Can't select or delete profile

I created a profile after the update to play 1.9.4 then deleted it. Then I created another profile for 1.9.4 and noticed there were 2 of them. I tried to delete the extra one but nothing happened. I could delete one of them though. When I try to select the glitched profile it does nothing.

I'm not sure if the first 1.9.4 profile I created is the one that glitched or if my mouse (which is kinda broken) double clicked "save" super fast and created the glitched profile.