Mojira Archive
MC-277469

Unlit torches on repeaters and comparators are still not mapped correctly

The bug

When converting redstone repeaters and comparators to the block model system in 1.8, the torches were initially incorrectly defined as simple cuboids, causing MC-50242. This was fixed in the next snapshot for lit torches, but has persisted to the modern day in the case of unlit torches.

How to reproduce

A resource pack that turns unlit redstone torches blue is attached to this ticket.

  1. Download this resource pack
  2. Load up any version from 1.6 to 1.7.10 and apply this resource pack
  3. Observe how unpowered redstone repeaters and comparators look
  4. Apply the same resource pack to 1.21.2
  5. Compare how the torches look

Expected results

The way the unpowered torches look would be the same as in 1.7.10 and earlier.

Actual results

It is not.

How to fix

Also attached to this report is a resource pack that fixes the affected repeater and comparator models. Applying both resource packs simultaneously returns the correct, pre-1.8 look. I give Mojang full permission to use these models to fix this issue.

Further notes

For 1.21.2 onwards this fix should only touch the Programmer Art resource pack.

Unresolved

Connor Steppie

2024-10-10, 06:04 AM

2024-10-11, 08:52 AM

0

0

Community Consensus

(Unassigned)

1.21.1, 1.21.2 Pre-Release 1

-