Emote buttons don't match what is 'emoted'

When doing emotes, if I click B, I should do the 'Victory Cartwheel' emote, but instead I do the 'Chicken Fly' emote instead.

When I click A, I should do the 'Chicken Fly' emote, but instead, I do the 'Victory Cartwheel' emote.

Buttons are pressed in this order: B - A