixed

Attachments1

generic_flowers_.jpg

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)

2018-04-26, 04:35:07 PM

Comments18

rplatham 2015-02-25, 09:00:52 PM

Confirmed on Samsung Galaxy S4 Android 4.4.2 running MCPE 0.10.5; however, the bug report needs revision to clarify if this is an iOS specific problem. Brian, please provide more details if you believe you observe different results on your iOS device.

I tested the following under Android 4.4.2 in a creative flat world:

Applying bonemeal to a grass block will yield some combination of small (1 block tall) grasses, small (1 block tall) ferns, poppies and/or dandelions on nearby/adjacent grass blocks. I would expect other types of vegetation to appear with some non-zero frequency that is dependent on the biome you are in.

Applying bonemeal to poppy yields only more poppies, as expected.
Applying bonemeal to dandelions yields only more dandelions, as expected.
Applying bonemeal to small grass turns it into a large (2 tall) grass, as expected.
Applying bonemeal to small fern turns it into a large (2 tall) fern, as expected.

Applying bonemeal to any other 1 tall flower left that flower the same as it was and created some poppies and sometimes some dandelions too. This was not expected and is likely a bug. I expected the bonemeal to produce more of the same flower that was being bonemealed and maybe some 1 tall grasses and/or ferns.

Applying bonemeal to any 2 tall vegetation does nothing. I expected the bonemeal to produce more of the same 2 tall vegetation that was being bonemealed and/or some of the 1 tall version of that vegetation if it exists (e.g. bonemealing 2 tall grass creates some new 1 tall grass around it)

Applying bonemeal to any brown mushroom creates a brown mushroom tree (if there's enough space around it to do so) as expected. If there isn't enough space, then nothing happens. Perhaps some more small brown mushrooms should appear?

Applying bonemeal to any red mushroom did nothing. I expected it to act the same as a brown mushroom.

Related Bugs:
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-7947 You cannot bonemeal 2 high plants
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-7801 Bone meal doesn't generate flowers which added in PE 0.9.0
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-7778 Bone meal with Mushrooms
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-7735 Bugs for Bone Meal
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-7537 BONE MEAL - MUSROOMS

AMAN4700 2015-05-17, 05:03:37 PM

Confirmed on Samsung Galaxy Note 3. Android 5.0
Build 10

Luis Robles 2015-10-20, 04:54:03 PM

Does this bug still appear in 0.12.2? If so please respond.

Katten 2015-10-20, 05:17:33 PM

Confirmed to affect 0.12.2 on iPhone 6 Plus (iOS 9.0.2).

Katten 2016-02-25, 05:11:56 PM

Confirmed to affect 0.14.0 on iPhone 6+ (iOS 9.2.1).

rplatham 2016-05-12, 04:20:49 PM

Restricted to Moderators

We should clean this bug report up since what is happening has changed. Bonemealing 2 tall flowers now produces a copy of that flower as an item. Bonemealing grass in creative flat always gives small red white and yellow flowers with grass. I haven't checked what it does in other biomes, maybe that's where other flowers generate? Also, bonemealing specific plants/flowers might generate other plants/flowers. Let's see if we can be more specific.

rplatham 2016-05-13, 12:08:26 AM

This is potentially fixed. For example, in swamp biomes, bonemealing grass gives different flowers (predominately blue orchids). I've tried a few other biomes and most give some combination of dandelions, poppies, azure bluets and oxeye daisys.

Zeb 2016-06-14, 03:59:06 AM

Confirmed for 0.15.0 on Windows 10. Right-clicking any one-block-tall flower (except dandelions) with bonemeal will cause several poppies to generate, and/or occasionally dandelions. Bonemealing dandelions causes predominantly dandelions to generate, with occasional poppies. But that's it. It's always poppies and dandelions that generate when you bonemeal one-tall plants. Bonemealing grass blocks, tall grass, double tall plants, and mushrooms all seem to work fine, though.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) 2016-06-17, 11:15:11 AM

edited 2016-06-17, 11:15:30 AM

Confirmed on 0.15.1 B1 Applying bonemeal to any one-high flower will only grow poppies and dandelions.

Zeb 2016-06-28, 03:36:56 AM

Affects 0.15.1 (Tested on Windows 10.)

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:39:43 AM

Confirmed on Windows 10 Edition. Version: 0.15.4

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:29:41 AM

Restricted to staff

Reported to VSO: 31428

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:29:47 AM

This bug has been reported to our internal bug tracker for further testing and a fix. It is scheduled to be fixed in one of the future updates (no specific date can be provided).

[MCPE Helper] Aspergerian 2016-11-18, 04:57:28 PM

Affects 1.0 Beta Build 2.

[MCPE Helper] Aspergerian 2017-03-03, 11:13:56 AM

Affects 1.0.4.1.

[MCPE Helper] Aspergerian 2017-03-11, 05:21:58 AM

Affects 1.0.4.11.

[MCPE Helper] Aspergerian 2017-03-16, 07:31:29 PM

Affects 1.0.5.3.

Insane96MCP 2017-07-20, 10:31:13 PM

Can confirm for 1.1.4

History76

Brian Green 2015-02-22, 01:33:25 AM

Changed description:

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable with the exception of the ploppy.
0To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower. On 2 block plants, nothing happens

Brian Green 2015-02-25, 02:30:10 AM

Added labels: bugs block minecraft glitch bug

Removed labels:

Brian Green 2015-03-14, 05:11:08 AM

Changed description:

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable with the exception of the ploppy and dandelion.
0To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower. On 2 block plants, nothing happens

Brian Green 2015-03-14, 05:11:53 AM

Changed summary:
Bonemeal-ing any flower gives you the generic dandelion and ploppy flower

Brian Green 2015-03-14, 05:13:50 AM

Changed description:

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable$(unlimited resource within a limited space)$ with the exception of the ploppy and dandelion.
0To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower. On 2 block plants, nothing happens

Brian Green 2015-03-14, 05:14:09 AM

Changed description:

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable (unlimited resource within a limited space) with the exception of the ploppy and dandelion.
0To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower. On 2 block plants, nothing happens

Brian Green 2015-03-14, 05:14:39 AM

Changed description:

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-7947You cannot bonemeal 2 high plantsFixed

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-7801Bone meal doesn't generate flowers which added in PE 0.9.0Invalid

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-7778Bone meal with MushroomsFixed

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-7735Bugs for Bone MealInvalid

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-7537BONE MEAL - MUSROOMSCannot Reproduce

rplatham 2015-03-20, 03:30:43 PM

Confirmation Status: Unconfirmed → Confirmed

rplatham 2015-03-31, 08:21:46 PM

Added Assignee: Daniel Wustenhoff

rplatham 2015-03-31, 08:23:05 PM

Added duplicates link:
MCPE-7947You cannot bonemeal 2 high plantsFixed

rplatham 2015-03-31, 08:23:34 PM

Removed relates to link:
MCPE-7947You cannot bonemeal 2 high plantsFixed

Deleted account 2015-05-02, 07:46:34 PM

Removed labels: glitch bug

Deleted account 2015-05-03, 03:21:00 AM

Removed labels: minecraft bugs

AMAN4700 2015-05-17, 05:03:44 PM

Added affects versions: 0.11.0 Beta 10

Katten 2015-06-18, 08:03:47 PM

Added affects versions: 0.11.1

AMAN4700 2015-08-02, 10:26:14 PM

Added affects versions: 0.12.1 Pre-release 0.12.1 Beta 2 0.12.1 Beta 3

AMAN4700 2015-09-09, 03:34:03 AM

Added affects versions: 0.12.1 Beta 5 0.12.1 Beta 4 0.12.1 Beta 1 0.12.1 Beta 13 0.12.1 Beta 12 0.12.1 Beta 11 0.12.1 Beta 10 0.12.1 Beta 9 0.12.1 Beta 8 0.12.1 Beta 7 0.12.1 Beta 6

AMAN4700 2015-09-11, 01:28:15 AM

Added affects versions: 0.12.1

AMAN4700 2015-09-14, 12:00:07 AM

Added affects versions: 0.12.1 Win10

rplatham 2015-10-05, 08:06:03 PM

Added labels: awaiting_confirmation

Katten 2015-10-20, 05:16:14 PM

Added affects versions: 0.12.2

Katten 2015-10-20, 05:16:17 PM

Added labels:

Removed labels: block awaiting_confirmation

Katten 2015-10-20, 05:19:40 PM

Removed duplicates link:
MCPE-7947You cannot bonemeal 2 high plantsFixed

Katten 2015-10-20, 05:20:18 PM

Changed description:

This bug makes every flower nonrenewable (limited resource within a limited space) with the exception of the ploppy and dandelion.
0To Reproduce, pick any flower except the ploppy then bonemeal the flower. On 2 block plants, nothing happens

AMAN4700 2015-11-03, 03:56:36 AM

Resolution: Unresolved → Fixed

Added affects versions: 0.13.0 Beta 1

Katten 2016-02-25, 05:11:56 PM

Resolution: Fixed → Unresolved

Katten 2016-02-25, 05:12:03 PM

Added affects versions: 0.14.0

gatharian 2016-04-04, 08:55:44 AM

Added relates to link:
MCPE-13304Double Flower Duplication BugFixed

Katten 2016-04-13, 03:02:56 PM

Added affects versions: 0.14.1

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) 2016-06-17, 11:15:22 AM

Added affects versions: 0.15.1 Beta 1

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) 2016-06-28, 10:00:26 AM

Added affects versions: 0.15.1

kaleb418 2016-07-02, 11:26:52 PM

Added is duplicated by link:
MCPE-16034Bonemealing flowers only spawn dandelions or ploppiesDuplicate

kaleb418 2016-07-02, 11:27:48 PM

Added affects versions: 0.15.0

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:38:40 AM

Resolution: Unresolved → Cannot Reproduce

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:39:29 AM

Deleted comment:

Cannot Confirm on Windows 10 Edition. Version: 0.15.4

If another mod can find this or you can, please comment.

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:39:33 AM

Resolution: Cannot Reproduce → Unresolved

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:39:49 AM

Added affects versions: 0.15.4

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:40:09 AM

Changed description:

AMAN4700 2016-08-08, 04:40:41 AM

Changed description:

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 10:39:22 AM

Added affects versions: 0.15.7

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 10:45:22 AM

Added affects versions: 0.15.90.2

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:25:18 AM

Changed summary:
Bonemeal-ing any flower gives you the generic dandelion and ploppy flower

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:35:06 AM

Changed description:

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

Update by

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:35:24 AM

Changed description:

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

Update by

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

Update by [Mojang] Adrian Östergård
0This bug has been reported to our internal bug tracker for further testing and a fix. It is scheduled to be fixed in one of the future updates (no specific date can be provided).
0Please, avoid duplicated comments. Post only NEW information regarding this bug.

[Mojang] Adrian Östergård 2016-09-13, 11:36:20 AM

Changed description:

[MCPE Mod] AMAN4700: You must bonemeal an existing flower for this to work.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) 2016-11-04, 12:53:31 PM

Added affects versions: 0.16.0

Zeb 2016-11-05, 08:30:18 PM

Added labels: flower

Removed labels:

Added affects versions: 0.16.1

Zeb 2016-11-17, 11:12:48 PM

VSO

Added affects versions: 0.17.0.1