Asterisks can't use selector arguments

Asterisks function differently than regular selectors. If you attempt to use arguments after the asterisk, the game will simply read them as part of the player name.

To replicate, create a scoreboard objective called "test". Set your value in that objective to 1. Then type

scoreboard players reset *[score_test=1]

It will reset the scores of the player "*[score_test=1]". Your score will not be reset.