MC-64416Wrong matched block names / missing distinction between block names
The bug
Some blocks use as name the translation of another block. This is pretty confusing for tools with the CanPlaceOn or CanDestroy tag or when using the /testforblock command.
Affected blocks
Probably outdated
| Block ID | Translation used |
|---|---|
| sapling | tile.sapling.oak.name ("Oak Sapling") |
| flowing_water | water ("Water") |
| flowing_lava | lava ("Lava") |
| piston_head | pistonBase ("Piston") |
| piston_extension | null ("tile.null.name")1 |
| daylight_detector_inverted | daylightDetector ("Daylight Sensor") |
| brown_mushroom | mushroom ("Mushroom") |
| red_mushroom | mushroom ("Mushroom") |
| brown_mushroom_block | mushroom ("Mushroom") |
| red_mushroom_block | mushroom ("Mushroom") |
| double_stone_slab | stoneSlab ("Stone Slab") |
| double_stone_slab2 | stoneSlab2 ("Stone Slab") |
| double_wooden_slab | woodSlab ("Wood Slab") |
| lit_furnace | furnace ("Furnace") |
| lit_redstone_lamp | redstoneLight ("Redstone Lamp") |
| lit_redstone_ore | oreRedstone ("Redstone Ore") |
| standing_sign | sign ("Sign") |
| wall_sign | sign ("Sign") |
| unlit_redstone_torch | notGate ("Redstone Torch") |
| stone_button | button ("Button") |
| snow_layer | snow ("Snow") |
| powered_repeater | diode ("Redstone Repeater") |
| melon_stem | pumkinStem ("Pumpkin Stem")2 |
| end_portal | null ("tile.null.name")1 |
| wooden_button | button ("Button") |
| powered_comparator | comparator ("Redstone Comparator") |
| leaves2 | leaves ("Leaves")3 |
| log2 | log ("Wood")3 |
| standing_banner | item.banner.white.name ("White Banner")4 |
| wall_banner | item.banner.white.name ("White Banner")4 |
| kelp_top | "Kelp" |
1 End portals and Piston Extensions look for tile.null.name, rather then tile.endPortal.name and tile.pistonExtension.name
2 Currently only a translation for tile.pumpkinStem.name exists, see MC-64455
3 A name like "... Variant 2" would be possible
4 Banners seem to use the item translation which would be wrong because the banner could have any color
Bad choosen names
| Block ID | Block name |
|---|---|
| double_plant | "Plant" |
| tallgrass | "Grass" |
| stone_slab2 | "Red Standstone Slab"5 |
5 Assuming that other stone slabs could be added in the future the name "Stone Slab Variant 2" would fit better
How to reproduce
To reproduce you can either create an item with the CanPlaceOn or CanDestroy tag or you can use the /testforblock command:
CanPlaceOn / CanDestroy
/give @p stone 1 0 {CanPlaceOn:["melon_stem"]}
/testforblock
/testforblock ~ ~ ~ melon_stem
2014-07-30, 07:15 PM
2018-04-26, 12:26 AM
2018-04-26, 12:26 AM
6
3
CanDestroy, CanPlaceOn, display-Name, translation
Minecraft 14w30c - Minecraft 18w07a
Minecraft 14w30c, Minecraft 14w31a, Minecraft 1.8-pre2, Minecraft 15w45a, Minecraft 15w51b, Minecraft 16w02a, Minecraft 1.9 Pre-Release 1, Minecraft 1.9, Minecraft 1.9.1 Pre-Release 1, Minecraft 1.9.1 Pre-Release 2, Minecraft 16w44a, Minecraft 1.11, Minecraft 1.11.2, Minecraft 18w07a