Inconsistency between /loot .. mine with silk touch and actual tool with silk touch for some blocks
Affects snow layers, cobwebs, and possibly some other.
Expected:
Mining a layer of snow with a silk touch pickaxe should drop a snow layer, the same way mining a bookcase with a silk touch pickaxe drops a bookcase and not the raw books.
This is consistent with /loot give @s mine ~ ~ ~ mainhand
Actual:
Mining it manually with a silk touch pickaxe gives nothing.
Using the /loot command will however drop you the snow layer.
Steps to reproduce:
- Run below commands while standing on a snow layer holding the pickaxe with silk touch.
/loot give @s mine ~ ~ ~ mainhand
- Alternatively, stand on the snow layer and just use:
/loot give @s mine ~ ~ ~ minecraft:diamond_pickaxe{Enchantments:[{id:"silk_touch",lvl:1}]}
Try to break the snow layer manually with the same pickaxe. You get nothing.
Suggested fix:
- Either make it consistent that both drop the item, or neither drop the item.
- Additionally, you should take a look at 'required item' + silk touch for various blocks and re-determine if it should or should not drop a block and make it consistent with /loot
2021-06-06, 04:01 PM
2021-06-07, 12:15 AM
2021-06-07, 12:10 AM
1
0
-