Black screen when joining world with fboEnable:false in options.txt

When I join a world, my screen turns black. When I hit escape, I can click till I hit the 'save and quit' button and I'm taken back to the main menu.

Update: It occurs with VBOs on and off. Sometimes I can see the world for a second before the screen goes black; other times, it is instantaneous.

Update 2: Updated to the Windows 10 Nvidia driver 353.62, no change.

Update 3: Added a video