Mojira Archive
MC-251034

Multiple-blocks-in-one-space blocks have inconsistent placement behaviour

The bug

There exist several blocks in Minecraft in which several instances of them can be placed within a single block space. For this report, I will divide them into three main categories:

  • Stackables: all slabs, snow layers
  • Groupables: all candles, turtle eggs, sea pickles
  • Coverings: vines, glow lichen, sculk veins

In certain situations, inconsistent and undesirable behaviour can be sighted when placing these blocks.

Placement Stackables Groupables Coverings Notes
On top of a base block Generally impossible Stack increases Generally impossible Stackables and coverings cover the full face of the target block.
On the side face of another block Stack increases Stack increases Generally impossible Coverings cover the full face of a target block.
On the top of an existing instance Stack increases Stack increases Amount increases
On the side of an existing instance Generally impossible Stack increases Group increases Stackables, being square-based and 16x16, do not permit non-flush placement.
On the side of an existing instance, flush with wall New stack created on adjacent block if possible Generally impossible Stack increases No groupables fill out a full block.

Expected results

For vines, glow lichen and sculk veins, targeted sections would create a new block on any adjacent walls.

Actual results

Doing this causes a new instance of the vine/sculk vein/glow lichen to be created inside of the targeted block. If no space exists for one, placement fails completely, even if there is valid space for the vine/etc. to be placed on in the adjacent block.

Invalid

Connor Steppie

2022-04-28, 01:02 PM

2024-01-11, 08:15 AM

2024-01-11, 08:15 AM

4

5

Community Consensus

(Unassigned)

placement-and-support

1.18.2 - 1.20.3 Release Candidate 11.18.2, 22w17a, 1.19.4, 23w17a, 1.20.2, 1.20.3 Release Candidate 1

-