MC-258689Wall signs, torches and skulls/heads no longer use wall variant translation keys since 18w02a
Between 17w47a and 18w01a (inclusive), wall signs, torches and skulls/heads used the translation key "block.minecraft.<wall id>", now they use "block.minecraft.<standing id>".
Steps to reproduce:
Replace <standing id> and <wall id> with the values matching the below table.
/give @s minecraft:diamond_axe[minecraft:can_break={blocks:["minecraft:oak_sign","minecraft:oak_wall_sign"]}]- Observe how the 2 match.
/tellraw @s [{"translate":"block.minecraft.<standing id>"},"\n",{"translate":"block.minecraft.<wall id>"}]- Observe how a different string is printed for the wall block.
| Block | Standing ID | Wall ID |
|---|---|---|
| Oak Sign | oak_sign | oak_wall_sign |
| Spruce Sign | spruce_sign | spruce_wall_sign |
| Birch Sign | birch_sign | birch_wall_sign |
| Jungle Sign | jungle_sign | jungle_wall_sign |
| Acacia Sign | acacia_sign | acacia_wall_sign |
| Dark Oak Sign | dark_oak_sign | dark_oak_wall_sign |
| Mangrove Sign | mangrove_sign | mangrove_wall_sign |
| Cherry Sign | cherry_sign | cherry_wall_sign |
| Bamboo Sign | bamboo_sign | bamboo_wall_sign |
| Crimson Sign | crimson_sign | crimson_wall_sign |
| Warped Sign | warped_sign | warped_wall_sign |
| Oak Hanging Sign | oak_hanging_sign | oak_wall_hanging_sign |
| Spruce Hanging Sign | spruce_hanging_sign | spruce_wall_hanging_sign |
| Birch Hanging Sign | birch_hanging_sign | birch_wall_hanging_sign |
| Jungle Hanging Sign | jungle_hanging_sign | jungle_wall_hanging_sign |
| Acacia Hanging Sign | acacia_hanging_sign | acacia_wall_hanging_sign |
| Dark Oak Hanging Sign | dark_oak_hanging_sign | dark_oak_wall_hanging_sign |
| Mangrove Hanging Sign | mangrove_hanging_sign | mangrove_wall_hanging_sign |
| Cherry Hanging Sign | cherry_hanging_sign | cherry_wall_hanging_sign |
| Bamboo Hanging Sign | bamboo_hanging_sign | bamboo_wall_hanging_sign |
| Crimson Hanging Sign | crimson_hanging_sign | crimson_wall_hanging_sign |
| Warped Hanging Sign | warped_hanging_sign | warped_wall_hanging_sign |
| Torch | torch | wall_torch |
| Redstone Torch | redstone_torch | redstone_wall_torch |
| Soul Torch | soul_torch | soul_wall_torch |
| Skeleton Skull | skeleton_skull | skeleton_wall_skull |
| Wither Skeleton Skull | wither_skeleton_skull | wither_skeleton_wall_skull |
| Player Head | player_head | player_wall_head |
| Zombie Head | zombie_head | zombie_wall_head |
| Creeper Head | creeper_head | creeper_wall_head |
| Piglin Head | piglin_head | piglin_wall_head |
| Dragon Head | dragon_head | dragon_wall_head |
This also affects wall banners, but those are tracked in MC-124142 and are missing their wall variant translation keys, unlike these blocks.
Unaffected blocks:
- Tube Coral Wall Fan
- Brain Coral Wall Fan
- Bubble Coral Wall Fan
- Fire Coral Wall Fan
- Horn Coral Wall Fan
- Dead Tube Coral Wall Fan
- Dead Brain Coral Wall Fan
- Dead Bubble Coral Wall Fan
- Dead Fire Coral Wall Fan
- Dead Horn Coral Wall Fan
2022-12-22, 01:09 PM
2024-12-18, 05:57 AM
10
9
1.13, CanDestroy, CanPlaceOn, hanging_sign, head, mismatched, redstone_torch, sign, skull, soul_torch, torch, translation, translation-string, wall_hanging_sign, wall_sign
-