Advancements broken

I tamed a horse the second I got in the game, and I got the achievement "Best friends forever" Which is normal, but I also got "A Complete Catalog" which is taming all cat variants.

What I expected to happen was...:
^^^

What actually happened was...:
^^^

Steps to Reproduce:
Coords, seed, system, and even the horse I'm on with his stats are all in my screenshots