Can not reel in fishing rod when a fish is caught

When I go fishing in water, when I do the action to reel in a catch, it doesn't reel in the bobber until the catch escapes.

What I expected to happen was:
I should have been able to catch something (Fish, treasure, etc.)

What actually happened was:
I wasn't able to reel in the catch

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Cast out a fishing rod into water
2. Wait for something to catch it
3. Try to reel in the catch as you would normally do